Club gave "The Pack" a grade of B, writing that "the storytelling in this episode is engaging and a few of the scenes genuinely creepy", though its central metaphor was not as developed as "Teacher's Pet". He felt that the episode was an example of how Sunnydale High did not feel like a believable high school, and criticized some of the action and the teenagers' hyena characteristics, but he praised Flutie's murder and Willow's development.
Club gave "The Pack" a grade of B, noting that "the storytelling in this episode is captivating and some scenes are genuinely unsettling", although its central metaphor was not as well-developed as "Teacher's Pet". He felt the episode did not accurately portray Sunnydale High as a believable high school, criticizing certain actions and the teenagers' hyena-like traits but praising Flutie's murder and Willow's growth.