instruction:
Given a post that is a real-life anecdote of a complex ethical situation and an associated claim about its type, verify if the claim is true or not. The claim asks if the posts are historical or hypothetical. The posts are "HISTORICAL" when the author has already done something and they are "HYPOTHETICAL" when the author is considering doing something in the future. Say 'yes' if the claim is true otherwise say 'no'
question:
CLAIM : The following post is HYPOTHETICAL. POST : Their dogs are outside on chains all day long. They have no shelter and it’s cold and might rain tonight. It’s typically not rainy here but it is cold. Dips in the low 30’s at night. 
I told them if they don’t get the dogs shelter I’m calling animal control. They bought one dog house. They have pit mix, chow/ German Shepard and a chihuahua. 
The chihuahua is in heat which is causing the other dogs to go crazy and pit was very aggressive to chow grabbing him by the neck. This was not play fighting. The neighbor had to come out and stop the fight which resulted in them getting shorter chains. 
He put up a “wall”between the two larger dogs which the chow is now jumping over and was actually stuck upside down for a few tense moments due to his short chain. It’s very dangerous. The neighbor came out and sprayed him with water to get him up stop making so much noise and then went back inside without fixing the wall issue. 
This is cause of me a great deal of anxiety. Every time I hear yelping I have to run to the window to make sure chow is not hung on his own chain or mauled by the pit. 
The chihuahua and chow were not originally chained. Only the pit. C and C killed s litter of kittens which is why they got chained too. At first I was think okay make it’s good. Pit has company now and they were all able to touch and play together cause their chains were long enough. But since chihuahua is in heat it is causing problems. 
It also looked like their daughter was hitting one of the dogs with a stick but I’m not 100% sure. She did throw them (C and C ) off the porch before though when chow was a puppy. She is maybe 6 or 7. 
So WIBTA if I call animal control or should I wait until she is out if heat and see if it gets better? 
There is also the weather factor. 

answer:
yes


question:
CLAIM : The following post is HISTORICAL. POST : A bit of backstory: I'm deployed to a foreign country for the Army. I have a fiancé back home. My fiancé has a friend, we'll call him John. John has been her friend for awhile and he seemed like a good friend until recently. About two weeks ago he tried to kiss my fiancé. Dick move. But she reacted the way she should have and I was all good with it. Until yesterday.

Yesterday I Facetimed my fiancé after she washed her dogs. She is going on a trip to see her parents (other side of America) and was talking about getting to the Airport. I suggested having John take her since she trusts him, even though I don't really care for me. She said "I thought you didn't like him?"

I replied "I don't, but I trust you"

She then panned the camera around to him, shirtless in her bed. They were both fully clothed otherwise. I freaked out a bit. I hung up on her, and when she called back I was pretty upset. She apologized, sent him home, and explained that he was helping her wash the dogs (Shes 5' 100lbs, they are both pitbulls) and his shirt got wet, so she put it in the drier. I said "Well, we have different morality of what's okay in a relationship." She tried to joke it off commenting on my having something to eat saying "Well you have a snack in bed too" and that's when I lost it. 

My Fiance has problems sleeping. I often tell her little stories to get her to bed. I told her "How about next time you can't sleep you call John too!" and hung up. She called until I picked up and apologized after sending him home, and cried about how she acted. All was good until I went to work.


During my work shift, it just ate at the back of my head. My fiancé usually calls about an hour after I get off before I go to bed. When she called I told her I needed a nights rest to really get over what happened. She called me a dick and hung up. That was two minutes ago. 


Reddit, AITA?

answer:
no


question:
CLAIM : The following post is HISTORICAL. POST : Throwaway account and on mobile. Apologies. Not going specific in case they browse reddit? But happy to answer any questions. 

Basically I have a friend who is throwing a birthday party for herself. Rather than invite people to a bar she is having everyone pitch in to get a private room at a bar with pool and giant Jenga and pay for an open bar - that only lasts 3 hours and has restrictions on drinks (like no shots and only miller and bud for beer)  Originally she said 30$ a person, now she is coming back and say 40$ a person. I had texted her the other day asking if DD’s still had to pay the same fee and that if I did drink it’d be one drink as I am still breastfeeding and don’t want to pump and dump. She said she wasn’t sure and would get back to me today. Well it’s the end of the day and no word, there was a post on the page for her event (where she invited over 100 people) and it said the new total, so I asked “does that include tax and gratuity”
Answer with: “Yes”
I had checked the website the day before and it said they will only serve one drink per person at a time and no shots are served. So I wanted to clarify and I asked “but no shots and only one drink at a time?” I asked this because it had never been mentioned once on the event page and I have a right to know what I’m getting if I’m going to spend that kind of money. I was met with a barrage of “40$ is great for an open bar, thanks so much *friends name*”
And then finally someone telling me “you don’t have to get the deal” (which should be mentioned on the event - don’t ya think?)  and “you can just get an Uber, you don’t have to DD it’s not that serious” 
To which I replied “well I’m breastfeeding my baby. So” 
Then my friend deleted all my comments and sent me text messages telling me to calm down, that her party isn’t about me, that I was complaining and being rude and that I should’ve texted her and asked my questions. 
I think people have the right to know exactly what their money will get them - especially if it’s 40$ for 3 hours only.. and no shots! But my friend never mentioned specifics on the event- just wants everyone to bring 40$ cash and give it to her and then they can all “have a great time” 
I’m happy to share screen shots if needed in the morning and any more info needed but that’s the basics. So AMITA for questioning what my money gets me ?? 


Edit: people seem to be getting side tracked in the comments. I didn’t ask if I should go or not- this isn’t a discussion on my attendance. I was curious if asking for more details about what’s included in the 40$ fee publicly made me an asshole.
answer:

no


