Don Marshall



The thing I like best about LeafsTV (which I still don't have) is the old games that they show.  It's not so much a Leafs/Thrashers game from three seasons ago as it is the really old stuff from the 60s and even the 50s, when they have that sort of thing on.  The attraction for me is the opportunity to watch players I never got to see. 

For most star players of days gone by there is a highlight package out there on youtube somewhere.  I find, though, that it's just so much better to watch a complete game - to see the little plays that don't make the highlight reels.  I like to watch Tim Horton clear the zone.  I like the speed of a Dick Duff as he goes wide on a defenseman.  I like Terry Sawchuk in the gorilla pose in the nets.

Just as much, though, I like to see the opposition.  These games are how I've gotten to see Howe, Hull, Orr, Beliveau.  So if I'm asking someone to tape a game for me, I pick it based mainly on the opposition.

Last night I got a new tape and it looks like a dandy.  There's the Leafs/Rangers game from 1971 where Bernie Parent's mask got pitched into the stands, and then there's the real gem - Game 2 of the 1960 Final, Leafs vs. Habs - the first game I've ever seen with the Rocket.

I got to watch the first period of this second game last night.  Habs got a pair early and then settled back and clogged it up.  Neither team got anything done on the power play and it looked like it would end 2-0 until the Leafs' Larry Regan potted one in the last minute.

A few thoughts:

  • it looks like there's a ton of room out there, but I think at least some of it is an illusion.  Yes, the players are a bit smaller, but I think a lot of it comes from the clean room syndrome.  There's no advertising on the boards or on the ice, and the lack of clutter translates to the eye as more space.  I also think the camera is zoomed out a bit, showing a little more ice than we normally see.
  • There is very limited hooking and holding, which also creates the perception of space.  A player who can skate can really move the puck in this game. 
  • They can all skate.  There isn't a player out there who won't take the puck and go with it.  Even the defenders who you'd normally think would stay home will carry it out of the zone and not pass off until they're well past their own blue line.  Given what they're wearing on their feet, they can really fly out there.
  • Playing with straight wooden sticks, long shots are almost completely useless.  They're always aiming to get the puck into a higher percentage area.  I haven't seen a slapper from the point yet.  Geoffrion and Horton are both noted for their slap shots, but neither has been open and in a position to use it.  Curious how a composite stick would change this game.
  • Danny Gallivan is doing the play by play.  He wonders about the age controversy over Johnny Bower - whether he's really 35 as he claims or 39 as many suspect.  Either way, he says, he's playing great in what is likely the twilight of his career.  (Little did Danny know, but Bower had almost 10 years left.)  Bower made one save where he cut down the angle so much he was halfway to the circle.
  • Leafs have a big winger named Garry Edmundson who can move really well.  No apparent hands, though.
  • Carl Brewer, who appears to be about 20, is playing like it.  He has made at least two brutal giveaways and was lucky to get away with both of them.
  • Doug Harvey can do whatever he wants, whenever he wants.  If he has the puck, he will give it up at a time of his own choosing.
  • The Rocket is 39 and is playing like a guy who has lost a step (leg problems in both of the past two seasons), so he really conserves his motion.  Still, great hands and has made a couple amazing passes.  He ended up with a second assist on the Habs' first goal.  If he can do this at 39, I can only imagine what he was like at 25.
  • You can tell the Leafs are still a couple years away.  The pieces are coming together, though.
  • Also - the Leafs are getting nowhere on their power plays mainly due to the efforts of #22 for the bad guys - Don Marshall.

Don Marshall certainly isn't a name you'd immediately associate the with the Leafs.  He was a checker and penalty killer on the great Hab teams of the 1950s, a better two-way guy with the Rangers of the 60s, putting enough points on the board in '66-67 to the the second-team all-star at LW, an original Sabre for one season and finally a one-year source of veteran help to the 1971-72 Leafs, a promising team that was mostly undone by the WHA.

I don't think he saw a lot of ice as a Leaf, registering only 2 goals and 14 assists.  He was a plus, though, which is pretty good for a defensive guy who isn't scoring much.

Anyhow, Don's tenure in Toronto was fairly uneventful and doesn't leave a lot of room for storytelling, but he's a nice way to let me talk about this neat tape.

Today's moral: watch your old games on LeafsTV.  Odds are the Leafs play well and might even win, and if they don't, the game is shown because the opposition does something interesting and that's worth seeing, too.  Even the Habs.

A point of discussion:  Could players from this earlier era hold their own against today's teams?  Personally, I think that if you were to match up the equipment, it might be closer than you think.  A lot would come down to the standard of officiating. 

Don's stats:

 1949-50  Montreal Jr. Canadiens  QJHL  35   8   7   15   10     16   1   4   5   4 
 1949-50  Montreal Jr. Canadiens  M-Cup              13   8   6   14   2 
 1950-51  Montreal Jr. Canadiens  QJHL  37   19   32   51   6     9   5   8   13   0 
 1951-52  Montreal Jr. Canadiens  QJHL  43   32   46   78   6     11   4   5   9   6 
 1951-52  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  1   0   0   0   0             
 1951-52  Montreal Jr. Canadiens  M-Cup              8   6   5   11   8 
 1952-53  Cincinnati Mohawks  IHL  60   46   51   97   24     9   5   5   10   0 
 1952-53  Montreal Royals  QHL  2   0   0   0   2             
 1953-54  Buffalo Bisons  AHL  70   39   55   94   8     3   1   4   5   0 
 1954-55  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  39   5   3   8   9     12   1   1   2   2 
 1954-55  Montreal Royals  QHL  10   5   3   8   2             
 1955-56  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  66   4   1   5   10     10   1   0   1   0 
 1956-57  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  70   12   8   20   6     10   1   3   4   2 
 1957-58  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  68   22   19   41   14     10   0   2   2   4 
 1958-59  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  70   10   22   32   12     11   0   2   2   2 
 1959-60  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  70   16   22   38   4     8   2   2   4   0 
 1960-61  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  70   14   17   31   8     6   0   2   2   0 
 1961-62  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  66   18   28   46   12     6   0   1   1   2 
 1962-63  Montreal Canadiens  NHL  65   13   20   33   6     5   0   0   0   0 
 1963-64  New York Rangers  NHL  70   11   12   23   8             
 1964-65  New York Rangers  NHL  69   20   15   35   2             
 1965-66  New York Rangers  NHL  69   26   28   54   6             
 1966-67  New York Rangers  NHL  70   24   22   46   4     4   0   1   1   2 
 1967-68  New York Rangers  NHL  70   19   30   49   2   +19   6   2   1   3   0 
 1968-69  New York Rangers  NHL  74   20   19   39   12   +15   4   1   0   1   0 
 1969-70  New York Rangers  NHL  57   9   15   24   6   +6   1   0   0   0   0 
 1970-71  Buffalo Sabres  NHL  62   20   29   49   6   -13           
 1971-72  Toronto Maple Leafs  NHL  50   2   14   16   0  + 2   1   0   0   0   0 
   Leaf Totals    50   2   14   16   0  + 2   1   0   0   0   0 
   NHL Totals    1176   265   324   589   127   --  94   8   15   23   14 

QJHL First All-Star Team (1952)
IHL First All-Star Team (1953)
James Gatschene Memorial Trophy (IHL - MVP) (1953)
Dudley "Red" Garrett Memorial Award (AHL - Rookie of the Year) (1954)
NHL Second All-Star Team (1967)
Played in NHL All-Star Game (1956, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1968)

- Traded to NY Rangers by Montreal with Jacques Plante and Phil Goyette for Dave Balon, Leon Rochefort, Len Ronson and Gump Worsley, June 4, 1963.
- Claimed by Buffalo from NY Rangers in Expansion Draft, June 10, 1970.
- Claimed by Toronto from Buffalo in Intra-League Draft, June 8, 1971.

the HHOF take on Don:

"Like so many athletically-minded lads, Don Marshall devoted parts of his entire year to playing football, baseball, and hockey. But within the culture of his native Verdun, hockey was clearly the sport of choice for most and Marshall, with his natural, fluid skating style, was no exception.

During his junior days with the Montreal Jr. Canadiens of the QJHL, he performed as an offensively-minded forward with a nose for the opponent's net. When he turned pro in 1952, he kept up the same tradition in the minors while skating for the Cincinnati Mohawks of the IHL, the Buffalo Bisons of the AHL, and the Montreal Royals of the QHL.

Midway into the 1954-55 campaign, the Canadiens summoned him to join their ranks. The problem the winger faced, however, was that the Habs were already thoroughly stocked with offensively skilled forwards. As such, Marshall's new role would be defensive in nature, an assignment he disliked although he never complained openly.

Instead, he toiled quietly, polishing his defensive tactics to the extent that he became one of the league's premier penalty killers. As payment for his adaptation, he enjoyed a record five-straight Stanley Cup victories between 1956 and 1960.

By 1963, however, the Canadiens had lost their championship touch. In an effort to shake things up, they packaged Marshall with Jacques Plante and Phil Goyette to acquire Gump Worsley among others from the New York Rangers.

In the Big Apple, Marshall initially felt out of place but quickly began to appreciate his new opportunity to assume a more offensive role with the club. In the process, it was evident that, thanks to the strong defensive skills he had developed in Montreal, he was an excellent two-way player.

In all, Marshall put in seven seasons with the Blueshirts and enjoyed his most prolific offensive phase. In 1965-66, he netted a personal-best 26 goals and 28 assists within the context of some very solid defensive play.

At the start of his third decade in the NHL, Marshall was claimed by the Buffalo Sabres in the Expansion Draft of 1970. His new role with the fledgling club was to provide some veteran leadership for the younger recruits. He did all of that and then some. Although the team struggled defensively, he managed to pot goals as though still in his prime.

In spite of his contribution, the aging winger was left up for grabs in the Intra-League Draft of 1971. The Leafs took advantage by bringing him to the Gardens for one final season. During his last run, he performed as a steady, reliable veteran who had the versatility to plug holes and provide a calming influence on the sometimes rattled atmosphere on Carleton St. At the close of the season, Marshall packed it in for good."



Log In Sign Up

use Yahoo! or OpenID


Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.


Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.


Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.





Choose an available username to complete sign up.
