Similarly, Andy Battaglia of The A.V. Club wrote that "nearly all of Fatherfucker falls back into ostensibly bracing anthems that sound plain stupid in such abundance." Robert Christgau named "I Don't Give A..." as a "Choice Cut".
Andy Battaglia of The A.V. Club similarly opined, "nearly all of Fatherfucker tends to revert to what seem like bracing anthems that sound embarrassingly bad in such abundance." Robert Christgau also named "I Don't Give A..." as a "Highlight."