In a review of the remix album PS You Love Me, Pitchforks Mark Richardson stated that with PS I Love You, "Kid proved to the world that he had processing and compositional skills to rank him amongst the heavy hitters of the genre.
According to Pitchfork's Mark Richardson in a review of the remix album PS You Love Me, Kid demonstrated his ability to compose and process music at a high level, placing him among the top artists in the genre.