The team's performance did not vary from the Skyhawks, but would not appear in the league finals again until 2012. A year later, the Trappers would win their first league title since 2009 and played host to the 2013 Dudley Hewitt Cup, finishing fourth. As a result of an Ontario Hockey League franchise returning to North Bay, the tournament was almost allocated a second time.
The team's consistent performance with the Skyhawks meant they wouldn't reappear in the league finals until 2012. A year later, the Trappers secured their first league title since 2009 and hosted the 2013 Dudley Hewitt Cup, finishing fourth. As a result of an Ontario Hockey League franchise returning to North Bay, the tournament was on the verge of being allocated for a second time.