The palmaris longus (PL) muscle is considered by many to be a vestigial muscle due to it having little to no functional significance on the upper limb. This, however, made it highly valuable in surgical procedures, especially as a graft in plastic and reconstructive cases. Variations in the muscle’s morphology were discussed in the literature, but some are more rare than others. Those variations may have clinical implications on different pathologies such as Guyon’s syndrome or Carpal tunnel syndrome based on the nerves and vessels surrounding it, and thus demand a proper understanding of the variation’s anatomy. Here, we report a case of one of the rarer variations, a unilaterally reversed palmaris longus muscle in the left forearm of a 55-year-old male cadaver, discovered in a routine teaching session. Throughout the case, we will discuss the normal anatomy, the variation, and the clinical implications this variation may have.