Teratomas are the most common benign ovarian neoplasms in young women. Typical computed tomography imaging findings include fat, fat fluid level, tooth or calcification, rokitansky nodule, floating balls sign, and tufts of hair. They can have unusual imaging features leading to diagnostic dilemmas. Studies have shown the presence of intratumoral fat to be specific to ovarian cystic teratoma. However, there are reports in the literature of mature cystic teratoma that do not contain fat in the lumen of the cyst which can hinder an accurate diagnosis. They can be associated with various complications like torsion, rupture, malignant transformation, infection, and autoimmune hemolytic anemias. Presented here is a case of mature cystic teratoma without visible intracystic fat which underwent torsion.