Team Fenson won the United States Olympic trials ahead of the 2006 Winter Olympics, which also counted as the 2005 National Championships. As a result, they represented the United States at the 2005 World Men's Curling Championship, where they just missed the playoffs when they lost a tiebreaker game to Norway's Pål Trulsen. At the Olympics they lost to Canada, skipped by Brad Gushue, in the semifinals and then defeated David Murdoch's Team Great Britain to take the bronze medal.
Team Fenson won the U.S. Olympic trials for the 2006 Winter Olympics, which also served as the 2005 National Championships. They competed at the 2005 World Men's Curling Championship and narrowly missed the playoffs after losing a tiebreaker to Norway's Pål Trulsen. At the 2006 Winter Olympics, they lost to Canada in the semifinals but defeated Team Great Britain for the bronze medal.