He was named the 2004 Walter Payton Award winner (Best College Player),  and 2004 Atlantic 10 Offensive Player-of-the-Day for the offseason, and helped lead William & Mary to a share of the Atlantic 10 title and its first appearance in the NCAA Division I-AA semifinals, along with the school's first 11-win season in the 111-year history of the program.
He received the 2004 Walter Payton Award for being the top college player, and was named the Atlantic 10 Offensive Player-of-the-Day during the pre-season. He helped lead William & Mary to a co-championship and their first NCAA Division I-AA semifinal appearance, marking the school's first 11-win season in its 111-year history.