While not specifically naming names, Hines provided enough detail in the article to identify individual athletes, leading to widespread criticism that this information could be used against closeted gay athletes, especially those living in repressive countries. Facing intense backlash online, The Daily Beast edited the piece to remove details that could allow athletes to be identified, and editor in chief John Avlon added a lengthy editor's note.
Hines' article contained enough information to identify specific athletes, sparking criticism that such details could be used against closeted gay athletes, particularly those in repressive countries. In response to intense online pressure, The Daily Beast revised the piece to remove identifying elements and included a lengthy editor's note by John Avlon.