Q: Given a post that is a real-life anecdote of a complex ethical situation and an associated claim about its type, verify if the claim is true or not. The claim asks if the posts are historical or hypothetical. The posts are "HISTORICAL" when the author has already done something and they are "HYPOTHETICAL" when the author is considering doing something in the future. Say 'yes' if the claim is true otherwise say 'no'
CLAIM : The following post is HISTORICAL. POST : Throwaway account for obvious reasons. 

Hey guys, so I live in a 2-bedroom apartment with my two roommates, we'll call them Emily and Jane. We're all seniors in college and have been living in this apartment for about a year and a half now. This past summer Emily decided to get an emotional support animal after her bunny of 10 years died, only this time she wanted a dog. Immediately, Jane and I had our doubts because Emily can be very self-absorbed, lazy, and very questionably able to take care of an animal with as many needs as a dog. However, we told her we would be okay with it as long as she met certain basic conditions like walking it, making sure it doesn't disturb our sleep/other needs, cleaning up after it....etc.

 Fast forward to September when she brings in this puppy she got from a luxury breeder, and the next few months are--to put it mildly--pretty fucking hard. It took the dog an insanely long time to get potty trained, and up until last week she was still peeing and pooping in random areas of the apartment. But here's the big thing: this dog was NEVER WALKED. The dog was in our apartment for WEEKS on end without so much as seeing the outside, and regardless of how many times we raised concerns over this our roommate claimed that because it was "cold" it was better to let the dog get some exercise at home (which, by the way, means throwing toys around for her to chase in a circle.) 

Anyway, two days ago, after the 8 month old puppy was left alone in Emily's room for three hours, we all came home to find her having what we later realized was a prolonged seizure. By the time we got to the vet she had died. The vet later told me privately that it was no surprise this happened if the dog was never walked and was left alone often: anxiety and deprivation from stimulation can be easy seizure triggers that are fatal. Not only that, but when Emily called the breeder to let him know, he told her none of his other puppies had ever gone through something like this. 

Jane and I thought Emily would be destroyed and we did everything we could to make it better. Imagine our SURPRISE when, after her mother flies in the NEXT DAY, they're talking about getting another puppy next WEEK from the SAME BREEDER. Her mother says Emily lost her emotional support animal and needs a new one to get through this. Neither of them seem to see that this untimely death is very much related to the way Emily took care of this dog. Jane and I are in shock. We absolutely do not want another dog to go through the life the previous one had. We just don't know what to do. AITA for preventing this from happening somehow? And how would I even do this? It's not like I can tell my roommate who is depressed that her dog died because of her.
A:
no