In 1993 she returned again, playing third for Thomas, this time finishing with a 5-6 record. The next year she joined up with Laura Phillips and the team lost in their final tie-breaker match to Sherry Anderson of Saskatchewan. Cunningham was Phillips' third for the next three Tournament of Hearts, finishing with a 5-6 record in 1995 and 1996 and losing to Alison Goring of Ontario in the 1997 semi-final.
In 1993, she returned to play third for Thomas' team, achieving a 5-6 record. The following year, she partnered with Laura Phillips and their team lost in a tiebreaker match against Sherry Anderson of Saskatchewan. Cunningham continued to be Phillips' third player for the next three Tournament of Hearts, finishing with a 5-6 record in 1995 and 1996 before losing to Alison Goring of Ontario in the 1997 semi-final.