Prospective randomized controlled trial comparing Lichtenstein with modified Bassini repair of inguinal hernia. [Lichtenstein patch versus Shouldice technique in primary inguinal hernia with a high risk of recurrence]. Pain after primary inguinal herniorrhaphy: influence of surgical technique. Prospective randomized comparison of the Shouldice and Lichtenstein hernia repair procedures. [Management of inguinal hernia--a comparison of current methods]. The tension-free hernioplasty in a randomized trial. Randomised study of Lichtenstein compared with Shouldice inguinal hernia repair by surgeons in training. [Mesh-plug operation for treating inguinal hernia. Randomized studies]. Lichtenstein patch or Perfix plug-and-patch in inguinal hernia: a prospective double-blind randomized controlled trial of short-term outcome. Short-term outcome after mesh or shouldice herniorrhaphy: a randomized, prospective study. ["Tension-free technique" in open inguinal hernia repair. A prospective, randomized study of postoperative pain perception ("tension-free reconstruction" vs. Shouldice technique)].
We present a prospective randomized study of 80 patients with inguinal hernia who underwent either a modified Bassini repair (n = 38) or a Lichtenstein mesh repair (n = 42). Treatment groups were matched for age, side of hernia, type of hernia and ASA grade. There was no difference in the time taken to perform the two operations: the mean time taken to perform Lichtenstein repair was 26.8 min (range 12 to 49), Bassini repair taking a mean of 27.5 min (range 9 to 51), P = 0.76. There was, however, a difference between the operating times with respect to the type of hernia present, direct hernias being the fastest to repair. Pain scores were assessed by a visual analogue scale, and there was significantly less pain in the Lichtenstein group, P = 0.028. Despite this, there was no difference between the analgesic requirements of the two groups, P = 0.073. In order to assess rehabilitation, lengths of time not working and not driving were assessed. There was no difference in either measurement, P = 0.335 and 0.467 respectively. Patients were followed up a mean of 7 weeks post-operatively (range 1 to 13 weeks). There was no significant difference between the two procedures with regard to post-operative urinary complications, wound infection or other complications. All measurements except the time taken to perform the operation were independent of the surgeon involved. The accuracy of the clinical diagnosis was also assessed, and found to be moderate, with 63% of diagnoses being correct. 209 primary inguinal hernias in patients older than 60 years with high risk for recurrence and for surgery were randomly allocated to Shouldice repair (107 hernias) or Lichtenstein patch (102 hernias). Over a 30 months period there was one recurrence in the Lichtenstein group. The amount of local anesthetic and postoperative pain medication was significantly reduced in the Lichtenstein group, 9.8% of repairs requiring no pain medication at all, and 29.4% none on the first postoperative day. No other hernia repair is as painless, innocuous, and easily performed under local anesthesia as the Lichtenstein patch. Both, Lichtenstein and Shouldice, serve their purpose almost ideally when done correctly. Pain is an important problem after ambulatory hernia repair. To assess the influence of the surgical technique on postoperative pain, two separate randomized, patient-blinded, controlled trials were performed in men with an indirect inguinal hernia.
                In study A, 48 patients with an internal inguinal ring smaller than 1.5 cm were randomly allocated to either simple extirpation of the hernial sac or extirpation plus annulorrhaphy. In study B, 84 patients with an internal inguinal ring wider than 1.5 cm were randomly allocated to extirpation plus annulorrhaphy or extirpation plus Lichtenstein mesh repair (modified). All operations were performed under unmonitored local anesthesia with standardized perioperative analgesia using methadone and tenoxicam. Pain was scored daily for the first postoperative week and after 4 weeks on a four-point verbal-rank scale (no, light, moderate, or severe pain) during rest, while coughing, and during mobilization (rising to the sitting position). Use of supplementary analgesics (paracetamol) was recorded. Cumulative daily pain scores for the first postoperative week and the number of patients who used supplementary analgesics were the main outcome measures.
                There were no significant differences in cumulative pain scores or use of supplementary analgesics between the treatment groups in either study. Cumulative pain scores were significantly higher during coughing and mobilization than during rest in both studies.
                Choice of surgical technique for open repair of a primary indirect inguinal hernia has no influence on postoperative pain. To compare the Lichtenstein, tension-free mesh, and the Shouldice, 4-layer Bassini repair of the inguinal hernia.
                Prospective randomized clinical trial.
                A private suburban hernia center.
                Six hundred seventy-two men with inguinal hernias, aged 20 to 90 years, seen at the hernia center between January 1, 1990, and December 31, 1995.
                Slightly modified Shouldice and Lichtenstein repairs were used to repair primary and recurrent inguinal hernias.
                Recurrence rates, symptoms (including patient satisfaction), and infections.
                A total of 717 repairs in 672 patients, including 45 bilateral repairs, have been monitored to date. Recurrence of hernia occurred in 7 Shouldice repairs and 2 mesh repairs. Twelve superficial infections associated with Shouldice and 6 associated with mesh repairs were found.
                Both types of hernia repair are comparable and effective, but long-term results favor the Lichtenstein technique for reducing recurrences (to a P value of .10), ease of technical mastery, and application to the outpatient setting by use of a local anesthetic. Between July 1995 and June 1996, 280 patients were operated on for inguinal hernia within the scope of a prospective, randomized study. The aim of the study was to compare the Shouldice technique with tension-free hernioplasty (Lichtenstein, TAPP). The operation time was comparable in all three groups. There was less need for analgesics and postoperative morbidity was less after the tension-free technique. No severe complications such as deep wound infection or infection of the implant were seen in any of the groups. After a follow-up period of 18 months, we found two recurrences after the Shouldice operation and one recurrence in each of the tension-free groups. Treatment satisfaction after tension-free hernioplasty was high. One year after the Shouldice operation, about 10% of the patients were dissatisfied because of persistent discomfort and pain. Because of lower morbidity, less pain, and low recurrence rates after tension-free hernioplasty, we find the tension-free techniques to be superior to conventional hernioplasty. The tension-free hernioplasty as introduced by Lichtenstein has gained increasing acceptance during the last decade although the technique has not been evaluated in a randomized trial.
                This randomized study compares the 2-year follow-up results after 102 tension-free hernioplasties with implantation of a prolene mesh in all groin hernias to 53 Cooper ligament repairs in direct hernias and 53 abdominal ring repairs in indirect hernias.
                After tension-free repairs five hernias recurred (5%), and after either Cooper ligament or abdominal ring repair, 16 recurrences were found (15%) (P = 0.025). No indirect hernias recurred after a tension-free repair; 2 recurred after abdominal ring repair (4%; NS). The recurrence rate after tension-free repairs for primary direct inguinal hernias was 7% as compared with 30% after Cooper ligament repair (P = 0.0081). No difference in complication rate between the tested methods was found.
                Recurrence rate is reduced to one-third after tension-free herniotomies as compared with the conventionel herniotomies without increase in complication rate. To compare the outcome following Lichtenstein open mesh technique or Shouldice repair for inguinal hernia operated on by surgeons in training.
                Prospective, randomised, trial.
                District hospital, Sweden.
                200 men with primary inguinal hernias.
                Lichtenstein mesh repair or Shouldice repair.
                Duration of operation, postoperative pain assessed by visual analogue scale (VAS), complications within 30 days, duration of sick leave, and recurrence within one year.
                178 patients were available for evaluation (n = 89 in each group). There were no significant differences in duration of operation, pain score, or incidence of postoperative complications. Patients in the mesh group took significantly less sick leave (mean 18.2 days) than those in the Shouldice group (23.8 days, p<0.05). The number of recurrences differed significantly between the groups with 9 in the Shouldice group and none in the mesh group (p<0.01).
                For surgeons in training the Lichtenstein open mesh technique is a better method of inguinal hernia repair than the Shouldice technique. The outcome is better for the patients and it is more cost-effective. In the period from October 1996 to April 1997 a prospective randomized study of one hundred patients with inguinal hernia was performed. 50 patients underwent the Bassini procedure (group I) and others tension-free mesh-plug repair (Lichtenstein in Rutkow's modification) (group II). The type of hernia was classified according to Gilbert's classification in Rutkow's modification. We used t- Student test and Mann-Whitney's test to evaluate significant differences. There was no significant difference in patients' age, types of hernia or the type of anesthesia between to groups. The time of operation was significantly shorter in group II (median 51.8 min) than in group I (median 63 min). During the post operative period more patients from group I required narcotic analgetics (64% versus 22%). The rate of complications was similar (8% and 6% respectively). Hospital stay was significantly shorter in group II-median 4 days versus 6 days in group I. Rehabilitation to normal activity and return to work was also shorter in group II-median 2 weeks versus 3 weeks (not statistically significant). During the follow up period 1-17 months no recurrences were observed. Open mesh used in anterior inguinal hernia repair can be configured as a flat patch (Lichtenstein operation) or as a cone-shaped preformed plug and supplementary patch (plug-and-patch operation; Perfix Plug; Davol Inc, Cranston, RI).
                One hundred forty-one patients were randomly allocated and blinded to receive either a Lichtenstein patch or a Perfix plug-and-patch. Information before the operation and on postoperative days 3 and 14 was recorded by an independent blinded observer to include operating time, postoperative pain, analgesic medication, return to activity and work, and quality of life assessment.
                Operating time (32 vs 37.6 minutes) was significantly shorter in the plug-and-patch group (P = .01). During days 1 through 8, patients who had undergone the plug-and-patch operation experienced less pain, and their physical functioning on day 3 was significantly better (P = .013). Days of analgesic medication (4.0 vs 4.6 days), return to normal activity (2.8 vs 3.6 days), return to work (17.0 vs 20.8 days), and total days of work missed (14.3 vs 16.1 days) were similar in both groups (P = NS for all comparisons).
                Compared with patients who received the Lichtenstein patch for ambulatory inguinal hernia repair, patients who underwent the Perfix plug-and-patch operation experienced less postoperative pain in the first 8 days after the operation but consumed similar postoperative analgesic medication. The rate of return to normal activity and work is similar in both groups, which indicates no superiority for the plug-and-patch operation in overall rehabilitation and societal costs. Overall hospital costs are greater for the plug-and-patch operation ($120 [US]) compared with the Lichtenstein patch ($20 [US]), with a negligible (5.6 minutes) saving of operating room time for the plug-and-patch operation. Retrospective analyses have shown that long-term recurrence rates after Lichtenstein mesh and Shouldice herniorrhaphies are low. Therefore differences in short-term outcome may be important determinants of one's choice of repair. Although proponents of the mesh repair claim that their methods is less morbid, to our knowledge no prospective comparative studies of short-term morbidity have been reported.
                One hundred five adult patients were randomized to undergo either a mesh or Shouldice inguinal hernia repair. Postoperative pain, narcotic use, and time to resumption of usual activities and employment were recorded. Patients were blinded to the type of repair received until all data were collected.
                There was no difference between the herniorrhaphy methods with respect to postoperative pain, duration of narcotic use, and time to resumption of usual activity and employment. Recovery was rapid for both groups of patients. By 3 days after operation, 50% of patients rated their pain as very mild or less and no longer required narcotic analgesics. Patients in both groups returned to usual activity and work by a median of 9 days after operation.
                Both of these well-established methods can be used to repair inguinal hernias with local anesthetics in an outpatient setting with minimal morbidity. Despite the "tension-free" design of the mesh repair, short-term outcomes of mesh and Shouldice repairs of inguinal hernias do not differ. A prospective randomized study was performed on 64 patients suffering from primary inguinal hernia. Two groups were formed, each consisting of 32 patients. The patients either underwent tension-free surgical treatment or Shouldice herniorraphy. The aim of the study was to determine if the tension-free operative technique on inguinal hernia patients reduces postoperative pain intensity by 2 days in comparison to the patients receiving Shouldice repair treatment. By using the VAS was shown that at no time was there any significant difference in the pain sensation levels between the two groups. The amount of pain tablets consumed among the patients was similar in each group. The number of complications in both groups was also comparable. During the postoperative follow-up of 6 days six patients in the tension-free surgical group and four patients in the Shouldice group developed uncomplicated hematomas on the 4th day, which were traced to the heparin medication. One patient from the Shouldice group suffered from temporary swelling of the scrotum. The advantage of open tension-free repair using extraperitoneally placed polypropylene mesh is that the technique is simple, size-adapted, and can be carried out easily and at any time under local anesthesia. With regard to the lower recurrence rate of hernia as published in the American literature, this can only be verified by randomized studies.
There is evidence that the use of open mesh repair is associated with a reduction in the risk of recurrence of between 50% and 75%. Although the trials were heterogenous there is also some evidence of quicker return to work and of lower rates of persisting pain following mesh repair.