While he only won twelve games out of thirty-five during his period in charge, this was enough to stave off relegation to the Third Division, which had looked a distinct possibility when Mitten was sacked, and he still had the respect of the fans for staying with the club for so long and showing a passion for the club. He stepped down as manager at the end of the season and was succeeded by Joe Harvey, though Smith remained at the club in various other capacities for several more years.
Despite winning only twelve out of thirty-five games during his time as manager, he kept the team from being relegated to the Third Division, a prospect that had seemed likely when Mitten was fired. He remained popular among fans for his loyalty and commitment to the club, even after stepping down at the end of the season and being replaced by Joe Harvey. Smith continued working with the club in other capacities for several more years.