However, in a 4–2 win over Exeter City on 30 October 2010, Weston was in a row with Robbie Simpson over a penalty kick and took a penalty spot, which resulted he missed the spot kick. This caused Manager Andy Scott to inform that Weston should not take penalties again. He then signed a contract extension on 26 November 2010, keeping him until 2013.
Weston's penalty miss against Exeter City led to his manager, Andy Scott, instructing him not to take penalties again. This resulted in a contract extension being signed by Weston, extending his stay at the club until 2013.