Nogan had put Reading ahead in the fourth minute with the first goal of the game, and by half-time they were 2–0 up, but two goals in the final 15 minutes saw Bolton force extra time and go on to claim a 4–3 victory. Reading then struggled in the 1995–96 campaign, only managing a 19th-place finish, with Nogan contributing 11 goals from his 45 appearances. He went on to score a further six goals across 25 appearances in the 1996–97 season, as joint-managers Mick Gooding and Jimmy Quinn led the club to an 18th-place finish.
Nogan had scored Reading ahead in the fourth minute with the first goal of the game, and by halftime they were 2–0 up, but two goals in the final 15 minutes saw Bolton force extra time and claim a 4–3 victory. Reading then struggled in the 1995-96 campaign, managing only a 19th-place finish, with Nogan contributing 11 goals from his 45 appearances. He went on to score six more goals across 25 appearances in the 1996-97 season, as joint-managers Mick Gooding and Jimmy Quinn led the club to an 18th-place finish.