Edgley was called as second counselor to Presiding Bishop Robert D. Hales in 1992. In 1994, Merrill J. Bateman replaced Hales and Edgley was retained as second counselor.
In 1992, Edgley served as the second counselor under Presiding Bishop Robert D. Hales. However, in 1994, Merrill J. Bateman succeeded Hales, and Edgley remained as the second counselor.