Treatment of a painful neuroma is a challenging problem for both the patient and the providers. Current surgical treatment options typically include excision of the neuroma and stump relation. However, with both treatment options, patients have high rates of persistent pain and rates of neuroma recurrence. We describe two patients with neuromas treated with our acellular nerve allograft reconstruction technique. This technique involves the excision of the neuroma and bridging the proximal nerve end to the surrounding tissue with an acellular nerve allograft. Both patients had immediate resolution of their neuropathic pain that was maintained at their final follow-up. Acellular nerve allograft reconstruction is a promising treatment option for the treatment of painful neuromas.