Since winning the third division title in 2002 North Otago has punched well above its weight making the 2nd Division semi finals in 2003,04, and 2005 but losing all three. In 2006 they entered the Heartland Championship but again losing in the semi-final.
Since winning their third division title in 2002, North Otago has consistently demonstrated strong performance, reaching the second division semi-finals in 2003, 2004, and 2005 but failing to win each time. In 2006, they entered the Heartland Championship, again falling short in the semi-final round.