Where should I mail all those documents?
All of those documents including the Application for Duplicate Title PDF [ 4 ] MV-902 should be mail to Title Bureau NYS DMV PO Box 2750 Albany , NY 12220 - 0750.
If i choose to apply for a replacement title at a DMV office, will i get the new ones directly there?
You will not. The certificates will only be printed at Albany in a secure facility and mailed to the owner afterwards. Therefore, doing the application online saves your time and it is the easiest way to do it.