Arising from the external and internal iliac veins, the common iliac veins (CIVs) carry blood from the lower extremities and pelvic region into the inferior vena cava at the level of the fifth lumbar vertebra. It is sometimes common to observe slight anomalies in vascular anatomy in patients; however, anomalies of the CIVs are rare. We present a case of a patient with significant edema of the left lower extremity due to extrinsic compression (May-Thurner syndrome [MTS]) involving a duplicated left CIV found during vascular angiography. Anomalies in pelvic vasculature are well documented in the medical literature; however, documented cases of a duplicated CIV remain few and far between. These anomalies in pelvic vascular anatomy are essential to be aware of to avoid surgical complications and understand their implications in associated pathologies.