In the episode, protagonist Huey Freeman seizes complete creative control of his elementary school's annual Christmas play, but runs into trouble with administration when he wishes to portray Jesus as black. Meanwhile, Riley Freeman rekindles an old grudge he has against Santa Claus.
The episode centers around Huey Freeman's attempt to direct the school's Christmas play and his desire to depict Jesus in a different light. This leads to conflict with administrators who may not agree with his artistic vision.  Riley Freeman also rekindles an old grudge against Santa Claus, adding another layer of humor to the story.