Kathman's argument that the plot is from a revival is based on the fact that Thomas Belte-a contemporary of Cooke-may also appear on the plot. In addition, records show that Cooke was at some point referred to as "Saunder"; he is listed under this name on his daughter's baptismal record.
Kathman argues that the plot is from a revival because Thomas Belte, a person who lived around the same time as Cooke, might be on the plot.  Furthermore, records show that Cooke was known as "Saunder" and this name appears on his daughter's baptism certificate.