When the Kalinago returned to their village, the settlers attacked them and 120 Kalinago were killed in the attack, including Tegremond. The following day, roughly 4,000 Kalinago were forced by the settlers into the area of Bloody Point and Bloody River where a battle broke out; historian Vincent K. Hubbard estimates 2,000 Kalinago were massacred while attempting to surrender. The account of the massacre by Jean-Baptiste Du Tertre described "piles of [Kalinago] bodies" after the massacre.
When the Kalinago returned home, they were attacked and killed by settlers, resulting in a high number of casualties; approximately 4,000 Kalinago were forced into Bloody Point and Bloody River, where a violent confrontation occurred. Historian Vincent K. Hubbard estimates that up to 2,000 Kalinago were slaughtered while attempting to surrender.