Debate has quickly risen regarding the authenticity of Davies' youth ministry activities, the band Evening Service, and the organization Love God's Way ranging from entertainment publications such as Spin to thousands of personal blogs  Some in the blogosphere maintained that Davies was truly  seeking to "convert" other homosexuals to heterosexuality . Others considered Davies ministry and the video part of a carefully designed hoax mocking the Christian Conservative community.
Discussion has rapidly escalated about the authenticity of Davies' youth ministry activities, Evening Service band, and Love God's Way organization, from entertainment magazines like Spin to numerous personal blogs. Some bloggers claimed that Davies was genuinely attempting to "convert" homosexuals to heterosexuality. Others believed these efforts were part of a carefully planned hoax targeting the Christian Conservative community.