Question:
Imagine the conversation that came before this response?
When did American football coach Bill Edwards begin coaching?

Answer:
DIALOG:
What branch of military did the American football coach Bill Edwards serve in?
- American football coach Bill Edwards enlisted in the U.S. Navy later in 1942 as America's involvement in the war intensified.
- What is the Western Reserve in relation to American football coach Bill Edwards?
- American football coach Bill Edwards left to coach the freshman football team at Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio in 1933.
- What year did American football coach Bill Edwards graduate?
- 


Input: See this dialog response. The band Shinedown released their second studio album, Us and Them, on October 4, 2005. What came before?
Came before: DIALOG:
What is Us and Them by Shinedown?
- 


Write the conversation that led to this response. Parsons' biology professors at Amherst were Otto C. Glaser and Henry Plough.
****
Conversation:
DIALOG:
What did Talcott Parsons study in Amherst College?
- As an undergraduate, Parsons studied biology, sociology and philosophy at Amherst College and received his BA in 1924.
- Did Talcott Parsons' family attended the same school?
- Amherst College had become the Parsons' family college by tradition; his father and his uncle Frank had attended it, as had his elder brother, Charles Edward.
- Who is one of Talcott Parsons' professor at Amherst
- 


Input: What came before. In 1992, Neil Diamond performed for President George H.W. Bush's final Christmas in Washington NBC special.
Solution: DIALOG:
What was Neil Diamond's first album of the 1990s?
- Lovescape
- What was significant about the 90s for Neil Diamond?
- The 1990s saw a resurgence in Neil Diamond's popularity.
- Did Neil Diamond do any touring or live performances?
- 


Question:
What might have been said before [Did any of TY.O's singles make the charts?] ???
**********
Answer:
DIALOG:
What was most important about 2011 for Taio?
- In March 2011, Cruz premiered an all-new song called Telling the World“
- Was Telling the World a hit?
- The song was released in the United Kingdom on March 20, 2011 via digital download, peaking at #138 on the UK Singles Chart.
- What band was Taio Cruz with when the song Telling the World was released?
- What was the movie Rio?
- Rio is a 2011 American 3D computer-animated musical adventure-comedy film
- Did anything else important happen to Taio Cruz in 2011?
- Cruz received his first Billboard Award in the United States. He announced onstage that his third album, entitled Black and Leather, would be released in the fourth quarter of 2011
- Was TY.O successful?
- The album itself reached top-twenty in Switzerland and top-thirty in Germany, considerably less successful than Cruz's previous albums.
- 


See the last examples. Predict the preceding dialog. DIALOG:
What is Us and Them by Shinedown?
- The band Shinedown released their second studio album, Us and Them, on October 4, 2005.
- What songs are on the album Us and Them by Shinedown?
- Shinedown's three singles from the album Us and Them, Save Me, I Dare You, and Heroes ended up being more successful than their prior album's singles.
- Which single between Save Me, I Dare You, and Heroes was the most popular song on the album Us and Them by Shinedown?
- The lead single, Save Me was Shinedown's first to reach the number one spot on the Mainstream Rock Charts, and held the position for twelve weeks in a row.
- What happened in 2005 for Shinedown?
- Shinedown did not start work on a follow up album until 2005, with the band finding the touring lifestyle too hectic to start writing or recording material.
- What happened in 2006 for Shinedown?
- Shinedown again toured heavily in support of the album Us and Them, including the 2006 iteration of the SnoCore Tour with Seether, Flyleaf, and Halestorm.
- Are there any other interesting aspects about the Shinedown article besides touring heavily in support of the album Us and Them?
- Shinedown worked with music producer Tony Battaglia, and chose to go in a more mature and stripped down direction for the sound of the album Us and Them.
- Did Shinedown only work with Tony Battaglia once?
- 
Preceding conversation:
DIALOG:
What is Us and Them by Shinedown?
- The band Shinedown released their second studio album, Us and Them, on October 4, 2005.
- What songs are on the album Us and Them by Shinedown?
- Shinedown's three singles from the album Us and Them, Save Me, I Dare You, and Heroes ended up being more successful than their prior album's singles.
- Which single between Save Me, I Dare You, and Heroes was the most popular song on the album Us and Them by Shinedown?
- The lead single, Save Me was Shinedown's first to reach the number one spot on the Mainstream Rock Charts, and held the position for twelve weeks in a row.
- What happened in 2005 for Shinedown?
- Shinedown did not start work on a follow up album until 2005, with the band finding the touring lifestyle too hectic to start writing or recording material.
- What happened in 2006 for Shinedown?
- Shinedown again toured heavily in support of the album Us and Them, including the 2006 iteration of the SnoCore Tour with Seether, Flyleaf, and Halestorm.
- Are there any other interesting aspects about the Shinedown article besides touring heavily in support of the album Us and Them?
- Shinedown worked with music producer Tony Battaglia, and chose to go in a more mature and stripped down direction for the sound of the album Us and Them.
- Did Shinedown only work with Tony Battaglia once?
- 