so is why not save that no you will ha have to open it up from elsewhere do you want to replace existing file no i actually tried to transfer it to my documents but yeah you have to you have to close that window cause that is the save one is not it so and then find it spreadsheet yeah but i have ta right i will just re do it that is the easiest way right well we have made our prototype anyway we can have a good look at that you pass it round to have a look y no it is a slightly curved around the sides very nice it is almost curved like up to the main display as well and the little line at the bottom indicates the bit the panel that you pull down and the extra function buttons are below that panel on the little line and we have got the stick on the button with the company logo on we also have a apple slash cherry design at the top so it is yeah cherry would be alright actually yeah yeah it is a bit more fun is not it and it is kinda not really at a kind of you think apple you think computers like apple mac yeah yeah we might get a copyright yeah what is this this one yeah and cherries are fun summery what is that one there ah that is the mute 0 okay for the m right it it would probably have to be labeled mute huh but we did not have anything small enough to write they are thinking okay for the 1st time well it was hard to get the h the actual labeling on the individual buttons yeah we just chose simple shapes for all them the important ones are the volume ones so we made them a bit bigger the mute could possibly be a bit smaller hum you separate off in color the volume related buttons from the channel related buttons so you have got the volume in orange on design there and the the channel is in blue yeah r right yeah and we chose a v +and v minus all these things have cost implications and so when i done my thing on cost a i had assumed that the only button that would be a different color would be the the red apple button so however i have now but yeah so but there would be a cost implication on that i will see if i can find them and as i suppose that so whether wanted to put in all these colors would be open to debate i suppose yeah sis well the colors would not like that is they would not be too important but we did not have any white play doh have so that is where the color buttons came from an important consideration right okay so and the 2nd one underneath would be the idea for the yes we will have the slide away right okay bottom so we have got detail design meeting right so so we have got prototype presentation which we have just done evaluation criteria and finance so i guess w we have to evaluate if that meets the various aspects that we are looking for from our previous meeting so other than the fact that it does not have the 2nd layer but obviously obviously it would but other than that we got the red apple we got the buttons and the only thing that has really changed is the is the colouration of the buttons yes yes and the bit after the evaluation criteria is is the finance right okay and the and the cost implication the only snag about this is that the cost is probably kind of important so and then the production evaluation as to how easy that would be to to manufacture and whether it would so if you had to do a presentation or will you just work it on the prototype that is it this this is a yes this is our presentation of the prototype that is the pr okay right so as far as the the finance of it would be concern would be to make sure that the cost aye the production cost cause you may remember that was one of the 1st considerations was to be in d under 1250 or €25125 so there is no redesign so that should right so seems to me that the thing that i have to do is is quickly find that could we get this on the board just so we can see or do you mean do you have the figures there we should plug it in right do you want to plu do you want to plug it in into the the back of that one okay kay alice so sh we could do it as we d go along the production costs looking at the prototype right kay this should be then okay so by the fact that we have got the simple chip and the kinetic energy source we have got a single curved case we have got a rubber case materials supplements so we had decided that we are having rubber buttons and have a push button interface okay w the button supplements well originally i thought there would just be one in there because it was the one red apple but so the so the real w the real question then would come in do you make all the buttons well do we will do it on the prototype so do 2 see how much it is 0 well so we have got one special button form which was the apple everything else is going to be a standard yeah yeah and then we would have we have got special material rubber wood titanium et cetera and that so i was originally i was thinking rubber was not special but according to this maybe it is so and the r i mean effectively we have got 16 buttons that we are going to have on there yeah i think you just do one do not you for the w i do not know is is is the sort of answer is that meant to be all 16 buttons and therefore i mean what is the op the option was maybe not to have rubber buttons but just to have the one that was soft and spongy and therefore i think i think it is just it is just a one else whereas it would be the special color would be for the so you would only have the one special button that was rubber whereas the rest would be hard plastic i thi i think i think the button supplement i is just a supplement for all the buttons made in a different material rather than per button i do not know though i would every design change is i dunno okay if we just had all the buttons as standard except for the one red apple then that would take care of that i guess we would have one special color and one special button form and when i plugged that in last time remember it has to be under 125 as far as i know that that took care of the of the various supplements and if what happened you have just gone off the window into another one it is on the bottom row maybe if you just minimize that one in the top right hand corner of the little box yeah now right okay so but the point would be that if we if we just did special sorry you were saying that it would be that one that you would put in one there yeah yeah okay so that is 9 one there so we have got some so it well is it s is no it is 97 i have got kay okay just give us a bit of so that would that would work out fine if as assuming your correction are are assuming that that one change covers all the buttons then that would be fine and there is nothing else as far as i can see that we we had planned to put on s i switching around those th on the electronics we got the sample sensor at the moment we have just got the simple chip which costs one i guess the sample sens sample speaker would be the voice recognition thing which puts up to 4 huh yeah we should be slightly over our budget but if we gather something else down to slightly lower standard yeah and maybe go with the one the special form buttons then we could have the speech well hold on if we okay that gives us 127 so maybe if we got rid of like the maybe one of the special colors kept them all the same color then we could have the voice recognition without but remember that the idea was to keep it the color of the 0 i see so just take out the special color for the apple and yeah yeah d would not you have to keep the simple chip there as well you know how you turn that one to a 0 would not the chip and the sample speaker be separate things so you need both of them yeah we have to have it 0 possibly yeah yeah maybe yeah maybe we would be giving up on the kinetic and go for battery instead yeah that would give you one less we should yeah that would save us one though we would still be slightly ov but you reckon that i i mean the thing is that you wanted to a appeal to people and not have to replace batteries yeah yeah well since it is the through the whole technology type thing you were saying in the market research that people like kind of interesting gadgets in them whether they would figure the the s sample senor and the sample speaker voice recognition be sort of a worthwhile thing to have and then still have the batteries or whatever they would prefer not you know what i mean the the problem was the battery is running out and losing the losing the remote yeah so you got to decide which of those is more important to them but which do you think or which do we think is the more important of the options i think the voice recognition in a sense at the moment we have got a total which we need to reduce down by one2 at least remember that was a minimum requirement the other option if we are planning on just going for something cheap and cheerful would be to make it originally we are going to make it a simple product shall we shall we evaluate the prototype as we have got it now 1st and then sort of make decisions about what needs to be changed after yeah makes sense okay okay right i have a little thing so we have all got a note of it is 137 is not it with everything we want on sorry do you want that back up yeah i just had a presentation to right do but i do think the v voice recognition thing would be more impressive than the fact that it has got no battery okay but remember the main the only reason we were planning on having the voice recognition was so that they could find the remote if it got lost right okay this is about the evaluation criteria that we use for the the prototype we have got here and so the method is that the design team makes a prototype and we evaluate the prototype against some criteria that we have formulated and those ones are going to be in response to sort of market research and also finance i guess and do that on a scale from say true being one and false being 7 so if it is neither true nor false then that is 4 so i got a set of criteria just based on the marketing that we need to add in a financial one as well at the end so we have to say whether it is true or false that the product looks and feels fancy the whether the product demonstrates technical innovation whether it is easy to use whether it is incorporating sort of the fashion element to attract the buyer and whether it is a sort of recognizable real reaction product and i have to go up onto the whiteboard and do this apparently so i will go over here okay right so the 1st one is does the product look and feel fancy so if we do a sort of a one so okay well we have a single curve which was maybe like the feel of the product is quite good yeah so okay then we have the rubber kinda spongy feel which was in at the time yeah yeah sorry that would be considered fancy yeah yeah i would maybe give it a a 2 of but i think what is one false or is t one true i forgot one is true one is true and okay 7 is fal 4 is neutral okay and a 4 is neutral so so maybe maybe a 2 yeah cause we have not got the double curve so we can not like say it is completely true go for one right but it is pretty close yep we have got almost everything we can okay okay right i going to put underneath so i have got some more space so false is 7 true is one and so say about a 2 for fancy you think yeah yeah okay yeah why not not m m maybe nearer 3 okay well d you do an average at the end i do not know 23 well it is just that saying something remember that when you look down we have got solar power we have got various other things you could have and we are not going for these options huh this this is just this is just for like the look does it sort of look fancy rather than functional so yeah i suppose that might be in the technical innovation bit yeah so that so sh should we go for a a 2 on that okay kay and i mean how much does the product demonstrate technical innovation do you reckon deciding between the kinetic power or the speech recognition and if we had either of those for our budget they both show a reasonable amount of speech recognition d yeah okay so what about the pr the prototype as it is we have got we have got the speech recognition on it have not we but not the kinetic but not the kinetic like the power no cause you can not afford that w we took that out too no we c ca yeah we can not afford both alright so did not you or so it does not it is pretty the prototype as it is is not sort of fulfilling the no may is maybe about neutral plus it it it has got something but it has not got maybe a 3 okay yeah well wait a minute in 137 we do have kinetic i would give it more than a 4 the problem is we have to reduce down from there to get it down to 125 right okay and one way of doing that would be to take out the kinetic so it is very much dependant on what you do with your options right okay and if you are definitely going for the sample sensor and sample speaker kay then because that the other functions we have got in are are more at the the special material the rubber wood titanium et cetera if you go for that th that is at the high end cause that is 6 whereas down at just special colors is 2 now you are trying to lose one2 so it seems to me that if you are going for the sample sensors speaker you are basically then having to go for the cheaper options on everything else okay and and the simple way to do it would be to have a battery to have your sample sensor speaker and then you are looking to take out 2 which would be come from the button supplements category s i am just going to check my email i am just going to check exactly what it said in the email for the product how much of a difference would it make if we made the case in plastic because we did say that we do not want to follow the fashion too much if the buttons are rubber that might be spongy enough and then it stand the test of time better interface type well plastic rather than rubber okay but i that that that would make the significant difference you could either you could have it if you have a in plastic rather than rubber then that would enable you to get you could keep kinetic then you could keep your sample sensor and you would be looking to take out 2 so you could fiddle that down your special form at the bottom or your special color at the bottom and that would enable you to to do it okay so it says if we make a slightly more fancy then we lose points innovation and if we make it more innovative innovative then we lose points on it being fancy so yeah yeah ye i just read the email again and it sort of says it is evaluate the design sort of as it is i think so i think we need to think about finance after we have sort of evaluated that design i do not know whether we are doing it in the wrong order or something or well okay but well i suppose it is rubber as it is is not it it is rubber as it is yes so i mean does this need to go up a bit or something cause we have got both the both the we got we have we have got 137 and we have got it in at the moment and if and basically we are going to reduce down from that the speech yeah yeah but the current one you would say would be fancy would be too yeah yeah yeah for for innovation so we have got the speech the speech thing and i would have said about a 2 as well do you reckon a 2 yeah 2 or 3 i would be happy with a 2 okay 0 2 and the next one is i will have to get it back up now the next on well i can just sing about easy to use i would have said yes i would go for a one on that at this point in time yeah okay yeah i would say so as well incorporates elements of fashion to attract buyer well yeah it certainly has some yeah it has got the cherry and the sponginess it does yeah yep say about a 3 maybe i do not know yeah m yeah it was just doing it quite well maybe 2 i think we are going to have to lose some of these but the moment as it stands it is yep yeah i would have said 2 would seem reasonable it is a 2 the product is a recognizable real r reaction product yeah this is the sensor using all of its all of its products all of its buttons and it has got a fairly big label on the bottom saying this yeah that is a bit rough at the minute yeah where it comes from so this is about sort of the corporate image of like new sort of sleek technology and all that sort of thing 0 as well as having the logo on and all that okay so sort of is it sort of a recognizable product does it fit in with our other other products which are sort of coffee makers and spacecraft s well it has got the same speech feature as the coffee machine what do y also it is kind of spongy rubberiness is maybe bit more kinda comfortable than kinda sleek and new age yeah it depends which way you look at it huh okay so we are going for a so maybe a kind of 3 23 d 2 or 3 yeah 2 or 3 well the logo would be more recognizable on the actual thing it is just that the pen would not really write on that paper sure but yeah i think the logo would definitely be recognizable and it does have attributes that other products do 2 aye go for it right okay 2 or 3 2 how right come on 2 that is that decided okay right so right so we are now on to changing it to get it to fit in with the budget requirements and then yeah what does what do all them numbers mean then do we add them up and rate or anything yeah we s yeah i think we sort of add them up so sort of at an average is going to be i am just going to do this in my head about a 2 2 one8 is not it or something i think anyway so yeah pretty close to a 2 yeah so it is so so it is i mean it is pretty good at the moment but it is going to get worse is not it but we have got to try and make sure it does not get too bad yep so should we get so are definite was it 137 was the definite price rule if has 2 b 2 b 2 yeah yes yeah okay so we need to well you can lose one2 and still meet the requirements do you want to plug it into yours so we can get up the okay well i put it back on the finances so i guess this is this the last stage once we sort out the finances part of it i am not sure we will probably have to re rate it yes i would have thought so yeah yeah we will make the adjustments and then see how are rates are going yeah okay so what was it control f 8 was not it ah it is on it is come on already 0 0 how kind right okay so you can see there that the if you want to keep kinetic right you have got a choice there of going down to battery which would save you one you have got the sample sensor and and sample speaker which is your big item 0 actually we just have a plastic case then we lose 2 points which gets us that is right which gets you in right within the budget range yes yeah i think that would be fine because that was just a trend and we do have rubber buttons anyway so that is 117 and then we could make sure we definitely had all the button supplements yeah different different colors yeah alright yeah i was i was thinking that because maybe maybe the sort of rubber case is a bit less in sort of the corporate identity than the sort of you know sleeker plastic case possibly yeah yeah okay so and that would allow us to have all the technical innovations so we would lose a little bit on the maybe kind of so we are going for plastic yes lose a little bit on the fashion yeah but yep 0 yeah and that would now be yeah that is that is within the budget and then do we actually have do we just have one special special forms down here well w there was debate as to how you would count them you got special color well originally i was assuming we had the red apple and therefore that was the special color yeah i think we should just imagine white buttons and we we have we have got we have got enough for another we have got nought 8 left so we have got enough for another yeah well we have got special form now that would be one button and the question was was that all buttons or is that just one button cause our plan really was to have one button only with a special so so no matter how you look at that that would be the same yeah but the but but but the the other thing would then be special material rubber wood titanium i think maybe the special color we have got 3 now just because the volume buttons are different yeah i guess we would have the ones which are blue at the moment would would just be the standard color alright so special color you want 3 in there yeah which i think we should yeah they will still be fine for the for the price okay well i thin i think you you you just need 2 for the special color cause it is just 2 supplements you know one original color and then sort of 2 supplements i think maybe that makes sense okay that is probably it okay yeah so we only ne we only need 2 for that okay cause i mean these these are molded the one color is going to be molded out of a piece of plas of rubber is not it okay yeah i would agree with that i think so special colors 2 right and we have got special form is the one apple the rest are all standard although you could argue that should maybe be you were making these buttons down the bottom i was presuming bigger than the other ones or were you ne was that the idea yeah the volume ones should stand out a bit maybe that will be a 2nd supplement yeah that then there is a spe a 2nd special form huh yeah i would have thought that is probably about r well well you got you got 12 okay so tha so i think that should still be okay yeah that is 123 so we are still right within budget on that yep that makes sense so decide we have lost a little bit on the fashion and lost a bit on the fancy kinda side of it yep but generally speaking we have kept the other attributes to the i would have said so yeah so you would maybe put fash fan fashion at 3 rather than 2 that is without so shall we do a well yeah and specially it definitely could fits the the real product what was the what is the company name real reactions real reaction produ i am not quite sure what does that mean r yeah yeah yeah yeah i mean it still seems definitely fit that p so that is like if that is the new age kind of inno innovative yeah so c type company then having the kinetic feature and the voice recognition is p quite high up on yep i would s so it is w if we have if we have put in for another special form on a button then maybe they could be a different shape like we got a cherry one maybe other ones could be something else shaped i do not know that would be poss seeing as seeing as it is cheaper to make them a different you mean of seeing as we have got you know we have made it a a special form so and that would sort of maybe keep us close on the sort of the fashion type one and it would sort of you know keep it quite fancy as well i do not know well you could argue you might do it once a year you would change because at the moment you are making a red apple yeah so it is a well you could so next year you could make next year is model the same but have it as a a yeah whate whatever a lemon yeah whatever fruit was in fashion next year yeah l a lemon lemon or something yeah i mean the volume buttons could be lemons or something maybe and that amount okay so we have what have we what have we rid of we got rid of the plastic yeah we have the main thing we have changed really is the casing is not it is it the rubber that yeah that was that was just about all we have yeah i think we have saved quite a bit because we have just got the push button interface which is by far the cheapest yeah but so maybe in a sense not having that maybe we have lost some maybe lost something on the innovation side i dunno and that is like the most standard type of button so i mean we have got we got rid of the rubber case but we have now s we now sort of got an extra form and an extra color for the buttons so maybe in terms of sort of fanciness and fashionability we are pretty much the same maybe yeah so i mean we could maybe put 2 again on them and everything else has stayed pretty much the same so well ease has certainly stayed yeah plus if anything that is special forms makes it slightly easier to yeah yeah yeah to use and what about the sort of innovation well we have still got the kinetic energy do you think okay and the speech feature yeah the speech feature and then the corporate identity i think we have cut just about the same we have maybe lost has not it it is hard to tell how the rubber the rubber casing would really affect how it would play out yeah yeah 0 whether whether that is considered to be sort of part of the corporate identity i do not know i mean it is maybe not i mean but i think more the the features of the actual control will be more important than maybe than the the actual esthetics but yeah yeah but either way i think we have made it fairly close to what yeah okay well i mean yeah i do not see how we could make it any more apart from maybe we cou doing the whole thing in the kinda light shade of blue like the casing but then what color would you make the r s just the the company logo so maybe there is like a set design which we get printed off well but you have got the company logo on there which would effectively be a stick on badge yeah okay so you are in a sense you are comparing the product without the company logo yeah and then y but you have got the space for it to stick it on yeah yeah hey what what what is the company color did you get told what the company color is or i am still not quite sure we have established that no i just we got the logo off the web browser do not think so but but i but in the sense that as you saw with the windows logo badge it does not really matter 0 right there is virtually n the way that you frame you know the windows badge on there it really does not matter what color it is so long as our company is logo is framed w in the same way as that with a like a black outline fact they have got black and white or black and silver so basically even if you had a silver the same color of silver on your display because you have got effectively a double edging on the on the logo it means that it splits off what your logo is from the from the product and that is actually quite a sneaky way of doing it okay huh cause you have got sort of we have got 2 to play with if you really wanted to you could put in another well in this one you have actually got 3 colors of buttons another color or would that be t yeah well we decided that the blue ones were the the standard color okay so you were talking about we are assuming that all the buttons on the 2nd panel the hidden away panel would all be standard yeah yeah which m may or may not be the case yeah shall we save the 2 for profitability then well yeah bu but but was the was there not a button that you were thinking of on the on the other opt you know on the 2nd page as it were that you were thinking of maybe having as a different color i do not think they would really need to be i think if they were just all small round blue buttons it would be fine yeah maybe we have m needs to be an enter button but could just be the same as well maybe for the the one they are going to see all the time we make it look good and fit the kind of idea of what they want and then for the more functional buttons we do not worry too much about that and just have that as like a plus it is hidden away anyway you are not going to see it at the start yeah i mean it is the sort of thing that i mean you want to pick up the controller and just hit a button quickly to change the channel or volume yeah well so if it is dead obvious then that is fine but if you are opening the panel and you are looking and you are tuning then you are paying a bit more attention so it may be sort of different color buttons is not so important alright okay cause you yeah yeah so so we just add that to profitability in effect yeah i mean so we have dropped the cost but right so we are meant to finish up in 5 minutes same sort of function the criteria it is alright kay just made a load of money should not we maybe lose a point on fashion go to a 3 cause we have lost the overall spongy feel cause it does not seem right that it just has not changed at all well but i think we said that w because you got rid of the rubber we put an extra an extra sort of fruit shape on one of the buttons alright le lemon sh did we decide what that was which button it was i think well we could have lemon shaped ones with the volume ones or something on the volume ones right or something like that that is good yeah definitely lemon shaped did did you have to have a rubber case though for rubber buttons or was it the other way around you had to have rubber buttons if you had the rubber case right okay so i think we can we are okay so we are okay this way around yeah so that so we have saved until the design team comes in and says get off but you are the design team then we say it is fine so it is all good saved €2 on that so what bit are we on to can i just check if that is a cherry or an apple did we decide against the apple because of apple mac and did we make it a cherry officially yeah i th i th 0 right right okay just in case we need that 2 for lawsuits and such like 0 drats i have botched that have not i so were we aiming for a certain target on that scale well we are aiming for one for all of them m but it really has to fit into the budget so right i guess we just have to adjust things to get it i in the which is fair enough and we seem to have least something in each criteria yeah we have not completely left anything out so yeah i think most as an overall product which has to be quite cheap we have just about achieved yeah everything yep so do we have anything else to discuss i do not know what is on the agenda right okay what is happened here right okay right okay right so we got we have got the closing so we have done the the finance bit and the excel project and the we have done the redesign so we are now on to project process now satisfaction with for example room for creativity leadership teamwork means et cetera whiteboard digital pens et cetera so we are actually now in a sense on to the evaluation of the course rather than the evaluation of the project is m my understanding of it huh so what did you and remembering that nobody is just over the curtain so finish your meeting now we should just go through this quickly and then huh yeah so i suppose the easiest way of doing it is to put some notes down which i will do okay so i think i have to finish that page 0 right okay so project evaluation so creativity did you feel you got a chance to express yourselves well enough yeah yeah well yeah i thought some of the divisions though between sort of the individual meetings were a bit arbitrary individual meetings how do you mean yeah well we were finding out various things in in you on your own in be in between the meetings and they did not the one meeting did not always follow on for the other one you know sort of we had things thrown in at the 2nd meeting where you know you would looked at the remote controls and seen the curviness but in the 1st one you would also looked at some remote controls and looked at the buttons and i do not understand why it would be in separate meetings that you would do that you know you would sort of you would probably present it at one or something like that the only thing you find is in a manufacturing process you would normally you go to a meeting you decide right you do this you do that you do that yeah then you go away you find out information you then come back you then discuss it you then go and change things around and then go back huh yeah so yeah i suppose and then be going out and finding more information each time and then diff things will be relevant whereas this time you are really getting it from a database source so it is not well anyway yeah yeah so what do you want to put down i have put seemed okay creativity seemed okay flow of information on on any given subject given subject sometimes disjointed yeah i think it maybe could have been a slightly more creative project i mean a remote control is not the most yeah the thing itself kind of fancy thing that you could imagine designing i can not think of a better example at the minute yeah have could have used a different example pel to increase create yeah is this go it kinda kis fits the purpose that it was something everyone knows about and then creativity something we can at least look at and think how we can improve on you have to do it within a set time frame is the other thing so yeah but think like it was a bit restrictive just to say that you have to design a television remote control in a way i mean it depends what sort of business you are in i guess i mean this one seems from the website it looks it is quite innovative but we are coming up with some bucket shop product are not we that is you know 15 quid one of those things like companies can have like a range of products and i th i d i do not know how it works but i guess that something got sent out and have like a brief to kind of but the other thing is that they are i am guessing that they are trying to use this software to to demonstrate how you could do a project i mean m my wife at the moment for instance is acting as a computer for you normally yeah you got a problem so you go to your tutor and find out information to see how to get it fixed so what she is doing is she is having to spend a day at the computer terminal at one end so that any student that comes along can ask whatever question and then you or the idea is that the whichever person is at the other end can point them in the right direction show them where to either give them directly give them help or secondly point them in the right direction either at the library or or or come back or go and see joe bloggs or whatever so and that was a project i suspect similar to this because they they were actually trying to debug the computer software to enable to enable it to work and of course you had the machine crashing and various things going wrong yeah well sh we look at the last slide see if it has got anything else so i think there is 11 more to go alright so we have got yeah i mean if you look at their products on their website here real reaction i mean it is all pretty high tech and cutting edge new ideas found did we find any no and it was quite good with this the white board having that and the digital pens like that is something that made it a little easier alright yeah yeah leadership teamwork we did find a new idea i mean sort of a kinetic remote control i have never seen one of them before batteries i think so voice recognition especially not could does yeah you have got voice recognition computers that is not remote controls yeah yeah well it is a different application of it yeah so it is just like the same products but just put together in a different way okay so how do you reckon teamwork went that went okay yeah yeah i guess we all had separate ideas and then discussed them yeah yeah to go reasonably well okay i do not think sort of the budget allowed us to do anything bit bit arbitrary well i mean i do not think it i just do not think it fitted in with the rest of their products i mean they have got all these sort of you know high definition d v d and portable 7 inch d lightweight computer screens and i am thinking do you know one cheap remote control does not really fit in so we are m we are meant to comment on leadership and the means e g whiteboard digital pens et cetera surely they they should produ well leadership is a bit of a funny one is not it and and new i new ideas found was the the other thing yeah but we can not really all fairly comment on leadership because you are the project manager you were the leader so our experience of leadership was not really as much as yours yeah yeah now i would much rather be in marketing but i certainly did not get this computer to work as well as i would have liked however alright means so whiteboard so really it is equipment 0 yeah it worked yeah very nice comput computers could be a bit difficult at times but but i mean i d i do not i am not sure i see the value in these i mean they record what you are writing and then what do you do with it where do you get the recording do you plug the computer or something i think there is a little there is a little chi so it is not just for us it is for the experiment as a whole so there is a little there is a little chip i think you must plug it into something and it produces a should we quickly look at the last slide sh right i think you watch a video of it kind of i do not know whether it just produces a big image of sort of everything you have written or something and page after page right new ideas found so one or 2 yeah kinetic powered remote control what was the other one voice recognition thing vo yeah and voice was it voice activated voice recognition yeah recognition s almost to fill in these fill in these questionnaires pretty much right so are the costs within budget yes 0 no is the project evaluated yes do not forget to complete final questionnaire and meeting summary then celebration is that everything i think that we have got 2 questionnaires and a report on the last meeting yeah so we do not re so really i tried to save this the last time at 123 and it did not seem to have saved anywhere mind you the the figure last was was different but it should be poss
so i will not save that no you have to open up from elsewhere the red exist do you want to replace it as the phone now i actually tried to transfer it to my documents but yeah you have to close that window because that is the save one is not it i will find it i will take a spreadsheet yeah but i will just redo it it is the easiest way well we are a prototype any way i do not have a pretty little it is like the curved on sides it is almost curved up to the main display as well and the little line at the bottom indicates the panel that you pull down and the extra function buttons are below that panel and we have got the stick on the bottom with the company no one we also have an apple slash cherry design at the top so it is yeah cherry will feel right actually yeah it is a bit more fun is not it and it is kind of not related to kind of to kind of you think apple you can computer type of yeah yeah we might get a copy that yeah what is this one that one that is the meat 0 that is the m it might it probably have to be labeled meat because we did not have anything small in it right well the prototype model is hard to get the ham the actual agent on the the original button yeah we just choose simple shapes for all them the important ones are the volume made them a bit bigger the mute could possibly be a bit smaller we separated off in color the volume related buttons from the channel related buttons you have got the volume in orange on the design there and the channel one would be right all these things have cost implications and so when i have done my thing on cost i had assumed that the only button that would be a different color would be the red apple button so however i have no longer figures that i did for that but yeah so there would be a cost implication on that and i suppose that so whether wanted to put in all these colors would be open to debate i suppose well the colors would not be too important but we did not have any wide played or an important consideration right okay so and the 2nd one underneath would be the idea for the yes not the slide away okay so we have got detailed design meeting right so we have got prototype presentation which we will just an evaluation criteria and finance so i guess we have to evaluate if that meets the various aspects that we are looking for from our previous meeting so other than the fact that it does not have the 2nd layer but obviously it would but other than that we have got the red apple we have got the buttons the only thing that has really changed is the coloration of the buttons and the bit after the evaluation criteria is the finance and the cost of location the only snag about this is that the cost is probably kind of important so and then the production evaluation as to how easy that that is would be to manufacture and whether it would so if you had to do a presentation or are you just working on the prototype right so as far as the finance of it would be concerned we would be to make sure that the cost the production cost because i remember that was one of the 1st considerations was to be under 1250 or 25 €125 so there is no redesign so that should right so it seems to me that the thing that i have to do is can we get us on the board just so if you can you right okay we could do as we can go along the production cost right okay the simple chip and the kinetic energy source we have got a single curved case we have got rubber case materials supplements so we had decided that we are having rubber buttons and okay the button supplements well originally i thought there would just be one in there because it was the one red apple but so the real question then would come in do you make all the buttons well we have got one special button form which was the apple everything else is going to be as standard we have got special material rubber wood titanium etc so i was originally i was thinking well rubber was not special but according to this maybe it is so and i mean effectively we have got 16 buttons that we are going to have on there yeah i think you just do one but well i do not know is the sort of answer is that meant to be all 16 buttons and therefore i mean what is the option was maybe not to have rubber buttons but just to have the one that was soft and spongy and therefore i think it is just a one else whereas it would be the special color would be for the so you would only have the one special button that was rubber whereas the rest would be hard plastic i think the button supplements is just a supplement for all the buttons it has been made in a different material i do not know i would every design change is i do not know okay if we just had all the buttons as standard except for the one red apple then that would take care of that i guess we would have one special color and one special button form and when i plugged that in last time you does not remember it has to be under 12 and a half as far as i know that that took care of the various supplements and if i am i am i am just gone off the window it is on the bottom road it is on the bottom road now right okay so but the point would be that if we if we just did special sorry you were saying that it would be that you would put in one there yeah okay so that is 9 one less we have got some so it was no it is 97 i have got okay so that would that will work out fine if assuming your correction or assuming that one change covers all the buttons then that would be fine and there is nothing else as far as i can see that we had planned to put on switching on those on the electronics we have got the sample sensor in the moment we have just got a simple chip which costs one i guess the sample sensor sample speaker would be the voice recognition thing yeah which puts up for 4 we should be slightly over our budget both together or something else that is slightly lower standard we do not know the one of the special 4 batteries that we can have well hold on if we okay that gives us 127 maybe if we go with the maybe one of the special colors kettlew is the same color then we could have the voice but remember that the idea was to keep it the color of the 0 i see so just take out the special color for the apple and yeah yeah and would not you have to keep the simple chip there as well you know how you turn that one in the chip and the sample speak there would be separate things 0 possibly yeah maybe we would be giving them the connecticut and go for battery instead that would give you one less but you reckon that i mean the thing is that you wanted to appeal to people and not have to replace batteries yeah yeah i said this is the whole technology type thing you were saying in the market research to people like kind of interesting gadgets and whether they were figure the sample sensor and the sample speaker always recognition it is over worth while things to have and then the battery is or whatever they would prefer you know what i mean the problem was the batch is running out and losing the yeah losing the remotes you have got to decide which of those is more important but which do you think or which do we think is the more important of the options in a sense of the moment we have got a total which we need to reduce down by one2 at least remember that was a minimum requirement the other option if we are planning on just going for something cheap and cheerful would be to make it and originally we are going to make a simple product shall we evaluate the prototype as we have got it now 1st and then sort of make decisions about what needs to be changed make sense right have a little thing so we have got it is 137 is not it with everything we want on sorry do you want that yeah i just had a presentation to right i do think the voice recognition thing would be more impressive when the fact that it has got no battery okay but remember the main the only reason we were planning on having device recognition was so that you could find the remote if it got lost right okay this is about the evaluation criteria that we use for the prototype we have got here and so the method is that the design team makes a prototype and we evaluate the prototype against some criteria that we have formulated and those ones are going to be in response to sort of market research and also finance i guess and do that on a scale from true being one a false being 7 so if it is neither true or false then that is 4 so i have got a set of criteria just based on the marketing that we need to add in a financial one as well at the end so we have to say whether it is true or false that the product looks and feels for fancy whether the product demonstrates technical innovation whether it is easy to use whether it is incorporating sort of the fashion elements to try to the buyer and whether it is a sort of recognizable real reaction product and i have to go up onto the whiteboard and do this apparently so i will go up here right so the 1st one is does the product look and feel fancy so if you do a sort of one so yeah well we have a single kiv which was yeah yeah heel the product is way okay and and we have the road and we have the rubber kind of spongy tree which we was in at the time yeah i am sorry about it it is really good bit there 2 i think what is one false or is one true i forgot one is true and okay 7 is fault 4 is neutral okay so so maybe about maybe 2 yeah because we have not got the double pair so i probably like go for one yeah we have got almost everything we can okay okay i am going to put that underneath so i have got some more space so false is 7 true is one so i say about 2 the fancy yeah we are not maybe near 3 okay 2 is 3 well it is just that in a sense remember that when you look down we have got solar power we have got various other things you could have and we are not going for these options this is just for like the look does it sort of look fancy rather than functional yeah i suppose that might be in the technical innovation yeah so we go for a 2 on that okay and i mean how much does the product demonstrate technical innovation i suppose we are deciding between the kinetic power or the speech recognition and if we had either of those for our budget they both show the reasonable amount of speech recognition okay so what about the prototype as it is we have got the speech recognition on it have not we but not the kinetic but not the kinetic power no forward that we took that out too yeah we can not for both all right did not know so it does not it is pretty the prototype as it is is not sort of fulfilling the it is maybe about neutral it has got something that it has not got okay well wait a minute in 137 we do have kinetic the problem is we have to reduce down from there to get it down to 125 and one way of doing that would be to take out the kinetic so it is very much dependent on what you do with your options and if you are definitely going for the sample sensor and sample speaker then because the other functions we have got in are more at the special material the rubber wood titanium etc if you go for that that is at the high end because that is 06 whereas down the at just special color is 2 and you are trying to lose one2 so it seems to me that if you are going for the sample sensor speaker you are basically then having to go for the cheaper options on everything else and the simple way to do it would be to have a battery to have your sample sensor speaker and then you are looking to take out 02 2 which would be come from the button supplements category i am just going to check exactly what it said in the email for how much of a difference would it make if we need the case in the past it because we did say that we do not want to follow the fashion too much that might be stringent enough and interface type well plastic rather than rubber okay that would make the same a difference you could either you could have it if you have that in plastic rather than rubber then that would enable you to get you could keep kinetic then you could keep your sample sensor you were looking to take out 2 so you could fiddle that down your special form at the bottom or your special color at the bottom and that would enable you to do it to do it okay so we make it slightly more fancy then we lose points of innovation if you make it more innovative then we need points of being fancies i just read the email again and it sort of says evaluate the design as it is i think so i think we need to think about finance after we have sort of evaluated that design i do not know whether we have done it in the wrong order or something so no well okay but i suppose it is rubber as it is is not it it is rubber as it is yes so i mean does this need to go up a bit or something because we have got both the both the we have got 137 and we have got it in at the moment and if and basically we are going to reduce down from that but the current one you would say would be fancy would be 2 yeah for innovation so we have got the speech thing and i would have said about a 2 as well yeah i would have a 2 okay 2 and the next one is i will have to get it back up now the next one well i can just sing about easy to use i would have said yes i would go for a one on that at this point in time yeah okay yeah i would use it as well and incorporate cellarer incorporates elements of fashion to attract buyer well it certainly has some yeah i would have some yeah yeah yeah yeah about 3 maybe i do not know yeah it is doing quite well yep yeah i would have to do some of these but the moment as it stands is yeah i would have said 2 it seemed reasonable the product is a recognizable real reaction product this is in the sense of using all of its products all of its back and it has got a big label on the bottom saying that comes from so this is about sort of the corporate image of like new sort of sleek technology and that sort of thing as well as having the logo on and all that so it sort of a recognizable product does it fit in with other products which are sort of copy makers and space craft i also got the same speech as the cup machine so it is kind of a spongy rogueriness maybe the more kind of comfortable for them kind of sleek and new light it depends on which why you look for it okay so we are going for a 23 well the logo would be more recognizable for recognizable on the actual thing it is just that the pen would not really write on that picture but yeah i think the logo would definitely be recognizable and it does have attributes that other to be 25 go for it right okay 23 2 right one that is that decided right so right so we are now on to changing it to get it to fit in with the budget requirements requirements and then yeah what all in the numbers mean then do we add them up and rate the cell or anything yeah i think we said of add them up so sort of an average is going to be about a 222 so yeah pretty close to 2 so yeah i mean it is pretty good at the moment but it is going to get worse is not it but we could try and make sure it does not get too bad so we are to get definite was it a 137 it was a definite price for all of the 3 side that it has yes yeah so you can lose one2 and still meet the requirements do you want to get into your so it can get up there okay i put it back on i guess this is the last stage which is so that the finance is probably i am not sure i will probably have to review it yes i would have thought so yeah well maybe just can okay so what was it control f 8 was not it 00 how kind right okay so you can see there that the if you want to keep kinetic right you have got a choice there or going down to battery which would save you one you have got the sample sensor and sample speaker which is your big item well actually we just have a plastic case and we lose 2 that is right which gets you like within the budget range yes yeah i think that would be fine because that was just a trend but we do have other buttons anyway so it is 11 to 17 and then we can make sure we definitely had all the bathroom supplements all right different colors yeah yeah i was thinking that because maybe maybe the sort of rubber case is a bit less in sort of the corporate identity than a sleeker plastic case okay so we are going for plastic yes we lose a little bit on the fashion yeah but yep and now we know but yeah that is within the budget do we actually have we just have one special forms down here well there was debate as to how you would count them you got special color well originally i was assuming we had the red apple and therefore that was the special color yeah we have got enough another yeah we have got no point left well we have got special form now that would be one button and the question was was all buttons or is that just one button because our plan really was to have one button only with the special so so no matter how you look at that that would be the same the other thing would then be special material rubber wood titanium i think maybe the special color we have got 3 now just because the volume ones are different i guess we have the ones which are blue at the moment all right so special color you want 3 in there yeah i think we should be yeah it is probably fine for the time okay you just need 2 for special color because it is just 2 supplements you know one original color and then 2 supplements i think maybe that makes sense okay okay i mean these these are molded the one color is going to be molded out of a piece of rubber okay yeah i would agree with that i think so special colors 2 we have got special form is the one apple the rest they are all standard although you could argue that should maybe you were making these buttons down the bottom i was presuming bigger than the other ones or were you was that the idea yeah volume one maybe that would be a 2nd step yeah it is a 2nd special phone huh i would have thought that is probably about wow wow okay is that right 122 so we are still yep that makes sense i would say we have lost a little bit under fashion and lost a bit on the fancy kind of yeah i would i said so so you maybe put fashion at 3 rather than 2 well it definitely fits the real product poster what is the real reaction i am not quite sure what does that mean it still seems to definitely fit that so that is like if that is a new age kind of innovative company then having the connected feature and the voice recognition yep so if we have put in for another special form on a button then maybe they could be a different shape like we have got a cherry one maybe the other ones could be something else shaped something else shaped i do not know that would be possible you mean no as soon as it is cheaper to make them a different as soon as we have got you know we have made it a special form so and that would sort of maybe keep us close on the sort of the fashion type one and it would sort of keep it quite fancy as well i do not know you could argue you might do it once a year you would change because at the moment you are making it a red apple so next year you could make next year is model model the same but have it as a yeah yeah whatever a lemon yeah a lemon lemon or something yeah i mean the model inputs can be lemons or something maybe no okay so what have we got rid of we got rid of the plastic yeah the main thing we have changed really is the casing is not it i think we have saved quite a bit because we have just got the push burn the interface which is my father too yeah it is maybe in the sense not having that maybe we have lost something in the innovation side and suppose that it is like the most standard type of battery so i mean we have got rid of the rubber case but we have now sort of got an extra form and an extra color for the buttons so maybe in terms of sort of fanciness and fashionability we are pretty much the same maybe so maybe put 2 again and then and everything else has stayed pretty much the same well ease has certainly stayed yeah because if anything the special forms makes it slightly easier to yeah yeah and what about the sort of innovation well we still got the kinetic energy okay and the speech feature and then corporate identity i think we have kind of just about the same how it would play out whether that is considered to be sort of part of the corporate identity i do not know it is maybe not i think more the features of the actual control will be more important than maybe than the actual seconds but either way i think we have made it fairly close to what yeah okay but i mean how it would make it any more apart from maybe doing the whole thing in the kind of lightshare of the face but then what color would you make it on is that just the maybe there is like a set design which well but you have got the company logo on there which would effectively be a stick on badge so you are in a sense you are comparing the product without the company logo and then but you have got the space for it to stick it on what is the company color did you get told that the company color is i do not think so but in the sense that as you saw with the windows logo badge it does not really matter there is virtually the way that you frame the windows badge on there it really does not matter what color it is so long as our company is logo is framed in the same way that with like a black outline in fact they have got black and white or black and silver so basically even if you had a silver the same color of silver on your display because you have got effectively a double edging on the logo it means that it splits off what your logo is from the product and that is actually quite a sneaky way of doing it because you have got sort of you have got point to play with if you really wanted to you could put in another another color well in this one you have actually got 3 colors of buttons we decided that the blue ones were the standard color okay so you were talking about we are assuming that all the buttons on the 2nd panel the hidden away on would all be standard yeah which may or may not be the case should we save the 2 for profitability then well yeah but was it not a button you were thinking of on the on the other option you know on the 2nd page as it were that you were thinking of maybe having as a different color i do not think it would be a really i think if we would just more small round blue button but it could be the end the button but that could just be seen as well maybe for the one they are going to see all the time we make a look good and fit the kind of idea of what they want and then for the more functional better it does not know what it is much about it just have that is like because it is hidden away anyway in the video and stuff yeah and it is a sort of thing that i mean you want to pick up the controller and just hit a button quickly to change a channel or volume so if it is dead obvious then that is fine but if you are opening the panel and you are looking and you are tuning then you are paying a bit more attention so maybe sort of different color buttons is not so important all right okay yeah yeah so we just add that to profitability in effect yeah i mean so we are going to drop the cost right so we are meant to finish up in 5 minutes same sort of function yeah quite a theory it is all right i just made a lot of money yeah it does not seem right that it just has not changed at all well i think we said that because we got rid of the rubber we put an extra sort of root shape on one of the buttons 0 do you decide what that was the button it was well we could have lemon shaped ones for the volume ones or something i do not know that idea that is good yeah definitely lemon shaped did you have to have a rubber case though for rubber buttons or was it the way around he had a rubber and had a rubber case right so we are okay this way around yeah until the design team comes in and says get off but you are the design team let me say it is fine okay so you are going to get that so what so what are you on to i can just check if that is a cherry or an apple we would decide against the apple because of apple math and the religious cherry official 0 right okay just in case we get that 2 for losses 0 rats have botched that over there so will we aim and focus on target on that scale well we aim for one for all of them but it really has to fit into the budget so i guess we just have to adjust things to get it in there which is fairly and we seem to madly some from each criteria yeah we have not could have anything out so yeah i think as an overall product which has to be quite cheap yeah yeah yep so do we have anything on the picture i do not know what is on the agenda all right okay right okay so we have got so we have done the finance bit and the excel project we have done the redesign so we are now on to project process satisfaction with for example room for creativity leadership teamwork means etc whiteboard digital accessible so we are actually now in a sense onto the evaluation of the course rather than the evaluation of the project is my understanding of it so what did you and remembering that nobody is just over the curtain so so i suppose the easiest way of doing it is to put some notes down which i will do so i think i have to finish that page okay so i am going to do project devaluation so creativity do you feel you have got a chance to express yourselves well enough i have got some of the divisions there between sort of the individual meetings were bit arbitrary individual meetings how do you mean yeah well we were finding out various things in your on your own in between the meetings they did not the one meeting did not always follow on for the other one you know sort of things thrown in the 2nd meeting where you know you would looked at the remote controls and seen the coveness point in the 1st one you would also looked at some remote controls and looked at the buttons and i do not understand why it would be in separate meetings but you would do that you know you would sort of you would probably present it at one or something like that well the only thing you find is in a manufacturing process you would normally you go to a meeting you say right you do this you do that you do that then you go away you find out information you then come back you then discuss it you then go and change things around and then go back so it is visiting the real world you would be going out or finding more information it is time whereas this time you are really getting from a database source so it is not yeah anyway so what do you want to put down want to put down i have put seemed okay creativity seemed okay and flow of information on on any given subject sometimes disjointed yeah i think it may have been i mean a remote control is not the most yeah the thing is i can not think of a better example i could have used a different example to increase yeah creativity you have to do it within a set time frame as the other thing so yeah but i always think it is a bit restrictive just to say that you have to design a television remote control it depends what sort of business you are in i guess i mean this one seems to be one when the website it looks it is quite innovative but we are coming out with some bucket shop product on finance you know that is just one of the things like 15 quid i do not know how it works but i guess it is just to have like a set out and they will have like a out and they would have like a piece to kind of but the other thing is that i mean they are i am guessing that they are trying to use this software to demonstrate how you could do a project i mean my wife at the moment for instance is acting as a computer for for normally you have got a problem so you go to your tutor and find out if you are a problem information to see how to get it fixed so what she is doing is she is having to spend a day at the computer terminal at one end so that any student that comes along can ask whatever question and then you are the idea is that the whichever persons at the other end can point them in the right direction show them where to either give them directly give them help or secondly point them in the right direction either at the library or come back or go and see job logs or whatever so and that was a project i suspect similar to this because they were actually trying to debug the computer software to enable it to work and of course you had machine crashing and various things going from so so all right so we have got yeah i mean if you look at their products on their website here real reaction when it is all pretty high tech cutting edge new ideas found did we find any no it is quite good with this the whiteboard having the digital pens i see it right leadership teamwork so we did find a new idea i mean sort of a kinetic remote control we have never seen one of them before they are all batteries i think voice recognition especially not one yeah you have got voice recognition computers that is not remote controls yeah okay it is like the same products but together so how do you reckon teamwork went okay yeah yeah i guess we all had set idea yeah yeah yeah to go reasonably well okay i do not think the budget allowed us to do anything but arbitry i mean i do not think it i just do not think it fitted in with the rest of their products i mean i have got all these sort of of you know high definition dvd portable 7 inch lightweight computer screen i think in one cheap remote control does not really do so we are meant to comment on leadership and it means e g whiteboard digital pens etc and new ideas found was the other thing yeah well we can not really all fail to comment on leadership because you were the project manager you would do so our experience in leadership was not really as much as yours now i am much more being marketed but i certainly did not get this computer to work as well as i would have liked however all right so whiteboard so really it is equipment it worked yeah very nice computers could be a bit difficult at times i mean i do not i am not sure i see the value in these i mean they record what you are writing and then what do with it where do you get the recording do you plug in the computer or something there is a little there is not just for us it is about it is a whole thing there is a little chip i think you must plug it into something and it produces a i do not know whether it just produces a big image of everything you have written or something like you have to pay new ideas found so one or 2 yeah kinetic powered remote control what was the one voice yeah yeah i am like powered and and voice there is a voice activated voice recognition recognition recognition are the cost of yes is the project evaluated do not forget to complete final question meaning summary then celebration i think we have got 2 questionnaires and a report on the last meeting so we do not really i tried to save this the last time at 123 and it did not seem to have saved anywhere mind you the figure last time was different but there should be post