Background: the deficiency of 5,10-Methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) constitutes a rare and severe metabolic disease and is included in most expanded newborn screening (NBS) programs worldwide. Patients with severe MTHFR deficiency develop neurological disorders and premature vascular disease. Timely diagnosis through NBS allows early treatment, resulting in improved outcomes. Methods: we report the diagnostic yield of genetic testing for MTHFR deficiency diagnosis, in a reference Centre of Southern Italy between 2017 and 2022. MTHFR deficiency was suspected in four newborns showing hypomethioninemia and hyperhomocysteinemia; otherwise, one patient born in pre-screening era showed clinical symptoms and laboratory signs that prompted to perform genetic testing for MTHFR deficiency. Results: molecular analysis of theMTHFRgene revealed a genotype compatible with MTHFR deficiency in two NBS-positive newborns and in the symptomatic patient. This allowed for promptly beginning the adequate metabolic therapy. Conclusions: our results strongly support the need for genetic testing to quickly support the definitive diagnosis of MTHFR deficiency and start therapy. Furthermore, our study extends knowledge of the molecular epidemiology of MTHFR deficiency by identifying a novel mutation in theMTHFRgene.