instruction:
In this task, you are given a paragraph, a question, and a candidate incorrect answer to the question. Your goal is to judge whether the provided answer is a valid incorrect answer to a given question. An incorrect answer should not truthfully answer the given question. A good incorrect answer should be closely related to the content of the paragraph and/or the question so that the readers are forced to read the whole paragraph to infer its [in]correctness. Additionally, an incorrect answer should be of the same semantic type as the given correct answer (e.g., both can be names of locations). If you think the given incorrect answer is good(and incorrect), indicate it by responding "Yes". Otherwise, respond "No". There are only two types of responses possible:"Yes" and "No".
question:
Paragraph- Sent 1: Ace , a wannabe rock star , is on his way to a concert of the band Guitar Wolf when space aliens invade the Earth .
Sent 2: As a result the dead rise to their feet in the countryside setting of Asahi , Japan , with an appetite for flesh .
Sent 3: Enlisting the help of his rock 'n roll blood brother Guitar Wolf , Ace and the members of the band get entangled in many misadventures with crazy rock managers in very tight shorts , transsexuals , naked women shooting guns in the shower , and bloodthirsty zombies ready to tear them apart .
Sent 4: Leather jackets , loud over-modulated music , laser guitar picks , motorcycles , guns , muscle cars , and fire abound .
Sent 5: Guitar Wolf , a Japanese trio signed to Matador Records in the US and self-proclaimed coolest rock band in the world star as the well-coiffed heroes .
Sent 6: It is also a love story , between Ace and Tobio , a trans woman .
Sent 7: The music , in a garage punk vein , plays an important role in the film .
Sent 8: It features music from Greg Cartwright of Reigning Sound and The Oblivians .
Sent 9: His 1997 song `` Twice as Deep '' by Greg Oblivian & the Tip Tops is featured .
Sent 10: This film is similar to another movie by a Spanish punk group , La matanza can bal de los garrulos lis rgicos produced by Siniestro Total. 
Question: What genre is the song "Twice as deep"? 
Incorrect Answer: Spanish Punk.
answer:
Yes.


question:
Paragraph- Sent 1: Sam Farragut is a sociopathic business executive in Southern California who forces a team of advertising agency employees to embark on a dangerous dirtbike trip to the Baja California desert in order to compete for his business .
Sent 2: The men are Warren Summerfield , a suicidal middle-aged ad executive who has been fired from the agency ; the straightlaced Paul McIlvain who is inattentive to his wife , and brash art designer Maxon who feels suddenly trapped after his girlfriend announces she is pregnant .
Sent 3: There are numerous long sequences of motorcycle riding on desert backroads .
Sent 4: Summerfield has been having an affair with McIlvian 's wife .
Sent 5: He has not told his wife that he was fired and is simply serving out his tenure at the agency while looking for a new position .
Sent 6: His wife is actually aware of the affair .
Sent 7: Farragut convinces the ad men to make the motorcycle journey on the pretext of looking for a location to shoot a commercial .
Sent 8: In reality , Farragut is reckless and looking to involve the men in spontaneous edgy adventure of his own manipulation .
Sent 9: After they leave , McIlvain 's wife suspects that Summerfield is planning to kill himself for the insurance money , but she can not convince Summerfield 's wife to instigate a search .
Sent 10: The four men travel deeper into Mexico on isolated dirt roads .
Sent 11: At one point Summerfield contemplates plunging off a cliff .
Sent 12: After being humiliated by a young American couple in a Baja bar , Farragut tracks them down on the beach while accompanied by Maxon . 
Question: Who is Summerfield having an affair with and does his wife know that he is having an affair? 
Incorrect Answer:   Maxon.
answer:
Yes.


question:
Paragraph- Sent 1: A stranger in town meets pretty young Susan Martinez De La Cruz and accompanies her to a barbecue , where wealthy Jason Carberry is saying a few words for the recently departed Robin Randall , a citizen who got shot .
Sent 2: Jason objects to the stranger 's presence , being Susan 's guardian and protective of her .
Sent 3: He challenges him to a shootout , but the stranger pulls his pistol before Jason 's can even clear the holster .
Sent 4: Calaveras Kate , a saloon singer who 's in love with Jason , is relieved when the stranger declines to pull the trigger .
Sent 5: Rafael Moreno suddenly rides into town and picks a fight with the stranger .
Sent 6: Their brawl continues until the arrival of Judge Wallace Wintrop and his niece , Sheila , who have come to town from back East and deplore all this random violence out West .
Sent 7: The stranger is recognized as Reb Randall , the dead man 's brother .
Sent 8: He is looking for the killer , who could be Rafael , or could be Jason , or could even be Billy Buckett , the coward of the county .
Sent 9: The women hold their breath to see if the men they love will survive . 
Question: Is Billy Bucket the killer? 
Incorrect Answer: Absolutely not.
answer:

Yes.


