Virginal breast hypertrophy, also known as juvenile macromastia or juvenile gigantomastia, is an uncommon condition characterized by the rapid and excessive growth of breasts in prepubertal or peripubertal girls in the absence of any hormonal or physiological causes. While virginal breast hypertrophy is a rare benign disorder that occurs independent of hormonal stimulation, it can cause a diagnostic challenge to physicians and requires a multidisciplinary team to get it right. It also results in detrimental effects, both physical and psychological, for young girls. We present a case of virginal breast hypertrophy in an 11-year-old Saudi girl, which was successfully managed. This report will contribute to knowledge sharing with healthcare professionals in Saudi Arabia about this rare case. It can also pave roads for further research to understand the underlying mechanisms and to standardize treatment modalities.