Computer Gaming World liked Inca II graphics, action, and music but criticized the schizophrenic gameplay and a voice acting. It is included in the magazine's list of Worst Games of All Time, described as "incoherent" and criticized for its "uneven graphics and ridiculous premise".
Computer Gaming World found Inca II's graphics, action, and music appealing but disliked its confusing gameplay and voice acting. It was listed among the worst games ever by the magazine, labeled as "incoherent" and criticized for its inconsistent visuals and nonsensical plot.