A gang ringleader who carried out a series of violent robberies at Dunkin’ Donuts stores, leaving two people dead, has dared a judge to give him the death penalty.

James Herard, who is serving nine life sentences for the shootings he committed in 2008, was told by a jury that he deserved capital punishment for his violent crimes, which saw him shoot an innocent bystander in the face.

But the 25-year-old – who has barked like a dog in court and laughed openly at victims as they gave testimonies – appeared nonchalant and confrontational when he addressed Judge John Hurley.

James Herard is already serving a 125-year sentence for the Dunkin Donut robberies - Picture: Broward Sheriffs Office
James Herard is already serving a 125-year sentence for the Dunkin’ Donuts robberies (Picture: Broward Sheriff’s Office)

Herard told the Florida courtroom: ‘Honestly and truly, I’m not asking you to spare me. Go ahead and do what you gonna do. I pretty much dare you to give me the death sentence because I’m innocent.’


As he sat in the dock in chains and handcuffs, he added: ‘I’m actually hoping you give me the death penalty because I know the Supreme Court won’t allow me to die for something that I didn’t commit.’

Despite the defendant’s combative attitude, his lawyers are ‘totally focused on trying to save his life’.

In an attempt to stop the judge from putting the criminal on death row, several of his fellow inmates gave evidence in court, and described him as their tutor, counsellor and motivator. Herard’s mother was brought to tears during their testimonies.

The convicted murderer is due to reappear in court next week, when he will be sentenced.