A randomized study comparing an antireflux system with a direct ureteric anastomosis in patients with orthotopic ileal neobladders. Better compliance contributes to better nocturnal continence with orthotopic ileal neobladder than ileocolonic neobladder after radical cystectomy for bladder cancer. Antireflux nipples or afferent tubular segments in 70 patients with ileal low pressure bladder substitutes: long-term results of a prospective randomized trial. Ileocaecal vs ileal neobladder after radical cystectomy in patients with bladder cancer: a comparative study. Renal function up to 16 years after conduit (refluxing or anti-reflux anastomosis) or continent urinary diversion. 1. Glomerular filtration rate and patency of uretero-intestinal anastomosis.
To assess the benefit of an antireflux system in patients with orthotopic ileal neobladders, as there is controversy about whether reflux prevention offers any advantages.
                We conducted a randomized prospective study between January 2002 and March 2004, on 60 patients (53 men and seven women) with a mean (sd) age of 52.7 (7.3) years, who were candidates for orthotopic neobladders. Patients with comorbidities were excluded. Preoperative evaluation included intravenous urography (IVU), cystoscopic biopsy and radioisotope renography to evaluate the differential glomerular filtration rates (GFRs). Cases with normal kidneys and ureters, and with similar GFRs, were enrolled. Surgery comprised a standard radical cystectomy with pelvic lymphadenectomy. The ureters were randomized to either a direct anastomosis into a 5-cm ileal chimney on one side, or to be implanted using the antireflux serous-lined extramural tunnel on the contralateral side in the same patient. Regular follow-up included IVU and renography every 6 months in cancer-free patients.
                The mean (sd) follow-up was 23 (9.6) months. There was prolonged urinary leak from a refluxing ureter in one patient that was treated with a temporary percutaneous nephrostomy. Symptomatic pelvic collections required tube drainage in six cases. Six ureters developed early anastomotic strictures (one direct and five antirefluxing), and were treated with endoscopic ureterotomy in three and open revision in three. Serum creatinine levels were normal in all patients throughout the observation period. GFRs were similar in the two groups. The mean GFRs before surgery and at 6, 12, 18, and 24 months after cystectomy were: 55.1, 50.7, 49.4, 52.2 and 53.9 mL/min for the direct side; and 56.1, 53, 52.4, 53.2 and 50.4 mL/min for renal units with antirefluxing implantation. There was a significant deterioration of the GFRs due to anastomotic strictures, from 48.6 (6.7) mL/min before surgery to 31.8 (15.9) mL/min after the revision (P = 0.01).
                The antireflux procedures were associated with a higher incidence of anastomotic strictures than the direct methods and there was a significant deterioration of renal function after obstruction. The long-term follow-up data are awaited. To investigate, in a randomized controlled study, the degree of continence after the creation of orthotopic ileocolonic and ileal neobladders after cystectomy and to explore a possible mechanism for the difference in continence between these 2 types of orthotopic neobladder.
                From 2003 to 2007, 71 male patients underwent orthotopic lower urinary tract reconstruction with either an ileocolonic or ileal neobladder after radical cystectomy. The degrees of continence and voiding patterns were individually evaluated using urodynamic examinations and a detailed patient questionnaire. The abnormal upper tract was evaluated using intravenous urography and ultrasonography.
                Complete daytime continence was achieved in 90.9% and 89.4% of the patients and functional nocturnal continence 48.5% and 76.3% of patients in the ileocolonic neobladder and ileal neobladder groups, respectively. The urodynamic data showed that the initial volume of both the ileocolonic and the ileal neobladder appeared to not be significantly different statistically, although the compliance of the ileocolonic neobladder was lower than that of the ileal neobladder (P < .05). No difference was found in the parameters such as flow rate, urethral profile length, maximal urethral pressure, or neobladder neck pressure between the 2 neobladder types.
                Although the ileocolonic and ileal neobladders can both achieve a large initial volume, the ileal neobladder has an advantage in the aspect of obtaining satisfactory nocturnal continence because of its greater compliance compared with that of the ileocolonic neobladder. Intestinal low pressure orthotopic bladder substitutes have no major coordinated contractions during micturition. Therefore, the importance and type of reflux prevention were assessed in a prospective randomized study.
                A total of 70 patients with an ileal low pressure bladder substitute was randomized to receive a nipple valve or an isoperistaltic afferent ileal tubular segment for reflux prevention.
                After median observation times of 57 and 45 months, respectively, the results regarding functional reservoir capacity, incidence of infected urine, urinary continence, voiding habits and serum electrolytes, urea and creatinine were similar in both groups. Severe upper tract dilatation due to ureteroileal or nipple stenosis occurred in 9 of 67 evaluable reno-ureteral units (13.5%) in patients with antireflux nipples and in 2 of 69 (3%) in patients with an afferent tubular segment. This difference in favor of the latter cases is significant (Fisher's exact test p < 0.03). Video urodynamics did not show reflux of contrast medium during voiding in either group. A simultaneous intravesical, intra-abdominal and intrapelvic pressure increase was noted during the Valsalva maneuver.
                While long-term upper tract preservation by an afferent tubular ileal segment must be confirmed in larger patient series with longer followup, our results indicate that reflux prevention in patients with orthotopic low pressure bladder substitutes is not a major concern and does not justify the use of antireflux mechanisms with a high complication rate. To compare an ileocaecal orthotopic bladder, (which has been the standard procedure in Egypt for >30 years) with the ileal neobladder, as there is no ideal continent orthotopic bladder replacement for patients after cystectomy for bladder cancer.
                Between June 1999 and December 2001, 60 patients with invasive bladder cancer were randomized into two groups. Group A comprised 29 patients who had radical cystectomy and reconstruction with an ileal neobladder (median age 50 years, 27 men and two women) and group B included 31 who had an ileocaecal bladder substitution after radical cystectomy (median age 51 years, 28 men and three women).
                The complication rate after surgery in group A was 17%, with two deaths, one from acute myocardial infarction and the other from haematemesis. In group B, the complication rate was 13%, with two deaths, one from a massive pulmonary embolism and the other from liver cell failure. Daytime continence was achieved in 93% of patients in group A and 90% in group B. The mean (sd) postvoid residual urine volume was larger in group A than group B, at 90 (72) vs 12 (20) mL. Acidosis and hyponatraemia were evident in the patients in group A but in none in group B (P < 0.05). The pelvicalyceal systems were preserved in 85% of patients in group A and 93% in group B during the 2-year follow-up. The mean (sd) renal cortical thickness was less in group A than in group B, at 1.8 (0.5) and 1.9 (0.2) cm, respectively. Although the cystometric capacity was greater and the basal pressure less in group A than B, these were not reflected in the degree of diurnal and nocturnal continence or back pressure on the renal units.
                Continence in both pouches was similar but the renal units were preserved better in the ileocaecal than in the ileal neobladder. Residual urine volume was greater in the ileal neobladder, with its potential complications of infection and stone formation, and acidosis was more evident. To evaluate the glomerular filtration rate (GFR) and incidence of anastomotic stenosis in patients with urinary diversion by ileal or colonic conduit (refluxing or anti-reflux uretero-intestinal anastomosis) or with a continent caecal reservoir.
                All conduit urinary diversions performed from 1977 to 1984 were randomized by type (ileal or colonic) and by the method of ureteric implantation (with or without anti-reflux technique). In continent caecal reservoirs anti-reflux implantation was used for both ureters. Total and separate GFR were measured pre-operatively and after a mean follow-up of 123 months (range 36-198) with 51Cr-EDTA and scintillation renography.
                Of the 56 evaluable patients, 18 had an ileal and 20 a colonic conduit, and 18 had a continent reservoir. The total mean GFR fell from 88 to 71 mL/min in the ileal group, from 84 to 65 mL/min in the colonic group and from 100 to 85 mL/min in the reservoir group. Separate GFR did not differ significantly between kidneys with and without reflux protection in the patients with a conduit diversion. Strictures occurred in 15 uretero-intestinal anastomoses and were unrelated to the mode of ureteric implantation (in the conduit groups). Renal function improved after ureteric reimplantation in six of seven kidneys, but after balloon dilatation in only one of five.
                GFR fell moderately in all three groups, with no significant intergroup difference, and the continent caecal reservoir compared favourably with conduit diversion. The fall in separate GFR did not differ significantly between kidneys with and without reflux protection. Surgical exploration of uretero-intestinal stenosis is recommended if renal function is threatened.
The evidence from the included trials was very limited. Only five studies met the inclusion criteria; these were small, of moderate or poor methodological quality, and reported few of the pre-selected outcome measures. This review did not find any evidence that bladder replacement (orthotopic or continent diversion) was better than conduit diversion following cystectomy for cancer. There was no evidence to suggest that bladder reconstruction was better than conduit diversion for benign disease. The clinical significance of data from one small trial suggesting that bladder replacement using an ileal segment compared to using an ileocolonic segment is better in terms of lower rates of nocturnal incontinence is uncertain. The small amount of usable evidence for this review suggests that collaborative multi centre studies should be organised, using random allocation where possible.