Based on the information present in the given passage, you need to write a correct answer to the given question. A correct answer is one that correctly and completely answers the question. Do not write answers that address the question partially or incorrectly. The correct answer must be contained in the given paragraph.
Example: Paragraph- Sent 1: Obama was born on August 4, 1961, at Kapiʻolani Maternity & Gynecological Hospital in Honolulu, Hawaii.
Sent 2: He is the only President to have been born in Hawaii.
Sent 3: He was born to a white mother and a black father.
Sent 4: His mother, Ann Dunham (1942-1995), was born in Wichita, Kansas, of mostly English descent, with some German, Irish, Scottish, Swiss, and Welsh ancestry. Question: How old was Obama's mother when he was born?
Example solution: 19.
Example explanation: Obama was born in 1961. His mother was born in 1942 and 1961-1942=19. Therefore, any of the following responses are considred correct: '19' and 'almost twenty'.

Problem: Paragraph- Sent 1: { { lang } } centers on a man who roams the street night after night .
Sent 2: Hidden under his hat and rain jacket he strives for one goal : to find the culprit - the one whom he can make responsible for his suffering .
Sent 3: If he wanted to , he could confront him , but he lacks the audacity to do so .
Sent 4: He considers suicide , but his courage fails him once again .
Sent 5: The options do not appear to present him with a way out and would not personally satisfy him .
Sent 6: Finley blames not himself , but only others .
Sent 7: In this case he looks to his girlfriend , Violet .
Sent 8: He drowns Violet in the bath whilst giving her a massage , Which had become a common ritual for them .
Sent 9: On one hand he does this out of malice , on the other to be close to her just one more time .
Sent 10: Through this action he wishes to break the growing distance he has come to feel between them , though the actual outcome is the infliction of the greatest possible loneliness , as he turns into a monster .
Sent 11: Finley only realizes with hindsight that his misdeeds far surpass those of Violet . 
Question: What was Finley doing with Violet before he killed her?.

Solution: Giving her a massage in the bath to be close to her.