HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >


Anyone been to My Kitchen Witch's (Monmouth Beach) Friday night dinners?

  • 5

Friends are taking us next week and was wondering if anyone has tried it, do they have decent wine glasses for the BYOB or should we bring our own?

Last week's Menu looked great, do they substitute for food allergies or taste/choices?

My Kitchen Witch Cafe
29 Beach Rd, Monmouth Beach, NJ 07750

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Just don't order a steak. :-)

    3 Replies
    1. re: Tay

      Is there a problem with their steak? Do elaborate...

      1. re: equal_Mark

        I think Tay is making an especially funny comment regarding my posting "Sirena Nightmare" where I explain an unbelievable ordeal in getting, or actually not getting a steak at Sirena....

        Very good Tay, but I am back on the meatless bandwagon!

        1. re: carlylecat

          Yup... That was a ref. to your other very excellent posting...
          FYI If you're back to a non-carnivore lifestyle, you might enjoy a meal at The Good Karma Cafe in Red Bank. NO STEAK,,I promise. :-)

    2. My husband and I dined at their Friday night meal and just loved it. The food was great, price was so reasonable for what they offer and the atmosphere was romantic. It's a really cute out with friends, date, quiet place.
      We did run into the fact that they had run out of desert and they felt horrible. They tried to make up for it by giving us a TON of take home baked goods which was very nice.
      The service is down home and they get to know you. What they make in that tiny kitchen blows me away.
      I do believe they will try and help out with dietary needs.
      I had steak and my husband seafood. The soup we had was wonderful and I can't say enough how I can't wait to go back again!
      And their breakfasts.... don't get me started, amazing. Best bacon I have ever had.