However, she did positively compare the American version of the show to the British version, stating, "All things considered, I think the first season is very underrated owing to unnecessary comparisons to the British version", but concluded that the episode was "its weak moment".
Despite comparing the American and British versions favorably, she acknowledged that the first season of the show was unfairly judged due to excessive comparisons to the British one. However, she ultimately deemed this particular episode as a low point for the series.