Feldstein included multiple retellings of previous stories, a move suggested by publisher William Gaines. This included "The Basket" and "The Gorilla's Paw" in the first issue and "Horror in the Freak Tent" and "Reflection of Death" in #2. Other contributing writers included Jack Oleck (who had worked as a writer on EC's earlier publications) and John Larner.
Feldstein re-told previous stories, as suggested by publisher William Gaines. This included tales like "The Basket" and "The Gorilla's Paw" in the first issue, and "Horror in the Freak Tent" and "Reflection of Death" in issue #2. Other contributors were Jack Oleck (who had previously worked on EC publications) and John Larner.