Friday, October 26, 2012

What’s Really Up With Dr. Ketchum’s DNA Project?

What’s Really Up With Dr. Ketchum’s DNA Project?
Hoax, Conspiracy, Or Nothing Unusual?
By TCC Team Member Dorraine Fisher

Empty Lab - Moving on up or Moving on out? 
            Well, there’s been a considerable amount of excitement in the Bigfoot world in the last couple months, but none of it has been good or constructive.  Mostly conjecture, hoaxing, and a lot of the general ridiculousness we’re so used to seeing. So we’re still hoping for something concrete from the DNA project. But that’s another mystery.

            Dr. Ketchum’s office was recently discovered to be vacant. While she posted this vague message on her Facebook page over the weekend: “We are moving the lab to a larger town and are in the process of selling the service part of it. We will be doing forensics and research oriented projects only.”

            But that only leaves the field wide open for speculation. How does this affect the awaited results of the DNA project? Or, if we dare ask,  is there a DNA project at all? Have we all been duped? Why is this taking so long, and why is there so much secrecy surrounding it? I had to sit down and ask myself, “Why is this whole project playing out in such a suspicious way?”

            And why do we think it’s suspicious?

            Well it could be that the doctor has pulled up stakes, closed the company website and fired her right hand person right in the middle of a major DNA discovery. Perhaps one of the greatest discoveries of all time. So we have to ask the question why. What’s going on?

            First, to address the idea that the DNA project is a hoax; a sham; doesn’t even exist, was finally squelched for me (slightly) when a very reliable source ensured me the project is very real and is still in pier review.

            Two other possibles came to mind: Some kind of conspiracy or some kind of financial gain. Or both.

            Since we’re all painfully aware that the government may have real information about the existence extraterrestrial life and is keeping it a secret, why couldn’t it be the same with bigfoot?

            The second thought is that the government may be attempting to block any information of bigfoot’s existence for some reason. Maybe the DNA project’s results are being suppressed. And why? The only reason this might happen is if the results were shocking or controversial to the point that the government might believe it’s some kind of security risk. That would cause them to try to put a gag order on the results of such a project, wouldn’t it? Say, if the rumors are actually true and Bigfoot is more human than we think?

            I talked to an official recently with 32 years experience working for the government to kind of clear my head on the conspiracy idea. I, like a lot of people, can get really engrossed in a good conspiracy theory, something like being glued to a weekly soap opera. So I knew I needed to ground myself on this one. But he insisted that conspiracy is a difficult thing to implement.

            “It never moves fast or quietly,” he said when he talked of the government and their dealings with any issues of importance. “Not everything is tied to a government cover-up. They would need probable cause to silence the study,” he added. “Since this is not a national security risk.”

            “But couldn’t some very controversial results of the study constitute a possible security risk? Say if certain religious or environmental sects took the news badly?” I asked.

            “No, again, they’d need probable cause; national security risk, or environmental threat,” he insisted.

            “So no chance of a gag order happening, especially this quick?” I asked.

            “No, I don’t think so. Something that big would’ve made the news for sure.”

             So I called all pertinent government offices at the local, state, and federal level, and found no evidence of any gag order on the project. Here is the list of places I called:
*Shelby County Clerk's Office
*Shelby County Attorney's Office
*Texas State's Attorney's Office
*US Dept. Of Justice
*US Dept. of Interior-Fish And Wildlife Division
So apparently he’s right. It’s not that easy to implement a conspiracy such as this as he said. It would take way too much time and way too much red tape. “It’s not as easy as some big wig calling the Department of Justice,” he elaborated. So there are certain channels everything must go through. That’s not to say it couldn’t be done, but it is to say that it would likely take longer than the amount of time we’ve all been waiting for the results.

            And the Department of the Interior’s Fish and Wildlife Bureau did share with me that this subject doesn’t even apply to their office if the creature is not yet proven to “quantifiably exist.” They only deal with known species and steps would have to be taken to prove its existence before any other action could be taken.

            Another possibility was whether the proven existence of the creature would affect the logging industry. Would that cause the government to attempt concealment of the creature’s existence?

            “It would have to start with the logging industry being told to stop, and then filing suit,” he explained.  Any action such as this could take months to put in place. Besides, if this were the case, environmental and wildlife groups would surely get wind of a new species of primate roaming the forests of the North American continent and bring it swiftly to public attention for their personal causes. It would be very hard to keep this quiet. The media would have a heyday.

            So even though I wasn’t completely convinced from this conversation that the government couldn’t do what they wanted when they wanted if they could convince themselves they had a good reason, the conspiracy idea was at least taken down a notch on my list of possible scenarios.

            So if we eliminate conspiracy, we’re left with one thing: money...and fame. Depending on the results of the study, this could potentially be a big money project for Dr. Ketchum. Book deals, public speaking engagements, and even possibly a consulting position to a larger DNA project could be in the works. There are many ways to make money from such a groundbreaking project. And when money and fame are involved, a person might be forced to decide with whom they would like to share all that. And that might explain Dr. Ketchum’s surprise break with Sally Ramey when the project was believed to be so close to fruition. And why has the doctor not had regular contact with the DNA submitters as was suggested by a couple of researchers I spoke to recently?

            But after all this speculating, should Dr. Ketchum be surprised that anyone would wonder so much and imagine so many different, sometimes crazy scenarios?  If she dislikes the rumors that are swirling right now, she may have only herself to blame. She’s had plenty of time to explain herself, but has chosen instead to keep her answers vague and keep us all wondering.

            I asked her this week if she’d like to make a statement and if the project was still on track, and she had only this to say. “Thanks, but I am not making any comments at this time other than to say that things are progressing.” 
            Give us a better explanation, Doctor, and the rumors can go away.

©The Crypto Crew

This post sponsored in part by


Have you had a close encounter or witnessed something unusual?
Help us!
Help Support The Crypto Crew
Now you can get our blog on your Kindle!


  1. Informative article Dorraine Fisher. Im leaning towards fame and fortune myself, and yes if Melba Kethum would give us clear answers than we would at least know where she and the DNA study stands. Frustrated as heck is sn understatement!

  2. I don't blame her for getting rid of her right hand person. She's the reason I distanced myself from the whole issue

  3. Everyone I know that has had close contact with her points to fame and fortune as the motivator and the resulting difficulties a product of her difficult personality. However, she just might not be quite brilliant enough to have pulled it off in the three years and must rely on the various labs and co-authors to meet the Journal requirements and maybe she has lost some cooperation among those unseen "colleagues?" Or, not. I would not care so much if one Justin Smeja wasn't making such audacious claims and other groups, also bent on fame and fortune, determined to kill one before a study comes out. Or stupid shows like "win $10M with proof." What a freakin bunch of greedy creeps BFers tend to be.

  4. Not sure how or why anyone would have faith in dr. Ketchum at this point.

    Spot on article and that's why I'm anticipating seeing ndep labs results from sierra kills through Tyler H and Bart Cutino's sierras team and Co, which includes smeja. They promised transparency when complete and Im hoping we at least get answers to the steak collected and boots.

    Cutino has emphasized some things as recently as his felton presentation on therm footage, that make sense and get overlooked, like smeja not hiding behind ketchum and pushing for independent dna analysis with no reliance on her because he doesnt trust her. Think about that, she says sierra steak is bigfoot and smeja wants someone else legit to test it and he essentially thinks she's a fraud though he seems to still believe piece they found is from big one shot. You can't make this stuff up! That also don't sound like a hoaxer imo.

    Then smeja called her to carpet when she claimed the sierra steak pic posted by RL wasnt the sierras piece. Smeja even described where he cut it and called her a liar! Bart has also been very vocal behind the scenes about ketchum for a long time, supposedly kept boots away from her she was demading and now publicly criticzing her deservedly imo on her bias , ethics and horse braiding craziness.

    I think these guys are going to come through with some results though i dont know what or when because i don't think they know when.. Bart is straight up guy and he emphasized providing results only when confirmed but he was overheard in santa cruz talking about frutration in time its taking as labs are "having issues" with sample apparently whatever that means. I know he really has tissue in 2-4 labs and one is canada for sure.

  5. Rather than conspiracy theories, let us utilize parsimony. Incompetence, that is the likely answer. It is much more probable that the paper was rejected, and what they call "peer review" is simply them scrambling to patch up the grievous holes in their methodology and assumptions.

    Thanks for asking all of the questions in this article!!


The Crypto Crew - Submit Sighting - TCC Team
Interactive Sightings Map
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...