Problem: I think there is a privilege here, and I think the privilege sometimes gets drawn in what appears to be an ad hoc manner. But my job is to find where to put the line down in this case. To traipse into the area of why they selectively used a quote as opposed to not using other things that were said I think is to get on a very slippery slope. It really almost precipitates a bias line of questioning, and I'm not going to allow it. I am trying to narrowly draw this.

Based on the paragraph above can we conclude that "her job is to find where to put the line down"?

A: No


Problem: Tony Shalhoub won best actor in a comedy for "Monk", and James Spader won best actor in a drama for "Boston Legal."

Based on the paragraph above can we conclude that "James Spader won best supporting actor for Boston Legal."?

A: No


Problem: Tha Smokin' Nephew is the first major label studio album by the rapper Baby Bash and his third album overall. Released by Universal Records, it entered the "Billboard" 200 at number 48. Five months after its release, the album was certified Gold by the RIAA. By March 2005, the album had sold 531,000 copies in the United States.

Based on the paragraph above can we conclude that "Baby Bash is a rapper. "?

A:
Yes