Loading articles...

Thatcher didn't want to be involved in Canada's Constitution drama: reports



This year marks the 30th anniversary of Trudeau’s successful gambit to bring home the Constitution through passage of legislation that included an amending formula and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Though Canada had long been in charge of its own affairs, there was still the matter of securing Westminster’s blessing of the plan, with a chorus of competing interests in Canada determined to have a say.

According to the minutes, Thatcher said “(Her Majesty’s Government) did not want to be accused of interfering in any way. HMG could help; and if, for example, queues of Indians knocked on the door of No. 10, the answer would be that it was for Canada to decide her future and not HMG.” The previous year a delegation of aboriginal chiefs and elders had spent a week in London, seeking British help to get a seat at the constitutional negotiating table.

During the meeting with Trudeau, it was suggested things would be easier for Britain if Canada “was united in its approach.”

Trudeau said the British government “would be accused of interfering whichever way things went.”

As for unanimity, “that could be forgotten,” added Trudeau. “The provinces would want to be heard and one or more of them would say that they were not getting what they wanted.”

The Canadian Press obtained copies of the previously confidential records from Britain’s National Archives with the assistance of Steve Hewitt, a senior lecturer in the Department of American and Canadian Studies at the University of Birmingham.

Thatcher and her government were obviously concerned “that they would become the lightning rod” for anger in Canada over the plan, said Hewitt, president of the British Association for Canadian Studies.



“The Prime Minister reiterated that she hoped that she would not have masses of people lobbying in front of No. 10,” say the minutes.


“He meant to unite Canadians if possible,” say the minutes. “But he recognized that he might in fact make things worse. He could foresee that Quebec, and perhaps other provinces, would not go along with what he wanted.” Trudeau’s private acknowledgment of the risk contrasts sharply with his public bravado, said Eric Adams, an assistant professor of law at the University of Alberta.




Trudeau’s desire to make the most of the opportunity was obvious to Thatcher and her advisers.



Records that came to light last spring showed that at one point the British cabinet considered denying Canada’s proposal to create a Charter of Rights over concerns that Trudeau was pushing the plan without the desired backing of the provinces.