At the time of the first professional football in the country Bennaars and SV DOSKO started in the Dutch Second Division. After three years of professional football at DOSKO Bennaars switched to NOAD, where he stayed one season before making another switch, towards Feijenoord. At his second season at Feijenoord Bennaars won his first trophy when the club won the Eredivisie.
When professional football first emerged in the country, Bennaars and SV DOSKO started playing in the Dutch Second Division. After three years of playing professionally at DOSKO, Bennaars moved to NOAD, where he stayed for one season before making another move to Feijenoord. During his second season with Feijenoord, Bennaars achieved his first trophy as the club won the Eredivisie title.