Newberry started in all three playoff games, beating the Indianapolis Colts in the 1995 AFC Championship Game by a score of 20–16, before losing to the Dallas Cowboys in Super Bowl XXX 17–27.
Newberry started every game in the playoffs, including the pivotal 1995 AFC Championship Game against the Indianapolis Colts, which he won 20-16, but ultimately lost to the Dallas Cowboys in Super Bowl XXX by a score of 27-17.