The club was an early powerhouse in its new league, becoming the first club to achieve a three-peat of premierships (1955-1956-1957), a record only equaled by Mitta United (1959-1960-1961). However by the early 1970s the club was in trouble, starved for on field success combined with not having very good facilities and with most players & club people residing in the Wodonga area. The tough decision was made following the 1975 season to disband the Kergunyah Football Club.
The club achieved early dominance in its new league, becoming the first team to win three consecutive championships (1955-1956-1957). However, by the early 1970s, the club faced challenges with on-field performance, poor facilities, and a majority of players and staff residing in Wodonga. This led to the decision to disband the Kergunyah Football Club after the 1975 season.