SignificanceReversal of fetal hemoglobin (HbF) silencing can ameliorate the effects of sickle cell anemia. Despite available gene therapy and stem cell transplantation modalities, the majority of affected patients worldwide will not have access to these in the near future. Thus, there is a need for safe and effective small-molecule therapeutics. We report here that stable occupancy of a major HbF silencing complex containing BCL11A, MBD2a–NURD, and PRMT5 and exclusion of the transcriptional activator NF-Y at the γ-globin gene promoter require specific features of MBD2a. These results provide a unified model for the relationships between the previously reported HbF silencers MBD2–NuRD, BCL11A, DNA methylation, and PRMT5 that may facilitate development of therapeutic agents to reverse HbF silencing.