When Yeagley retired from playing in 2002, he moved to the Crew's front office as an assistant general manager for a year. When Yeagley's father announced that he planned to retire from coaching after the 2003 NCAA season, Yeagley left the Crew and joined the Indiana soccer team as a non-paid assistant coach.
In 2002, when Yeagley retired from playing, he joined the Crew's front office as an assistant general manager for a year. After his father's retirement plan was announced in 2003, Yeagley left the Crew and became a non-paid assistant coach with the Indiana soccer team.