Elevated basal serum tryptase (BST) levels are markers of both mast cell activation and overall mast cell burden. We present a family of four individuals with elevated tryptase levels greater than or equal to 20 mcg/L, all of whom exhibited signs and symptoms suggestive of mast cell activation. Differential diagnoses included hereditary alpha tryptasemia (HaT), systemic mastocytosis (SM), and mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS). In three individuals, SM was ruled out with normal morphology on bone marrow biopsy combined with negative genetic markers. Further workup would be required for the diagnosis of MCAS since serum tryptase levels were not obtained in our emergency department during acute episodes. Although genetic testing for HaT was not available upon initial workup, HaT remains the most likely explanation for this family’s elevated BST.