In so doing, Argyle Park flouted the general expectation within the Christian music industry that bands will be positive and evangelistic. This, along with the generally dark image of the band, led to much of the criticism that Argyle Park faced from within the underground Christian music scene and music press.
Argyle Park's unconventional approach to Christian music, characterized by a dark image and lack of positive messaging, led to negative feedback from both the underground Christian music community and the music critics.