Taste of Country praised the cover commenting that All That Remains honors the song's dark nature with intense electric guitars and drums, coupled with Labonte's haunting vocals. The cover is also notable for containing a signature heavy metal scream on the song's title. All That Remains' cover features Labonte's vocals being layered to create an ethereal effect along with female backing vocals by Diamante Azzura.
Taste of Country praised All That Remains' rendition of the song, highlighting its dark tone and powerful instrumentation, including intense electric guitars and drums, as well as Labonte's haunting vocals. The cover is also notable for incorporating a signature heavy metal scream on the title and layering Labonte's vocals with female backing vocals by Diamante Azzura to create an ethereal effect.