With blood stream infections (BSIs) representing a major cause of mortality and morbidity worldwide, blood cultures play a crucial role in diagnosis, but their clinical application is dampened by the long turn-around time and the detection of only culturable pathogens. In this study, we developed and validated a shotgun metagenomics next-generation sequencing (mNGS) test directly from positive blood culture fluid, allowing for the identification of fastidious or slow growing microorganisms more rapidly. The test was built based on previously validated next-generation sequencing tests, which rely on several key marker genes for bacterial and fungal identification. The new test utilizes an open-source metagenomics CZ-ID platform for the initial analysis to generate the most likely candidate species, which is then used as a reference genome for downstream, confirmatory analysis. This approach is innovative because it takes advantage of an open-source software’s agnostic taxonomic calling capability while still relying on the more established and previously validated marker gene-based identification scheme, increasing the confidence in the final results. The test showed high accuracy (100%, 30/30) for both bacterial and fungal microorganisms. We further demonstrated its clinical utility especially for anaerobes and mycobacteria that are either fastidious, slow growing, or unusual. Although applicable in only limited settings, the Positive Blood Culture mNGS test provides an incremental improvement in solving the unmet clinical needs for the diagnosis of challenging BSIs.