They recorded over several evenings in 1953 and 1954. The songs that appeared on the album were chosen based on how well Odetta, Larry, the Weisses, and the audience liked each song. Altogether, Odetta and Larry performed at the Tin Angel for about 8 months.
The selection of songs for the album was a collaborative process involving Odetta, Larry, the Weisses, and the audience who attended the performances at the Tin Angel. The duration of the performances was approximately eight months.