Abp Chaput isn't saying anything new. Pope Benedict XVI said the same many times. When that happened, I said the Pope was wrong to think so and even more wrong to say so out loud. (But I happened to be in a small parish where no one was a letter-writer, so my archbishop never found out.) Back in the day, even the rather conservative group I was pastor to thought that +Chaput was in error when he ordered a pastor to remove the children of a gay couple from his parish school. Frankly, he's not that relevant at the moment. I'll find ways to preach the Gospel without mentioning his name.