The anesthetic technique for calcaneal surgery has been reported to include peripheral nerve blocks, such as a sciatic block in the popliteal fossa, followed by intraoperative sedation. Sciatic nerve blocks are associated with limb weakness and fall risk. We present a case of a patient presenting for outpatient calcaneal surgery. The anesthetic plan consisted of a proximal, ultrasound-guided, single-injection selective posterior tibial nerve block followed by intraoperative sedation. The nerve block was performed, surgery concluded, and the patient received six hours of postoperative analgesia. Once the nerve block effects receded, the postoperative pain was managed with only over-the-counter analgesics while the patient was at home. We recommend an ultrasound-guided proximal posterior tibial nerve block for outpatient surgery involving the calcaneus to preserve lower extremity motor strength and provide postoperative analgesia.