His most notable achievement was appearing in the 1937 Scottish Cup Final which Aberdeen lost 2–1 to Celtic; the Dons were also runners-up in the 1936–37 Scottish Division One table behind Rangers, having been third behind the Old Firm teams the previous season – McKenzie missed only three matches across those two campaigns.
His most notable accomplishment was participating in the 1937 Scottish Cup Final, where Aberdeen lost 2–1 to Celtic; the Dons also finished second in the 1936–37 Scottish Division One standings behind Rangers, having been third the previous season – McKenzie missed only three matches across those two campaigns.