Permanent band members were eventually selected, including drummer Matt Fine and bassist Jesse Fine, followed by guitarist Tedd Foxx. The band continued writing songs, and in 2004 they showcased at the Double Door in Chicago, where the band caught the attention of a Columbia Records rep. The Adored inked a major-label deal with Columbia Records in fall 2004.
The band's lineup was eventually finalized, with Matt Fine on drums and Jesse Fine on bass joining Tedd Foxx on guitar. The group continued to create new music and perform live, culminating in a showcase at the Double Door in Chicago in 2004, where they caught the attention of a Columbia Records representative. The Adored secured a major-label contract with Columbia Records in fall 2004.