Methemoglobinemia is an acute medical emergency that requires prompt correction. Physicians should have a high degree of suspicion of methemoglobinemia in cases that present with hypoxemia that does not resolve with supplemental oxygenation, and they should confirm this suspicion with a positive methemoglobin concentration on arterial blood gas. There are multiple medications that can induce methemoglobinemia, such as local anesthetics, antimalarials, and dapsone. Phenazopyridine is an azo dye used over-the-counter as a urinary analgesic for women with urinary tract infections, and it has also been implicated in causing methemoglobinemia. The preferred treatment of methemoglobinemia is methylene blue, but its use is contraindicated for patients with glucose-6-phosphatase deficiency or those who take serotonergic drugs. Alternative treatments include high-dose ascorbic acid, exchange transfusion therapy, and hyperbaric oxygenation. The authors report a case of a 39-year-old female who took phenazopyridine for 2 weeks to treat dysuria from a urinary tract infection and subsequently developed methemoglobinemia. The patient had contraindications for the use of methylene blue and was therefore treated with high-dose ascorbic acid. The authors hope that this interesting case promotes further research into the utilization of high-dose ascorbic acid for managing methemoglobinemia in patients who are unable to receive methylene blue.