12.2: Graph Structures
- Describe and interpret relationships in graphs.
- Model relationships with graphs.
Graph theory is used in neuroscience to study how different parts of the brain connect. Neurobiologists use functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to measure levels of blood in different parts of the brain, called nodes. When nodes are active at the same time, it suggests there is a functional connection between them so they form a network. This network can be represented as a graph where the vertices are the nodes and the functional connections are the edges between them. (Mikey Taylor, "Graph Theory & Machine Learning in Neuroscience," Medium.com, June 24, 2020.
Importance of the Degrees of Vertices
One reason scientists study these networks is to determine how successful the communication within a network continues to be when it experiences failures in nodes and connections. Graphs can be used to study the resilience of these networks. (Mikey Taylor, "Graph Theory & Machine Learning in Neuroscience," Medium.com, June 24, 2020)
The graphs in Figure
represent neural networks, where the vertices are the nodes, and the edges represent functional connections between them. Which graph do you think would represent a network with the highest resistance to failure? Which graph would probably be the most vulnerable to failure? How might this relate to the degrees of the vertices?- Answer
-
Graph B represents a network that would have the highest resistance to failure because there are more edges connecting the nodes indicating there are more connections between nodes than on either of the other graphs. This would make the network more resistant to failure because there are more options to work around a faulty edge or node. Graph A would probably be the most susceptible to failure because the network depends on a few particular edges and vertices for connections. There are more vertices of higher degree in Graph B than in Graph A because there are more edges connecting the nodes.
Sociologists use graphs to study connections between people and to identify characteristics that make communities more resilient, more likely to stay connected over time. In the graphs shown, the edges represent social connections and the vertices are individuals.
Which graph do you think represents the most resilient community? What is the sum of the degrees of all the vertices in this graph?
Which graph do you think represents the community that is least likely to stay connected over time? What is the sum of the degrees of all the vertices in this graph?
Is the sum of the degrees higher or lower in a more resilient community?
Relating the Number of Edges to the Degrees of Vertices
In the applications of graph theory to neuroscience and sociology in Example
and YOUR TURN , there was a correlation between the degrees of vertices and the resilience of a network. Researchers in many fields have also observed a direct relationship between the number of edges in a graph and the degrees of the vertices. To begin to understand this relationship, consider a graph with five vertices and zero edges as in Figure .Instead of being marked with a name, each vertex in Figure 12.21 is marked with its degree. In this case, all of the degrees are 0 so the sum of the degrees is also zero. Suppose that we add an edge between any two existing vertices and indicate the degrees of the vertices. This gives us a graph with five vertices and one edge like the graph in Figure
.Note that the degrees of two vertices increased, each by 1. So, the sum of the degrees is now 2. Suppose that we continue in this way, adding one edge at a time and making note of the number of edges and the sum of the degrees of the vertices as in Figure 12.23.
Figure
demonstrates a characteristic that is true of all graphs of any shape or size. When the number of edges is increased by one, the sum of the degrees increases by two. This happens because each edge has two ends and each end increases the degree of one vertex by one unit. As a result, the sum of the degrees of the vertices on any graph is always twice the number of edges. This relationship is known as the Sum of Degrees Theorem .
For the Sum of Degrees Theorem,
\[sum of the degrees \(=2 \times\) number of edges \nonumber \]
or
\[\text { number of edges }=\frac{\text { sum of degrees }}{2} \nonumber \]
Suppose that a graph has five edges.
- Find the sum of the degrees of the vertices.
- Draw two different graphs that demonstrate this conclusion.
- Answer
-
- The sum of the degrees is twice the number of edges: 2 × 5=10. The sum of the degrees is 10.
- See Figure .
Suppose that the sum of the degrees of a graph is six.
Find the number of edges.
Draw two graphs that demonstrate your conclusion.
Completeness
Suppose that there were five strangers in a room, A , B , C , D , and E , and each one would be introduced to each of the others. How many introductions are necessary? One way to begin to answer this question is to draw a graph with each vertex representing an individual in the room and each edge representing an introduction as in Figure
.Let's approach the problem by thinking about how many new people Person \(A\) would meet, then Person \(B\), and so on, making sure not to repeat any introductions. The first graph in Figure
shows Person \(A\) meeting Persons \(B, C, D\), and \(E\), for a total of 4 introductions. The next graph shows that Person \(B\) still has to meet Persons \(C, D\), and \(E\), for a total of 3 more introductions. The next graph shows that Person \(C\) still has to meet Persons \(D\) and \(E\), which is 2 more introductions. The next graph shows that Person \(D\) only remains to meet Person \(E\), which is 1 more introduction. The final graph has \(4+3+2+1=10\) edges representing 10 introductions. The last graph is an example of a complete graph because each pair of vertices is joined by an edge. Another way of saying this is that the graph is complete because each vertex is adjacent to every other vertex. Figure shows complete graphs with three, four, five, and six vertices.Suppose we want to know the number of introductions necessary in a room with six people. This would be represented by a complete graph with six vertices, and the total number of introductions would be , the number of edges in the graph. In fact, you can always find the number of introductions in a room with people by adding all the whole numbers from 1 to .
The number of edges in a complete graph with vertices is the sum of the whole numbers from 1 to , .
Suppose that we want to determine how many introductions are necessary in a room with 500 strangers. In other words, suppose that we want to determine the number of edges in a complete graph with 500 vertices. Adding up all the numbers from 1 to 499 could take a long time! In the next example, we use the Sum of Degrees Theorem to make the problem more manageable.
Use the Sum of Degrees Theorem to determine the number of introductions required in a room with
- 6 strangers.
- 10 strangers.
- strangers.
- Answer
-
- Since there are 6 strangers, there are 6 vertices. Since each individual must meet 5 other individuals, there are 5 edges meeting at each vertex which means each vertex has degree 5. Since there are 6 vertices of degree 5 , the sum of degrees is \(6 \cdot 5=30\). By the Sum of Degrees Theorem, the number of edges is half the sum of the degrees, which is \(\frac{30}{2}=15\). So, the total number of introductions is 15.
- Since there are 10 strangers, there are 10 vertices. Since each individual must meet 9 other individuals, there are 9 edges meeting at each vertex which means each vertex has degree 9. Since there are 10 vertices of degree 9 , the sum of degrees is \(10 \cdot 9=90\). By the Sum of Degrees Theorem, the number of edges is half the sum of the degrees, which is \(\frac{90}{2}=45\). So, the total number of introductions is 45.
- Since there are \(n\) strangers, there are \(n\) vertices. Since each individual must meet \(n-1\) other individuals, there are \(n-1\) edges meeting at each vertex which means each vertex has degree \(n-1\). Since there are \(n\) vertices of degree \(n-1\), the sum of degrees is \(n(n-1)\). By the Sum of Degrees Theorem, the number of edges is half the sum of the degrees, which is \(\frac{n(n-1)}{2}\). So, the total number of introductions is \(\frac{n(n-1)}{2}\).
Determine the number of introductions necessary in a room with 500 strangers using the Sum of Degrees Theorem.
Now we have a shorter way to calculate the number of introductions in a room with strangers, and the number of edges on a complete graph with vertices. Let’s update our formula.
The number of edges in a complete graph with vertices is .
Subgraphs
Sometimes a graph is a part of a larger graph. For example, the graph of South Florida Airports from Figure 12.8 is part of a larger graph that includes Orlando International Airport in Central Florida, which is shown in Figure
The graph in Figure
includes an additional vertex, MCO, and additional edges shown with dashed lines. The graph of direct flights between South Florida airports from Figure 12.1.7 is called a subgraph of the graph that also includes direct flights between Orlando and the same South Florida airports in Figure . In general terms, if Graph B consists entirely of a set of edges and vertices from a larger Graph A , then B is called a subgraph of A .In Figure
, Graph G is given, along with four diagrams. Determine whether each diagram is or is not a subgraph of Graph G and explain why.- Answer
-
- Diagram J is not a subgraph of Graph G because edge ec is not in Graph G .
- Diagram K is a subgraph of Graph G because all of its vertices and edges were part of Graph G .
- Diagram L is not a graph at all, because there is a line extending from vertex a that does not connect a to another vertex. So, Diagram L cannot be a subgraph.
- Diagram M is not a subgraph of Graph G because it contains a vertex f , which is not part of G .
Draw a subgraph of Graph F from Figure 12.1.3 that has exactly four vertices and five edges.
Identifying and Naming Cycles
When you think of a cycle in everyday life, you probably think of something that begins and ends the same way. For example, the water cycle (Figure 12.29) begins with water in a lake or ocean, which evaporates into water vapor, condenses into clouds, and then returns to earth as rain or some other form of precipitation that settles into lakes or oceans. A cycle in graph theory is similar in that it begins and ends in the same way: It is a series of connected edges that begin and end at the same vertex but otherwise never repeat any vertices.
In a cycle, there are always the same number of vertices as edges, and all vertices must be of degree 2. Cycles are often referred to by the number of vertices. For example, a cycle with 5 vertices can be called a 5-cycle. Cycles can also be named after polygons based on the number of edges. For example a 5-cycle is also called a pentagon. Table
lists these names for cycles of size 3 through size 10.| Cycle Category | Number of Edges | Example |
|---|---|---|
| triangle | 3 | |
| quadrilateral | 4 | |
| pentagon | 5 | |
| pentagon | 6 | |
| heptagon | 7 | |
| octagon | 8 | |
| octagon | 9 | |
| octagon | 10 |
There are many more polygon names, including a megagon that has a million edges and a googolgon that has \(10^{100}\) edges, but usually we just say \(n\)-gon when the number \(n\) is past 10 . For example, a cycle with 11 edges could be called an 11-gon.
Notice that the 10-cycle, or decagon, appears to cross over itself in Table
. Remember, graphs can be drawn differently but represent the same connections. In Figure , the same decagon is transformed into a graph that does not appear to overlap itself. We have done this without changing any of the connections so both diagrams represent the same relationships, and both diagrams are considered decagons.Did the name "googolgon" ring a bell for you? If so, there is a good reason for it. The creators of Google.com renamed their search engine Google, a misspelled reference to the number "googol" alluding to the enormous number of calculations their algorithm can tackle. A googol is a 1 followed by 100 zeroes, or \(10^{100}\). William L. Hosch, "Google, American Company," https://www.britannica.com/topic/Google-Inc , Encyclopedia Britannica online)
Cyclic Subgraphs and Cliques
When cycles appear as subgraphs within a larger graph, they are called cyclic subgraphs . Cyclic subgraphs are named by listing their vertices sequentially. The vertex where you begin is not important. Graph K in Figure
has two triangle cycles ( g , h , j ) and ( h , i , j ), and one quadrilateral cycle ( g , h , i , j ).The same cycle can be named in many ways, but we must keep in mind that listing two vertices consecutively indicates an edge exists between them. For example, (g, h, i, j) can also be named (h, i, j, g) or (j, i, h, g). However, you cannot name it (g, i, h, j,) which doesn't reflect the correct order of the vertices. We can see that the order (g, i, h, j) is incorrect because the cycle has no edges gi or hj.
Identify the types of cyclic subgraphs in Graph H in Figure
and name them.- Answer
-
In order to avoid missing a cycle, begin by analyzing the vertex a , then proceed in alphabetical order. Vertex a is part of two cycles, the quadrilateral cycle ( a , b , f , g ,) and the hexagonal cycle ( a , b , c , d , e , f ). Next look at vertex b . It is part of the hexagonal cycle ( b , c , d , e , f , g ). After checking each of the remaining vertices, we see there are no other cycles.
In order to avoid naming the same cycle twice, consider naming cycles beginning with the letter closest to the beginning of the alphabet and then progressing clockwise.
Which types of cycles are in Graph G in Figure
? Use the vertices of the graph to give a name for one of each type that you find.We have seen that sociologists use graphs to study the structures of social networks. In sociology, there is a principle known as Triadic Closure. It says that if two individuals in a social network have a friend in common, then it is more likely those two individuals will become friends too. Sociologists refer to this as an open triad becoming a closed triad. This concept can be visualized as graphs in Figure a and person b each has a friendship with person c . In the closed triad, person a and person a have also developed a friendship. Notice that the graph representing the closed triad is a three-cycle, or a triangle, in graph theory terms.
Another topic of interest to sociologists, as well as computer scientists and scientists in many fields, is the concept of a clique . In a social group, a clique is a subgroup who are all friends. A triad is an example of a clique with three people, but there can be cliques of any size. In graph theory, a clique is a complete subgraph.
The graphs in YOUR TURN
represent social communities. The vertices are individuals and the edges are social connections. Use the graphs to answer the questions.- Which graph has the most triads? Name the triangles.
- Which graph has the fewest triads? Name the triangles.
- How might an increase in the number of triads in a graph affect the resilience of a community? Explain your reasoning.
- Identify a clique with more than three vertices in Graph E by naming its vertices.
- Answer
-
- Graph E has the most triads. The triangles are ( a, b, c ), ( a, e, g ), ( c, f, i ), ( e, g, h ), ( e, h, i ), and ( f, h, i ).
- Graph D has the fewest triads. There are no triangles in the graph.
- More triads means vertices of greater degree, which indicates greater resilience. Specifically, if an edge is removed from a closed triad, there the two individuals who are no longer adjacent are still connected by way of the third member of the triad.
- The vertices a, e, c, and g form a clique with four vertices.
From Exercise 35 in Section 12.1.0 Exercise s, Chloe is interested to know how many in her network of Roblox friends are also friends with each other, so she polls them. The following is a list of each of Chloe’s friends and their common friends. Find a pentagon cycle in the graph of the Roblox friends in Chloe’s network that includes Chloe.
- Aria is friends with no one else in Chloe’s network.
- Benicio is friends with Dakshayani, Eun-ah, and Fukashi.
- Dakshayani is friends with Benicio.
- Eun-ah is friends with Benicio and Fukashi.
- Fukashi is friends with Benicio and Eun-ah.
Three-Cycles in Complete Graphs
Just as complete graphs have a predictable number of edges, complete graphs have a predictable number of cyclic subgraphs. Let’s look at the three-cycles within complete graphs with up to six vertices, which are shown in Figure
.Let's list the names of all the triangles in each graph. Since every pair of vertices is adjacent, any three vertices on a complete graph form a triangle . There is only one triangle in the complete graph with three vertices, ( a , b , c ). For the rest of the graphs, it is important that we take an organized approach. Start with the vertex that is first alphabetically, listing any triangles that include that vertex also in alphabetical order. Then, proceed to the next vertex in the alphabet, and list any triangles that include that vertex, except those that are already listed. Keep going in this way as shown in Table 12.2.
| Complete Graph With: | 3 Vertices | 4 Vertices | 5 Vertices | 6 Vertices |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All a triangles | ( a , b , c ) |
(
a, b, c
), (
a, b, d
),
( a, c, d ) |
(
a, b, c
), (
a, b, d
), (
a, b, e
)
( a, c, d ), ( a, c, e ) ( a, d, e ) |
(
a, b, c
), (
a, b, d
), (
a, b, e
), (
a, b, f
)
( a, c, d ), ( a, c, e ), ( a, c, f ) ( a, d, e ), ( a, d, f ) ( a, e, f ) |
| Other b triangles | None | ( b, c, d ) |
(
b, c, d
), (
b, c, e
),
( b, d, e ) |
(
b, c, d
), (
b, c, e
), (
b, c, f
)
( b, d, e ), ( b, d, f ) ( b, e, f ) |
| Other c triangles | None | None | ( c, d, e ) |
(
c, d, e
), (
c, d, f
)
( c, e, f ) |
| Other d triangles | None | None | None | ( d, e, f ) |
| Total | 1 |
(4+3+2+1)+(3+2+1)+(2+1)+1
|
Look at the last row in Table
. Do you see a pattern emerge for counting triangles in a complete graph? Without drawing a complete graph with 7 vertices, we can predict that it will have triangles inside it. This pattern also appears in a famous diagram known to Western mathematicians as "Pascal’s Triangle." Figure 12.35 displays the first 11 rows of Pascal’s Triangle. Row 0 of Pascal’s Triangle only has the number 1 in it. The first and last entries in each of the other rows are also 1s. Otherwise, all the entries are formed by adding two entries from the previous row. For example, in row 6, entry 1 is 6, which was found by adding 1 and the 5 from the previous row, and entry 2 is 15, which was found by adding the 5 and the 10 from the previous row, as shown in Table .IMPORTANT! When you count the rows and entries of Pascal’s Triangle begin with row 0 and entry 0, not row 1 and entry 1.
The Mathematical Secrets of Pascal's Triangle by Wajdi Mohamed Ratemi
If we begin to list the third entries in each row of Pascal's triangle from the top down, we see 1, 4, 10, 20, 35, and so on. Notice that these values are exactly the number of triangles in a complete graph of sizes 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, respectively. Specifically, entry 3 in row 7 is 35, the number of triangles in a complete graph of size 7. Let's practice using Pascal’s triangle to find the number of triangles in a complete graph of a particular size.
STEPS TO FIND THE NUMBER OF TRIANGLES IN A COMPLETE GRAPH OF SIZE n
- Step 1 Calculate the entries in row n of Pascal's Triangle using sums of pairs of entries in previous rows as needed.
- Step 2 The number of triangles is entry 3 in row n . Remember to count the entries 0, 1, 2, and 3, from left to right.
Use Pascal’s Triangle in Figure 12.35 to find the number of triangles in a complete graph with 11 vertices.
- Answer
-
Step 1: Identify the row number and calculate its entries. Since the complete graph has 11 vertices, we will need to look in row 11 of Pascal’s Triangle. Use row 10 in Figure 12.35 to find the entries in row 11 as shown in Figure
.
Step 2: Find entry number 3. The number of triangles is in entry 3. Remember to count the entries beginning with entry 0 as shown in Figure
.Entry 3 in row 11 is 165. So, there are 165 triangles in a complete graph with 11 vertices.
A sociologist is studying a community of 13 individuals in which every person has a social connection to every other person. How many closed triads are there in the community?
Since the entries in Pascal’s Triangle are useful in many applications, many resources such as online and traditional calculator functions have been developed to assist in calculating the values. The website dCode.xyz has a tool that automatically calculates entries in Pascal’s Triangle using these steps:
Step 1: Make sure to select Index 0.
Step 2: Select your preference, display the triangle until a particular row (line), display only one row (line), or calculate the value at coordinates (which means give the value of a single entry).
Step 3: Enter row number (line number) you are interested, or enter the row number and entry number in parentheses: (row number, entry number).
Step 4: Select Calculate.
Step 5: Retrieve the answer from the results box.
Check Your Understanding
-
True
-
False
-
True
-
False
-
True
-
False
-
True
-
False
-
True
-
False
-
True
-
False
7. A student found that the sum of the degrees of the vertices in a graph was 13. Why is that impossible?
8. A student finds the number of edges in a complete graph by taking half the number of vertices, then subtracting one from the number of vertices, then multiplying these two values together. Will the student get the correct result?