His first marriage was to Susan A. Metcalfe September 28, 1838. He married his second wife, Maria Chapin, in 1842. It was after her death that he married Elizabeth Rutherford, granddaughter of the author Eliza Fenwick, in 1844.
His first marriage took place on September 28, 1838, with Susan A. Metcalfe. In 1842, he married his second wife, Maria Chapin. After her death, he wed Elizabeth Rutherford, granddaughter of the author Eliza Fenwick, in 1844.