After three ineffective performances by Cooper, Parcells called Allegre back and signed him on September 25, becoming the team's sixth kicker in 19 games. During the team's Super Bowl run in 1986, he kicked game-winning field goals in consecutive weeks in a crucial mid-season stretch. Allegre kicked the opening kickoff of Super Bowl XXI, with the announcer stating that "Raúl Allegre, will kick off, number 2" just before the contest began.
After three unsuccessful attempts by Cooper, Parcells brought back Allegre and signed him as the team's sixth kicker in 19 games. During their Super Bowl run in 1986, Allegre kicked game-winning field goals in consecutive weeks during a crucial mid-season period. Allegre kicked off the Super Bowl XXI kickoff, with the announcer announcing that "Raúl Allegre will kick off, number 2" before the game began.