Blue Rider cross-complained. Konvitz successfully filed a summary judgement motion for Blue Rider against GFI in the trial court but Blue Rider's cross-complaint was dismissed. GFI appealed the summary judgement against it to the Court of Appeal, Second Appellate Division.
GFI countered Blue Rider's lawsuit. Konvitz successfully petitioned for a summary judgment in favor of GFI in the lower court, but Blue Rider's counter-claim was dismissed. GFI then appealed the unfavorable ruling to the Court of Appeal, Second Appellate Division.