The album received positive reviews. Justin Donnelly of Blistering gave the album a positive review and wrote "Skeletons may be both more and extreme in either directions, but with Holt’s upfront lyrical stance, Bill Kennedy’s (Monster Magnet, Nine Inch Nails, Filter) amazing production and a growth in mature evident within the songs, Nothingface will surely mark their mark from year onwards."
The album received positive feedback from reviewers.  Justin Donnelly of Blistering highlighted the lyrical content, Bill Kennedy's production skills, and the development of mature themes within the songs. He predicted that Nothingface would achieve lasting success.