Nicolai reviewed Otto R*ssler's research paper on the safety of the LHC and issued a statement highlighting logical inconsistencies and physical misunderstandings in R*ssler's arguments. Nicolai concluded that ``this text would not pass the referee process in a serious journal.'' Domenico Giulini also commented with Hermann Nicolai on Otto R*ssler's thesis, concluding that ``his argument concerns only the General Theory of Relativity (GRT), and makes no logical connection to LHC physics; the argument is not valid; the argument is not self-consistent.''
Nicolai reviewed Otto R*ssler's research paper on the safety of the LHC and issued a statement highlighting logical inconsistencies and physical misunderstandings in R*ssler's arguments.
nsubj
Number=Sing
Nicolai
Nicolai
PROPN
NNP
root
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Past|VerbForm=Fin
review
reviewed
VERB
VBD
nmod:poss
Number=Sing
Otto
Otto
PROPN
NNP
flat
Number=Sing
R<UNK>ssler
R<UNK>ssler
PROPN
NNP
case
's
's
PART
POS
compound
Number=Sing
research
research
NOUN
NN
obj
Number=Sing
paper
paper
NOUN
NN
case
on
on
ADP
IN
det
Definite=Def|PronType=Art
the
the
DET
DT
obl
Number=Sing
safety
safety
NOUN
NN
case
of
of
ADP
IN
det
Definite=Def|PronType=Art
the
the
DET
DT
nmod
Number=Sing
LHC
LHC
PROPN
NNP
cc
and
and
CCONJ
CC
conj
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Past|VerbForm=Fin
issue
issued
VERB
VBD
det
Definite=Ind|PronType=Art
a
a
DET
DT
obj
Number=Sing
statement
statement
NOUN
NN
acl
VerbForm=Ger
highlight
highlighting
VERB
VBG
amod
Degree=Pos
logical
logical
ADJ
JJ
obj
Number=Plur
inconsistency
inconsistencies
NOUN
NNS
cc
and
and
CCONJ
CC
amod
Degree=Pos
physical
physical
ADJ
JJ
conj
Number=Plur
misunderstanding
misunderstandings
NOUN
NNS
case
in
in
ADP
IN
nmod:poss
Number=Sing
R<UNK>ssler
R<UNK>ssler
PROPN
NNP
case
's
's
PART
POS
nmod
Number=Plur
argument
arguments
NOUN
NNS
punct
.
.
PUNCT
.
Nicolai concluded that ``this text would not pass the referee process in a serious journal.''
nsubj
Number=Sing
Nicolai
Nicolai
PROPN
NNP
root
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Past|VerbForm=Fin
conclude
concluded
VERB
VBD
mark
that
that
SCONJ
IN
punct
``
``
PUNCT
``
det
Number=Sing|PronType=Dem
this
this
DET
DT
nsubj
Number=Sing
text
text
NOUN
NN
aux
VerbForm=Fin
would
would
AUX
MD
advmod
not
not
PART
RB
ccomp
VerbForm=Inf
pass
pass
VERB
VB
det
Definite=Def|PronType=Art
the
the
DET
DT
compound
Number=Sing
referee
referee
NOUN
NN
obj
Number=Sing
process
process
NOUN
NN
case
in
in
ADP
IN
det
Definite=Ind|PronType=Art
a
a
DET
DT
amod
Degree=Pos
serious
serious
ADJ
JJ
obl
Number=Sing
journal
journal
NOUN
NN
punct
.
.
PUNCT
.
punct
''
''
PUNCT
''
Domenico Giulini also commented with Hermann Nicolai on Otto R*ssler's thesis, concluding that ``his argument concerns only the General Theory of Relativity (GRT), and makes no logical connection to LHC physics; the argument is not valid; the argument is not self-consistent.''
nsubj
Number=Sing
Domenico
Domenico
PROPN
NNP
flat
Number=Sing
Giulini
Giulini
PROPN
NNP
advmod
also
also
ADV
RB
root
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Past|VerbForm=Fin
comment
commented
VERB
VBD
case
with
with
ADP
IN
obl
Number=Sing
Hermann
Hermann
PROPN
NNP
flat
Number=Sing
Nicolai
Nicolai
PROPN
NNP
case
on
on
ADP
IN
nmod:poss
Number=Sing
Otto
Otto
PROPN
NNP
flat
Number=Sing
R<UNK>ssler
R<UNK>ssler
PROPN
NNP
case
's
's
PART
POS
obl
Number=Sing
thesis
thesis
NOUN
NN
punct
,
,
PUNCT
,
advcl
VerbForm=Ger
conclude
concluding
VERB
VBG
mark
that
that
SCONJ
IN
punct
``
``
PUNCT
``
nmod:poss
Case=Gen|Gender=Masc|Number=Sing|Person=3|Poss=Yes|PronType=Prs
his
his
PRON
PRP$
nsubj
Number=Sing
argument
argument
NOUN
NN
ccomp
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin
concern
concerns
VERB
VBZ
advmod
only
only
ADV
RB
det
Definite=Def|PronType=Art
the
the
DET
DT
amod
Degree=Pos
General
General
ADJ
NNP
obj
Number=Sing
Theory
Theory
PROPN
NNP
case
of
of
ADP
IN
nmod
Number=Sing
Relativity
Relativity
PROPN
NNP
punct
(
(
PUNCT
-LRB-
appos
Number=Sing
GRT
GRT
PROPN
NNP
punct
)
)
PUNCT
-RRB-
punct
,
,
PUNCT
,
cc
and
and
CCONJ
CC
conj
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin
make
makes
VERB
VBZ
det
no
no
DET
DT
amod
Degree=Pos
logical
logical
ADJ
JJ
obj
Number=Sing
connection
connection
NOUN
NN
case
to
to
ADP
IN
compound
Number=Sing
LHC
LHC
PROPN
NNP
nmod
Number=Sing
physics
physics
NOUN
NN
punct
;
;
PUNCT
:
det
Definite=Def|PronType=Art
the
the
DET
DT
nsubj
Number=Sing
argument
argument
NOUN
NN
cop
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin
be
is
AUX
VBZ
advmod
not
not
PART
RB
parataxis
Degree=Pos
valid
valid
ADJ
JJ
punct
;
;
PUNCT
:
det
Definite=Def|PronType=Art
the
the
DET
DT
nsubj
Number=Sing
argument
argument
NOUN
NN
cop
Mood=Ind|Number=Sing|Person=3|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin
be
is
AUX
VBZ
advmod
not
not
PART
RB
compound
Number=Sing
self
self
NOUN
NN
punct
-
-
PUNCT
HYPH
parataxis
Degree=Pos
consistent
consistent
ADJ
JJ
punct
.
.
PUNCT
.
punct
''
''
PUNCT
''