She criticized the final scene featuring Scully tied up with duct-tape, commenting that the way she was loosely tied up was unrealistic. The fact that the episode's "absurd concept" was simply a "side-story" also drew positive attention, summarizing her review with, "otherwise a creepy and engaging detective story".
The reviewer panned the final scene, noting that Scully was not adequately restrained. However, she praised the episode's unusual plot device, describing it as a secondary narrative thread that added to the story's appeal.