In this task, you are given a paragraph, a question, and a candidate incorrect answer to the question. Your goal is to judge whether the provided answer is a valid incorrect answer to a given question. An incorrect answer should not truthfully answer the given question. A good incorrect answer should be closely related to the content of the paragraph and/or the question so that the readers are forced to read the whole paragraph to infer its [in]correctness. Additionally, an incorrect answer should be of the same semantic type as the given correct answer (e.g., both can be names of locations). If you think the given incorrect answer is good(and incorrect), indicate it by responding "Yes". Otherwise, respond "No". There are only two types of responses possible:"Yes" and "No".

[Q]: Paragraph- Sent 1: The series starts in Baghdad at an undetermined time .
Sent 2: The Sultan Shahryar has gone mad after accidentally killing his wife during a failed coup d' tat , which she had planned with Shahryar 's brother Schahzenan .
Sent 3: In his madness , Shahryar believes that all women now want to kill him , but the law states that the Sultan must be married again or the throne will be passed to his brother .
Sent 4: Shahryar therefore orders Grand Vizier Ja'Far ( ( ( Jim Carter to bring him a harem girl to marry and then have executed the next day .
Sent 5: In order to prevent this , the Grand Vizier 's clever daughter , Scheherazade , decides to marry the Sultan herself .
Sent 6: Scheherazade has a plan to prevent her execution and at the same time cure the Sultan of his madness .
Sent 7: With the help of some tutoring from a bazaar storyteller , Scheherazade tells the Sultan a story every night , stopping at dawn with a cliffhanger and refusing to continue until dusk .
Sent 8: Shahryar must therefore let Scheherazade live for another day in order to hear the rest of the story .
Sent 9: Cunningly , Scheherazade has hidden a moral within every story , to bring the Sultan out of his madness .
Sent 10: Meanwhile , Schahzenan hears about the Sultan 's madness and that he is unable to execute Scheherazade .
Sent 11: Perceiving this as weakness , Schahzenan leads his army to Baghdad in an attempt to take the throne by force .
Sent 12: However , by the time Schahzenan 's army reaches the city , Scheherazade 's plan has worked .
Sent 13: As a result of her stories , Shahryar has overcome his madness and has fallen in love with Scheherazade . 
Question: Based on which weakness of Sultan, Schahzenan leads his army to Baghdad in an attempt to take the throne? 
Incorrect Answer: sultan forgot his plan.
[A]: Yes.


[Q]: Paragraph- Sent 1: The film opens with Sunita , a medical student , and her friends working on a project about the human brain .
Sent 2: She wants to investigate the curious case of Sanjay Singhania , a notable city businessman , who is reported to have anterograde amnesia .
Sent 3: Her professor denies access to Sanjay 's records as it is currently under criminal investigation .
Sent 4: Sunita , nonetheless , decides to investigate the matter herself .
Sent 5: Sanjay is introduced as he brutally murders a man .
Sent 6: He takes a Polaroid picture of the man , and writes on it `` done '' .
Sent 7: It is revealed that Sanjay has anterograde amnesia where he loses his memory every 15 minutes .
Sent 8: Sanjay uses a system of photographs , notes , and tattoos on his body to recover his memory after each cycle .
Sent 9: It is revealed that Sanjay is ultimately out to avenge the death of his sweetheart Kalpana , and that he is systematically killing the people who were responsible for it .
Sent 10: His main target is `` Ghajini '' , a notable social personality in the city .
Sent 11: Police Inspector Arjun Yadav , on the case of the serial murders , tracks Sanjay down to his flat and attacks and disables him .
Sent 12: Yadav finds two diaries where Sanjay has chronicled the events of 2005 and 2006 .
Sent 13: The film flashes back to 2005 as Yadav reads the diary .
Sent 14: Sanjay Singhania is shown as the owner of the Air Voice mobile telephone company .
Sent 15: In the course of his business , Sanjay sends his men to meet Kalpana , a struggling model , about putting up a billboard above her apartment .
Sent 16: The owner of Kalpana 's advertising firm misinterprets this as a romantic advance , and in view of a possible lucrative Air Voice ad campaign and other benefits , encourages Kalpana to accept the overture . 
Question: When Sunita begins to investigate, what does she initially learn.? 
Incorrect Answer: That Sanjay is a murderer.
[A]: Yes.


[Q]: Paragraph- Sent 1: Amateur tennis star Guy Haines wants to divorce his vulgar and unfaithful wife Miriam , so he can marry the elegant and beautiful Anne Morton , daughter of a senator .
Sent 2: While on a train to meet Miriam , Haines meets Bruno Anthony , a forward stranger who recognizes Guy from gossip items in the newspapers that detail his marital problems .
Sent 3: During lunch in Bruno 's compartment , Bruno tells Guy about his idea for the perfect `` Criss-cross '' murder : he will kill Miriam and in exchange , Guy will kill Bruno 's father .
Sent 4: Since both are strangers , otherwise unconnected , there is no identifiable motive for the crimes , Bruno contends , hence no suspicion .
Sent 5: Guy hurriedly leaves the compartment but leaves Bruno thinking he has agreed to the deal .
Sent 6: Guy accidentally leaves his cigarette lighter behind , a gift from Anne to Guy , which Bruno pockets .
Sent 7: Bruno heads to Guy 's hometown of Metcalf and follows Miriam and her two beaux to an amusement park , where he briefly illuminates her face with Guy 's lighter , then strangles her to death .
Sent 8: Guy 's problems begin when his alibi an inebriated college professor on the same train as Guy can not remember their meeting .
Sent 9: But they increase exponentially when Bruno makes repeated appearances into Guy 's life as he seeks to remind Guy that he is now obliged to kill Bruno 's father , according to the bargain he thinks they struck on the train .
Sent 10: Bruno sends Guy the keys to his house , a map to his father 's room , and a pistol .
Sent 11: Soon after , Bruno appears at a party at Senator Morton 's house and hobnobs with the guests , much to Guy 's apprehension and Anne 's increasing suspicion . 
Question: What are the things given by Bruno to kill his father? 
Incorrect Answer: a pistol.
[A]:
No.


