Cardiac amyloidosis remains a rare disease caused by the extracellular deposition of abnormal proteins-amyloids in the myocardium. These protein structures in the myocardium are associated with high morbidity and mortality, with prognosis hinging on early detection and treatment. Three main types of cardiac amyloidosis have been identified: light chain (AL), familial or senile (ATTR), and secondary amyloidosis which is associated with chronic inflammation. Cardiac amyloidosis classically presents as diastolic heart failure with symptoms of volume overload low voltage on electrocardiogram (ECG) and echocardiographic features of diastolic dysfunction and paradoxical left ventricular hypertrophy (paradoxical with respect to low voltage on ECG). Early suspicion should trigger additional laboratory and imaging workup to facilitate early detection. Early detection remains critical to prognosis. Herein, we present two patients admitted to a safety-net hospital within one month of each other with distinct presentations yet important, overlapping characteristics that led to the diagnosis of AL amyloidosis in both patients.