Tolley was born in Honesdale, Pennsylvania. He graduated from Syracuse University in 1916. He served in the military during World War I from May 13, 1917, until July 25, 1919, attaining the rank of captain.
Tolley originated from Honesdale, Pennsylvania. He completed his studies at Syracuse University in 1916. During World War I, he enlisted in the military on May 13, 1917, and remained until July 25, 1919, rising to the position of captain.