As of February 2010, Mitchell's comeback had netted him three wins and two losses, His last loss was to current WBA light heavyweight champion Beibut Shumenov, who won and lost two razor thin controversial decisions to Gabriel Campillo.
In February 2010, Mitchell's comeback journey included three wins and two losses; his last defeat was against the current WBA light heavyweight champion, Beibut Shumenov, who had also experienced two closely contested, controversial victories over Gabriel Campillo.