BackgroundIn midwifery education, the clinical learning experience (CLE) is a critical component to gaining competency and should comprise greater than 50% of a student’s education. Many studies have identified positive and negative factors affecting students’ CLE. However, few studies have directly compared the difference in CLE based on placement at a community clinic versus a tertiary hospital.MethodsThe aim of this study was to examine how clinical placement site, clinic or hospital, impacts students’ CLE in Sierra Leone. A once 34-question survey was given to midwifery students attending one of four public midwifery schools in Sierra Leone. Median scores were compared for survey items by placement site using Wilcoxon tests. The relationship between clinical placement and student’s experience were assessed using multilevel logistic regression.ResultsTwo-hundred students (hospitals students = 145 (72.5%); clinic students = 55 (27.5%) across Sierra Leone completed surveys. Most students (76%, n = 151) reported satisfaction with their clinical placement. Students placed at clinics were more satisfied with opportunities to practice/develop skills (p = 0.007) and more strongly agreed preceptors treated them with respect (p = 0.001), helped improve their skills (p = 0.001), provided a safe environment to ask questions (p = 0.002), and had stronger teaching/mentorship skills (p = 0.009) than hospital students. Students placed at hospitals had greater satisfaction in exposure to certain clinical opportunities including completing partographs (p < 0.001); perineal suturing (p < 0.001); drug calculations/administration (p < 0.001) and estimation of blood loss (p = 0.004) compared to clinic students. The odds of students spending more than 4 h per day in direct clinical care were 5.841 (95% CI: 2.187–15.602) times higher for clinic students versus hospital students. There was no difference between clinical placement sites in regards to number of births students attended (OR 0.903; 95% CI: 0.399, 2.047) or number of births students managed without a preceptor/clinician present (OR 0.729; 95% CI: 0.285, 1.867).ConclusionThe clinical placement site, hospital or clinic, impacts midwifery students’ CLE. Clinics offered students significantly greater attributes of a supportive learning environment and access to direct, hands-on opportunities for patient care. These findings may be helpful for schools when using limited resources to improve the quality of midwifery education.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12909-023-04413-y.