Amyloidosis is a plasma cell dyscrasia that leads to the excessive production and deposition of mutant protein fragments in various organs. Cardiac amyloidosis is often implicated in two main subtypes: transthyretin (ATTR) and light chain (AL). While both subtypes increase the risk of restrictive cardiomyopathy, cardiogenic shock, and arrhythmias, poorer outcomes are seen in those with cardiac infiltration secondary to AL amyloidosis. Prognosis depends on the timing of diagnosis and the extent of the disease burden prior to recognition and treatment. The following case report describes a young patient who was admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) for concerns of decompensated heart failure of unknown etiology, later determined to be due to amyloidosis. We describe her clinical course prior to and during hospital admission, along with the proposed physiologic factors that may have contributed to her poor outcome.