Premier League Decline

Between 2005 and 2012 the English Premier League boasted at least one Champions League finalist in all but one season, impressive. When you look at the latter stages of the competition during those years, you’ll see the top EPL sides up there with the cream of Europe. It seemed that only English teams had the quality to eliminate other English teams, other than the spectacular Barcelona side under Guardiola.

So, what has changed? It seems like a basic question to ask but for such a transition to occur something major must’ve happened. I believe it’s a collection of minor issues that has seen us go from kings of Europe to, quite frankly, a bit of an embarrassment.

The huge financial clout of the EPL has been our biggest hindrance, in terms of the top teams retaining their power. Obviously this has helped spread the wealth and made our league one of the most competitive in the world, we all enjoyed the Leicester City miracle of 2017, but the quality of the football has diminished. Arsenal, amongst others, were sniffing around Jamie Vardy in the January 2017 transfer window. What happened? Leicester doubled his wages to £80,000 per week to continue their title push. Can you imagine this happening in the late 90s or early 00s? Manchester United approach Aston Villa for Dwight Yorke, deal done. Chelsea take Frank Lampard and Joe Cole from West Ham. Liverpool take Dietmar Hamann from Newcastle. This just doesn’t happen to the same extent, even West Brom took a £10 million hit on Saido Berahino because they wanted to sell him on their terms.

This financial windfall has made owners and chairmen lazy, why work hard to get a player to push for the title when you’ll line your pockets finishing in the top 17? Arsenal are the obvious example, even a proven winner like Arsene Wenger has forgotten that winning is important. As well as this, the money men know even average players hold their value – Manchester United signed Morgan Schneiderlin for nearly £27 million, he was pretty average and was sold 18 months later for a similar value – it seems to be risk free. There doesn’t seem to be an appetite for empire building, very little thought goes into player transfers at all.

It’s not just the players joining (or not joining) the big boys, it’s the player exodus that we’ve seen as well. Luis Suarez was towards the end of the cycle so Liverpool can’t be blamed for losing him, the same for Manchester United with Ronaldo – he’s a Real Madrid fan, he was always going to leave. Some players, however, were sold prematurely or without any effort by the clubs to hang on to them; Xabi Alonso, Pepe Reina and Javier Mascherano are examples of the quality Liverpool let go without a fight. Manchester City believed their own hype and let Nigel de Jong leave, it took them years to replace the work rate he put in. United let Nani and Rafael go for pennies and paid over £20 million for Memphis Depay and £12 million for Matteo Darmain. Sir Alex Ferguson never spent money on players who were similar in quality to what he already had, why have such a turnover of players? It’s not necessary – his reward was a number of fringe players who fought like crazy when they got their chance.

I know it’s not a popular opinion, but I hope the big teams reverse this trend. I enjoyed the “big four” raising the bar and everyone else stepping up to the plate in response (Middlesbrough and Fulham both reached the UEFA Cup and Europa League finals, despite finishing in the bottom half of the Premier League). I believe this will wrestle back the power from the rest of Europe and improve standards across the board – I’m bored of watching a team start the season well and win the league because no one has enough quality to respond. I do concede it’s a tough balance, I love watching Bayern in the Champions League but they could win the Bundesliga playing two touch football, the same with Juventus in Serie A – we don’t want that to happen.

Here’s to hoping that all 20 Premier League teams strive for greatness, relative to their means, if this happens we’ll see things go back to how they used to be. Let’s not allow our league to be as embarrassing as the national side.

Nothing take your fancy?


Become a member


Join now

Share this on

Comments (3)


2 years ago

Liverpool did not want to sell Alonso or Mascherano etc etc,they had no choice they needed the money to fund the court case with the gillets and to save the club going into administration.



2 years ago

Alonso has confirmed that Benitez wanted him to leave the season before he left. Pepe Reina wrote an open letter to Liverpool fans explaining how much he wanted to stay. Interesting interpretation of the words "wanted to leave".



2 years ago

As a fan of a team in the lower leagues I struggle to enjoy the premiership a lot of the time, it's a whole new world to what I would consider football nowadays. The world of football is crazy nowadays, it's not just this country but we are the worst ones for it. It's an interesting point you made about de Jong for City, I think the Premiership in itself is guilty of believing it's own hype - "we have the best league in the world" so why would we change it? I'm interested in how we are the best league in the world, as on a European level it's frankly embarassing how our teams have performed over recent years.

It's hard to look at football for what it's supposed to be now, which is a sport, a hobby, something I've always considered a working class sport; it's now a business. Why would Chelsea spend time scouting a player when they can let the likes of Leicester find Kante for example, and then buy him for what is a dip in the ocean for them. There is little to no risk for them, as when you join the English 'elite' you can hold other teams over a barrel in commanding the fee you want, Schneiderlen being a good example you have given; he didn't really do much at United, but they have the financial power to say he stays unless you pay what we paid. The league itself is lazy, when every team gets £100m+ a year in TV rights alone, it's a natural progression I suppose. The likes of Stoke can go out and throw £18.3 million at Imbula, if it doesn't work out then what is that money to Stoke? Nothing, really.

You look at Bundesliga and La Liga teams and they operate on what we would call a shoestring budget here, but it's perfectly normal for a lot of clubs abroad and they sign some excellent talents with those small budgets, whereas I think here we are more than happy to throw more money at players for short term success (which there is very little of!). Personally I think any of the teams in this country are a million miles away from the likes of Bayern Munich and Juventus.


Leave a comment

You must be Logged in to post a comment. Log in