Computer Gaming World liked Inca II graphics, action, and music but criticized the schizophrenic gameplay and a voice acting. It is included in the magazine's list of Worst Games of All Time, described as "incoherent" and criticized for its "uneven graphics and ridiculous premise".
Computer Gaming World praised Inca II's visual aspects, gameplay style, and music but found its gameplay illogical and voice acting poor. It was included in the magazine's list of worst games ever due to its confusing nature and flawed premise.