Comparison of dose-response effects of inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate and budesonide in the management of asthma. Budesonide inhaled via Turbuhaler: a more effective treatment for asthma than beclomethasone dipropionate via Rotahaler. Endocrine and lung function in asthmatic children on inhaled corticosteroids. A comparison of inhaled budesonide and beclomethasone dipropionate in childhood asthma. Comparison of budesonide and beclomethasone dipropionate for treatment of asthma. Methodological aspects on clinical trials with inhaled corticosteroids: results of two comparisons between two steroid aerosols in patients with asthma. Asthma treatment with a new corticosteroid aerosol, budesonide, administered twice daily by spacer inhaler. Comparison of budesonide and beclomethasone dipropionate in patients with severe chronic asthma: assessment of relative prednisolone-sparing effects. Comparison of a new corticosteroid aerosol, budesonide, with beclomethasone dipropionate in the treatment of chronic asthma. High-dose inhaled steroids in the management of asthma. A comparison of the effects of budesonide and beclomethasone dipropionate on pulmonary function, symptoms, bronchial responsiveness and the adrenal function. Clinical efficacy of budesonide Turbuhaler compared with that of beclomethasone dipropionate pMDI with volumatic spacer. A 2-year randomized study in 102 asthma patients. Twice daily inhalation of a new corticosteroid, budesonide, in the treatment of chronic asthma. Urine cortisol excretion in children treated with high doses of inhaled corticosteroids: a comparison of budesonide and beclomethasone. Comparison of two high dose corticosteroid aerosol treatments, beclomethasone dipropionate (1500 micrograms/day) and budesonide (1600 micrograms/day), for chronic asthma. Once daily inhalation of budesonide in the treatment of chronic asthma: a clinical comparison.
The dose-response effects of inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) and budesonide (BUD) administered b.i.d. with the aid of metered dose aerosols were studied in 128 patients (67 men and 61 women, mean age 53 years) suffering from asthma bronchiale. The study was designed as a multi-centre, double-blind, four-period cross-over study, followed by a single-blind double placebo period. BDP was administered in doses of 400 and 1000 micrograms, and BUD in doses of 400 and 800 micrograms. The results in terms of peak expiratory flow (PEF) in the morning and evening, daily symptoms score and use of inhaled beta 2-agonists did not reveal any clinically significant differences between the drugs or between high (800 micrograms BUD, 1000 micrograms BDP) and low (400 micrograms BUD/BDP) doses. However, statistically significant differences were recorded for the corresponding parameters when comparing the placebo with preceding steroid periods. Adverse effects consisting mainly of oropharyngeal candidiasis, hoarseness and cough occurred in 54 of 468 treatment months (12%). The carry-over effects of inhaled steroids are longer lasting than was previously assumed. Chlorofluorocarbon-propelled metered dose inhalers are facing a worldwide ban. Dry powder inhalers have been developed for the agents used in treatment of asthma.
                Our objective was to compare the effects of two inhaled glucocorticosteroids in dry power inhalers: budesonide (delivered via Turbuhaler) and beclomethasone dipropionate (delivered via Rotahaler).
                A randomized, crossover study with two steroid-treatment periods of 8 weeks. At the end of the study, the treatment with the inhaled steroid was stopped for 4 weeks. Sixteen adult patients with moderately severe asthma participated. Before the study all patients were treated with an inhaled steroid in a median dose of 0.60 mg/day (range 0.15-0.80); during the study they received 0.20 mg twice daily. Peak expiratory flow rate was measured twice daily at home throughout the study, lung function was assessed every fourth week and airway responsiveness was measured before and after each period. Preference concerning efficacy and inhaler type was assessed at the end of the study.
                Twelve patients completed the study. Lung function, airway responsiveness, and symptoms deteriorated significantly in the steroid-free washout period; this period had to be shortened in 5/12 patients. Mean morning peak expiratory flow was significantly higher during budesonide treatment than during beclomethasone dipropionate treatment, the difference being 17 L/min (95% C.I.: 2-32 L/min, P = .026). Airway responsiveness improved 1.1 doubling concentrations after budesonide treatment, but decreased 0.3 doubling concentrations after beclomethasone dipropionate treatment. The difference between the values after budesonide and beclomethasone dipropionate treatment was 1.4 doubling concentrations (95% C.I.: 0.4-2.4 doubling concentrations, P = .033). Forced expiratory flow in one second improved slightly more during budesonide than during beclomethasone treatment. The difference was 4.3% predicted (95% C.I.: -0.7-9.3%). Most patients reported budesonide Turbuhaler to be more effective (10 versus 0) and easier to use (11 versus 1) than beclomethasone dipropionate Rotahaler.
                As a consequence of the difference in local potency of the steroids and the fact that Turbuhaler deposits more drug particles in the lung than Rotahaler, budesonide inhaled via Turbuhaler appeared to be a more effective steroid formulation than beclomethasone dipropionate inhaled via Rotahaler. The safety of inhaled corticosteroids in the treatment of chronic asthma has been questioned. In a prospective crossover study asthmatic children not controlled on other medications were commenced on beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) or budesonide (BUD), both administered at the dose of 200 micrograms twice per day for 2 wk each in randomized order. Recordings at home included twice daily symptom scores, peak expiratory flow readings, and the use of additional antiasthma medications. Before and after each treatment period the patients were admitted for overnight blood sampling for cortisol, ACTH, and growth hormone, 24-h urine collections for cortisol, and detailed lung function tests. A total of 12 children completed the study. The nocturnal serum cortisol production was significantly reduced by 27 and 35% after 2 and 4 wk of treatment (p = 0.005, p = 0.004; Wilcoxon test), and the urinary free cortisol showed a similar reduction of 33 and 48% (p = 0.023, p = 0.005). Such suppression could be shown on both drugs, BDP and BUD, and there was no significant difference between them. The ACTH and growth hormone values were not significantly changed on any treatment. Lung function tests showed an impressive improvement in FVC, FEV1, FEF50, and FEF25 after 2 wk of treatment regardless of the medication. Differences in lung function improvements between the two drugs were very small and not of clinical relevance. The observations indicate that even low-dose inhaled corticosteroids in the form of BDP or BUD have a systemic effect, which emphasizes the importance of using the minimum dose compatible with good control of asthma. The objective of this study was to compare the clinical effects of beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) and budesonide in asthmatic children using two common ways of administration. Twenty-one children, aged 4-14 years, who regularly used inhaled corticosteroids for their control of asthma were included in the study. The drugs were studied by using a double-blind randomized cross-over design trial with a single-blind placebo period at the end. Each period lasted 3 weeks. The dosage was 100 micrograms b.i.d. for both drugs. Budesonide was administered via a spacer inhaler (Inhalet), and beclomethasone dipropionate via a standard actuator. Compared with placebo, both drugs significantly improved PEFR values for morning (20% for budesonide and 14% for BDP) and evening (14% for budesonide and 9% for BDP). Both morning and/or evening peak flows were significantly higher during the budesonide treatment as compared with the BDP treatment. In comparison with the placebo period, FEV1.0 was significantly improved with budesonide but not with BDP. Plasma cortisol, WBC counts, differential and eosinophilia counts in blood were determined at the beginning and the end of each period. All of the values except for the eosinophil counts were within normal ranges. Candida was looked for but not found in any case. No other adverse effects were registered. For most of the children, a deterioration of the state of their asthma and increased need for concomitant therapy during the placebo period confirmed their steroid dependence. The number of administrations with concomitant anti-asthmatic therapy increased during placebo by 61% as compared with the budesonide therapy, and by 40% compared with the BDP therapy. Beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) and budesonide (BUD) were each given in a dose of 200 micrograms twice daily by metered dose inhaler to 10 asthmatic children already dependent on treatment with steroids. In a double blind randomised crossover study each course lasted one month. No clinically important differences were found between the two treatments when symptom scores, symptom free days, additional use of salbutamol, and results of lung function tests were considered. Metyrapone mildly reduced the plasma concentration of 11-deoxycortisol in two patients during treatment with budesonide, and in four during treatment with beclomethasone. It is concluded that although they are usually safe, both drugs may cause mild adrenal suppression when given in a dose of 200 micrograms twice daily. The efficacy of beclomethasone dipropionate aerosol (BDA) 100 micrograms q.i.d. was compared with that of budesonide aerosol 10 micrograms q.i.d. in 17 patients. The efficacy of inhaled BDA 100 micrograms q.i.d. was also compared with that of budesonide 50 micrograms q.i.d. with and without an extension tube (Inhalet) attached to the actuator in 23 patients. Both studies included placebo periods. The trials were performed with the cross-over technique in patients with stable asthma. Each treatment was randomized and given in periods of two weeks starting with a run-in period. The patients recorded peak expiratory flow rates (PEF) twice daily and filled in diary cards for cough, wheeze, breathing difficulties and use of beta 2-receptor stimulant aerosol. In the first study the patients came to the hospital twice weekly throughout the trial for spirometry and interview. In the second study they came every second week. Budesonide and BDA were superior to placebo. Budesonide in doses of 100 micrograms and 50 micrograms were as efficacious as BDA 100 micrograms q.i.d., while budesonide 50 micrograms q.i.d. with Inhalet was slightly more effective. Treatment for two weeks was found to be sufficient. For each parameter the average of the last four days of each period was found to be relevant in the comparison. The placebo period should preferably not be placed at random in the trial, but as the last treatment period. nan The relative prednisolone-sparing effects of inhaled budesonide 400 micrograms daily and beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) 400 micrograms daily were compared in a double-blind crossover study of 26 patients with chronic asthma requiring treatment with BDP and oral prednisolone in a daily dose of 5 mg or greater. During each period of the trial budesonide and BDP were inhaled via conventional pressurized inhalers in a dose of 100 micrograms four times daily. Prednisolone was reduced by 1 mg per month from the patient's normal maintenance dose to zero or to the point at which asthmatic symptoms became unacceptable. The mean reduction in prednisolone dose during BDP treatment was 2.65 mg compared with 1.8 mg at the end of the budesonide period. The difference between the prednisolone-sparing properties of BDP and budesonide assessed in this way in this group of patients was statistically significant in favour of BDP. The mean minimum prednisolone doses at the end of the treatment periods were 3.46 mg for BDP and 4.3 mg for budesonide. Since inhaled steroids were not withdrawn the absolute prednisolone-sparing properties of the two drugs were not assessed, and thus a pharmacological potency ratio cannot be derived from the results. It is concluded that BDP is marginally more potent than budesonide in its prednisolone-sparing properties. nan The efficacy of budesonide (800 micrograms b.d.) and beclomethasone dipropionate (750 micrograms b.d.) in controlling the symptoms of asthma, pulmonary function, bronchial responsiveness to histamine, and adrenal function, was assessed in a double-blind, double-dummy cross-over study of 36 adult chronic asthmatic patients. The patients, the majority of whom were assessed to be affected to a severe degree, were insufficiently controlled in their current regimen of inhaled steroids and/or inhaled and oral bronchodilators. A 2 weeks baseline period preceded 6 weeks of treatment with each of the study drugs. Both treatment groups showed improvements from baseline in clinical assessment of lung function carried out after the first 6 weeks of treatment. No significant differences were seen throughout the entire 12 weeks study, when comparing the effects of the treatments on FEV1, FVC, PEF or the histamine PC20. Asthma severity, symptom score and inhaled bronchodilator use showed the same results after both treatments. It is concluded that inhalations of budesonide and beclomethasone dipropionate in high doses are equally potent in the treatment of severe asthma. There is no significant influence on the adrenal function and no significant side effects during a period equal to that of the present study. A total of 102 patients had their asthma treatment with beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) optimized in order to achieve the best possible control of symptoms. Thereafter, the BDP doses were gradually reduced over a 2-year period (1988-90) to the lowest possible without deterioration of their asthmatic condition. In the beginning of 1990, treatment was changed in 76 patients (group A) to the nearest possible dose of budesonide delivered via Turbuhaler. Twenty-six randomly selected patients (25% of the study population; group B) continued treatment with BDP. In both groups, dose reductions were tried during 1990-2 every third month as long as the patients remained symptom-free and without significant decreases in FEV1 or PEF. In group A, the maintenance dose could be reduced from 1003.9 +/- 325.4 micrograms BDP (mean +/- SD) to 602.9 +/- 454.4 micrograms budesonide Turbuhaler (P < 0.001). In group B, no significant dose reduction was possible; the mean dose was +/- SD 1067.3 +/- 36.6 micrograms in 1990, and 1019.2 +/- 324.7 micrograms in 1992. The results indicate that, in efficacy, 0.6 mg budesonide Turbuhaler corresponds to approximately 1.0 mg BDP with volumatic spacer. This difference is probably due to an improved pulmonary delivery of budesonide with Turbuhaler. The efficacy and side-effects of a new corticosteroid, budesonide, was assessed by comparison with beclomethasone dipropionate in double-blind, cross-over study of 30 patients with chronic asthma. The treatment regimens were budesonide 200 micrograms twice daily by conventional pressurized aerosol with a tube spacer attached and beclomethasone 100 micrograms four times daily via a conventional inhaler. Each treatment was given for four weeks. Results were analyzed using Student's t-test for paired comparisons. No significant differences were found for morning and evening peak flow rates, symptom scores, bronchodilator inhaler usage or forced vital capacity. Forced expiratory volume in one second after 4 weeks on each treatment was significantly higher following budesonide therapy (p less than 0.05), but the absolute changes were small and unlikely to be of clinical relevance. There were no major side-effects during either treatment period, but compared with pre-treatment levels serum creatinine and lactic dehydrogenase levels rose significantly during treatment with budesonide (p less than 0.01 and p less than 0.05 respectively). None of these results reflected clinically important biochemical or haematological changes. There was a significant reduction in neutrophil counts following treatment with beclomethasone (p less than 0.05). In the short term treatment of chronic asthma, budesonide administered twice daily is as effective as four times daily beclomethasone. A twice daily dosage regimen should improve patient compliance with therapy. Thirty one children with asthma were treated with inhaled beclomethasone and budesonide in a randomized cross-over study of 2 x 6 weeks' duration. The excretion of free cortisol in two 24 hour urine samples, collected at the end of each treatment period, was significantly higher (mean = 76.3 nmol per day) during budesonide treatment than during beclomethasone treatment (mean = 53.7 nmol per day) (p less than 0.01). The difference between the two drugs was more pronounced in the eight children who received 1,000 and 1,200 micrograms per day than in the 22 children who received 800 micrograms per day. Four children had cortisol excretion below the normal range when treated with beclomethasone. This was seen in one child during budesonide treatment. The age of the child did not influence the result. The long term clinical significance of these findings has yet to be elucidated. Twenty eight patients with chronic asthma took part in a double blind single crossover controlled trial of inhaled budesonide and inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate, using high doses of 1600 micrograms and 1500 micrograms daily respectively. Both drugs were administered by pressurised aerosol inhaler; the inhaler containing budesonide and its matching placebo were fitted with a collapsible spacer device. There was no significant difference in the control of asthma during the two six week treatment periods. There was no significant difference in FEV1 and forced vital capacity after four and six weeks of treatment or in mean morning and evening peak expiratory flow rates for the last 21 days of treatment. There was a small but statistically significant reduction in the daytime wheeze score while they were taking high dose budesonide but there was no difference for daytime activity, cough, and night symptoms. The mean basal cortisol concentrations were significantly lower after six weeks of high dose treatment than before treatment (budesonide p less than 0.01, beclomethasone p less than 0.05). There was no difference between mean basal cortisol values after six weeks of high dose treatment, and there was no effect on the rise of cortisol obtained after a short tetracosactrin test. High dose inhaled corticosteroids produced few side effects and were well tolerated. In a short-term, open cross-over clinical efficacy study, inhalation of budesonide 800 micrograms once daily was compared to inhalation of budesonide 400 micrograms twice daily and beclomethasone dipropionate 200 micrograms four times daily in 20 patients with stable steroid-dependent chronic asthma. Budesonide was inhaled through a spacer tube. The drugs were given in 3-week periods. Clinical symptoms, consumption of beta 2-agonists and peak flow were measured. In all but one patient, the reduced frequency of budesonide inhalations to only once daily has not given significantly different results compared with more frequent inhalations.
There is limited high quality randomised controlled trial data comparing the relative efficacy of BDP and BUD. Current guidelines (BTS 1997; GINA 1995; NHLBI 1997) assume BDP and BUD to have equal efficacy, such that for each defined level of asthma severity, the recommended doses BDP and BUD are the same. Although there is some data to suggest that BUD via Turbohaler is more effective than BDP via either Rotahaler or MDI (with and without spacer), these comparisons are confounded by use of different delivery devices, and are not sufficient to warrant a change in guideline recommendations.