A randomized trial of circumferential pulmonary vein ablation versus antiarrhythmic drug therapy in paroxysmal atrial fibrillation: the APAF Study. A Randomized Controlled Trial of the Efficacy and Safety of Electroanatomic Circumferential Pulmonary Vein Ablation Supplemented by Ablation of Complex Fractionated Atrial Electrograms Versus Potential-Guided Pulmonary Vein Antrum Isolation Guided by Intracardiac Ultrasound Circumferential Pulmonary Vein Ablation With Additional Linear Ablation Results in an Increased Incidence of Left Atrial Flutter Compared With Segmental Pulmonary Vein Isolation as an Initial Approach to Ablation of Paroxysmal Atrial Fibrillation Circumferential pulmonary vein ablation: does use of a circular mapping catheter improve results? A prospective randomized study. Role of residual potentials inside circumferential pulmonary veins ablation lines in the recurrence of paroxysmal atrial fibrillation. Selective segmental ostial ablation and circumferential pulmonary veins ablation. Results of an individualized strategy to cure refractory atrial fibrillation Prevention of Iatrogenic Atrial Tachycardia After Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation: A Prospective Randomized Study Comparing Circumferential Pulmonary Vein Ablation With a Modified Approach Achievement of pulmonary vein isolation in patients undergoing circumferential pulmonary vein ablation: a randomized comparison between two different isolation approaches. Catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation in patients with diabetes mellitus type 2: results from a randomized study comparing pulmonary vein isolation versus antiarrhythmic drug therapy. Symptomatic and asymptomatic atrial fibrillation after pulmonary vein ablation and the impact on quality of life. Ablation for longstanding permanent atrial fibrillation: results from a randomized study comparing three different strategies.
OBJECTIVES We compared ablation strategy with antiarrhythmic drug therapy ( ADT ) in patients with paroxysmal atrial fibrillation ( PAF ) . BACKGROUND Atrial fibrillation ( AF ) ablation strategy is superior to ADT in patients with an initial history of PAF , but its role in patients with a long history of AF as compared with ADT remains a challenge . METHODS One hundred ninety-eight patients ( age , 56 + /- 10 years ) with PAF of 6 + /- 5 years ' duration ( mean AF episodes 3.4/month ) who had failed ADT were r and omized to AF ablation by circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA ) or to the maximum tolerable doses of another ADT , which included flecainide , sotalol , and amiodarone . Crossover to CPVA was allowed after 3 months of ADT . RESULTS By Kaplan-Meier analysis , 86 % of patients in the CPVA group and 22 % of those in the ADT group who did not require a second ADT were free from recurrent atrial tachyarrhythmias ( AT ) ( p < 0.001 ) ; a repeat ablation was performed in 9 % of patients in the CPVA group for recurrent AF ( 6 % ) or atrial tachycardia ( 3 % ) . At 1 year , 93 % and 35 % of the CPVA and ADT groups , respectively , were AT-free . Ejection fraction , hypertension , and age independently predicted AF recurrences in the ADT group . Circumferential pulmonary vein ablation was associated with fewer cardiovascular hospitalizations ( p < 0.01 ) . One transient ischemic attack and 1 pericardial effusion occurred in the CPVA group ; side effects of ADT were observed in 23 patients . CONCLUSIONS Circumferential pulmonary vein ablation is more successful than ADT for prevention of PAF with few complications . Atrial fibrillation ablation warrants consideration in selected patients in whom ADT had already failed and maintenance of sinus rhythm is desired . ( A Controlled R and omized Trial of CPVA Versus Antiarrhythmic Drug Therapy in for Paroxysmal AF : APAF/01 ; http:// clinical trials.gov/ct/show ; NCT00340314 ) Background —The study was conducted to compare relative safety and efficacy of pulmonary vein antrum isolation ( PVAI ) using intracardiac echocardiographic guidance and circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA ) for atrial fibrillation ( AF ) using radiofrequency energy . Methods and Results —Sixty patients ( 81 % men ; 81 % paroxysmal ; age , 56±8 years ) failing 2±1 antiarrhythmic drugs were r and omly assigned to undergo CPVA ( n=30 ) or PVAI ( n=30 ) at 5 centers between December 2004 and October 2007 .  CPVA patients had circular lesions placed at least 1 cm outside of the veins . Ipsilateral veins were ablated en block with the end point of disappearance of potentials within the circular lesion . Left atrial roof line and mitral isthmus line were ablated without verification of block . For patients in AF postablation or with AF induced with programmed stimulation , complex fractionated electrograms were mapped and ablated to the end point of AF termination or disappearance of complex fractionated electrograms . PVAI did not include complex fractionated electrogram ablation . Esophageal temperature was monitored and kept within 2 ° C of baseline or under 39 ° C . Success was defined as absence of atrial tachyarrhythmias ( AF/AT ) off antiarrhythmic drugs . There was no difference between CPVA and PVAI regarding to baseline variables , catheter used , duration of the procedure , or RF delivery . Fluoroscopy time was longer with PVAI ( 54±17 minutes versus 77±18 minutes , P=0.0001 ) . No significant complications occurred in either arm . PVAI was more likely to achieve control of AF/AT off antiarrhythmic drugs ( 57 % versus 27 % , P=0.02 ) at 2±1 years of follow-up . Conclusions —A single PVAI procedure is more likely to result in freedom from AF/AT off antiarrhythmic drugs than CPVA supplemented by complex fractionated electrogram ablation in select patients Background —There has been growing concern that linear ablation is associated with an increased risk of iatrogenic arrhythmias in patients undergoing ablation for atrial fibrillation ( AF ) . Therefore , we compared circumferential pulmonary vein ablation plus left atrial linear ablation ( CPVA+LALA ) with segmental pulmonary vein isolation (PVI)in  patients with paroxysmal AF . Methods and Results —Sixty-six consecutive patients with paroxysmal AF were prospect ively r and omly assigned to receive PVI versus CPVA+LALA ( consisting of encircling lesions around the pulmonary veins ) , a roof line , and a mitral isthmus line with documentation of bidirectional mitral isthmus block . All patients were seen at 1 , 3 , 6 , and every 12 months after ablation , with 14-day continuous ECG monitoring every 6 months . At 16.4±6.3 months after 1 ablation procedure , 19 patients ( 58 % ) remained free of atrial arrhythmias after PVI versus 17 patients ( 51 % ) after CPVA+LALA ( P=0.62 ) . After PVI , 14 patients had recurrent paroxysmal AF , whereas after CPVA+LALA , 8 patients had recurrent AF , 6 had atypical left atrial flutter ( LAFL ) , and 2 had both AF and LAFL ( P=0.32 between PVI versus CPVA+LALA for AF but P=0.002 for LAFL ) . Twenty-eight patients ( 85 % ) remained arrhythmia-free after 1.3±0.5 PVI procedures versus 28 patients ( 85 % ) after 1.4±0.6 CPVA+LALA procedures ( P = NS ) . Fluoroscopy time was longer after CPVA+LALA versus PVI ( 91 versus 73 minutes , P=0.04 ) . Conclusions —As an initial ablation approach in patients with paroxysmal AF  , more LAFL occurred after CPVA+LALA and fluoroscopy times were longer compared with segmental PVI BACKGROUND The best method for performing atrial fibrillation ( AF ) ablation is still under debate . The importance of using a circular mapping ( CM ) catheter for assessing isolation of the pulmonary vein ( PV ) antrum on the outcome of the procedure has not been clearly established . OBJECTIVE The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether use of a CM catheter improves the arrhythmia-free proportion after circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA ) . METHODS A series of 146 consecutive patients ( 83 % males , age 53 + /- 10 years , 53 % paroxysmal AF ) were r and omized to two ablation strategies . In both groups , ipsilateral PV encirclement was performed until disappearance or dissociation of the local electrogram within the surrounded area . In the first group , only the radiofrequency catheter was used to both map and ablate ( CPVA group , n = 73 ) . In the other group , a CM catheter was added to assess the electrical activity of the PV antrum ( CPVA-CM group , n = 73 ) . An ablation line along the left atrial roof was also created in all patients . RESULTS Procedural and fluoroscopic times were longer in the CPVA-CM group ( P < .05 ) . Severe procedure-related complications occurred in 1 ( 1.4 % ) patient in the CPVA group and in 3 ( 4.1 % ) patients in the CPVA-CM group ( P = .317 ) . After mean follow-up of 9 + /- 3 months , 31 ( 42.5 % ) patients in the CPVA group and 47 ( 64.4 % ) patients in the CPVA-CM group were arrhythmia-free without antiarrhythmic medication ( P = .008 ) . CONCLUSION Use of a CM catheter to ensure isolation of the PV antrum improved the success of CPVA but increased some procedural requirements BACKGROUND Residual gaps due to incomplete ablation lines are known to be the most common cause of recurrent atrial fibrillation ( AF ) after catheter ablation . We hypothesized that any residual potentials at the junction of the left atrium and pulmonary vein ( PV ) , inside the circumferential PV ablation ( CPVA ) lines , would contribute to the recurrence of AF or post-AF ablation atrial flutter ( AFL ) ; therefore , the elimination of these potentials increases AF-/AFL-free survival rates . METHODS AND RESULTS One hundred and two patients with paroxysmal AF ( PAF ) were enrolled and prospect ively r and omized to a group with  ablation of residual potentials  as add-on therapy to  CPVA + PV electrical isolation ( PVI ) ( group 1 , n = 49 ) , or a group without ablation of the residual potentials ( group 2 , n = 53 ) . Post-CPVA residual potentials , inside the ablation lines , were identified by contact bipolar electrode mapping catheter and a detailed 3-dimensional voltage map . Twenty-three patients in group 1 and 18 patients in group 2 had post-CPVA residual potentials ( 46.9 % vs 34.0 % , P = 0.182 ) . The AF-/AFL-free survival rate during follow-up of 23.3 ± 7.9 months was not different in comparisons between the 2 groups ( P = 0.818 ) , and 79.6 % and 81.1 % of the patients in groups 1 and 2 maintained a sinus rhythm ( P = 0.845 ) , respectively . CONCLUSIONS Residual potentials inside CPVA were commonly found in the patients with PAF after CPVA + PVI . Further ablation of residual potentials did not increase the efficacy of catheter ablation in patients with PAF Aims Previous studies have analyzed the efficacy of atrial fibrillation (  AF )  ablation in series of consecutive patients or comparing methods in a r and omized way , without taking account individual patient characteristics . The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of a strategy based on selecting the ablation method according to patient clinical features in drug-refractory paroxysmal or persistent AF . Methods and results Patients with left atrial diameter ≤40 mm and runs of atrial tachycardia of more than ten beats during Holter recording were selected for selective segmental ostial ablation ( SSOA ) in order to disconnect only those pulmonary veins with electrical potentials . The remaining patients underwent circumferential pulmonary veins ablation ( CPVA ) to modify left atrial substrate by extensive linear lesions . A group of 131 consecutive patients were included . Mean follow-up was 21.5 ± 15.2 months . In paroxysmal AF , 44 and 55 patients were selected for SSOA and CPVA , respectively , and the efficacy of the procedure was similar in the two groups ( 77 vs 74 % ; log-rank test p = NS ) . In persistent AF , 6 and 26 patients underwent SSOA and CPVA , respectively , and greater efficacy was observed in the second group ( 17 vs 65 % ; log-rank test p = 0.004 ) . Conclusions Selecting the ablation method according to patient characteristics achieved good results and reduced the overall amount of ablated atrial tissue in patients with paroxysmal AF . However , in persistent AF the SSOA technique showed very limited efficacy despite the previous patient selection and a CPVA-like procedure may be the appropriate choice in all cases Background —Circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA ) is effective in curing  atrial fibrillation ( AF ) , but new-onset left atrial tachycardia ( AT ) is a potential complication . We evaluated whether a modified CPVA approach including additional ablation lines on posterior wall and the mitral isthmus would reduce the incidence of AT after PV ablation . Methods and Results —A total of 560 patients ( 291 men , 52 % ; age , 56.5±7.3 years ) entered the study ; 280 were r and omized to CPVA alone ( group 1 ) and 280 to modified CPVA ( group 2 ) . The primary end point was freedom from AT after the procedure . In group 1 , 28 patients ( 10 % ) experienced new-onset AT , and 41 ( 14.3 % ) experienced recurrent AF . In group 2 , 11 patients ( 3.9 % ) experienced AT , and 36 ( 12.9 % ) had recurrent AF . Group 1 was more likely to experience AT than group 2 ( P=0.005 ) . Freedom from AF after ablation was similar in both groups ( P=0.57 ) . Among those in group 1 , gap-related macroreentrant AT was documented in 23 of the 28 patients ( 82 % ) , and focal AT was found in 5 ( 18 % ) . In group 2 , gap-related macroreentrant AT was found in 8 of the 11 patients ( 73 % ) , and focal AT was seen in 3 ( 27 % ) . Two patients in group 1 and 1 patient in group 2 had both AT and AF . The strongest predictor of AT was the presence of gaps ( P<0.001 ) . Conclusions —Modified CPVA is as effective as CPVA in preventing AF but is associated with a lower risk of developing incessant AT INTRODUCTION Circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA ) with the endpoint of pulmonary vein ( PV ) isolation has been developed as an effective therapy for atrial fibrillation ( AF ) . This endpoint can be achieved either by closing gaps along circular lines or by segmental PV isolation inside the circular lines after creation of initial CPVA lesions . We investigated whether the clinical outcome depends on the PV isolation approach used during the first-time CPVA procedure . METHODS AND RESULTS One hundred consecutive patients ( 69 male ; age , 56.7 + /- 11.6 years ) who underwent first-time CPVA for treatment of symptomatic AF were enrolled . PV isolation was r and omly achieved either by CPVA alone ( aggressive CPVA [ A-CPVA ] group , n = 50 ) or by a combination of CPVA with segmental PV ostia ablation ( modified CPVA [ M-CPVA ] group , n = 50 ) . Recurrence of atrial tachyarrhythmias ( ATa ) within 3 months after the initial procedure occurred in 30 patients ( 60 % ) in the M-CPVA group and in only 15 patients ( 30 % ) in the A-CPVA group ( P < 0.01 ) . ATa relapse after the first 3 months was detected in 21 patients ( 42 % ) in the M-CPVA group , compared with 9 patients ( 18 % ) in the A-CPVA group ( P = 0.01 ) . At 13 + /- 4 months , patients treated by the A-CPVA approach had greater freedom from ATa recurrence than patients who underwent M-CPVA ( P = 0.01 ) . The M-CPVA approach was the only independent predictor associated with procedural failure ( RR 0.318 ; 95 % CI 0.123 - 0.821 ; P = 0.02 ) . CONCLUSIONS When PV isolation is the endpoint of CPVA , the efficacy of the A-CPVA approach is better than that of M-CPVA INTRODUCTION Atrial fibrillation ( AF ) and diabetes mellitus type 2 ( DM2 ) often coexist ; however , a small number of patients with DM2 undergoing catheter ablation ( CA ) of AF  have been included in previous studies . The aim of this study was to evaluate safety and efficacy of ablation therapy in DM2 patients with drug refractory AF . METHODS AND RESULTS From January 2005 to September 2006 , 70 patients with a diagnosis of DM2 and paroxysmal ( n = 29 ) or persistent ( n = 41 ) AF were r and omized to receive either pulmonary vein isolation or a new antiarrhythmic drug treatment ( ADT ) with a 1-year follow-up . The primary endpoint was the time to first AF recurrence . By Kaplan-Meier analysis , at the end of follow-up , 42.9 % of patients in the ADT group and 80 % of patients who received a single ablation procedure and were without medications were free of AF ( P = 0.001 ) . In the ablation group , a significant improvement in quality -of-life ( QoL ) scores as compared with ADT group was observed . Six patients in the ADT group ( 17.1 % ) developed significant adverse drug effects . Hospitalization rate during follow-up was higher in the ADT group ( P = 0.01 ) . The only complication attributable to ablation was one significant access-site hematoma . CONCLUSION In patients with DM2 , CA of AF provides significant clinical benefits over the ADT and appears to be a reasonable approach regarding feasibility , effectiveness , and low procedural risk BACKGROUND The aim of this prospect i ve study was to evaluate the recurrences of atrial fibrillation ( AF ) and flutter ( AFL ) after circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA )  using repetitive long-term Holter recordings , and to evaluate the change in quality of life ( QoL ) , especially in patients with asymptomatic AF recurrences . METHODS A total of 149 patients with AF were followed up with 7-day Holter monitoring at 3 , 6 , and 12 months after CPVA .  We calculated the burden of AF/AFL defined as the percentage of time in AF/AFL , and patients with documented arrhythmia were divided into isolated symptomatic episodes of arrhythmia , mixed symptomatic/asymptomatic arrhythmia , or isolated asymptomatic arrhythmia . The QoL was analyzed with SF-36 question naires in patients with sinus rhythm after CPVA , and in patients with recurrence of symptomatic and asymptomatic arrhythmia , respectively . RESULTS Asymptomatic arrhythmia was observed in 44 % of the patients with documented arrhythmia at 12 months of follow-up . In patients with persistent AF , 63 % of the documented arrhythmia at 12 months of follow-up was asymptomatic and often persistent . In the subgroup of patients with asymptomatic arrhythmia , the QoL improved significantly in the physical scores , in contrast to patients with symptomatic arrhythmia who had unchanged or worsened QoL scores . CONCLUSIONS Asymptomatic arrhythmia is very common after AF ablation . Our data indicate that these patients improve their physical component of the QoL significantly , which may be considered a palliative success of treatment . We suggest that patients with asymptomatic AF recurrences are carefully evaluated before considering reablation . Repetitive rhythm monitoring after AF ablation is very important considering the postablation management of anticoagulant therapy BACKGROUND This prospect i ve multicenter r and omized study aim ed to compare the efficacy of 3 common ablation methods used for longst and ing permanent atrial fibrillation ( AF ) . METHODS A total of 144 patients with longst and ing permanent AF ( median duration 28 months ) were r and omly assigned to circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA , group 1 , n = 47 ) , to pulmonary vein antrum isolation ( PVAI , group 2 , n = 48 ) or to a hybrid strategy combining ablation of complex fractionated or rapid atrial electrograms ( CFAE ) in both atria followed by a pulmonary vein antrum isolation ( CFAE + PVAI , group 3 , n = 49 ) . RESULTS Scarring in the left atrium and structural heart disease/hypertension were present in most patients ( 65 % ) . After a mean follow-up of 16 months , 11 % of patients in group 1 , 40 % of patients in group 2 and 61 % of patients in group 3 were in sinus rhythm after one procedure and with no antiarrhythmic drugs ( P < .001 ) . Sinus rhythm maintenance would increase respectively to 28 % ( group 1 ) , 83 % ( group 2 ) , and 94 % ( group 3 ) after 2 procedures and with antiarrhythmic drugs ( AADs , P < .001 ) . The AF terminated during ablation , either by conversion to sinus rhythm or organization into an atrial tachyarrhythmia , in 13 % of patients ( group 1 ) , 44 % ( group 2 ) , and 74 % ( group 3 ) respectively . CFAE alone , performed as the first step of the ablation in group 3 , organized AF in only 1 patient . CONCLUSION In this study , the hybrid AF ablation strategy including antrum isolation and CFAE ablation had the highest likelihood of maintaining sinus rhythm in patients with longst and ing permanent AF . Electrical isolation of the PVs , although inadequate if performed alone , is relevant to achieve long-term sinus rhythm maintenance after ablation . Bi-atrial CFAE ablation had a minimal impact on AF termination during ablation
We observed statistically significantly better AT recurrence-free survival with CPVA than with ADT .
BACKGROUND Circumferential pulmonary vein ablation ( CPVA ) has become common therapy for atrial fibrillation ( AF ) , but results of large r and omized controlled trials comparing this procedure with antiarrhythmic drug therapy ( ADT ) have not been published to date .
We conducted a systematic literature review to assess whether CPVA is superior to ADT for the management of AF .