The great power struggle

It's all very well to hate windmills, but we need to find new ways to source energy, and we're running out of time to argue about it.

Why are the English not the Dutch? Because they hate windmills, at least those new, sleek sexy types that generate wind power. I learned that today at Hay, where I was speaking about climate change. But with atmospheric CO2 equivalent at around 430ppm, and the threshold of dangerous climate change estimated to be around 450ppm, we don't have a lot of time to argue about it.

So, how to convince the English to be more like the Dutch, and to love their windmills? First, they need to understand that windmills don't chop up many birds, especially if well-sited. If birds were the issue then cats would be banned rather than windmills. It would also help if people asked themselves the question of where they might get their power if not from windmills. Tidal power might work, but many people worry abouit the fate of places like the Severn estuary. Nuclear power might work, but that technology has many opponents, too.

Perhaps I'd be more sympathetic to the wind protestors if they decided that they'd do withoput mains power. That way, we could side-step the thorny issue of how we generate our electricity.

All our blogs from Hay are collected here. Guardian Books features the latest news from Hay, literary blogs and a daily podcast.