The next day, The Providence Express published the following account of Rantoul's argument in the case: "The able and conclusive argument of this distinguished gentlemen occupied two hours and a half in the delivery. It was, throughout, the most learned address to which we have ever listened . .
The following day, The Providence Express published a detailed account of Rantoul's argument in court: "The esteemed gentleman presented a compelling and thorough argument that lasted for two and a half hours. This was one of the most impressive addresses we have ever witnessed."