Teacher: Given a post that is a real-life anecdote of a complex ethical situation and a question asks if AUTHOR, NOBODY, EVERYBODY, or OTHER is wrong in the situation. Answer the question and classify your answers into yes or no.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
Is AUTHOR wrong in the post ? POST :  Pretty much was hanging out with two friends. I was watching the Lakers game. They won at the very last minute and I immediately hopped up and celebrated. Before I could even finish celebrating one friend started going on about how the Lakers suck. It just pissed me off so much I screamed at her to get out my room until she left. 


She knows I'm a huge fan and she likes them too. She was only saying it to antagonize me. Am I the dick here?
Solution: yes
Reason: It is very rude to shout at someone and ask her to leave the room even if her comments may have antagonized the author. Hence author is at fault here.

Now, solve this instance: Is AUTHOR wrong in the post ? POST : Last week I purchased a Volcano on ebay for $300. For those of you that dont know, the Volcano is a vaporizer that is used for the ole devils lettuce. Its a tank of a unit thats known for  for its sturdiness and basically lasting forever. The unit was described as used which I figured was fine - maybe some scuffs or some residue but whatever. The listing also described and pictured a traveling case. Cool.

 I get it a week later and the case has a hole in the back the size of a quarter. My friend points out that you could fit the plug through so you can just keep it in the case the whole time when using it. It made sense and then I didnt care so much.

Then i go to plug it up and see the grounding prong is missing on the power cable, but theres still a hole im the cable as if one had been there before. I contacted the manufacturer of the vape with the serial number and confirm that its a 2011 unit and should, in fact, have a ground prong.The Volcano uses up 100 - 111 watts of electricity when its on. Neither of these defects were pictured (although the hole in the case I dont care so much about). 

I take pictures and open up a refund request on ebay. The seller offered me a $20 refund because it was "fully operational" (he is correct, it does turn on and function) and he "only sold it cause he was in a motorcycle accident and needed money." 

 
I rejected the refund and want to pursue a full refund through ebay if necessary but kind of feel bad too. I know it functions, but but the cable just sketches me out, as well as the fact that he imtentiomally chose not to picture either thing. WIBTA?
Student:
no