The 2013–14 season was a more successful one on the pitch for Argyle, and during it Argyle re-signed Luke McCormick and so Cole found himself as the club's back-up goalkeeper, only for injuries to McCormick to see him play exactly the same number of times as McCormick that year.
During the 2013-14 season, Argyle had a successful run on the pitch. This success was partly due to Luke McCormick's re-signing, which led to Cole being the backup goalkeeper. However, injuries to McCormick meant that Cole played the same number of games as McCormick during this season.