A big part of the reason why Milo Y. and Andrew Sullivan are popular (and MSW is not) is that the public can tell when someone is faking.  

That faking colors their whole message, and tells the reader their pontifications are so much hot air.

That is, they don't support closeted Catholicism, closeted professional Catholics, or a culture where gay Catholics feel it necessary to stay in the closet.

Funny that some progressives feel otherwise.   mm mm mm!