Gluteal compartment syndrome is a rare disorder and no definitive treatment has yet been established. Fasciotomy is often the treatment of choice for gluteal compartment syndrome, but there have been only a few cases that have improved with conservative therapy. A 26-year-old male with a body mass index of 40.5 who underwent femoral nail extraction surgery had severe pain in the right buttock and numbness in the right lower extremity. Initially, we suspected transient pain due to prolonged exposure to the same posture, but muscle weakness in the lower extremities and worsening of renal function appeared over time. Orthopedic evaluation revealed physical examination findings and MRI imaging findings consistent with gluteal compartment syndrome. Conservative treatment with temporary dialysis was chosen instead of fasciotomy because of the time required for diagnosis. Dialysis was started on postoperative day 3, renal function and muscle weakness recovered over time, and the patient was discharged home on postoperative day 37. At six months post-op, the patient was walking without pain and he had no changes in his peripheral neurologic examination compared to his preoperative baseline. Orthopedic surgeons should always be aware of the possibility of gluteal compartment syndrome when especially obese patients with prolonged operation times appeal to acute buttock pain. Diagnosis should be made as early as possible to get a good prognosis.