Thank you for Mr. Kaplan's  apt comments; said as a human being, woman & lawyer for 37 years. 

I agree that the former Camp, J.  made not only  unprofessional  and inappropiate comments to say the least ;  but assume that both prosecutor & defence counsel must have raised and reviewed the current legal criteria  for his decision, which he chose to ignore in his ultimate decision.   As colleague Southey wrote, AAgggh .  yours v. truly