You will be given a definition of a task first, then some input of the task.
In this task, you are given a sentence and question which can be answered using the sentence. Your task is to answer the question using the information from the sentence. The answer to the question is unique and it is a continuous text span from the sentence.

Sentence: While Ballard recuperates in the hospital , the released spirits , unharmed from the nuclear explosion , attack the city . 
 Question: when was something attacked  by someone?
Output:
While Ballard recuperates in the hospital