text:  The other is villanously faulty as a composition where loaf is piled upon loaf for rock and castle and the tree is common and hedge-grown for the purpose of making gates; but the other would have been a fine picture not of the historical class--the parts are all common the little blown about underwood is totally deficient in all form and character--rocks and trees and they do not as in a former discourse--Reynolds had laid down that they should--sympathize with the subject; then as to the substance of the cloud he is right--it is not voluminous it is mere vapour