The Supreme Court delivered its judgment on 9 August 2012, declining Right to Life's appeal by a 3-2 majority decision and upholding the Wall v. Livingston decision. The Court ruled that the Abortion Supervisory Committee could not investigate the decision-making of certifying consultants in individual cases but also made it clear that the ASC could ask consultants how they were making their decisions in general.
The Supreme Court's ruling on August 9, 2012, regarding Right to Life's appeal was a 3-2 decision in favor of upholding the Wall v. Livingston decision. The court ruled that the Abortion Supervisory Committee could not investigate individual cases but allowed them to inquire about general decision-making practices.