In Austria, female physicians must immediately disrupt their surgical training as soon as their pregnancy is announced. In Germany, surveys on the topic of “female surgeons performing surgery during pregnancy” led to a reform of the German Maternity Protection Act, which came into force on January 1, 2018, and allows female physicians to perform risk-adapted surgery during pregnancy at their own request. However, in Austria, such reform is still pending. The study aimed i) to assess the current situation of how pregnant female surgeons handle their training under the actual restrictive legislature in Austria, especially in context of operative activity, and ii) to identify needs for improvements. Therefore, a nation-wide online survey, initiated by the Austrian Society for Gynecology and Obstetrics and the Young Forum of the Austrian Society of Gynecology and Obstetrics, was performed from June 1 to December 24, 2021, among employed physicians working in surgical specialties. To conduct a general needs assessment, the questionnaire was made available to both female and male physicians in all positions. In total, 503 physicians participated in the survey, of which 70.4% (n = 354) were women and 29.6% (n = 149) were men. The majority of the women (61.3%) were undergoing residency training at the time of their pregnancy. The announcement of the pregnancy to the supervisor(s) occurred on average in the 13th week of gestation (week 2–40). Before that, pregnant female physicians spent an average of 10 h per trimester (first trimester: 0–120 h; second trimester: 0–100 h) in the operating room. The main reason for women to continue surgical activity despite their (yet unreported) pregnancy was “own request”. 93% (n = 469) of the participants explicitly wished to be able to perform surgical activities in a safe setting during pregnancy. This response was independent of gender (p = 0.217), age (p = 0.083), specialty (p = 0.351), professional position (p = 0.619), and previous pregnancy (p = 0.142). In conclusion, there is an urgent need to offer female surgeons the possibility of continuing surgical activities during pregnancy. This handling would significantly increase the career opportunities for women who want to build up both a successful career and a family life.