Following his senior season, Sunderlage was selected to play in a North-South All Star game where he was the high scorer for the North. In two varsity seasons, Sunderlage's Elgin Maroons teams won 35 games while only losing 6 (win pct=85.3%).
Following his senior season, Sunderlage was chosen to participate in a notable All Star game between the North and South, where he led the North in scoring. During his two varsity years, Sunderlage's Elgin Maroons teams experienced tremendous success, winning 35 games while losing just six (a testament to their dominance).