Study of the effect of different prophylaxis frequencies on the periodontium of young adult males. Preventive periodontic treatment procedures: results over 46 months. 3-year longitudinal study of the periodontal status of an adult population with gingivitis. Comparative longitudinal study of 2 methods of scheduling maintenance visits; 2-year data. Effect of professional tooth cleaning on healing after periodontal surgery. The effect of a single scaling with or without oral hygiene instruction on gingival bleeding and calculus formation. Significance of frequency of professional tooth cleaning for healing following periodontal surgery. Effect of monthly professional mechanical tooth cleaning on periodontal health in adults. The effect of systematic plaque control on bone regeneration in infrabony pockets.
nan nan 69 adults ranging in age from 20 to 73 (mean age: 37) were randomly assigned to a control (C) and a test (T) group. Of these, 61 completed the 3-year longitudinal study. All subjects had varying degrees of gingivitis at the start, but no overt periodontitis. Following a base line examination for P1I, GI, probing depth (PD) and recession, a differential darkfield microscopic (DDFM) count of subgingival bacterial morphotypes was carried out on a pooled sample originating from one tooth surface in each sextant with the greatest probing depth. Examinations were repeated every 6 months for 3 years. The C group received regular prophylaxes every 6 months. The T subjects received prophylaxes according to a previously described schedule, and on the basis of the DDFM test outcome. Recall intervals at the end of the study for the T group ranged from 1 to 24 months (mean: 15.7 months). Of 30 subjects in the T group at the end of the study, one half had not had their teeth cleaned for periods of 18 to 36 months without any detectable deterioration in their periodontal status by comparison with the other T subjects or the patients in the C group. Both C and T subjects exhibited increased mean P1I and GI scores as compared to base line during the first half of the study. However, mean PD measurements remained unchanged. Increases in PD from base line of 3 mm or more were observed only in approximately 1 out of a 1000 individual tooth surface comparisons, a frequency comparable to that expected to occur by chance alone. This observation indicates that in this population, little if any pocket formation occurred during the study period. GI score increases of 2 units or more occurred in relatively few subjects. 2 of 31 C patients accounted for 42% of the affected dental units, while 5 out of 30 T subjects accounted for 40.8% of the affected dental units in that group. These observations suggest that despite the relatively high prevalence and incidence of gingivitis, the subjects were relatively resistant to periodontitis. Neither preventive schedule was effective in eliminating gingivitis. The lack of significant destructive disease in this population prevented any meaningful comparison of the relative effectiveness of the two preventive maintenance regimens in preventing recurrences of periodontitis. This report compares the clinical and microbiological status of 2 groups of subjects with treated periodontis on different maintenance schedules. 43 control (C) subjects were given prophylaxes every 3 months. 40 test (T) subjects were given this service on a flexible schedule according to the proportions of spirochetes and/or motile rods in fresh smears of subgingival scrapings. Both groups were examined every 6 months clinically and microbiologically. This report presents base line, 1- and 2-year data. Generally, mean values for both groups did not differ significantly from one another. Both groups exhibited comparable increases in GI and PLI scores during the first 2 years of this study. No change in probing depth was noted between base line and the 2-year examination. However, a slight increase in attachment level, as determined by probing, was noted in both groups. Both groups also exhibited similar proportions of bacterial morphotypes at base line and subsequent examinations. Disease recurrence, defined as an increase in probing depth of 3 mm or more from base line on any tooth surface during the 2-year period, tended to be more prevalent in the C than in the T group (15/43 C and 9/40 T subjects). However, the proportional difference between the groups was not statistically significant. Subjects with disease recurrence in the T group had greater proportions of spirochetes at base line than subjects in the same group without disease recurrence (20.2% versus 9.8%, p less than 0.01). This difference in proportions persisted if both groups were examined jointly, but was only of borderline significance (16.0% versus 10.5%, p = 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS) The investigation was undertaken to find out whether favourable conditions for healing after periodontal surgery would develop in patients whose oral hygiene was professionally maintained at a high standard. The study was performed on 20 patients with advanced periodontal disease. Following an initial examination, comprising plaque index and gingival index scoring, measurement of pocket depths and loss of attachment, the patients were randomly distributed between a test and a control group. The patients first received professional cleaning of the teeth once every 2 weeks. The patients of the control group were recalled for scaling of the teeth once every 6 months. All patients were reexamined after 6, 12 and 24 months. It was found that the control patients were unable to maintain a high standard of oral hygiene with the result that the treatment of the periodontal disease failed. The patients of the test group maintained a high standard of oral hygiene, and the treatment of the periodontal disease was, therefore, successful. 136 students of both sexes aged 14-18 years who were deprived of regular dental care participated in a 22-month longitudinal study. All students underwent scaling of the assigned teeth in 2 quadrants according to a randomised split-mouth design on contralateral quadrants. 2 groups of students were formed, one group received oral hygiene instruction (OHI). Follow-up examinations on gingival bleeding and calculus were carried out 6, 12, and 22 months after the scaling session. The prevalence of calculus on assigned teeth at baseline was high with a mean score of 1.10. At the end of the study, new calculus formation on scaled teeth reached a mean score of 0.58. Formation of calculus still continued on non-scaled teeth, but at a lower rate than on scaled teeth. Scaling resulted in an approximately 20% reduction of the gingival bleeding score which remained during the 22 months follow-up period. OHI had no significant effect on the calculus and bleeding scores. Since the effect of scaling alone on the gingival condition was small and the effect of a single OHI negligible, the practice of occasional scaling without repeated OHI, which is commonly employed in developing countries, should be considered as clinically irrelevant and of little use in improving the standard of periodontal health. nan The beneficial effects of comprehensive dental prophylaxis programs are well recognized. In order to study the factors determining the effectiveness of these programs, 28 periodontal recall patients were subjected to monthly professional mechanical tooth cleanings. Experimental and control teeth were randomly selected according to a splitmouth cross-over method. The Plaque and Gingival indices were recorded 1 month prior to the study, at the start, and at 4, 8, and 12 months. One month prior to the study calculus and bacterial plaque were thoroughly removed from all teeth. During the study period only the experimental teeth were cleaned. Efforts were made not to influence the oral hygiene of the participants by any other means. Following the initial tooth cleaning and during the preexperimental period the Plaque and Gingival indices decreased to a low level on both the experimental and control teeth (mean P1I = 0.4, mean GI = 0.3). This high standard of oral hygiene and gingival health was maintained throughout the study period, and no differences could be observed between experimental and control teeth. This indicates that factors other than the mechanical professional cleaning were responsible for the maintenance of gingival health. It is suggested that participation in the program in itself may have motivated the patients to improve their oral home care. A clinical trial was undertaken to test the hypothesis that periodontitis can be cured and that bone regeneration occurs in infrabony pockets in patients maintained on an optimal standard of oral hygiene. The material comprised 24 patients with advanced periodontal disease. After an initial examination, the patients were randomly distributed into one test group and one control group. All the patients were given instruction and practice in a proper oral hygiene technique, and then subjected to periodontal surgery using the modified Widman flap procedure. Following treatment, during a 2-year period the patients of the test group were recalled once every second week for professional tooth cleaning. The control patients were recalled once every 12 months for prophylaxis. The results showed that all osseous defects of the patients of the test group were refilled with bone. The control patients, on the other hand, could not maintain a high standard of oral hygiene, and exhibited a progressive deterioration of the periodontal tissues during the postsurgical observation time.
The research evidence is of insufficient quality to reach any conclusions regarding the beneficial and adverse effects of routine scaling and polishing for periodontal health and regarding the effects of providing this intervention at different time intervals. High quality clinical trials are required to address the basic questions posed in this review.