Plasma cell leukemia is a rare yet aggressive form of multiple myeloma characterized by high levels of plasma cells circulating in the peripheral blood. We recently experienced a case of plasma cell leukemia that had been in stringent complete remission for nine years after autologous stem cell transplantations with subsequent courses of lenalidomide maintenance therapy, and then relapsed as an extramedullary plasmacytoma in the central nervous system. Assessment of the bone marrow did not prove proliferation of plasma cells at relapse, but imbalanced elevation of serum levels of free light chains was observed without changes in other clinical biomarkers including immunoglobulin levels. Salvage chemotherapy with isatuximab, pomalidomide, and dexamethasone (IsaPD) was promptly initiated. After two courses of IsaPD, significant remission was achieved and the neuronal symptoms completely resolved. When excessive serum levels of clonotypic free light chains are noted, their significance should be carefully assessed even when plasma cell propagation in the bone marrow is not observed. In such cases, hematologists should search for extramedullary proliferation of plasma cells, including in the immune-privileged central nervous system.