foreclosure sale. Id. 4 . The appeal was not decided before the settlement described herein was reached and was therefore voluntarily dismissed pursuant to Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b). 5 . A short sale is a sale of real property for less than the total amount owed on a loan secured by that real property that nonetheless, by agreement, generally releases the property from the encumbrance. See Daniel F. Hinkel, Practical Real Estate Law 167 (7th ed.2014). 6 . Diviacchi claims that he did not learn of the events that occurred between the time he filed his lien and the filing of the stipulation of dismissal until September 21. 7 . But cf. Goldstein, Goldman, Kessler & Un-derberg v. 4000 E. River Rd. Assocs., 64 A.D.2d 484, 488, 409 N.Y.S.2d 886 (N.Y.App.Div.1978)(per curiam) (<HOLDING>). 8 . We note that nothing in our decision
holding that the refiling of a tax lien during bankruptcy proceedings did not create perfect or enforce a lien in violation of the  362a4 holding that the lien bond releases the property from the lien but the lien is then secured by the bond holding that although the attorney successfully argued for a reduction in the tax assessment of his clients property producing a measurable saving of taxes for three tax years the savings were not proceeds subject to a lien within the meaning of new yorks attorneys lien statute holding that while section 1825b2 does not extinguish an earlier lien or excuse the payment of a tax by the fdic it does deny the ability to use a lien on fdic property as a vehicle for collection of delinquent tax holding that a lien holder who is not served and joined as a party to a tax suit cannot have his lien extinguished by the tax sale