Price Peterson, of TV.com, gave a mostly positive review, writing that "I don't know how I feel about the Lily Kane case getting reopened like this, but I still really enjoyed all the Kendall stuff. […] the different Neptune factions have started to come together in an understandable way.
Price Peterson, of TV.com, offered an overall favorable critique, indicating that "I am unsure how I feel about reopening the Lily Kane case but still enjoyed all the Kendall material. […] The various Neptune factions have started to unite logically."