Reynolds spent most of his year as a left-side cornerback, though he played the right side in 1993 for the Buccaneers and in 1996 for the Patriots. Reynolds also returned two fumble recoveries for touchdowns and returned a blocked field goal attempt for a touchdown.
During his career, Reynolds primarily played as a left cornerback. However, he switched to the right side of the defense with the Buccaneers in 1993 and with the Patriots in 1996.  He also demonstrated his versatility by recovering two fumble returns for touchdowns and returning a blocked field goal attempt for a touchdown.