Godfrey was expected to face Demetrious Johnson on September 30, 2010 at WEC 51. However, Godfrey was forced off the card with an injury and replaced by WEC newcomer Nick Pace. Godfrey was defeated via first round submission by highly touted WEC newcomer Michael McDonald on November 11, 2010 at WEC 52. Following his second straight WEC loss Godfrey was cut from the promotion.
Godfrey
Michael McDonald