Thrilling Wonder Stories also reviewed the volume favorably, saying that "Weinbaum wrote easily and vividly and his characterization is such that the reader never fails to feel the pressing and urgent reality of what is actually arrant make-believe."
Thrilling Wonder Stories commended the volume, indicating that "Weinbaum wrote fluently and vividly, and his portrayals were such that the reader consistently experienced a strong sense of actuality in the fantastical elements."