During this period of success, Lubick reportedly received interest and coaching offers from several other high-profile programs, including Miami and USC. But the commitment to his program, and intense efforts from fans to keep the lovable coach in Fort Collins, lead to Lubick staying at CSU each time. In 1998, Lubick's Rams finished 8–4 and third in the WAC but were not invited to a postseason bowl.
As Lubick's team experienced a period of success, he received attention and guidance from several other top-ranked programs, including Miami and USC. Nevertheless, his loyalty to his program, coupled with the passionate support of fans who wanted him to stay in Fort Collins, led him to remain at CSU each time. In 1998, Lubick's Rams concluded the season with an 8–4 record and a third-place finish in the WAC but were not selected for a postseason bowl.