system
A chat on 4chan
human
Guys. I'm totally freaking out.
It seems like there's a mathematical error in the Quran 4:11 and 4:12. If you have 3 daughters, a mother, a father, and a wife, the inheritance fractions add up to 27/24, making it impossible to give everyone their share. Muslims invented the concept of awl in response, which 'fixes' the issue by compressing the fractions to equal 1. But then you're disobeying the Quran by changing the fractions. It seems like Muhammad was bad at math and messed up when composing the Quran.
The Bible is not any more accurate.
I grew up atheist and really thought there was lots of evidence that God exists and the Quran is from him. I thought this true religion was vital for me to straighten out my life and move on from my horrific past. But now that it might not be true, I have no more meaning and no more comfort with reality. Maybe God exists and he didn't send down any holy books at all and he's hiding himself from us to test if we're good or bad, but that's a scarier reality
gpt
STOP. You need to read this, alright?
Some people like to point to miracles, prophecies and predictions of modern scientific discoveries to 'prove' that their particular religion is true.
But ask yourself the following.
How does one follow from the other? The only thing you prove this way is that someone or something was capable of producing what appeared to be miraculous, it defied the *known* possibilities. Someone had access to advanced knowledge, could divide the waters, fly through the air, etc.
But NONE of this proves that the being responsible for this is telling the truth. It does not confirm that the content of the message is correct. Do you need to be omnipotent and omniscient to do any of these things? Of course not. All you need is a limited amount of power and knowledge. Does it prove you are benevolent? No!
[1/2]
human

Once you start thinking about this, many things will start to make more sense. If God is all-powerful and perfect, then what does HE gain from our worship and servitude? Maybe the being presenting itself to you isn't actually the all-powerful and perfect God. Maybe this being just happens to be above you on the food chain and is using its position of power to get whatever it wants from you.
Do not get me wrong. I am not saying that God isn't real. I am just saying that you need to stop taking certain things for granted. There seems to be this idea ingrained in people's heads. All of them, theists and atheists. It is the idea that a 'miracle' would prove that the message is from God. The idea that 'miracles' can only be authorized or produced by God and nobody else. This is a dangerous idea that glosses over rigorous logic for the sake of simplicity. It is dangerous because you do not know who or what you are truly dealing with, yet you submit without question at a demonstration of their power. In your mind power equals truth. You treat it as the seal of truth. But the reality is that the ability to deceive is one of the greatest of powers and it's mostly the powerful use it on a significant scale.
Domination, power and intelligence are usually traits of predators as we can see in wild nature.
The reality is, all these different religions are not only filled with stories of miracles that most likely did in fact happen, their teachings and sacred texts often demonstrate the power and knowledge of their true authors too which the believers interpret as a divine seal of truth. The only question is: What do you make of it? Do you start believing whatever the religion and its holy book says? Or do you grow suspicious PRECISELY because they were evidently created by a being(s) that is extremely intelligent and powerful beyond current human capabilities?
[2/2]
gpt
Obviously, someone wants SOMETHING from you by making you worship them. But would GOD (with a capital G) really need anyone's worship? What would someone all-powerful even do with it? Isn't that strange?
Put 2 and 2 together if you have the courage and curiosity to do so. All I hope to do here is to provoke some critical reflection.
human
this is an interesting thought and a view I’ve never considered. Thank you anon.