SummaryMicrobial community assembly is a complex dynamical process that determines community structure and function. The interdependence of inter-species interactions and nutrient availability presents a challenge for understanding community assembly. We sought to understand how external nutrient supply rate modulated interactions to affect the assembly process. A statistical decomposition of taxonomic structures of bacterial communities assembled with and without algae and at varying dilution frequencies allowed the separation of the effects of biotic (presence of algae) and abiotic (dilution frequency) factors on community assembly. For infrequent dilutions, the algae strongly impact community assembly, driving initially diverse bacterial consortia to converge to a common structure. Analyzing sequencing data revealed that this convergence is largely mediated by a decline in the relative abundance of specific taxa in the presence of algae. This study shows that complex phototroph-heterotroph communities can be powerful model systems for understanding assembly processes relevant to the global ecosystem functioning.