AllMusic editor Leo Stanley called All That I Am "an entertaining collection of contemporary soul that alternates between smooth ballads and hip-hop-inflected dance-pop. At his best, Joe can make this music irresistible; at his worst, he merely makes it entertaining.
AllMusic editor Leo Stanley describes All That I Am as "an engaging compilation of modern soul that switches between soothing ballads and dance-pop with hip-hop influences. At his peak, Joe can make this music captivating; at his lowest point, he merely makes it enjoyable.