In 2004, McMenamy made a return to modeling by walking the runway for the Prada fashion house. That same year, she chose to stop dyeing her hair, and instead let it go gray. The next year, McMenamy was booked by Marc Jacobs for his fall/winter 2005 campaign.
McMenamy revisited modeling in 2004 when she appeared on the runway for Prada. She made a deliberate choice that year to stop coloring her hair and instead let it mature to its natural gray color. The following year, McMenamy was selected by Marc Jacobs to be part of his fall/winter 2005 promotional campaign.