TASK DEFINITION: Given a post that is a real-life anecdote of a complex ethical situation and a question asks if AUTHOR, NOBODY, EVERYBODY, or OTHER is wrong in the situation. Answer the question and classify your answers into yes or no.
PROBLEM: Is OTHER wrong in the post ? POST : So to start this story off, I’ve been fostering this beautiful Great Dane dog for over a year now. It was only suppose to be 2days then changed 6 six weeks. Now here we at 1 year later. 

Now this doggo was my mother’s fiancés dog. My mother kicked the dog out after she got sick and starting puking and pooping everywhere so me and my husband took her. When we got her she was skin and bone. She was so depressed she would never come out of her kennel. 

After a couple months and getting her on a meal plan that didn’t make her sick. She started to gain weight (she was 80ish pounds when we got her and she should be about 125). We later found out she was Mel nourished as a puppy. After all this of course I fell in love with this dog. I know she is the dog for me. She protects me. Even when I passed out in the bathroom she was trying to wake me up and keep me awake until I could call ambulance. 

Every morning we cuddle after my husband goes off to work and she never leaves my side.

Here’s my problem. 

I’ve poured 500-1000$ into the dog over a year w my husband. Including the pet deposit at our new house the previous “owner” didn’t pay. 

Now he wants her back now that he has a new house away from my mom. I love her I don’t wanna give her back. 

AITA if I want to keep her? 



SOLUTION: yes

PROBLEM: Is EVERYBODY wrong in the post ? POST : My friends and I got paired up with a girl for a history project . This girl is very smart and is in the top ten of class. The bad thing is that she’s not doing her fair share of work. We’ve been texting her asking if she’s done with her research but she always responds that she’s busy with another activity like National Honor Society or band practice and that she doesn’t have it. I understand that because she’s in the top of the class she’s very busy but I don’t think we should have to pick up her slack. My friend decided to just do her research. Today she asked for all of the research so she can write her report but my friend has taken her name off of the project and is refusing to share the research with her. This is a big project that is worth a lot of points and I know how much her rank is worth to her so I suggested that she pay us. My friend agreed to this and she begrudgingly did so as well. My friend came up with a price but it was a lot higher than what I intended it to be but she ended up paying. There’s no risk of her reporting us because it’ll show she didn’t do the work and she’d get in trouble also but I feel like my friend asked for too much money ($110) and I’m thinking about giving my half of it back to her.

SOLUTION: yes

PROBLEM: Is NOBODY wrong in the post ? POST : Sorry for my poor english.

I have always been slightly sosial awkward, and normally dont take much part in setting opp parties or arrangements with familiy. Whenever sombody asks me to go get this, or drive there buy this, i do that i an instant, no arguments about how far i need to drive or how much something costs. But I only do stuff when asked. My sister came to me today and said that she thinks i dont participate in arrangements enough. She said that its is always here or my other sister who orders and pays for stuff like cakes and such for events around our parents. I didnt argue with here about that, because they always have arranged stuff like this, and i kind of become a "middel man". I drive and get the cake, pick up my sisters, or get items they need, and if it is not paid for i just pay for it, no questions asked. But i told her that, even though i dont take inititativ in arrangements by buying the cakes, or order them or other items, i help as much as i can in other areas. Neither of my sisters drive anywhere, whenever something is needed, i drive, and that also means i maintain the car that alle 3 of us use. Pay the gas, maintenance and other necessitis. I always thought that my contribution by beeing this "middel man" was more then enough.

So i am wondring am i in the wrong here? Am i the Asshole for always letting my sisters the initiativ in arrangmentes and order things and then just fill the gaps?

SOLUTION:
no

