This paper discusses modeling the behavior and prediction of fracture of brittle materials. Numerous publications show that progress in this area is characterized by the emergence of a number of new models that meet the requirements of the mining industry, construction and other engineering practices. The authors focus only on one class of models, paying special attention to the compromise between simplicity of solution and versatility of the model. A new version of the model is proposed, taking into account the advantages of previous models. We present a differential energy criterion for brittle fracture substantiated, according to which, fracture occurs at a certain ratio of dissipated and stored (elastic) energy. Fracture is considered as the end of the deformation process with a virtual transformation of the initial material almost without cracks into a real material with cracks. The highest and lowest elastic moduli are analytically determined, respectively, on the ascending and descending branches of the stress–strain curve. A graphical version of the algorithm for determining the brittle fracture point on the post-peak branch of the stress–strain curve is proposed. The modeling results are consistent with the experimental data known from the literature.