He won 10 or more games in 7 seasons with the Browns, but the Browns were a perennial losing team, and Blaeholder had only one non-losing season with the Browns (in 1932 when he went 14–14). During the 1935 season, he was traded to the Philadelphia Athletics for Sugar Cain and Ed Coleman.
Despite winning 10 or more games in seven seasons with the Browns, Blaeholder's tenure was marked by a string of losing seasons. His only non-losing season came in 1932 when he went 14–14. In 1935, he was traded to the Philadelphia Athletics for Sugar Cain and Ed Coleman.