In his review, Carl Kimlinger claimed Baccano! to be "one of the best, and certainly the most cleverly written series in recent years" and described it as "lethally fun" before giving the series an 'A' rating for both the subbed and dubbed versions.
Carl Kimlinger rated Baccano! highly, considering it one of the best and most ingeniously crafted series in recent years. He characterized it as "lethally entertaining" and awarded it an 'A' rating for both versions.