59(e) motion must be filed within ten days after entry of judgment. See also W.D. WASH. BANKR. R. 9013-1(h) (stating that such motions must be filed within ten days after entry of judgment or order). Here, no written judgment or order was entered and the motion for reconsideration was filed almost eight months after the bankruptcy court’s oral ruling. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 58 defines when entry of judgment has occurred. See also FED. R. BANKR. P. 9021 (applying Rule 58 to bankruptcy proceedings). At the time of the bankruptcy court’s ruling and until December 1, 2002, Rule 58 did not limit the time for filing a motion for reconsideration when no separate written judgment has been entered. See Carter v. Beverly Hills Sav. & Loan Ass’n, 884 F.2d 1186, 1189-90 (9th Cir. 1989) (<HOLDING>). On December 1, 2002, an amendment of Rule 58
holding that where the appealing party withdraws its postjudgment motion and the district court does not issue an order on the motion or the withdrawal the time to appeal begins to run from the entry of final judgment holding that oral rendition of judgment supported by the courts docket sheet was insufficient express specific written order is required holding that a notation on the docket indicating courts decision without a separate written order or judgment did not start time for postjudgment motion holding that a postjudgment motion to incorporate a sanction as part of the final judgment is a motion to modify the judgment and extends the trial courts jurisdiction holding that the rendition of a judgment is the act of the court in pronouncing the judgment accompanied by a notation on the trial docket and any later document setting out in greater detail the judgment merely confirms the docket entry