The Forge were finalists in the Robertson Cup Tournament, the NAHL championship, during their inaugural season and were the first expansion team to do so. During their second season, the Forge set a national Junior A record with 43 wins and won the NAHL's regular season championship as well as the Robertson Cup Tournament. In two seasons, the Forge advanced 18 players onto scholarships with Division I college hockey programs.
The Forge were successful in their first two seasons, reaching the finals of the Robertson Cup Tournament and winning the NAHL championship. They also set a national Junior A record for wins during their second season.  In total, they helped 18 players advance to Division I college hockey programs.