Overall, Heitmuller played in 95 major league games, 89 as an outfielder and 69 in left field. He had a career batting average of .271 with a .368 on-base percentage.
Throughout his professional career, Heitmuller played in 95 major league contests, mostly as an outfielder and occasionally in left field. His overall batting performance was marked by a .271 average and a .368 on-base rate.