Silver nanoparticles have become one of the most commercially and industrially relevant nanomaterials of the 21st century, owing to their potent antibacterial properties, as well as their useful catalytic and optical properties. Although many methods have been explored to produce AgNPs, we favor the photochemical approach using photoinitiators to produce AgNPs, owing to the high degree of control over reaction conditions, and the generation of so-called AgNP ‘seeds’ that can be used as-is, or as precursors for other silver nanostructures. In this work, we explore the scale-up of AgNP synthesis using flow chemistry and assess the usefulness of a range of industrial Norrish Type 1 photoinitiators in terms of flow compatibility and reaction time, as well as the resulting plasmonic absorption and morphologies. We establish that while all the photoinitiators used were able to generate AgNPs in a mixed aqueous/alcohol system, photoinitiators that generate ketyl radicals showed the greatest promise in terms of reaction times, while also showing greater flow compatibility compared to photoinitiators that generate 𝛼-aminoalkyl and α-hydroxybenzyl radicals. These findings help to establish a guideline for adapting photochemical AgNP syntheses to flow systems, helping to improve the scalability of the method in one of the largest industries in nanomaterial chemistry.