Newnan has grasped three meetings in a row up through the 2009 season. In 2004 the Grangers opened up with the old-time rivals for the first time since 1999. The preseason ranked #1 in 3A Grangers defeated the 5A preseason ranked #2 Cougars 35-7, to start off their undefeated state championship season in 2004.
Newnan's achievement of three consecutive wins up to the 2009 season was notable. In 2004, the Grangers resumed their rivalry with traditional opponents after a five-year gap. The preseason top-ranked Grangers dominated the preseason second-ranked Cougars 35-7, establishing the tone for their undefeated state championship season in 2004.