He was defeated for reelection on November 3, 2009 by James LeMunyon. In 2014, Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe announced that he was appointing Caputo to the board of the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority.
Caputo's reelection campaign on November 3, 2009, ended in defeat when he lost to James LeMunyon. Two years later, in 2014, Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe chose Caputo to serve on the board of the Metropolitan Washington Airports Authority.