Is the premise "A man in a black striped shirt playing the trombone." true if "A man plays classical jazz on the trombone."?
it is not possible to tell
Is the premise "Two men are ice fishing." true if "the boy  was listening to music"?
no
Is the premise "A young man shocks the audience with his skateboard tricks." true if "The young man knows skateboard tricks."?
yes
Is the premise "One guy playing his instrument." true if "One man is playing his instrument."?

yes