Skip to content

The Lib Dems switching from Remain to revoke could cause a problem

As Jo Swinson's party well knows, bold political policies can end up causing big political problems.

Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson participates in a question and answer session during the Liberal Democrats autumn conference at the Bournemouth International Centre in Bournemouth.
Image: If Jo Swinson leads the Lib Dems to a majority government, she will cancel Brexit
Why you can trust Sky News

As delegates raised their hands in a vote to adopt a policy of stopping Brexit altogether, it was clear the endorsement was overwhelming - the party of Remain was to become the party of revoke.

It might seem that the two "Rs" are one and the same, but in practice they're not.

If Jo Swinson leads the Liberal Democrats to a general election victory and forms a government, the second referendum she and her party have been calling for so long will now not happen.

Jo Swinson
'Our country is divided,' says Lib Dem leader

Their parliamentary majority, they argue, would be the mandate to revoke unilaterally Article 50, which is the legal process for leaving the European Union.

In reality, however, that is highly unlikely.

The Lib Dems have had a boost in parliament by the defection of six MPs, but their number still stands at just 18.

Listen to "Talks and Speakers | Stephen Barclay, Harriet Harman & Chuka Umunna" on Spreaker.


More from Brexit

To win a parliamentary majority they would need to win more than 300 constituencies that they do not currently hold.

With polling in Sunday's Observer putting them at 16%, compared to 37% for the Conservatives, for now at least the prospect of Prime Minister Swinson seems distant.

The effect of the shift from Remain to revoke may therefore be more symbolic than substantial, but it is significant in what it says about the wider party political context of the Brexit debate.

Sophy Ridge On Sunday
In full: Sophy Ridge on Sunday

A few months ago, Ms Swinson's predecessor Sir Vince Cable said shifting the party's policy to outright revocation of Article 50 was "tempting", but said he still believed a referendum was the best way out of the impasse.

The main thing that has changed between those comments, ahead of the European Parliament elections, and now is the prospect of an imminent general election.

Ms Swinson's hope is that making the Liberal Democrats' electoral offering explicitly and unambiguously opposed to any form of Brexit, she can take votes from Conservatives aghast at the direction Boris Johnson is heading.

And, equally, from Labour voters who feel unclear where their party stands.

Party leader Jo Swinson hugs her new MP Sam Gyimah
Moment Tory rebel was revealed as Lib Dem

But while the vast majority of delegates in Bournemouth clearly agreed with that strategy, there were some voices of doubt.

"This strikes me as an undeliverable promise," said Niall Hodson, a councillor from Sunderland, from the conference podium.


"That if we end up in a coalition - could happen - we aren't going to be pushing through revoking Article 50.

"I mean, I hope we'll get a People's Vote but I don't want to be in a position again where the Liberal Democrats have promised something and done something else.

"And I think there's a real danger of that with revoking Article 50."

If the ultimate aim is to win the Remain voter bloc, rather than win an election overall, an eye-catching policy pledge is an understandably attractive tactic.

But as the Lib Dems well know, bold political policies can end up causing big political problems.

More stories