Two trips were also made to the Final Four in Baseball in 1957 and 1965 bowing out in the semi-finals 1-0 to Doylestown and 11-2 to Shaker Heights respectively.
In both years of 1957 and 1965, the team reached the Final Four in Baseball but lost in the semi-finals. They faced Doylestown with a score of 1-0 and Shaker Heights with a score of 11-2.