The next batter, Josh Donaldson, was hit by the pitch on a 0-1 count which made members of the Yankees mad. After a discussion by Márquez and his crew, Márquez threw out García with no warning which confused and angered García and the Blue Jays dugout believing there was no intent. Márquez also threw out Blue Jays pitching coach Pete Walker for arguing.
The next batter, Josh Donaldson, was hit by a pitch on a 0-1 count, leading to anger among Yankees players. After a discussion between Márquez and his crew, Márquez ejected García without warning, causing confusion and anger in the Blue Jays dugout who believed there was no intent behind it.  Márquez also threw out Blue Jays pitching coach Pete Walker for arguing.