Given a post that is a real-life anecdote of a complex ethical situation and an associated claim about its type, verify if the claim is true or not. The claim asks if the posts are historical or hypothetical. The posts are "HISTORICAL" when the author has already done something and they are "HYPOTHETICAL" when the author is considering doing something in the future. Say 'yes' if the claim is true otherwise say 'no'

[EX Q]: CLAIM : The following post is HISTORICAL. POST : My gf and I have been together 3 years. My gf has been struggling with anxiety since middle school. She claims that the read receipts being turned on for our messages make her anxious. 

Here’s the thing. I’ve been under a lot of stress at school. Lately I have been falling asleep without texting her goodnight. It’s not a big deal to her, but it is to me. I make a point to text her good morning and good night. So I turned them on and she asked me why. I said it was so she would know if I fell asleep or something.

She told me they make her uncomfortable because she jumps to the conclusion that I am upset if she sees I read the text and didn’t respond. In the beginning of our relationship (I was definitely a dick to her and was borderline abusive. I have changed quite a bit since then) I would turn them on if i was mad at her to let her know I read the messages, but wasn’t going to respond. She claims that gave her a lot of anxiety, and for this reason, feels anxious when they are on. I told her she’ll get used to it.

Lately, she has not been texting me as much (we usually talk throughout the day), like 5 to 6 messages per day, and prefers to talk over the phone or in person. I think she is being childish and immature. AITA here?

Tl; dr: my gf hates read receipts and claims they give her anxiety. I turned mine on so she can know if I fall asleep at night. I think she’s being childish and immature, they’re just read receipts. She won’t text me as often anymore due to them being on.
[EX A]: no

[EX Q]: CLAIM : The following post is HISTORICAL. POST : So the girl in question has said that she does not love my friend multiple times but he still hasn't given up.
But then last week me and the girl started dating, and now my friend is mad at me should I break up with her or should I keep going?
(BTW she is really hot that's why this hole argument started)
[EX A]: no

[EX Q]: CLAIM : The following post is HISTORICAL. POST : Throwaway

Sister, we'll call D, brings her boyfriend, we'll call M, on vacation. After dinner, cousins wanted to do shots. I (25F) had a shot, but I didn't want more than one. In all, I had half a beer and a shot, my cousins had about 4 shots, and M was a couple shots and beers in

Owner of the rental house calls, saying there were too many cars in the driveway and we need to move one. Street parking was not aloud, so we thought about finding some lot and parking a car there. M freaks out saying that everyone was drunk and no one should be driving

I wasnt remotely close to being drunk, *however*, I agreed that we all had been drinking and we should find another plan. Since all of the houses around were empty vacation rentals, we could move a car into the neighbors driveway, which was *at most* ten feet away. My cousin gets the keys to his car, and M *freaks out*, running around and yelling

My cousin had drank a bit more than us, so he shouldnt be the one to move the car. I would never drive drunk or even close to mildly inebriated, so I offered to move the car the ten feet

M grabs my arms, gets close to my face, says "NO. You're DRUNK". After telling him repeatedly that I wasnt, he refused to listen and kept telling yelling. My cousin was about to hand me the keys, M snatches the keys out of my cousins hands.

The owner calls again, saying if we don't move a car from the driveway he'll call the sheriff to kick us out. Everyone is agitated/stressed, M still refuses to give us the keys. It becomes an alpha male dick swinging thing between the men. My sisters and third cousin come out to see whats happening. Things start to get aggressive, when my third cousin comes out, I figure she can move the car since she didn't drink

We tell M that my third cousin is absolutely sober and can move the car, he *still* refused to hand over the keys. M doesn't give a real reason, keeps saying "NO"

With M being unreasonable, things get more aggressive between the men. One cousin gets in M's face, tries to grab the keys from M. M retaliates with "Get the fuck out of my face" and shoves my cousin. A full on fight breaks out between the men

I try to break up the fight, put M in a headlock. The fighting stops, I let go of M. M throws the keys at us and storms off. After getting the keys, original problem was solved in 30 seconds

Later, D got most of the version of events from M and he says us three 'jumped' him, so D demands I apologize to him. I tell D that everything that happened was stupid, no one was right, and everyone shares part of the blame

D gives me an ultimatum, apologize to M or she'll stop talking to me

I figured once everyone cooled off it would be fine, so I tell D that I never expected an apology from M and I think it's absurd that they are demanding one from me

I fully believe **ESH through and through**, myself included.

But ATIA for putting my sisters boyfriend in a headlock and not wanting to apologize for it?
[EX A]:
yes

