Merkel cell carcinoma (MCC) is a rare neuroendocrine dermal malignancy seen in elderly light-skinned individuals, associated with immunosuppression and Merkel cell polyomavirus infection. As a neuroendocrine tumor, the recurrence and metastasis of MCC can be evaluated using positron emission tomography-computed tomography (PET-CT) with the Gallium-68-DOTATATE (Ga-68-DOTATATE) radiotracer, which has demonstrated increased sensitivity to neuroendocrine metastases when compared to F-18 fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG). Here, we present the case of a patient with known metastatic MCC with a new, abnormal focus of increased radiotracer activity in the thoracic spine on Ga-68-DOTATATE PET-CT suspected to represent a metastatic lesion. Further evaluation with MRI revealed a benign vertebral hemangioma, highlighting the limitations of this radiotracer in the setting of benign spinal lesions. Multimodality imaging findings of metastatic MCC and potential pitfalls of Ga-68-DOTATATE PET-CT staging are discussed.