Allenhurst station opened on May 17, 1897, as a replacement for the Interlaken station on the New York and Long Branch Railroad, a joint operation between the Central Railroad of New Jersey and Pennsylvania Railroad. As part of opening, Interlaken station became a Sunday-only stop on the railroad until its closure on July 31, 1904. The station joined the National Register of Historic Places in August 1980, despite the poor condition of the station depot.
Allenhurst station debuted on May 17, 1897, as a replacement for Interlaken station on the New York and Long Branch Railroad, a collaboration between the Central Railroad of New Jersey and Pennsylvania Railroad. Upon its opening, Interlaken station became a seasonal stop on the railroad until it closed on July 31, 1904. The station was recognized by the National Register of Historic Places in August 1980, despite being in poor condition.