Alison explains that they had been together before Livvie interfered, and they were very much in love. Rafe contemplates everything Alison has told him and confronts Livvie. She accuses Alison of being jealous and that everything she said are lies.
Alison tells Rafe that they had a relationship before Livvie got involved, and they were very much in love.  Rafe thinks about what Alison has told him and then confronts Livvie. Livvie accuses Alison of being jealous and says everything she's saying is untrue.