Holder answers the waterboarding question

HOLDER ANSWERS THE WATERBOARDING QUESTION…. When Alberto Gonzales was the nominee for Attorney General, he went to great lengths to avoid describing waterboarding as torture, or even addressing whether the practice is legal. Michael Mukasey’s A.G. nomination was nearly derailed by his unwillingness to address similar questions.

It wasn’t a trick question. Today, Eric Holder answered it.


Judiciary Committee Chairman Pat Leahy (D-Vt.) followed up, asking if foreign countries would have the authority to waterboard U.S. citizens, if they deemed it necessary for their national security. “No, they would not,” Holder replied, “It would violate the international obligations that I think all civilized nations have agreed to — the Geneva Conventions.”

And finally, Leahy asked whether the president has the authority to override the law regarding torture. Holder responded, “Mr. Chairman, no one is above the law. The president has a constitutional obligation to faithfully execute the laws of the United States.”

These are obviously the correct answers. That the nation has reached the point at which these questions would even have to be asked, and Holder’s responses come as something of a relief, is testament to Bush’s legacy as it relates to the rule of law.

Support Nonprofit Journalism


Yes, I’ll make a donation