"Everytime" failed to succeed commercially, peaking at No. 60 on the UK Singles Chart in November 1997, but reaching number two for two weeks on the US Billboard Hot Dance Club Songs chart the following month.
Despite its failure to gain widespread popularity, "Everytime" managed to reach a moderate level of success, peaking at No. 60 on the UK Singles Chart in November 1997, and briefly holding the top spot for two weeks on the US Billboard Hot Dance Club Songs chart the following month.