Abner/Alfonso's text rivals (and in many ways surpasses) the Ramon Martí's Pugio Fidei in length, complexity, variety of sources and psychological impact, although there is no evidence that Abner/Alfonso actually knew of the polemical Dominican's work.
Abner/Alfonso's text outshines Ramon Martí's Pugio Fidei in terms of scope, sophistication, range of references, and psychological effect, although it is unclear whether Abner/Alfonso had knowledge of Martí's contentious Dominican treatise.