Esophageal adenocarcinoma (EAC) is the consequence of longstanding gastroesophageal reflux, which leads to inflammation and could cause Barrett’s esophagus (BE), the main risk factor for EAC development. The 5 year survival rate of EAC is poor since the diagnosis occurs at the late stage of the disease. To improve patient management, a better comprehension of the mechanism undergoing the evolution through to adenocarcinoma is needed. Within this scenario, the resident microbiome investigation was studied. This study aimed to explore the esophageal microbial profile in patients affected by non-dysplastic BE, low- and high-grade dysplastic BE, and EAC to identify parameters characterizing cancer progression and to develop a score suitable for clinical practice to stratify cancer risk. The microbiota was investigated through the 16S rRNA gene sequencing of esophageal biopsies. The microbial composition was evaluated at each different taxonomic level along the disease progression. To further investigate bacteria potentially associated with cancer development, non-dysplastic and dysplastic/cancer patients were compared. The presence of the six significant microbial features with multivariate analysis was used to develop a multiparametric score (Resident Esophageal Microbial Dysbiosis Test) to predict the risk of progression toward EAC. Finally, the diagnostic ability of the test and its discrimination threshold for its ability to identify dysplastic/cancer patients were demonstrated. Since EAC has been related to obesity, the relationship between these microbial parameters and patients’ diet/lifestyle habits was also investigated. Developing microbiome-based risk prediction models for esophageal adenocarcinoma onset could open new research avenues, demonstrating that the resident microbiome may be a valid cancer risk biomarker.