In 1994, O'Toole competed at the British Columbia Bodybuilding Championships where a scoring error gave the initial light heavyweight class win to another competitor. This decision was reversed by the organization a few weeks later, but only the class win could be reversed and not the overall competition, which all those present including guest poser Dennis Newman had assumed would go to O'Toole
In 1994, during the British Columbia Bodybuilding Championships, O'Toole won the light heavyweight class initially due to a scoring error. However, this victory was later corrected by the organization but not the overall competition result, which everyone, including guest poser Dennis Newman, had anticipated would go to O'Toole.