GamePro, in a favorable review of the Nintendo 64 version, said, "Fans of California Speeds arcade counterpart will bask in its sharp N64 port, but serious racing fans may be disappointed by the game's lack of replay depth.
The GamePro review highlights the positive aspects of the N64 version of California Speeds, particularly its visual enhancements, while acknowledging that dedicated racing fans might find the game's limited replayability disappointing.