In a review of the remix album PS You Love Me, Pitchforks Mark Richardson stated that with PS I Love You, "Kid proved to the world that he had processing and compositional skills to rank him amongst the heavy hitters of the genre.
Pitchfork's Mark Richardson reviewed the remix album "PS You Love Me" and stated that Kid's work on "PS I Love You" showcased his talent for composing and processing music to be considered amongst the best in the genre.