You are likely right, monica.  And things may have started sliding downhill with a change of leadership in the '80's, when the first of the non-alumni rectors were installed.  Interestingly, the first three were Blase Cupich, now cardinal, of Chicago, Thomas Olmsted, now boshop of Phoenix, and Earl Boyea, now bishop of Lansing.  (The only previous rector to be named a bishop was Henry J. "Grimmy" Grimmelsman, first bishop of Evansville, from the '40's.)  Some 30 years back, our parish at the time employed a Josephinum student in its Hispanic summer program, who mentioned privately that many students there were gay.  (He was not.)  Even earlier, there were some glaring exceptions to "typical"  -- David Heimann, an alumnus/faculty member who had a pedophile ring involving boys from the then-high school; Jack Bauer, an alumnus who produced pornography and ultimately died in federal prison.  The attrition rate back then exceeded 90%.  Hope this helps.