Problem: Continue the following story.

The girls were looking for the belt and not the hat inside of the closet because the 
Here's how I want to continue it: hat was found.

Problem: Continue the following story.

Hunter did not play sports in high school but Ian did because 
Here's how I want to continue it: Hunter was too weak to participate.

Problem: Continue the following story.

Donald wanted to get a milkshake but Nick didn't want one. 
Here's how I want to continue it:
Nick had a lactose intolerance.