Sanders claimed the song was "kind of a tough one to choose" because the band had a lot of new material to choose from, but felt "pretty happy" with its inclusion. "When I Get Home, You're So Dead" was one of the first songs the band wrote.
Sanders expressed that choosing the song was "a bit challenging" due to the band's extensive library of new compositions, yet he was "very pleased" with its selection. "When I Get Home, You're So Dead" was among the initial tracks the band created.