Inside The Conservative Plan To Continue The Fight Against LGBT Equality

Undercover At The Religious Right's Anti-LGBT “Future Conference”


The meeting was part of the 2015 Future Conference, an event organized by Skyline Pastor Jim Garlow in order to respond to “the thorniest and most challenging issues in the current cultural landscape.”

In promotional materials for the gathering, Garlow warned “our nation is in trouble” due to the lack of a “clear proclamation of biblical answers to the messiness of our culture.” According to Garlow, pastors can no longer speak out about things like homosexuality because they are considered “political.”

The four-day conference, which Media Matters attended undercover, featured presentations covering a range of issues -- from the threat of Islam to “biblical economics” -- but its unifying theme was the alleged rise of Christian persecution across the globe, and especially in the United States as a result of growing acceptance of LGBT people.




“The Rainbow Flag ... Has Become The Dark Flag Of Tyranny”

Speakers at the Future Conference presented many of the same homophobic talking points that have defined the religious right for the past several years. Many disparaged same-sex relationships as destructive and unhealthy. Frank Schubert -- the political strategist behind many of the country's most successful anti-LGBT campaigns -- told his audience that “sexual entanglements” between gay men pose “substantial risk of harm,”  and called gay sex “inherently unhealthy” :

Others decried LGBT activists as being overly-aggressive and totalitarian. “The rainbow flag of tolerance has become the dark flag of tyranny overnight,” warned Everett Piper, president of Oklahoma Wesleyan University. Conservative columnist Star Parker lamented that “homosexuality is now dividing us and bringing hostility into the public square. They're coming out of the closet -- they're forcing the church in.” Michael Brown, an anti-LGBT activist known for showing up at gay pride events to badger attendees, declared that the “gay revolution has within itself the seeds of self-destruction.”

FRC Vice President for Church Ministries Kenyn Cureton, in a presentation about mobilizing churches to get involved in political battles, described LGBT activists as “pawns of a malevolent master.”


What Happens After Obergefell?





Civil Disobedience


In a video message to the conference. Liberty Counsel founder Mat Staver compared a Supreme Court decision legalizing marriage equality to Dred Scott, the infamous Supreme Court decision that found African Americans were not American citizens. “Our highest respect for a higher law,” Staver said, “requires that we not give respect to an unjust decision.” He explicitly suggested that religious adoption agencies should refuse to place children in households headed by same-sex couples, adding that the Supreme Court lacked the power to enforce its decisions.

That sentiment was echoed by several other speakers, including Schubert, who argued that a constitutional convention might be needed to override an “illegitimate” decision on same-sex marriage from the Supreme Court. NOM's Brian Brown touted his organization's "Presidential Marriage Pledge," which -- in addition to calling for a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage -- asks presidential candidates to pledge to work to “overturn any Supreme Court decision that illegitimately finds a constitutional 'right' to the redefinition of marriage.”


Fighting Non-Discrimination Protections

Speakers also touted efforts to undermine and sidestep non-discrimination laws that would prohibit them from discriminating against LGBT people on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. Steve Riggle, a Houston pastor at the center of the national controversy surrounding Houston's Equal Rights Ordinance (HERO) earlier this year, decried the city's attempt to extend “special rights” to LGBT people, peddling the myth that sexual predators would exploit the law by pretending to be transgender and sneaking into women's restrooms. 

In a session titled “Homosexual Marriage - Obliterating Religious Liberty,”  Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) senior counsel Kevin Theriot warned audience members that non-discrimination laws threaten the freedom of churches and businesses to act out their faith. ADF has been at the forefront of representing business owners who refuse service to gay customers, arguing that religious businesses should be exempt from non-discrimination protections. It's also the group behind the national push for state  “religious freedom” laws, which would give business owners a legal defense for refusing service to gay customers. He offered audience members copies of ADF's booklet "Protecting Your Ministry," which offers advice on how for-profit businesses and churches can avoid non-discrimination lawsuits.

“Are you willing to do what it takes to prepare yourself for the coming onslaught?” Theriot asked before describing how churches might insulate themselves from discrimination complaints. One tactic, advised Theriot, is to take advantage of the ministerial exemption to non-discrimination laws by broadly defining “ministers” to include employees like IT technicians and food bank workers. 


Influencing The Media


Ted Baehr, Chairman of the Christian Film & Television Commission, touted efforts to inject Christian themes and imagery into mainstream television and film. Shows like “Will & Grace,” he argued, had gotten society comfortable with an “illegal, demonic form of marriage.” Using Hollywood to expose the public to Christian values is, according to Baehr, a key step in turning the tide in America's culture war.

Other speakers were more concerned with coverage of LGBT issues in news outlets. In a presentation titled “Dealing With Media,”  conservative author and right-wing activist Jason Mattera suggested that the key to winning public opinion was to invert the dominant media narrative about LGBT equality by decrying LGBT activists as intolerant bullies while painting religious conservatives as the real victims in the culture war.

Leftists are “the most intolerant, bigoted people on the planet. And that is, they want Christianity purged from the public square,” Mattera declared. He urged his audience to portray the fight for LGBT equality as intolerant when talking to reporters or appearing on TV:  “Why do they hate diversity? Why do they hate tolerance? I'm for a multiplicity of viewpoints. Isn't that what America is about? Why does that person want to compel me to do something I don't want? What is it about fascism that appeals to them?”  

That “flip the script” tactic -- essentially calling LGBT activists bullies -- has been widely successful in influencing conservative media coverage of the fight for LGBT equality in recent years. Stories about anti-gay bakers and florists who are fined for refusing service to gay customers have helped motivate the recent wave of “religious freedom” laws and gin up opposition to non-discrimination efforts that protect LGBT people.


The End Of “Comfortable Christianity”

Near the end of the conference, NOM's Brown warned conference-goers that “the days of comfortable Christianity are over” :



