Filarial nematodes can cause debilitating diseases such as lymphatic filariasis and onchocerciasis. Oxfendazole (OXF) is one promising macrofilaricidal candidate with improved oral availability compared to flubendazole (FBZ), and OXF is currently under preparation for phase 2 clinical trials in filariasis patients. This study aimed to investigate the immune system’s role during treatment with OXF and FBZ and explore the potential to boost the treatment efficacy via stimulation of the immune system. Wild type (WT) BALB/c, eosinophil-deficientΔdblGata1,IL-4r/IL-5−/−, antibody-deficient μMT and B-, T-, NK-cell and ILC-deficientRag2/IL-2rγ−/−mice were infected with the rodent filariaLitomosoides sigmodontisand treated with an optimal and suboptimal regimen of OXF and FBZ for up to 5 days. In the second part, WT mice were treated for 2–3 days with a combination of OXF and IL-4, IL-5, or IL-33. Treatment of WT mice reduced the adult worm burden by up to 94% (OXF) and 100% (FBZ) compared to vehicle controls. In contrast, treatment efficacy was lower in all immunodeficient strains with a reduction of up to 90% (OXF) and 75% (FBZ) forΔdblGata1, 50 and 92% forIL-4r/IL-5−/−, 64 and 78% for μMT or 0% forRag2/IL-2rγ−/−mice. The effect of OXF on microfilariae and embryogenesis displayed a similar pattern, while FBZ’s ability to prevent microfilaremia was independent of the host’s immune status. Furthermore, flow cytometric analysis revealed strain-and treatment-specific immunological changes. The efficacy of a shortened 3-day treatment of OXF (−33% adult worms vs. vehicle) could be boosted to a 91% worm burden reduction via combination with IL-5, but not IL-4 or IL-33. Our results suggest that various components of the immune system support the filaricidal effect of benzimidazolesin vivoand present an opportunity to boost treatment efficacy.