Joe Tacopino of PopMatters praised the tracks for their production and mature storytelling, calling the album "more subtle and honest than Jack White’s various projects." He concluded with, "These ambitious youngsters are definitely worth the trip, even without the ostentatious vocal harmonies."
Joe Tacopino of PopMatters highlighted the album's refined production and thoughtful storytelling, noting that it surpasses Jack White's other efforts in its understated yet sincere approach. The reviewer suggests that this promising group is worth investigating, despite their decision to forego elaborate vocal harmonies.