The first league match was against Redhill and was won 1–0 in front of a crowd of over 800. Sutton left the ground at the end of the 1912–13 season as the ground became unavailable due to Sutton Adult School forming their own team.
The inaugural league contest was against Redhill and resulted in a 1–0 victory before an audience of more than 800. Sutton departed the stadium at the conclusion of the 1912–13 season as the facility became inaccessible due to the establishment of a rival team by Sutton Adult School.