Among other positive reviews were those from LGBT rights activist Dan Savage, Republican senator Rick Santorum, Matt Reynolds of Christianity Today, and Ryan T. Anderson of National Review. In The Times Literary Supplement, libertarian Nigel Ashford commented that "the tone of the book—of reason and logic, respect for opponents and willingness to engage in intellectual combat—is set by Corvino himself in his examination of the case against homosexuality, and by the inclusion of a rebuttal of his own arguments."
The book received positive reviews from various individuals, including Dan Savage (LGBT rights activist), Rick Santorum (Republican senator), Matt Reynolds (Christianity Today), and Ryan T. Anderson (National Review).  Nigel Ashford, writing in The Times Literary Supplement, praised the book's tone of reason, logic, respect for opponents, and willingness to engage in intellectual debate, noting that it was set by Corvino himself in his examination of arguments against homosexuality and a rebuttal of his own points.