Disodium cromoglycate compared with beclomethasone dipropionate in juvenile asthma. Nebulized budesonide inhalation suspension compared with cromolyn sodium nebulizer solution for asthma in young children: results of a randomized outcomes trial. Cromolyn versus triamcinolone acetonide for youngsters with moderate asthma. Growth during one year of treatment with fluticasone propionate or sodium cromoglycate in children with asthma. Comparison of fluticasone propionate and sodium cromoglycate for the treatment of childhood asthma (an open parallel group study). A comparison of the effects of sodium cromoglycate and beclomethasone dipropionate on pulmonary function and bronchial hyperreactivity in subjects with asthma. Inhaled steroids compared with disodium cromoglycate in preschool children with episodic viral wheeze. Comparison of the cost-effectiveness of budesonide and sodium cromoglycate in the management of childhood asthma in everyday clinical practice. A 12-month double-blind clinical comparison of betamethasone valerate and sodium chromoglycate in the treatment of asthma. Effects of long-term treatment with inhaled cromoglycate and budesonide on bronchial hyperresponsiveness in patients with allergic asthma. The combined use of betamethasone valerate and sodium cromoglycate in the treatment of asthma. Betamethasone 17 valerate aerosol and disodium chromoglycate in severe childhood asthma. A comparative study of the effects of ketotifen, disodium cromoglycate, and beclomethasone dipropionate on bronchial mucosa and asthma symptoms in patients with atopic asthma. Long-term treatment with sodium cromoglycate, nedocromil sodium and beclomethasone dipropionate reduces bronchial hyperresponsiveness in asthmatic subjects. Betamethasone valerate compared with sodium cromoglycate in asthmatic children. Comparison between sodium cromoglycate (MDI: metered-dose inhaler) and beclomethasone dipropionate (MDI) in treatment of adult patients with mild to moderate bronchial asthma. A double-blind, double-dummy randomized, parallel-group study. Effects of regular inhalation of beclomethasone dipropionate and sodium cromoglycate on bronchial hyperreactivity in asthmatic children.
In a double-blind controlled crossover trial of inhaled disodium cromoglycate and beclomethasone dipropionate in juvenile asthma, beclomethasone produced higher therapeutic scores but significantly so in only two indices--wheeze-free days and morning peak flow rates. Combined treatment offered no advantage over beclomethasone alone. No side-effects were noted. The findings confirm other studies of cromoglycate and a steroid aerosol (betamethasone 17-valerate) but disagree with the only other comparative trial of cromoglycate and beclomethasone, in which both were found equally effective. The availability of antiinflammatory asthma medications for infants and young children has been limited. The objective of this study was to compare effects of nebulized budesonide inhalation suspension and cromolyn sodium nebulizer solution on asthma-related health outcomes in young children with asthma.
                We conducted a randomized, parallel-group, 52-week, open-label study in 36 US clinical sites. Patients included 335 children who were 2 to 6 years of age and had persistent asthma that had been treated with at least 1 long-term control medication; 287 children (86%) completed the study. Patients received budesonide inhalation suspension, 0.5 mg daily (n = 168), or cromolyn sodium nebulizer solution, 20 mg 4 times daily (n = 167), for 8 weeks, followed by dose titration at the investigator's discretion. The main outcome measure was the rate of asthma exacerbations over 52 weeks. Secondary measures included times to first asthma exacerbation and first use of additional asthma therapy, asthma symptom scores, rescue medication use, and health care resource use.
                The budesonide group had a mean (median) asthma exacerbation rate of 1.23 (0.99) per year compared with 2.41 (1.85) for the cromolyn group, significantly longer times to first exacerbation and first use of additional long-term asthma medication, greater improvements in asthma symptom scores, reduced use of rescue medication, and fewer urgent care visits. Both treatments were well tolerated.
                Budesonide inhalation suspension was more effective than nebulized cromolyn sodium in young children with persistent asthma. Both treatments were well tolerated with similar adverse event profiles. Although both cromolyn (C) and inhaled corticosteroids are anti-inflammatory therapies for childhood asthma, there are few controlled comparisons of these medications for asthma therapy in children. None were conducted in the United States, and none specifically study triamcinolone acetonide (T) versus C. This 12-week evaluation followed 31 youths, aged 8 to 18 years, with moderate asthma who were assigned to receive C or T according to a prerandomized and blinded code. Patients were instructed to take two inhalations from the study metered-dose inhaler (active T or placebo) and to inhale the contents of one study-provided ampule (C, 20 mg, or placebo) from a compressor-driven home nebulizer three times per day. Patients also used albuterol, two inhalations from a metered-dose inhaler, three times a day (before study medication) and, additionally, if needed. Patients maintained a daily diary, recording extra medication use, adverse experiences, peak flow rates morning and night, and asthma symptom scores. Laboratory assessment of pulmonary function was done at 1, 4, 8, and 12 weeks. Cosyntropin challenge and methacholine bronchoprovocation challenge were performed at the beginning and end of the study. C and T provided similar, adequate asthma control. Symptoms of wheezing, cough, and chest tightness decreased, and daily peak expiratory flow rate increased with both regimens compared to during a 2-week baseline when patients received medication only as needed. There was no significant change in methacholine sensitivity and no change in endocrine function, as measured with fasting plasma control before and after administration of cosyntropin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS) The aim of this study was to compare accurately measured growth over 12 months in asthmatic children treated with either fluticasone propionate (FP) 50 micrograms twice daily (b.i.d.) or sodium cromoglycate (SCG) 20 mg four times daily (q.i.d.). After a 2-week run-in, asthmatic children aged 4-10 years from 15 UK centers were randomized in a 3:4 ratio to open-label FP (n = 52) or SCG (n = 70). After 8 weeks, those whose asthma was not adequately controlled were switched from SCG to FP or withdrawn. Standing height was measured (Holtain stadiometry) at baseline, after 8 weeks and at 6 weeks intervals thereafter for 1 year. Morning peak flows (PEFam) were recorded by patients for 2 weeks during baseline, and 1 week before each visit during treatment. Urinary free cortisol (24 h) was measured at baseline, 6 months, and 1 year. After 8 weeks, 22 patients were withdrawn from SCG group (and were switched to FP), and five patients were withdrawn from the FP group due to poor asthma control. A further 21 and 11 patients were withdrawn from the SCG and FP groups, respectively, during the course of the study. There were no significant differences between patients who received FP and SCG for 1 year (n = 34 and n = 26, respectively) in terms of height velocity adjusted for age and gender (HV), or height velocity standard deviation scores adjusted for gender (HVSDS). Mean HV (mean HVSDS) were 6.0 cm/yr (0.1) and 6.5 cm/yr (0.5) for FP and SCG, respectively. There were no treatment differences in mean 24 h urinary free cortisol levels at 6 and 12 months. Mean % predicted PEFam improved over 1 year in both groups but to a greater degree in the FP group. We concluded that growth was normal in mildly asthmatic children receiving FP (50 micrograms bid) for 1 year. There were fewer withdrawals and lung function improved to a greater extent in FP treated patients than in patients receiving SCG. Inhaled corticosteroids are highly effective in the treatment of asthma at all ages and their use in younger children is increasing. As concerns exist about the long-term systemic side-effects of high dose inhaled corticosteroids, current guidelines continue to recommend sodium cromoglycate (SCG) as first line regular medication for children with frequent symptoms. Few published studies have compared the safety and efficacy of inhaled corticosteroids with SCG in children. This study compares SCG with the new inhaled corticosteroid, fluticasone propionate (FP), which has theoretical advantages over other currently available corticosteroids due to its negligible oral bioavailability. This was a randomized, open, multi-centre, parallel group comparison of 50 micrograms FP twice daily and 20 mg SCG four times daily over 8 weeks, preceded by a 2-week baseline period. Sixty-two general practices and two hospital centres enrolled 225 asthmatic children aged 4-12 years (110 received FP; 115 received SCG). Outcome measures improved in both groups, with a significant difference in favour of FP for the key variables of mean morning and evening % predicted PEFR and % of symptom-free days and nights. No significant difference was observed for FEV1, or relief medication use. Two children taking FP and 10 children taking SCG withdrew because of adverse events. This study showed that low dose FP was effective and superior to SCG in young children with mild-moderate asthma. Safety studies of longer duration are needed before changing the current recommendations for inhaled corticosteroid therapy. After a run-in period of 2 weeks, receiving a regimen of inhaled beta 2-agonists and/or theophyllines, 38 atopic patients with asthma with perennial symptoms were randomly allocated to receive an 8-week treatment of additional inhalation treatment with either sodium cromoglycate (SCG), 2 mg four times daily, and placebo beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP), or BDP, 200 micrograms twice daily, and placebo SCG. After crossover, each group received the opposite treatment for the final 8 weeks. FEV1, FVC, and provocation concentration of histamine causing a 20% fall in FEV1 (PC20) were determined monthly and peak expiratory flow (PEF) daily throughout the study. A significant increase in FEV1, FVC, and PEF (p less than 0.01) was observed after BDP treatment was started, and likewise, in the second period, an increase in both FEV1 and PEF (p less than 0.05) was observed. The total effect on logarithm-natural (Ln) (PC20), i.e., the mean effects of the two periods, was also significant (p less than 0.01). SCG, however, was most effective when it was used as the first drug, indicated by a significant increase in FVC in the first period (p less than 0.05). Neither in the first nor in the second period did SCG treatment influence the Ln (PC20) value positively, and the SCG treatment administered in the second period could not maintain the improvement in the pulmonary function (i.e., FEV1, FVC, and PEF) obtained initially with the BDP treatment. When the effect of BDP on FEV1, FVC, PEF, and Ln (PC20) was compared to the effect of SCG in the first 8-week treatment period, no significant difference was observed (p greater than 0.1).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS) In school children with atopic asthma the beneficial effects of disodium cromoglycate (DSCG) and beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) are well-established. In preschool children, wheezing is quite common, and in the majority of cases the symptoms are episodic and reported to be associated with viral infections rather than atopy. We compared the efficacy of regular treatment with DSCG and BDP for prevention of wheezing in preschool children. We were interested to establish whether regular treatment with inhaled anti-inflammatory drugs could lead to a decrease in bronchial responsiveness. In 15 patients (median age, 56 months; range, 43-66 months) bronchial responsiveness was assessed by measuring specific airway resistance (sRaw) during a histamine provocation test. The concentration of histamine eliciting a 100% increase in sRaw (PC100his) was determined. In a double-blind crossover study, patients inhaled either DSCG 10 mg three times a day or BDP 100 microg three times a day for 2 months. After a wash-out period, treatment was changed to BDP or DSCG, respectively. Daily peak flow measurements were carried out, and exacerbations were noted. PC100his was measured at the start and end of each treatment period. No significant decrease in bronchial responsiveness was seen (PC100his DSCG: before 1.3, after 1.66 mg/ml, Pvalue not significant; BDP: before 1.1 after 1.22 mg/ml, Pvalue not significant). Significantly higher morning peak flows were observed on BDP therapy (160 on BDP vs. 150 L/min on DSCG, P < 0.03). BDP treatment resulted in significantly fewer wheezing exacerbations (7 vs. 16, P < 0.005) compared with DSCG therapy. We conclude that in preschool children with episodic virally induced wheezing, BDP therapy was superior to DSCG aerosol treatments for the prevention of exacerbations of wheezing, although no significant effect on bronchial responsiveness was noted during either treatment protocol. Budesonide and sodium cromoglycate are both recommended as maintenance therapy for childhood asthma.
                To compare the cost-effectiveness of these two treatment strategies in clinical practice, in an open-label, pharmacoeconomic clinical trial.
                Health economics were evaluated in 138 children, ages 5 to 11 years, with unstable asthma not previously treated with corticosteroids or cromones. The asthma was stabilized during 4 to 6 weeks with budesonide 200 to 400 microg twice daily. The children were then randomly allocated to one of the two treatment strategies aiming at maintaining asthma control for 12 months; budesonide 400 microg/day (N = 69) or sodium cromoglycate 60 mg/day (N = 69). If asthma control was judged unsatisfactory, the doses were increased or the children were switched to the alternate treatment.
                In children continuing on the same treatment, the degree of asthma control was similar in the two groups at study end. To maintain asthma control, 42% of cromoglycate children switched to budesonide, and then experienced a 14% increase in symptom-free days. No budesonide patient had to switch therapy because of lack of asthma control. Although not statistically significant, total annual cost per patient was 24% (Swedish kronor 4195; US $487; Euro 485) lower in the budesonide than the cromoglycate group, mainly due to a lower cost for asthma medication.
                A budesonide strategy for continued maintenance treatment, after an initial period of stabilizing treatment with budesonide, resulted in lower costs and less drug switches than did a strategy with sodium cromoglycate. nan Twenty two allergic patients with bronchial asthma completed this study. Effects of long-term treatment with inhaled cromoglycate 4 x 2 mg.day-1 were compared to the effects of inhaled budesonide 4 x 0.1 mg.day-1 on symptoms, additional beta 2-agonist use, lung function and bronchial hyperresponsiveness measured by the provocation concentration of histamine producing a 20% fall in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) (PC20 histamine) and exercise-induced fall in FEV1. The study was carried out in a double-blind way with a randomized crossover design using a double-dummy technique. After a single-blind placebo period, the two active treatment periods of 6 weeks were separated by a single-blind placebo period. Symptom score and beta 2-agonist use decreased during both active treatment periods, which showed no mutual differences. Morning and evening peak expiratory flow rates were significantly higher during treatment with budesonide versus placebo (p less than 0.01 and p less than 0.001), and also versus cromoglycate (p less than 0.02 and p less than 0.05). FEV1 showed improvement after a 6 week treatment with budesonide versus placebo (p less than 0.05), although there was no significant difference between the two active treatments. PC20 histamine did not change during treatment with cromoglycate. Budesonide showed a significant increase in PC20 histamine versus placebo (p less than 0.05) and was marginally significantly better than cromoglycate (p = 0.05). Exercise-induced fall in FEV1 was not changed by cromoglycate, but improved significantly during budesonide in comparison with placebo (p less than 0.01) and also with cromoglycate (p less than 0.001).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS) A double-blind comparison of betamethasone valerate, sodium cromoglycate and the combination of these two treatments was carried out in twenty-two adult patients with asthma. Regular fortnightly assessments were made in the clinic throughout the study and adrenal function was monitored and found to be normal. All patients measured their peak expiratory flow rates in the morning and evening and monitored their symptoms daily on a record card as well as recording bronchodilator usage. Assessment using these parameters indicated that treatment with betamethasone valerate compared with sodium cromoglycate resulted in an improvement in the patients' asthma which was stitistically significant (P less than 0-001). Overall the combined treatment produced a better response than sodium cromoglycate (P less than 0-02) but a poorer response compared with the steroid aerosol given alone (P greater than 0-05). In only two patients was the response to the combined therapy significantly greater than to either drug given alone. Eleven children with severe perennial asthma and a poor clinical response to disodium cromoglycate were studied in a 4-month, double blind trial involving 1 month's treatment with placebo, disodium cromoglycate, betamethasone 17 valerate, and both drugs combined according to a predetermined random design. Each drug apparently reduced symptoms and improved daily peak flow and fortnightly spirometric measurements compared with placebo, but the improvement after betamethasone 17 valerate was greater in part because of the way this group of patients was selected. There did not appear to be any additional benefit when both drugs were used together. Betamethasone 17 valerate was not compared with beclomethasone diproprionate aerosol and there is no reason to believe it may be superior. Corticosteroid aerosols have potential hazards which may prove to equal those of long-term systemic steroids, but they offer the prospect of satisfactory control of symptoms without the risk of growth suppression in children with severe asthma. Disodium cromoglycate remains the drug of choice in severe childhood asthma and the use of corticosteroid aerosols should be confined to those children who fail to respond satisfactorily to disodium cromoglycate. Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disorder of the airways that is characterized by infiltration of many inflammatory cells into the bronchial mucosa. We compared the effects of ketotifen, disodium cromoglycate (DSCG), and beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) on inflammatory cells in the bronchial mucosa and on the asthma symptoms of patients with atopic asthma. In this 12-week parallel study, 32 patients were randomly allocated to either the ketotifen group (2 mg day-1, n = 13), DSCG group (8 mg day-1, n = 9) or BDP (400 micrograms day-1, n = 10). Each subject recorded daily asthma symptoms and peak expiratory flow (PEF). Before and after treatment, pulmonary function and bronchial responsiveness to methacholine were evaluated, and fibreoptic bronchoscopy and biopsy were performed before and after treatment. Biopsy specimens were obtained by bronchoscopy. We performed immunohistochemistry using specific monoclonal antibodies for activated eosinophils (EG2), mast cells (AA1), and T cells (CD3, CD4, and CD8). Our clinical findings showed significant improvement in symptom score and bronchial responsiveness (P < 0.01) each) in all groups. Both the DSCG and the BDP groups had significantly better symptom scores than the ketotifen group (P < 0.05, both groups). PEF significantly increased in the DSCG group in comparison to the ketotifen (P < 0.01) and BDP (P < 0.05) groups, FEV1% increased significantly in the DSCG (P < 0.01) and BDP (P < 0.05) groups in comparison to the ketotifen group. Compared with their baseline values, treatment significantly decreased EG2+ activated eosinophils, and CD3+ and CD4+ T cells, in each group (P < 0.01). Both the DSCG (P < 0.05) and the BDP groups (P < 0.01) exhibited significant decreases in AA1+ mast cell count, but this was not observed in the ketotifen group. Comparing before- and after-treatment values, only the DSCG group exhibited a significant decrease in the number of CD8+ T cells (P < 0.01). Ketotifen, DSCG, and BDP all showed anti-inflammatory activity as determined by examination of the bronchial mucosa of asthmatic patients; and both the DSCG and BDP groups had better clinical responses than the ketotifen group. 165 patients (106 males, 59 females) entered an open group comparative study of a 12-week test treatment on bronchial hyperresponsiveness (BHR) determined by methacholine challenge. Patients were randomly allocated to receive nedocromil sodium (4 mg q.i.d.), sodium cromoglycate (10 micrograms q.i.d.) and beclomethasone dipropionate (500 micrograms t.i.d.). At the end of the study, an 2.25-fold increase of the PD20FEV1 was noted in all the treated patients. No significant difference was noted among the treatments. A double-blind, cross-over study was undertaken to compare inhalation of betamethasone valerate (BV, 800 microgram daily) with sodium cromoglycate (SCG, 80 mg daily) in twenty children requiring bronchodilators for perennial asthma. Each treatment period lasted 4 weeks but statistical comparisons were made only in respect of the last 14 days of each therapy. When the children were using BV they required not only less of the bronchodilator drugs but had fewer symptoms and higher daily peak expiratory flow rates when taking SCG. Statistically, all these differences were highly significant. For 2 weeks before the main trial each child was given a placebo aerosol (single-blind) to assess severity of asthma. In comparison with this period, SCG was associated with a significantly increased peak expiratory flow rate a lower symptom score by day but not by night, but their usage of bronchodilators followed a similar pattern. When the BV period was compared with the placebo period, patients had an even more significant rise in peak expiratory flow rate, less day and night symptoms, and took hardly any bronchodilators. The response to the two drugs did seem to depend upon which was given first. No monilial infections were found, nor any measurable defect in adrenal response from either treatment. Betamethasone valerate is considered to be superior to sodium cromoglycate as a treatment for childhood asthma insufficiently controlled on bronchodilators. This study compared the efficacy and tolerability of sodium cromoglycate (SC) and beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) in adult patients with bronchial asthma inadequately treated with bronchodilators alone. The study was a double-blind, randomized, double-dummy, parallel-group study. Patients with mild to moderate symptomatic asthma, inadequately treated with bronchodilators only, were, after a 2-week run-in (base-line) period, randomized to 8 weeks of treatment with either SC 10 mg four times daily or BDP 100 micrograms four times daily. Salbutamol metered-dose inhaler was given as relief medication. A total of 37 patients were randomized for treatment, 19 patients in the SC group and 18 patients in the BD group. Efficacy and safety were determined by daily record card data: morning and evening peak-expiratory-flow rates (PEFR), daytime and nighttime asthma symptom scores, and rescue salbutamol use. At clinic visits, FEV1 and FVC were measured, as were the physician's and the patient's assessment of the medication at the end of the study. The safety and tolerability of the trial medication were assessed by monitoring adverse events throughout the study. A clinically and statistically significant improvement of the asthma in FEV1, symptom scores, rescue medication, and global opinion of efficacy was observed, and both groups provided equivalent efficacy. The morning PEFR as well as the evening PEFR for both groups improved, but was statistically significant only for the BDP group (M-PEFR). Both drugs were well tolerated with only a few minor adverse events. This trial shows that SC and BDP are equally effective anti-inflammatory treatments for mild to moderate bronchial asthma in adults. The efficacy of beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) was compared with sodium cromoglycate (SCG) and placebo in a double-blind parallel group study of 30 asthmatic children over a two-month period. All the three treatment groups received salbutamol concomitantly. Lung volumes, airway mechanics and the nonspecific bronchial hyperreactivity to carbachol were measured at the beginning and the end of the study. Two patients were excluded because of unequal clinical conditions at the entry and the end of the study and three because of lack of co-operation. Three patients (1 on SCG, 2 on placebo) dropped out because of worsening clinical symptoms. The improvement in airway mechanics shown by the group treated with BDP (n = 7) was significantly greater (p less than 0.01) than in the group treated with SCG (n = 8). Nonspecific hyperreactivity to carbachol improved significantly in the BDP group (factor 5.9) compared to the SCG group (factor 1.9). Childhood asthma seems to be better controlled by a combination of BDP and salbutamol, than by SCG and salbutamol.
ICS were superior to SCG on measures of lung function and asthma control for both adults and children with chronic asthma. There were few studies reporting on quality of life and health care utilization, which limited our ability to adequately evaluate the relative effects of these medications on a broader range of outcomes. Although there were no differences in adverse effects between ICS and SCG, most trials were short and may not have been of sufficient duration to identify long-term effects. Our results support recent consensus statements in the U.S. and elsewhere that favour the use of ICS over SCG for control of persistent asthma.