Cristina concludes that all the girls murdered were good girls and that the murderer must have learned of their innocence through the confessional. Cristina finds a secret tunnel behind the confessional, and is knocked unconscious by the murderer. Jack also finds the secret door, and within the tunnel the tied-up Cristina and a secret chamber in which the corpses of Mother Bernadette and the missing girls have been arranged in a gruesome replication of the Last Supper.
Cristina forms an opinion that the murdered girls were blameless and that the killer must have learned of their innocence through the confessional. Cristina stumbles upon a hidden passage behind the confessional, but is knocked out by the killer. Meanwhile, Jack also discovers the secret door and finds a concealed room containing the bodies of Mother Bernadette and the missing girls, arranged in a twisted reenactment of the Last Supper.