Yes, please send us a completed Application for Duplicate/Renewal Registration and a photocopy of your NY State driver license, permit, non-driver ID, or other proof of identity by mail, along with a check/money order for $ 3 payable to the Commissioner of Motor Vehicles.
That's helpful to hear. Do you know how to order by phone?  Could you give me the phone number just in case I need it?
You can call the Custom Plates Unit at 1-518-402-4838.  Office hours are 8:00am - 4:00pm, Monday through Friday
May I ask another question about ATVs? Is it true that I cannot replace my 1971 Dodge registration document online?