Too often this is a life or death matter for gay teens.  Last I checked the suicide and homelessness rate for religious teens wasn't even close to the same numbers for as it for gay teens.  When that much pain is involved in an issue, compromise with the forces causing the pain is more akin to betrayal than anything else. 

However, I doubt the LGBTQ community is going to isolate itself as a special case from other communities which will come under attack during the Trump administration.  There will be a coalescing of groups who join together to protect everyone's rights....even Islamic religious rights.  The gay community is in some respects uniquely positioned to provide leadership in this joint effort.  This is now a time to stick together, not necessarily stick out.