Beginning previews on November 4, 2011 with a December 1 opening night, Osnes once again played Bonnie, this time in the Broadway debut of Bonnie and Clyde at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre. She was joined by her Asolo Rep castmate Jeremy Jordan as Clyde.
Beginning previews of Bonnie and Clyde on November 4, 2011, marked a new chapter for Osnes, who again played Bonnie, this time alongside her Asolo Rep castmate Jeremy Jordan as Clyde in the Broadway debut.