in the sections below we’ll give you an overview of the best car insurance companies in arizona am best financial strength rating a through our indepth research we found that state farm is the best choice for arizona drivers the company offers many types of discount opportunities especially for teen drivers and young drivers students can earn a discount of up to 25 on their car insurance premiums for example if they enroll in state farm’s telematics insurance program steer clearⓡ drivers under 25 can earn up to 20 off their insurance rates for drivers over 25 the company’s usagebased drive safe  save™ program monitors driving habits which can lead to significant discounts our review team reached out to state farm for a comment on its reviews but did not receive a response state farm is the largest insurance provider in the country according to the national association of insurance commissioners naic the company offers fullcoverage car insurance as well as a wide range of additional coverage options including state farm often ranks highly in jd power consumer studies in the jd power 2022 us auto insurance study℠ the company won first place for customer satisfaction among providers in the southwest with 885 out of 1000 points state farm scored even higher in the jd power 2022 us insurance shopping study℠ earning 885 points in our august 2022 survey which polled nearly 7000 people about their satisfaction with their insurance providers state farm received an average rating of 42 stars out of 50 for overall customer satisfaction more than 19 of respondents had state farm car insurance policies making it the most popular insurer in our survey am best financial strength rating a the hartford mainly caters to drivers 50 or older since data from the us census bureau shows more than a third of the state’s residents fall into this demographic the insurer is an ideal choice for arizona drivers the hartford partners with aarp to offer exclusive rates to aarp members though its primary customer base is a little older the hartford does offer discounts for good students and for drivers under the age of 21 who take defensive driving courses the hartford also has discounts for hybrid and electric cars and for cars with multiple air bags in addition to the standard insurance coverages the hartford offers these addons through its aarp auto insurance program the hartford received the top score for midsize insurers in the jd power insurance shopping study earning 889 out of 1000 points in the jd power auto insurance study the company was second only to state farm in the southwest showcasing its commitment to customer satisfaction the provider also has a ratings from both am best and the bbb am best financial strength rating a american family insurance is one of our picks for the best car insurance in arizona because its average cost for full coverage is about 12 below the state average and about 11 below the national average policyholders may be able to save even more money with discounts such as these our team reached out to american family insurance for comment about its negative customer reviews but did not receive a response american family offers the six standard types of car insurance and policyholders can purchase a number of addon coverages including american family scored exactly average in the jd power insurance shopping study with 855 points out of 1000 in the jd power auto insurance study however american family scored above average for the southwest region with 833 points only about 2 of respondents in our car insurance survey had a policy from american family but it ranked the highest in customer satisfaction customers with american family insurance gave the company a 45star average rating out of 50 am best financial strength rating a geico is the secondlargest auto insurer in the us holding roughly 14 of the market share in 2021 according to the naic the provider is known for its high policy limits and generally low rates geico also offers 16 discount opportunities including options for those who maintain clean driving records students who keep up good grades and owners who install antitheft devices in their vehicles geico offers all six standard auto insurance coverages with some of the highest coverage limits on the market in addition to its fullcoverage policy options geico provides addon coverages including though it has excellent financial strength and a high rating from the bbb geico matched the regional average in the jd power auto insurance study scoring 827 out of 1000 points our review team reached out to geico for a comment on this score but did not receive a response sixteen percent of respondents in our 2022 survey reported having geico car insurance making it the thirdmost popular provider in our poll after state farm and progressive those with geico coverage rated the company an average of 41 out of 50 stars for customer satisfaction am best financial strength rating a according to the naic allstate is the fourthlargest insurance provider in the country along with its array of coverage options allstate has a claim satisfaction guarantee that will credit up to six months of insurance premiums if you’re not satisfied with how the company handles your insurance claim the allstate rewards® program incentivizes good driving habits by offering gift cards and shopping rewards via a points system in addition to the six standard types of car insurance coverage allstate offers many optional addon coverages to ensure you’re protected these include allstate extended vehicle care which is similar to an extended warranty and deductible rewards® which reduces your deductible for each accidentfree year allstate also has two usagebased insurance programs drivewise® and milewise® which both offer discounts based on your driving habits though it’s the fifthbest option for car insurance in arizona allstate did score below the regional average in the jd power auto insurance study 824 points compared to 827 for the region our team reached out to allstate for a comment about the scores but did not receive a response about 9 of respondents in our august 2022 car insurance survey reported having allstate insurance policies and they were generally satisfied with the company those respondents rated allstate 41 out of 50 stars on average