Toner made 17 appearances for The Imps, scoring twice, before being loaned out to Cambridge United later that season. Toner made eight appearances for United, and the club were eventually relegated from the Football League at the end of the season.
During his tenure with The Imps, Toner made 17 appearances and scored two goals, after which he was loaned to Cambridge United. In just eight games for United, the team was relegated from the Football League by season's end.