In this task, you're given a short story of five sentences written in natural language. However, the order of the given story is not correct. Your job is to return the correct order for the given five sentences to create a coherent short story with the new order that has the correct flow. Generate your answer using the number of sentences in the correct order, such as '23415'.

Sentence1: We told the kids that Santa must have share with the reindeer. Sentence2: One year we found cookie pieces outside in the snow. Sentence3: Sometimes my kids wondered if Santa Claus was real. Sentence4: Each Christmas day we found an empty cup and cookie crumbs. Sentence5: Each year we left cookies and milk for him on Christmas Eve.
54132