Print and Go Back Forde [Print without images]

Saturday, July 28, 2007
Updated: July 30, 12:22 PM ET
No one can rival a QB's to-do list

By Pat Forde



It's an action hero's set of job requirements. There is James Bond calm, Spock intelligence, Chuck Norris machismo and Clint Eastwood charisma packed into every play. And that's just the in-game to-do list.

Brian Brohm
Louisville's Brian Brohm calls quarterback the most pressure-filled spot on any field.

Pregame, no player puts in more work studying the opposition and absorbing that week's game plan. Postgame, no player is held more accountable for what just happened.

You must explain to the media about the second-quarter interception and the fourth-quarter drive that stalled in the red zone. You must accept maximum responsibility for what didn't get done -- even if your line leaked all day and your split end dropped two key passes and your tailback went the wrong way on a toss sweep. You must share credit for what did get done -- even the stuff that wouldn't have happened if you hadn't made heroic plays. And in the locker room you must be the team leader -- even if your ribs ache and your psyche is bruised and you really just want to spend a secluded minute crying on your mom's shoulder.

But don't just take my 470 words for it. Listen to the guys who play the position and coach the position better than anyone else currently in the college game.

Cal coach Jeff Tedford: "I don't know of anything that's harder. I'm amazed at what these guys do sometimes. How they do what we ask them to do, mentally and physically, is pretty special."

Louisville QB Brian Brohm, a three-sport athlete in high school: "It's definitely the position in any sport with the most pressure, even more than a golfer or tennis player. You have to worry about more than yourself. You have teammates who are going to be on your back if you don't do well."

USC QB John David Booty: "You've got to become a man [to play quarterback in college]. You have to fess up to what happened -- sometimes it's good, sometimes it's bad. You've got to live with being booed out sometimes. You can't wear it on your sleeve. Everyone's looking at you and how you're going to react. You've got to blow it off and keep playing."

Of course, it's not exactly a thankless task. Especially if you're good.

Quarterbacks get the hot chicks and the big headlines, and 26 of them have gotten the Heisman Trophy, too (six of the past seven have gone to QBs). They go on to get massive money, like Peyton Manning and Carson Palmer. They go on to get television analyst jobs, like Kirk Herbstreit and Dan Fouts and Doug Flutie. Some even go on to get elected to office, like J.C. Watts and Heath Shuler.

But it takes a special breed to be a great quarterback, with a unique mix of attributes. This is Tedford's five-part recruiting checklist when shopping for a QB:

1. Mental and physical toughness. "Obviously, physically, you're going to take a pounding, and you've got to get up and have your team follow you. You have to be mentally tough because if you throw a couple picks, you've got to be tough enough to come back."

2. Intelligence. "You've got to be able to understand and control the offense."

3. Competitiveness. "We look for a guy who wants the ball in his hands with the game on the line."

4. Escape dimension. "Not everything happens the way it's drawn up. We want a guy who can elude the rush and make something happen when a play breaks down."

5. Natural throwing motion. "He's got to be able to get the ball around the field."

Jeff Tedford
Cal coach Jeff Tedford has put multiple quarterbacks in the NFL.

That pretty well covers the human body, top to bottom: head, heart, guts, arm, feet. Finding that total package isn't always easy, and coaching the package to peak effectiveness is vital to team success. That's why Tedford -- who has molded a number of NFL QBs, including David Carr and Trent Dilfer -- is in the meeting room with his quarterbacks every day.

"Tom Brady hasn't always been Tom Brady," Booty said. "It was playing with coach [Charlie] Weis and other coaches who helped make him what he is."

But by college, it's hard to instill a quarterback with that Brady-esque ability to thrive under all the pressure that comes with his position. Whether it's nature or nurture, that leadership trait usually surfaces earlier.

"There's got to be a mind-set where you're able to perform when everything goes wrong and everyone's looking at you," Brohm said. "Everyone's saying, 'What the heck's going on?' and you've got to be calm."

Part of being calm is lacking a fear of failure. There is no time in the huddle to stew over worst-case scenarios -- and definitely no time in the pocket.

"If you hesitate a second, you're probably going to get picked or take a sack," Brohm said. "You've got to trust your judgment and let it rip."

Then shrug off the consequences if it goes wrong.

"Sometimes you have to live with a bad result, and it sucks," Booty said. "Sometimes they get you and you have to tip your hat to them. But I've always played quarterback, and I was always the pitcher in baseball. I take pride in wanting the ball in my hands. I have the guys' respect because of that."

Much respect is accorded to a great quarterback. But he has to earn it the hard way, 30 action-packed seconds at a time.

Pat Forde is a national columnist for He can be reached at