okay here we go alright the agenda for thi 0 alright the agenda for this meeting is we will initially have the prototype presentation by our 2 designers and then we will evaluate it given the criteria that that we gave gave it and talk about our finances whether we were under or over our budget i have a a spreadsheet where we can calculate our prices for every aspect of of what we have made given our options and evaluate the product as a group okay and so 1st we will have the prototype presentation do you need the powerpoint for this yeah i just got a few slides so show them alright thank you do you want to present it this is what we came up with yeah here we are it is a pretty simple design it is based on a mango yeah and we mango shape on a mango okay yeah and we have the company logo here and this will be the infrared here and this will be the power point the on off button kind yeah the l e d 0 okay i am sorry what was the where is the l e d oops it is in the middle of one of the little r s 0 okay and then the other one is the power and we just have a simple design we wanted it all to be so it is palm held accessible from your thumb yeah palm held and all the yeah yeah buttons are accessible from your thumb notice you have a number 10 button so you do not have to 0 that was a mistake was not it okay right no that is a 0 you just need the nought take that one off sorry i was in charge of the numbers no problem ah and this is just if you have got like 11 or 12 or thirt the plus so one +one would be 11 or you can go 13 or something 0 you press that 1st and then you go 13 yeah you press a plus button 0 okay i have never heard of that kind before well we just thought we have all the numbers here so we wanted something representative of numbers larger than 10 and yeah because if you on your average remote if you press one twice you just go to or say you wanted channel 12 yeah you press one and then you go to channel one and then 2 then you would just go to channel 2 instead of 12 yeah 0 there is no e okay so if you did like one +2 you could go to channel 12 or 2 +2 is channel 22 so the +and then yeah 0 i okay but would you have to go 0 +one if you wanted to go to channel one or 2 no no th all that is why we have all these numbers these numbers these numbers all work independently up to 9 yeah but i mean if you press it will go to that channel right away yeah cause you got to press the plus afterwards 0 no the plus is only for if you are going past the number 9 yeah i know but if if i want to go to say number like 65 channel 65 60 if i press the 6 it will go to channel 6 you p and then i will press the +and then it will go to 6 and then put the 5 and it will go to 65 0 no you press the +1st i i well it does not we have not really s i would have thought you pressed the +1st and then the 65 0 but she says plus press which what do you think is simpler well i do not mind we can further define that i th it is a i would not have thought it would be a problem that it went to channel 61st in like on the way to channel 65 yeah yeah it would not be a problem yeah but i was just wondering like as long as we realize that is what it will do but i suppose it is not as snappy well the there is a there is a delay on remotes i think oops where you can have it it is like a 52nd input time yeah yeah yeah if you do not put it so as long as you hit them dada yeah yeah yeah that yeah it should be fine yeah as long as there is not a big pause between the t hitting the 2 buttons yeah so was there so on the top there is volume and and channel which is so you could just go like that without thinking about it like a channel channel up volume up okay cool c and v just so we can flick right where where is the power button yeah it is in the middle of one of the little r s it is the bigger r it is the r 0 okay so it is just like yeah so it is all accessible yeah we deci without m taking your hand off the remote yeah yeah we went for like a a circular design for the numbers because we thought that is kind of a more natural movement than just going like that with your thumb 0 okay e ergonomics are all considered yeah and it might actually help with the repetitive stress injury as well ergonomic definitely ergonomic yeah it could cause another type of repetitive stress injury though okay but yeah no i mean it is a different movement so yeah yeah and the feel of it i mean we have made this out of play doh which is representing the you know the rubber and the spongy rubberness the spon yeah yeah cause it was said before in the material specification that this the this anti r s i material is often used in stress balls so this has got a you know a bit of give to it yeah and it just feels feels different yeah bit of a stress ball feel yeah would you like to feel it yourselves yes how it fits in the palm of your hand i would my goodness thanks there you go and you yes genevieve yeah 0 it is nice 0 i think i killed the 5 i did i killed the 4 and something 0 god 0 okay as for the colors we were presented with a limited range of colors for this prototype 0 it smells good of play doh yeah but we are thinking that seeing as we are having it in interchangeable casing anyway that this is not necessarily a representation of the true colors that we would necessarily use or the combination and we are thinking to carry on with the fruit and vegetable theme the color combination just could just be named after different fruit like banana could be black and yellow 0 right watermelon red and green or vanilla might be the most popular if it just blends in more settled cream instead of the others are all a bit garish cause it would be quite subtle and yeah it looks more think like vanilla and banana would banana is more representative of our color scheme like the company the yellow and black yeah okay yeah so that for corporate identity that would probably be the most strength i mean watermelon you know m probably appealing to the yeah seasonal kinda christmas you know yeah yeah yeah apple green brown more kinda trendy you know khaki yeah the pomegranate is kinda girly and funky kind of and then the vanilla is more for the more sophisticated customer who just wants something that fits in with all decor cool yeah okay yeah we thought of the components it was definitely a focus of ergonomics and just a single ha handheld device i mean you do not need to use both hands one hand to hold this and type in with the other you can just use your thumb yeah as we said the rubber is probably used for comfort and anti r s i and that is about it alright thank you very much good work everyone bravo alright and so now that we have we have a prototype we need to go over the finances and seeing if this prototype matches what our budget can handle so i have something i am going to you want the 0 wait a minute do you need to do a presentation 1st i do not know what order it goes in yeah i am going to check that out for a 2nd i have one go what time is it anyw 0 yeah sorry you are right evaluation cri okay evaluation criteria is next in line that is me yeah hello 0 there we go okay come on my computer come on sorry my computer is giving me technical difficulties just press function 8 again should i press it again last time i did that it sh okay you are right and then again i think one more time 0 still not there yeah yeah okay now i think for this one i could would you guys prefer use the whiteboard or mayb maybe i will just do it on right on the screen where you can see it we are going to be doing an evaluation report together based on the protoptype that we have just seen and looking looking back at my notes from our both our conceptual and our functional meetings i made a list of what our original requirements and goals were back to our kick off meeting this morning and we will evaluate as to whether we have s done what we set out to do and we are going to do it on a one to 7 scale where one is true and 7 is false so basically the lower p the lower the points the better okay so question number one does the remote whoops sorry 0 i am not going to be able i will do it on the whiteboard i can not change it so i am g i am going to ask you to push it down once okay i will write down our scores up on the ooh okay so number one do we have a fancy look and feel feel i think we have been quite successful with the rubber coating and yeah the look is a little bit more playful well yeah yeah yeah i guess that depends on your definition of fancy but it is definitely different it is not your traditional yeah 0 definitely different yeah i think the color has a lot to do with it i mean th the colors we were given for making the prototype are not the colors that i think we would have necessarily chosen yeah it is not the kind of ooh at all sleek red black and yellow and orange 0 you were only given red and black 0 okay yeah so not very sleek and we do not want to go for black because most remote controls are black or gray yeah so we want it to be stand out that way anyway yeah but if you can imagine that in like a s just a maybe a kind of pale metallic y finish or something okay yeah a metallic y finish we were thinking well i know know it is for rubber yeah polished i mean diff if you can visualize this in nice colors i think it would look quite fancy okay yeah yeah yeah i kinda i like the potato look 0 well potato mango fruit and veg we we were we were thinking about yeah it is mango it is very different it is what it is mango 0 sorry the mango the mango look potato is fine yeah it is fruit or vegetable depends on your mood potato is fine yeah totally it is really adaptable so i myself would say a one or a 2 yeah i would say 2 personally i w i would say 2 i think it is a 2 okay and p for the fanciness fancy yeah one being true so i 23 2 okay actu that is pro that is going to get confusing like that yeah okay so question number 2 was is it techn technologically innovative so i know we have the kinetic energy which is very innovative yeah yeah and the use of the rubber use of the rubber the use of the l e d yeah for the anti r s i yeah the l e d use is not particularly innovative and we do not have any scroll buttons it is all pushbuttons is not there is no l c d control so if we are thinking about the rest of the market it is sort of probably halfway yeah in some aspects it is like we said yeah i would say maybe 3 i will go for 3 as well yeah and i think i mean it it is tough to say because we were we did not want it to be any more innovative than this because then that would have defeated the purpose no yeah yeah we want it simple though it was our specification would not be simple yeah so i mean i we will put 3 but i think we actually reached our goal yeah yeah we did not want it any more than that okay question number 3 will it be easy to use i think so yeah yeah very yeah yeah yeah yeah i think one for that s yeah i think it is you can not really get confused with that yeah yeah one yeah no i mean there will be s we have to work out the number the plus system th the plus number thing yeah that is the only thing yeah but once that is figured out it should be fine yeah and perhaps the turning on but number 4 is this a good looking remote remember that 75% of users find most remote controls ugly it is definitely again i think the color comes into this yeah color will definitely be a factor i think that the logo could be smaller okay yeah and maybe not such a prominent way but the maybe like at the bottom kind of remember the management said that it it had to be prominent not in whoops 0 it just had to be on there i guess should just not touch it yeah do not worry this time it is the 3 i killed i was just wondering if it should be like flatter or i suppose i have got quite big hands i like the appeal of it being like a big glob in your hand well yeah but you know what i have just thought of there now what where is it going to sit in your living room is it not going to fall off the arm of the sofa maybe if the bottom was just sort of flat and then the rest is like yeah the bottom could be like ch chopped a bit yeah but then it would not sit as comfortably in your hand round 0 that is true it would still be comfortable i think yeah thing is like that it is not going anywhere particularly we c we could handle it i think maybe it could it could be on the bottom so you would not loo like if it is flat here so it sits up yeah like that 0 that would be nice ah it would fall over all the time though it would be annoying yeah it is less what is th ha yeah i g if it is weighted maybe h it has got higher center of gravity like that kay we are done designing details details okay come on so is this a good looking remote would we want to show it off to our friends 3 you would though cause it is bit it is more interesting than other remotes yeah i think it was another color and it was like i think it would look okay i think maybe a 2 yeah i mean i gue yeah it is personal taste but i would definitely go for that rather than like your average plain old remote like that but definitely in another color i am not happy with those colors yeah yeah okay so should we say 2 for that sure yeah yeah yeah okay question number 5 what is will people be willing to spend €25 on this product remember that 80% of users were willing to spend more money when a remote control looked fancy i think we have to market it in the right way that to say that it is simplistic yeah so people do not just see it and think this is so simplistic i do not want to spend €25 yeah we have to market it yeah it the marketing will have a lot to do with it yeah and the kinetic energy shaker style y whoo ooh no and the kinetic energy part yeah yeah shake it and the buttons fall off durable but you know those will be firmly on do not shake 0 no the plus no i guess i do not know much about the remote control industry how much your average sells for but i know i am are not i you are use the 0 make a new one but you are our marketing expert i think they are about 10 po £10 are not they about £10 but you do not have to buy batteries 15 so in the long term this can actually save you money yeah yeah that is true 0 so we will market it that way too exactly yeah exactly so yeah i think with a good marketing scheme and the personalisation options it will good point yeah i would give it a 2 still though yeah yeah yeah okay number 6 can someone read it out does this prototype match the operating behavior of the average user or yeah yeah so that was mainly that the statistics we said yeah i think it does very well 0 yeah because yeah because the most accessible buttons are the volume and the and the channel changing the zap yeah and it is just you will not have to think about it yeah you do not have to look down to find them they are clearly there easy to use yeah yeah i guess the i think the key word there is average cause there were some people that used the video input and sound and stuff simple yeah but they are not you and i really so yeah okay so one yeah yeah okay number 7 c heather could you push it down will this remote control be easy to find when lost remember that 50% of users lose their remote regularly now is there the is the alarm system still was it implemented we have the alarm system yeah the bu when you press the alarm system the lights behind the and it will vibra it yeah l lights on and or flash as well but i mean it is not obviously obvious from the outside that that is going to happen cause you can not s particularly see an alarm it will be again in the marketing i thought the light from the inside was going to light up yeah the light it will or or was it going to make a noise but yeah but when the alarm is not yeah but both if you you press the button it makes a noise right it turns into a duck and starts quacking yeah yeah you could s yeah 0 that would be brilliant yeah here i am awesome awesome i would be tempted to well the thing is if it was had an alarm system i mean when it when it lights up as we i mean it could light up when the alarm went yeah but if it was hidden underneath the cushion or something there would not be any point so you can not see the alarm but it would light up it would have to be in the market i though w it was going to make a noise okay yeah yeah but you still could not see it alarm but you can not see an alarm inside the alarm system itself it would just be a little speaker on the back or something okay we 0 you are just explaining why it is not on the prototype yeah but yeah it will be there yeah so we can we could say that 0 okay it w yeah whoo okay sorry we can give it a one because compared to every other remote ever m ever made this one will be easier to find yeah totally yeah okay sorry heather that was not very clear no problem question number 8 will it be easy to learn how to use this remote when brand new remember that 34% of users usually found it difficult so it has to be yeah it is eas they will pick it up and they will know what to do totally so the plu the plus w once that is written down on the page that will be really simple will not it the plus thing needs to be worked on yeah yeah i think just because it is we have decided to reduce it down to the basic buttons i think that in itself makes it so much easier to use yeah well yeah do does it make more sense for the middle one to be an just an enter button so then you would have to push 2 buttons every time at least yeah so it is just like channel 66 enter that kind of annoys me though when it is 06 when you have to press i do not know why yeah but you do not have to press zeros you could just press 6 enter or 12 enter 0 okay and or 66 enter y and then like 12 enter right alright aye yeah yeah yeah i think that is probably more straightforward yeah good yeah okay so we can we will say yes it is one i would say w yeah one yeah yeah okay ooh question number 9 0 will it minimize the effects of r s i which was repeated strain injury yeah injury which affected over a quarter of users s i think so it is like right in the but if you are zapping yeah your thumb might get a little bit yeah that is what i was thinking i do not think it will f we may have to do some more research into other strain injuries that we do not know about yeah the biology yeah but it is soft it is soft and and that is kind of what the and people could the powerpoint slide thing said would be good for r s i so maybe it is but yeah yeah i do not know what other options there are i think we are getting that is true yeah could i mean you could hold it in your left hand and d use your index finger but there is not really any other options unless it is like a keyboard so i think we did as as much as you can with a remote control yeah yeah yeah so one or 2 do you think i i would say t 2 i think yeah i think too yeah 2 okay yeah okay number 10 did we somehow incorporate the company color and logo yes we did yeah now is the color going to be there even if it is like vanilla n we we can not really do that because for example on the banana theme we can not have it as being yellow is the yellow it will not stand out so n it is not always going to be the same color it sounds like the color is something that we well yeah the colors are yellow and gray yeah gray yeah so it could be gray on the banana one yeah could be gray yeah but i mean the yell yeah d yellow is ugly though depending on the yeah that is right we did not even rea so i think we will have to talk to our executive managers and see if we can get away with just the r r yeah yeah i think this is the the factor that we have been least successful in confronting okay perhaps a metallic or or like that is gray and it would not be that expensive to have a little bit of metal yeah no yeah that is not rubber and the buttons in the middle okay yeah so do you think that is more of a 3 then 34 4 i think 4 well i do not what do what well we have good reasons for it so we but we can still put a hum a 4 okay okay okay and final question did we stay true to our motto and put the fashion into electronics current trends of fruits and veggies desire for sponginess i would say so following that briefing we did but maybe more like 2 cause there is no like pictures of fruit it is just sort of naming it by a fruit yeah yeah yeah with the with the colors like the color scheme names and stuff yeah no are the plates interchangeable i think i missed a few they are yeah yeah yeah so you can have banana and kiwi and okay yeah yeah yeah yeah okay so that is something that is kind of in the making too like maybe it will become more that is fashionable in itself to have interchangeable plates it is i think w yeah i think one well that was our brief and we followed the brief well we have not got a big banana but the thing is i think if somebody saw that and you said what was that inspired from i do not know if you would instantly say mango 0 yeah be like no no yeah maybe if it was scented 0 that would be class 0 yeah there we go that would be great yeah we have money for that alright so based on this evaluation do we average them out sorta thing yes we do so i wh what was i going to put for that a 2 for fashion 0 i would say 2 yeah 2 okay okay so our average there 5681011 1213151921 divided by 11 it is is one9 or something it is yeah i do not know these things between one and 2 between one and 2 between okay so that is pretty fantastic close to 2 yeah yeah that is very good cause the highest we could have got is one i got alright does that seem right then yeah cause we have a 4 to bring down okay aye it seems like it should be more around 2 yeah yeah should have added 5 do we have an online calculator i am attempting to do that right now this is okay yeah it is one9 ooh yay 0 wow well done go heather pauls well that is excellent yeah alright now with that over and done with our next step is to see if we are under budget and my computer is frozen and now it is not okay so in our shared folder if everyone could go there right now sorry i am going to steal a cable are you going to do that okay it is it is is that the project document it is an excel file 0 production costs yeah yeah kay there we go production costs and i have to access that as well it says it one moment kay so far i have added what i think or what is going on great it is blinking at me it is locked for editing read only i am going to open up a 2nd one then cause it is locked for editing i have the original in my my email account 0 is it locked cause i am in it i dunno i think it just means that we can not add any more to it now or okay have you have you completed it no 0 right no i was hoping that you guys could okay okay there we go okay here we go so we need to tally up how much our w our product will be costing so if you can look up at the screen the large screen 0 i guess looking at your own too and telling me which one you think yeah okay we are using kinetic which is quite a large expense at €3 yeah 0 right we are using a regular chip yeah it is cur it is double curved so its curved all around double double curved yeah that is another 3 we are already at 5 we are using plastic and rubber so yeah good thing plastic is free we are at 8 what about a special color s are we using that yeah i guess we should do it just for one kind yeah so it is like special color well we will have 2 colors right yeah well one color for the case one color for the buttons so we can yeah we have push button interface so that is inexpensive and we have a special color for the button and we also have a special form and a special material and a special material yeah oof which puts us just barely under budget hurray congratulations guys is good yeah good work guys so our operating cost is €1220 that is good awesome and back to our powerpoint so we have kay yes we are so we need to do a product evaluation again which is probably i dunno a different extension of a of the actual project rather than the product yeah a project is is yeah yeah cause we are talking about leadership teamwork so wh how we actually went round about doing it yeah alright so do you guys feel like there was room for creativity i think we were pushed pushed for creativity i mean we were not really given a lot of time or materials yeah to go about our design task the ma or materials yeah so i think we could have done with a bit more time ye okay so it would be like need more time and materials yeah but you were allowed m creativity yeah i think so as like but you were supposed to have creativ yeah and the conceptual and functional like we were very creative in in coming up with an idea i guess but m yeah yeah well we were just limited by resources really and like if we had decided to use the l c d screen when we can down to it yeah okay right and like solar power backup and everything then we would not have been able to afford that so that did limit creativity creativity right just resources okay but yeah the fruit and veg idea great leadership yeah is this me being like guys do you like me good leadership i think we stayed on task yeah yeah we did yeah we have seeing as we have come out with what we intended a pro a product within the budget i think that is a sign of good leadership and also our personal coach helped us along the way so you know yeah and the timing was good i think it has been fine we never were pushed for time or sat around doing nothing so yeah yeah good timing oop okay and project manager of course teamwork i think we worked great as a team yeah yeah yeah was good teamwork i think we are well suited to our roles yeah yeah alright how were our means we needed more play doh colors yeah yeah and more play doh cause that was all the red we had yeah so even if we wanted to make a bigger prototype we would not have been able to yeah it c it might have been bigger 0 really okay but ever everything else was satisfactory is that good yeah the computer programs are good yeah the yeah it could be really straightforward for the computer yeah i do not think there was anything i think the only thing was having to remember to you know to tick the okays but i think i was the only one who struggled with that yeah i am actually not sure if i have saved my presentations yeah they will probably still be there me too yeah new ideas found i do not really know what that means well i think we have all learnt stuff from each other like the n yeah yeah through discussion just about each different got new ideas from each other i am not sure new ideas found yeah well i guess we really it we bounced off of each other which was cool yeah yeah like based on marketing stuff and then you would say something about interface and yeah worked well yeah yeah and we were a able to modify each other is ideas yeah to fit in with our areas of expertise yeah each other is 0 does it have smart materials by the way sorry does it have smart materials 0 yeah 0 yeah well did it come into the into i dunno if we counted that in the costs if if it if it if it can be afforded okay well with that achieved our last slide is our closing slide yes our costs are within budget yes it is evaluated generally positively yeah and do not forget to complete final questionnaire and meeting summary then we celebrate in such a way that i have no idea by watching t v yay fantastic okay brilliant alright yeah thank you very much okay bye conclusion dadada
yeah there you go okay thank you okay thank you sorry 0 yeah why do we have 2 different microphones okay what would the difference yeah the difference interesting okay i can not see where the screen all right okay here we go there we go all right the agenda for this 0 all right the agenda for this meeting is we will initially have the prototype presentation by our 2 designers and then we will evaluate it given the criteria that we gave it and talk about our finances whether we were under or over our finances under or over our budget i have a spreadsheet where we can calculate our prices for every aspect of what we have made given our options and evaluate the product as a group okay and so 1st we will have the prototype presentation do you need the powerpoint for this yeah i have just got a few slides all right thank you this is a pretty good here we are this is what we came up with it is a pretty simple design it is based on a mango yeah 0 mango yeah and we have the company logo here and this will be the infrared and this will be the powerpoint the on off button 0 okay yeah sorry what was it where is the all the id it is in the middle of one of the other one is the power and we just have a sample design we wanted it all to be palm held yeah palm held and all the buttons are accessible on your thumb notice you have a number 10 button that was a mistake was not it right no 0 to make that one off sorry i was in charge of the number it is a problem and this is just that you have got like 11 or 12 the plus so one +one you can go one3 0 press a plus button then you go one 3 yeah 0 okay i have never heard of that kind before well we just thought we have all the numbers here so we wanted something representative of numbers larger than 10 yeah yeah because if you on your average remote if you press one twice you just go to or say you wanted channel 12 you press one then you go to channel one and then 2 then you would just go to channel 2 instead of 12 0 there is no 0 okay so if you just like one +2 you could go to channel 12 or 2 +2 is channel 10 would you have to go 0 +one if you wanted to go to channel one or 2 no no that is where we have all these numbers these numbers these numbers all work independently up to 9 yeah but i mean if you press it it will go to that channel right away yeah because you have got to press the plus afterwards 0 no the plus is going past number 9 yeah i know but if i want to go to say number 65 channel 65 if i press the 6 it will go to channel 6 and then i will press the +and then we will go to 6 and then put the 5 and we will go to 65 i do not know i would not thought you pressed plus number 65 but she is very i do not mind what are you saying define that i i would not have thought it would be a problem that it went to channel 61st yeah like on the way to channel yeah it would not be a problem yeah i am just wondering like as long as we realize that what it will do there is a delay on remotes i think where you can have it it is like a 52nd input time so as long as you hit them da da yeah yeah it should be fine as long as it is not a big pause between hitting the 2 buttons yeah so on the top there is volume and channel channel and volume up okay cool you could just feel like that without thinking about it right where is the power button it is in the network it is the bigger 0 okay so it is just like it is all accessible without taking your hand off the remote yeah yeah we went for like a circular design for the numbers because we thought that was kind of a more natural movement than just going like that with your thumb 0 okay ergonomics are all considered egonomics definitely ergonomic it might actually help with the repetitive stress injury it could cause another type of repress okay but yeah no i mean it is a different movement and the feel of it i mean we have made this out of plato which is representing the you know the rubber yeah spongy rubberness because it was said before in the material specification that this the this anti rsi materials often using stress bolts so this has got a you know a bit of give to it and yeah a bit of a stress bar feel yeah yeah feel it yourself yeah how it fits my goodness there you go thank you did you did you 0 it is nice 0 i think i killed the 5 i did 0 god okay as for the colors we were presented with a limited range of colors for this prototype but we are thinking that seeing as we are having it in interchangeable casing anyway that this is not necessarily a representation of the true colors that we are we would necessarily use all the combinations and we are thinking to carry on with the fruit and vegetable theme the color combination just could be named after different fruit like banana black and yellow watermelon red green or vanilla might be the most popular if it is just a blending more subtle creams it looks more a bit garish do you like vanilla and banana would banana is more representative of our color like the company the yellow and black yeah 0 okay yeah so that for corporate identity that would probably be the most strength i mean watermelon you know probably appealing kind of christmas you know yeah seasonal apple green brown more kind of trendy you know yeah the pomegon it is kind of girly and funky kind of cool yeah more to the more sophisticated customer yeah something that is like all of decor okay yeah we thought of the components it was definitely a focus of ergonomics and just a single handheld device i mean you do not need to use both hands one hand to hold this and type in with the other you can just use your thumb yeah as you said the rubber is probably used for rubber is probably used for comfort and anti rsi that is about it all right thank you very much good work everyone all right and so now that we have a prototype we need to go over the finances and seeing if this prototype matches what our budget can handle so i have something i am going to 0 wait a minute do you need to do a presentation 1st i do not know what order it goes in yeah i am going to check that out for a 2nd 0 yeah sorry you are right evaluation criteria is next to me yeah okay come on my computer sorry my computer is giving me technical difficulties just press out should i press it again last time i did that it just okay you are right and then again i think one more time 0 still out there yeah yeah yeah yeah okay now i think for this one i could would you guys prefer to use the whiteboard or maybe i will just do it on right on the screen where you can see it we are going to be doing an evaluation report together based on the prototype that we have just seen and looking looking back at my notes from our both our conceptual and our functional media i made a list of what our original requirements and goals were back to our kickoff meeting this morning and we will evaluate as to whether we have done what we set out to do and we are going to do it on a one to 7 scale where one is true and 7 is false so basically the lower the points the better okay so question number one does the remote whoops sorry 0 i am not going to be i will do it on the whiteboard i can not change it so i am going to ask you to push it down once okay i will write down our scores up on the okay so number one do we have a fancy look and feel feel i think it has been quite successful with the rubber coating the look is a little bit more playful yeah yeah yeah i guess it depends on your definition of fancy but it is definitely different it is not a traditional yeah yeah i think the color has a lot to do with it i mean the colors we were given for making the prototype are not the colors that i think we would have necessarily chosen it is not the kind of we are only given red and black red and yellow and orange yeah so and we do not want to go for black because most women are people who are black or gray we wanted to stand like that way in here but if you can imagine that in like as just maybe a kind of pale metallic y finish or something well i know it is for rubber i mean you can visualize this in nice colors i think it would look quite a healthy yeah i kind of like the potato look it is very good 0 well please i was my fruit and veg i was sorry the mango the mango we were we were so it is fine yeah fruit or vegetable depends on your mood yeah totally so i myself would say a one or a 2 i would say 2 personally i would say 2 okay one being true so i had 2 2 okay actually that is this may get confusing okay so question number 2 was is it technologically innovative so i know we have the connection energy which is very innovative yeah yeah and the use of the rubber use of the rubber the use of the rsi led the led use is not particularly innovative and we do not have any scroll buttons it is all push buttons there is no lcd control so if we are thinking about the rest of the market yeah it is sort of probably halfway in some aspects it is yeah and i think i mean it is tough to say because we we did not want it to be any more innovative than this because then we want it defeated the purpose so i mean i will put 3 but i think we actually reached our goal yeah we did not want it any more than that okay question number 3 will be easy to use i think so yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah i think it yeah yeah can not really get confused with that i mean there will be we had to work out the number the plus the plus system but once that is figured out yeah it should be fine turning on number 4 is this a good looking remote remember that 75% of users find most remote controls ugly again i think the color comes into this yeah color will definitely be a factor i think that the logo could be smaller yeah and maybe not such a prominent way but like at the bottom kind of remember the management said that it had to be prominent or just had to be on there i guess just not touch it this time is the 3 i killed i was just wondering if it should be like flatter i suppose i have got quite big i like the appeal of it being like a big glob yeah but you know what i have just thought of then where is it going to step in your loving room you are not going to fall off to the arm maybe if the bottom is just sort of flat yeah the bottom could be like chopped a bit but the animal is that is comfortable that is true it would still be comfortable things like that it could be on the bottom so you would not like if it is flat here so it sits up yeah like that 0 that was all over all the time yeah if it is weighted maybe details so is this a good looking remote would we want to show it off to our friends you would though because it is more interesting yeah i think it was another color and it was like i think it would look okay maybe 2 i mean i would definitely go for that rather than like your average remote like that but definitely in another color i am not happy with that with a color okay so should we say 2 for that sure yeah okay question number 5 was will people be willing to spend €25 on this product remember that 80% of users were willing to spend more money when remote control looked fancy i think we have have to market it in the right way but yeah to say that it is simplistic so people do not just say it and think this is so simplistic i do understand 25 yeah the marketing of lots doing it and the kinetic energy yeah yeah styley 0 no shake it in the buttes fall but you know those will be firmly on no i guess i do not know much about the remote control how much your average sells for but you are a marketing expert i know i am right i think they are quite 10 not right but you do not have to buy batteries so in the long term this can actually say even by market it exactly yeah so yeah i think with a good marketing scheme and the personalization options it will yeah i would give it a 2 yeah yeah okay number 6 can someone read it out does this prototype much the operating behavior the average user yeah yeah so that was mainly that yeah i think it is a because yeah because the most accessible buttons are the volume and the and the channel changing and it is just you will not have to think about it you do not have to look down to find them that clearly they are easy to use yeah yeah i guess the i think the keyword there is average because there were some people they use the video input and sound and stuff yeah but they are not you and i really so okay so one yeah okay number 7 heather can you push it down well this remote control be easy to find when lost remember that 50% of users lose their remote regularly we have the alarm system is the alarm system still was it implemented yeah when you press the alarm system the light yeah lights on the end or flash the ball but i mean it is not obviously obvious from the outside that is going to happen because you can not particularly see an alarm i thought the light on the inside is going to light up light it will but when the alarm is not yeah if you must the button makes the noise right yeah it turns into a duck and starts quacking yeah yeah awesome if it was had an alarm system i mean when it lights stuff i mean it could light up when the alarm went but if it was hidden underneath a cushion or something it would not be any point so you can not see the alarm but it would like that i thought okay it was going to make a noise yeah alarm we can not see an alarm inside it is the alarm system itself okay you just explain why it is not on the prototype but yeah it will be there so we can say that 0 okay we could give it a one because compared to every other remote ever made this one will be easier to find yeah okay sorry heather no problem question number 8 will it be easy to learn how to use this remote when brand new remember that 34% of users usually found it difficult totally it has to be yeah see they will pick it up and they will know it to do the plus thing makes we worked on once that is written down on the page that would be really something yeah i think just because it is we have decided to reduce it down to the basic buttons i think that in itself makes it so much easier does it make more sense for the middle one to be just an enter button so then you would have to push 2 buttons every time at least yeah so it is just like gentle 66 and 3 that kind of annoys me though and it is 0 sex when you have to press you can have to press 0 you can just press 6 enter 0 okay or like 12 yeah i think that is probably more straightforward yeah good yeah okay so we can we will say yes it is one yeah okay question number 9 we will minimize the effects of rsi which was repeated strain injury which affected over a quarter of users i think so so it is like right in the but if your thumb might get a little yeah i do not think it will we may have to do some more research and the other strain injuries that we do not know about it is soft it is soft and that is kind of what the and people powerpoint slide thing said would be good for yeah i do not know what other options we get yeah that is true because i mean you can hold in your left hand and use your index figure but there is not really any other options unless it is like a keyboard i think we did as much as you can with remote control yeah so one or 2 do you think i think yeah i think 2 okay okay number 10 did we somehow incorporate the company color and logo yes we did no is the color going to be there even if it is like vanilla is the yellow we can not really do that because for example on the banana thing we can not have always been yellow it will sound like it is not always going to be the same color it sounds like the color is something that we yeah the colors are yellow and gray gray yeah so it could be gray on the banana one yeah it could be gray yeah i mean the yellow is ugly though depending on that yeah that is right so i think we will have to talk to our executive managers and see if we can get away with just the rr yeah i think this is the the fact is that we have been leased okay perhaps the middle okay perhaps it is gray and it would not be that expensive to have a little bit of better right yeah that is the middle yeah okay so do you think that is more of a 3 then 4 4 well i think 4 well i do not but we have good reasons for it so we can still put a 4 okay okay and final question do we stay true to our motto and put the fashion into electronics current trends of fruits and veggies desire for sponginess i would say so following that brief in nature but maybe more like 2 because there is no like pictures of fruit it is just sort of naming it by a fruit yeah yeah like the colors you names yeah now are the plates interchangeable i think i missed yeah they are so you can have banana and kiwi yeah okay okay so that is something that is kind of in the making too like maybe it will become more that is fashionable in itself to have interchangeable plates i think yeah i think one well that was a brief thing as far as the place i think if somebody saw that and you said what was that inspired from i do not know if you would instantly say mango maybe if it was scented 0 yeah there we go that was great yeah we have money for that all right so based on this evaluation do we average them out sort of thing yes we do so what was i going to put for that 2 for fashion i would say 2 yeah 2 okay okay so our average there are 5 6 8 10 11 12 13 15 19 21 divided by 11 one9 i do not know these things it is between one and 2 between one and 2 okay so that is pretty fantastic yeah yeah that is very good because the highest you could have got is one all right that seems right then yeah yeah it is cool it has been going okay it seems like it should be more around 2 yeah yeah i am trying to we have an online calculation i am attempting to do that okay yeah it is one9 0 wow well good call that cause all right now with that over and done with done with our next step is to see if we are under budget and my computer is frozen and now it is not okay so in our shared folder if everyone could go there right now sorry i am going to 0 you are going to steal a cable okay if that is a project though it is it is it is an excel file 0 production cost yeah there we go production cost and i have to access that as well one moment okay so far i have added what i think what is going on great it is blinking at me it is locked for editing i am going to open up the 2nd one then it is locked for editing i have the original in my that email account or is it locked because i am in it i do not know i think it just means that we can not add any more to it now have you completed it no no i was hoping that you guys could okay there we go okay here we go so we need to tally up how much our product will be costing so you can look up at the screen the large screen i guess looking at your own too and telling me which one you think okay we are using kinetic which is quite a large expense of €3 yeah we are using a regular chip yeah it is double curved so it is curved all around it is another 3 we are already at 5 we are using plastic and rubber yeah so good thing plastic is free 8 what is a special color yeah i guess we should do it just for one kind yeah so it is like special color where we will have 2 colors right one color for the case one color for the buttons so we can we have push button interface so that is inexpensive and you have a special color for the button and we also have a special form and special material which puts us just barely under budget hooray congratulations good work guys so our operating cost is €1220 awesome and back to our powerpoint so we have okay yes we are so we need to do a project evaluation again which is probably i do not know a different extension of the actual project rather than the product yeah a project is it yeah because we are talking about leadership team work so how we actually went around about doing it yeah all right so did you guys feel like there was room for creativity i think we were pushed pushed for creativity i mean we were not really given a lot of time all of the materials yeah to go about our design task so i think we could have done it a bit more time okay so it would be like need more time and materials yeah but you were allowed creativity yeah i think so was like but you were supposed to yeah and the conceptual and functional like we were very creative in coming up with an idea i guess yeah well we were just limited by resources we could down okay if we had decided to use the lte screen and like solar power backup and everything and we would not have been able to afford that so that did limit creativity right just easy but yeah so you know that is what i did great yeah leadership is this me being like guys do you like me good leadership i think we stayed on task yeah we did as soon as we have come out with what we intended a product within the budget i think that is the sign of the leadership and also our personal coach helped along the way so you know and the timing was good we never were pushed for time or sat around doing nothing yeah yeah there is a little coke i think i work as a team yeah yeah i think we are well suited to our roles yeah yeah all right how are our means  we needed more play doh colors yeah and more play doh because that was all of the red we had so if we wanted to make a bigger process 0 really we would not have been able to okay whatever was satisfactory is that yeah the computer programs are good yeah it could be really straightforward for a computer yeah i think the only thing was having to remember to you know tick the okay so i think i was the only one who struggled with that i am actually not sure if i am safe by presentation yeah they will probably still be there new ideas found i do not really know what that means i think we have all learned stuff from each other yeah yeah just about each different fact so we have got new ideas from each i am not sure new ideas found yeah well i guess we really we bounced off of each other which was cool yeah like based on marketing stuff and they need to say something about interface and yeah and we were able to modify each other is ideas yeah yeah 0 does it have smart materials by the way sorry does it have smart materials 0 yeah well did it come in the i do not know if we counted that no cost okay okay okay so with that achieved our last slide is our closing slide yes our costs are within budget it is evaluated generally positively and do not forget to complete final questionnaire and meeting summary then we celebrate fantastic in such a way that i have no idea okay brilliant all right thank you very much okay bye