Problem: If "I couldn't find a spoon, so I tried using a pen to stir my coffee. But that turned out to be a bad idea, because it got full of ink.", is "The coffee got full of ink." correct?

Answer: yes


Problem: If "The woman held the girl against her will.", is "The woman held the girl against the woman's will." correct?

Answer: no


Problem: If "During a game of tag, Ethan chased Luke because he was "it".", is "Ethan was "it"." correct?

Answer:
yes