Within two years, construction work was underway at the new stadium site and the last league game at Fellows Park was played on 1 May 1990, when Walsall, in the process of their second successive relegation which took them into the Football League Fourth Division, drew 1–1 at home to Rotherham United, with Andy Dornan scoring the last league goal at the ground – his only goal in his time at Walsall.
Two years after construction began on the new stadium, the final game at Fellows Park was played on May 1st, 1990.  Walsall, relegated to the Football League Fourth Division, drew 1-1 against Rotherham United in their last match at the ground. Andy Dornan scored the final league goal for Walsall during his time with the club.