The team won the Stanley Cup in its first year, but even with largely the same lineup, struggled badly in 1918–19 (now under the name the Toronto Arenas), finishing with five wins and 13 losses.
In their first year of competition, the team claimed victory; however, with a largely unchanged lineup, they struggled significantly in the 1918–19 season (renamed as the Toronto Arenas), ending up with five wins and thirteen losses.