Amyloids are misfolded proteins that aggregate into fibrillar structures, the accumulation of which is associated with the pathogenesis of many neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer’s disease (AD). Early, sensitive detection of these misfolded aggregates is of great interest to the field, as amyloid deposition begins well before the presentation of clinical symptoms. Thioflavin-S (ThS) is a fluorescent probe commonly used to detect amyloid pathology. Protocols for ThS staining vary, but they often use high staining concentrations followed by differentiation, which causes varying levels of non-specific staining and potentially leaves more subtle amyloid deposition unidentified. In this study, we developed an optimized ThS staining protocol for the sensitive detection of β-amyloids in the widely used 5xFAD Alzheimer’s mouse model. Controlled dye concentrations together with fluorescence spectroscopy and advanced analytical methods enabled not only the visualization of plaque pathology, but also the detection of subtle and widespread protein misfolding throughout the 5xFAD white matter and greater parenchyma. Together, these findings demonstrate the efficacy of a controlled ThS staining protocol and highlight the potential use of ThS for the detection of protein misfolding that precedes clinical manifestation of disease.