In 2020, Charlie Mason from Soaps She Knows placed Brady at #34 on his list of the 35 most memorable characters from Days of Our Lives, saying that "Eric Martsolf’s alter ego is, in short, the perfect soap character: a basically decent fellow who is drawn to anything — and anyone — that is bad for him."
In 2020, Charlie Mason from Soaps She Knows ranked Brady as #34 on his list of the 35 most memorable characters from Days of Our Lives. He described Eric Martsolf's portrayal of Brady as a "basically decent fellow" who is drawn to negative situations and people.