TASK DEFINITION: We would like you to assess the QUALITY of each of the following argument (discussing Gay Marriage) and determine if the argument is Valid or Invalid. A valid argument is clearly interpretable and either expresses an argument, or a premise or a conclusion that can be used in an argument for the topic of gay marriage. An invalid argument is a phrase that cannot be interpreted as an argument or not on the topic of gay marriage.
PROBLEM: I care about legitimacy, so even though I might agree that a law is bad, or even that it is severely unjust, I would not advocate or support judges overturning those laws without an appropriate legal basis.

SOLUTION: Valid

PROBLEM: Some people may think atheists are unintellectual; based on that premise, then atheists cannot give consent.

SOLUTION: Invalid

PROBLEM: If you want your position to be taken seriously from any moral perspective, you cannot say "i don't care if it's rational, just that we get to make the decision."

SOLUTION:
Invalid

