Bustle Tobi Gbile ranked "I Found a Way" at number four on his These Childhood Theme Songs Will Give You Feels list, saying the theme song is one of his favorites and that it became "one of Nickelodeon's staple tracks in the mid 2000s".
According to Bustle Tobi Gbile, "I Found a Way" is one of his favorite songs and he ranked it number four on his list of childhood theme songs that evoke strong emotions. He also noted that this song became popular with Nickelodeon in the mid-2000s.