Ask Not what Others Can Do for You


She sent me the emails from one friend from Pakistan, (let us call him Zaheer) asking me to respond to him. I publish a sample of Zaheer’s emails and my response to him, in the hope that it may help others in the same situation.


hello madam,

hope you fine. madam i contact you over a year ago and i told you that time i want to leave islam and want to be atheist i hope you remember and i leave islam but I am still with my muslim family i hate them, but i don’t have choice and they still don’t know about me if they know they kill me its legal in islam.

actually i want just your help and i am useable parson for you i can go anywhere make film for you and what you want then you can explain to world about islam and rule but now i want to move anywhere were i can feel freedom i’m 29 year old but still single coz i don’t wanna marry with a muslim girl and i worry about myself my family many time beat me coz i not perform prayer.

plz i need to move to any non-muslim country so plz tell to anyone who can do something to help me. I can’t say this to any other parson coz i don’t trust anyone.

plz save my life. Is there any parson or organization that can help me?  i want to leave this country and live there where not Islamic rules im so upset. Sometime I am thinking about suicide.  Plz ma’am plz.

Plz ma’am do something im really upset and i dont wanna live this muslim country anymore i want to live where i can do what i want and here maybe thay kill me i want to annocecd that im not muslim and plz contact with any parson who can help me i return help you about your projact i promise.

So i need just your help plz dont forget me i cant explain how i spend my last year here. i contact you a year ago and that time you told me same thing Plz ma’am do somthing and save my live i want to live free

Thank you


 Dear Zaheer,

This is Ali Sina. I am an ex-Muslim from Iran, now living in Canada. I understand your situation. There are millions of people like you suffering in Islamic countries. Many Iranians in Iran feel the same way you do. They don’t believe in Islam and are trapped in a very repressive Islamic country where they can be thrown in jail and killed if discovered.

You wrote to Ms. Geller pleading her to save your life. You say you hate your Muslim family and that if they find out about your disbelief they will kill you, and as the result you are suicidal. I have difficulty to understand this. If life is so precious that your biggest worry is getting killed, why you want to commit suicide?  If it is not worth much and you are thinking of ending it why not letting others to help you out?

You say you want to leave Islam. If you don’t believe in Islam you have left it already. Once you stop believing in the lies of Muhammad, you are set free. You no longer fear his bogus deity and his sadistic torture chamber and the rest of his nonsense and stupidity, which have paralyzed the minds of his believers. The chains of his lies are broken. Now it is up to you to step out of his prison of mind. No one can do that for you. We can shed light and break the chains of deception, but it is up to you to stand up and walk out of that prison.

You think Pakistan and your situation with your family is your prison.  They are not. The prison is in your mind.  Ms. Geller does not have a magic want. She can’t do miracles. She can use legal means and the power of social media to help young Muslims when their lives are in danger.  That is all she can do. How can she help you in Pakistan?  By what laws can she defend you? She has no clout in that country or any Islamic country. Furthermore, you are a big man. You have to take responsibility for your own life.

We humans suffer mostly because we don’t live in a world of reality.  The reality is that you are not the only person living in an Islamic country that wants to escape his condition. Nine out of ten people living in Islamic countries, whether they believe in Islam or not, want to go somewhere else.  Many risk their lives and take dangerous trips to take refuge where there is more opportunity. Can we possibly help all these people?  

Assuming we could, would that be the solution? Can we accommodate millions of apostates in non-Muslim countries? What about the religious minorities? They are also being persecuted. Every day more people are leaving Islam. In Iran alone, tens of millions of people have stopped believing in Islam. Can we send all these people a ticket to a western country?

This is not the way to do it. We want to get rid of Islam and transform the Islamic countries to free countries were all the people can pursue life, prosperity and happiness.

Your problems come from your own thinking and you are the only person that can help yourself. Let us analyze your thinking first. You say you hate your Muslim family.  Why? Do you hate them because they are Muslim?  If this is the only reason then you have missed the point.  We don’t leave Islam to hate Muslims.

The truth is that you don’t get along with your family. Most (almost all) families in patriarchal societies are dysfunctional. We are all victims of the nefarious Islamic culture. A society that calls half of its members awrat, which literary means pudenda, something defective, something to hide and be ashamed of, cannot produce healthy individuals. These “defective” members of the society are the mothers and primary educators.  When you demean them, the entire society is demeaned.  Belittled women have low self-esteem. They cannot raise emotionally healthy sons.  Therefore, virtually all Muslim families are dysfunctional and all Muslims are psychologically damaged.

You are not the only victim of Islam. All of us are. Even after we leave this evil religion we remain its victims until the day we die.  Eighty percent of human personality is formed during the first 8 years of his or her life. When children are beaten, abused and ignored as it is the norm in all Islamic countries, they become damaged for the rest of their life. To grow emotionally healthy, children need love and attention, which they cannot possibly get when there are half a dozen or more of them in every family. The ideal number of children in a family is two or three. Four is too many. In Muslim families, there are generally half a dozen to a dozen children and if the husband is polygamists, the number of children can reach fifty or more, as was the family of Osama bin Laden. As the result every Muslim is a psychopath.  They are all a bunch of sickos, constantly hurting each other and everyone else. They can then go and accumulate two or three doctorates, but their emotional and psychological growth is often stalled at the age of three.  Most Muslims, (including ex-Muslims) are emotional dwarfs. We have big heads, but tiny hands and feet. We can intellectualize, but emotionally we are children.  

A recent study shows that one in every three Iranians suffers from depression and/or anxiety. These are the root causes of many other psychological problems. Those who conducted the study claim the actual number is two out of three, and that in their view most people interviewed were not telling the truth.

Although Islam is a major contributor to this tragedy the reality is that even when we leave Islam we can’t be happy unless we overcome our psychological hangover.

We use anger to overcome our anxiety. This makes us more violent than any other people. It would be foolish to say Islam has nothing to do with it.

We can never be happy unless we restore our emotional health. There are two ways to do that. One is to work on our children and make sure we don’t pass to them our negative beliefs, emotions and feelings that have made us psychological handicaps.  In the first eight years of their life children absorb everything uncritically, and everything that they observe becomes their operative system for the rest of their life. This operative system is the sub-conscious mind.  Once children pass that age, their personality is formed and there is nothing you can do to change it.

However, once we reach the age of 18 we can change our subconscious mind consciously, through will power and practice. This is a slow process and not easy. Formatting the subconscious mind is like learning a new language. You can learn any language easily when you are a child and speak it fluently and with no accent. You can also learn any language when you are an adult, but this time you have to exert a lot of effort, learn the grammar and the structure of the language and you’ll never be able to speak it as fluently as someone who learned that language in childhood. For our unborn children, there is hope, but for us this is the only way.

How can we reformat our subconscious mind?  To do that you have to change your conscious thoughts from negative to positive and charge them with emotions! You have to be persistent. Gradually, the old and negative programming in the subconscious mind is replaced by a new positive one.

There is a law in the universe, discovered by your Hindu ancestors thousands of years ago. It was also discovered by others across the world, independently. This law states that whatever thought you hold in your mind, whether positive or negative, it will manifest itself in reality. Buddha said, “We are shaped by our thoughts; we become what we think. When the mind is pure, joy follows like a shadow that never leaves.”

What if the mind is full of hate, anger and despair? Well, that is what you get in life. If you have hatred and anger towards your Muslim family or anyone, you can change your country, but your life will stay the same – just as unhappy as it is now. With this much negativity, anger and hate that exude from your emails, you can only attract more negativity, more anger and more hate.

Jesus said, “For whoever has, to him more shall be given, and he will have abundance. But whoever does not have, even what he has shall be taken away from him.”

He was talking about the secret of the universal law of attraction. The universe loathes beggars and complainers. The more you beg and the more you whine the more you attract misery to your life. Our life is the manifestation of our dominant thoughts. In order to chance your life you have to change your thoughts. You have to replace your negative thoughts with joyous and positive thoughts. You can’t hate and expect love in your life? Replace the thoughts of hatred with the thoughts of love if you want happiness.  

What you sow is what you reap. Swami Vivekananda said, “We are what our thoughts have made us; so take care about what you think. Words are secondary. Thoughts live; they travel far.” Mahatma Gandhi said, “A man is but the product of his thoughts what he thinks, he becomes.”

What are your thoughts? What do you think about all day? If what your emails to Ms. Geller are your typical thoughts, you can live a lifetime of unhappiness and your lot will never change.  But if you change your thoughts, you can change your destiny.

You are not a teenager who must dependent on your family. We receive many emails from such people. All we can tell them is to focus on their studies. That is the key to their freedom. But you are a 29 years old. Why for Pete’s sake you still live with your family? At this age you should be independent. Go to another city. Live apart. It is very unhealthy for a man in your age to live with his family.

For your life to change, you have to fill your heart with love and gratitude. Nothing attracts more bounty than love and gratitude. I should say nothing else attracts any bounty  other than love and gratitude. 

Instead of whining and complaining be grateful and give thanks for what the universe has given you. Feel yourself rich and happy. Your positive thoughts will resonate through the universe and the universe echoes back. Replace the resentment in your heart with compassion and love. “Buddha said, “Those who are free of resentful thoughts surely find peace.

Our thoughts not only change our inner world, they also change the outer world.  In the words of Confucius, “The more man meditates upon good thoughts the better will be his world and the world at large.”  Our collective thoughts affect the situation in the world. One and a half billion Muslims emit thoughts of hate. This negativity results in disharmony, wars, revolutions, economic upheavals, diseases, poverty and chaos.  What difference it will make if we change our religion and still hold on to hate?  We can’t change our lives by just changing our names. We have to change our thoughts before we can change our world.  Your happiness depends on the content of your thoughts. Take control of your thought and you will take control of your life.

To plagiarize John F. Kenedy, ask not what others can do for you. Ask what you can do for others. This is the key to happiness.

I followed happiness to make her mine,
Past towering oak and swinging ivy vine.
She fled, I chased, over slanting hill and dale,
Over fields and meadows, in the purpling vale.

Pursuing rapidly over dashing stream,
I scaled dizzy cliffs where the eagles scream;
I traversed swiftly every land and sea,
But always happiness eluded me.

Exhausted, fainting, I pursued no more,
But sank to rest upon the barren shore.

One came and asked for food, and one for alms;
I placed the bread and gold in bony palms;
One came for sympathy, and one for rest;
I shared with every needy one my best;
When lo! sweet Happiness, with form divine,
Stood by me, whispering softly, “I am thine.”

— Burleigh

Mother Theresa

There are millions of people who are in the same or worse predicaments than yours. It is impossible for us to help everyone. Only you can help yourself.  Think of your vicissitudes as a blessing for you to grow.

Below you find a few links. Listen to them every day.  They can change your life. Don’t give up and don’t expect immediate result.  You need to change your thoughts. Your present thoughts are the result of 29 years of negative thinking. You can’t change them overnight.  Listen to them for at least 30 days before you can see any result. Once you see result, continue and read and listen to similar talks.  The lessons in these talks will teach you how to take control of your thoughts and once you do that you can take control of your life. You can have everything you want.  Your freedom, your happiness and your future are in your own hands. Your life is what your thoughts make it.


These are just a few. You can find more audios like these on Youtube. Do this for 30 days until your subconscious mind starts changing. Once that happens, you will begin to see the change in your life.

You may also like...

No Responses

  1. knowTheEnemy says:

    Ali Sina is showing pic of MT as an example of someone who spent her life helping the poor and downtrodden. Do you have a better example? Whose picture will satisfy you?

    ["… but for the poor she gave only the advice to pray."]

    Well we don't know if that is true or not, but are YOU a better example than MT? Is there anyone in your group who has dedicated his/her life to making other people's lives better?? Can you name them, and tell us what s/he is doing?

  2. @lldhr says:

    You are showing the pic of MT the Mother Teressa? She was the most selfish lady, enjoyed the riches and Hindus healthe care but for the poor she gave only the advice to pray.

  3. greatthinker says:

    jesus is not god,,you christian worship allah….

  4. cchuckc says:

    //I thought we shall not see your trolls again. //
    Wishful thinking 🙂

  5. ihateislam says:

    I thought we shall not see your trolls again. But, as they say, old habits die hard. Since there is nothing new in what has now become your habitual rants, the best thing is just to ignore you. It is not worth wasting one second giving you some recognition by replying to your endless repetitions.

  6. Slave of Prophet says:

    Yes, Brother all the translation of Quran are fake. Quran can not be translated non-Arabic language. All books are fake which claims to have translation of quran. 

  7. narcole1919721 says:

    But wewerent talking about english dajjal translation. You interupted, how rude. mr chuck, knock door first and salam.

  8. chuck says:

    //i didnt give him which verse which ayat so that he couldnt find english dajjal translation//
    True. But that doesn't mean othes won't know it or help another person. Contrary to how you think some people do help others 🙂

  9. narcole1919721 says:

    Why dont you convert to chucks secret religion then mr sakat?

  10. Sakat says:

    Have you attended his marriage ?then tell me how old Ayesha at that time,see you are fighting a loosing battle for an insane person ,i feel pity for you,

  11. Sakat says:

    !!! ROFALMAO!!!, really you are a genius mate.

  12. narcole1919721 says:

    Did you attend his wedding? 

  13. narcole1919721 says:

    Mr chuck, i was talking to mr sakat. queue please. i didnt give him which verse which ayat so that he couldnt find english dajjal translation. i was giving him original arabic.

  14. chuck says:

    //What that answer mean by the way ? //

    She is quoting Q 30:22,
    And among His Signs
    Is the creation of the heavens
    And the earth, and the variations
    In your languages
    And your colours: verily
    In that are Signs
    For those who know.

    Which is bogus.

    How and why should be the variations of languages or colours be a sign on Allah? And what does this 'sign' signify. The verse ends rather cryptically with 'for those who know'. In fact 'those who know' don't need any signs it is required for THOSE WHO DON'T KNOW!!!
    In fact can she explain why this chapter starts with Alif Lam Mim and what does it mean?

    In fact this verse doesn't answer what you are asking. The question is why reveal a book, which is going to be the final version of the 'truth', as you say, in a language that is spoken by only about 3% of world population today. At the time when the Quran was authored it might have been far lesser.

  15. Sakat says:

    What that answer mean by the way ? i am eager to know it ,at the same time entitle for clarification upon its real meaning .

  16. Sakat says:

    Yes he, who could fondle with six year old girl at the age of 52 ,how you describe him ,the modern jurisprudence say he is pedophile a criminal ,you should thanq me ,i have not used that term.

  17. narcole1919721 says:

    Its god's answer in quran to your question

  18. narcole1919721 says:

    Wa min aayaatihii khalqu as samaawaati wa al ardhi wakhtilaafu alsinatikum wa alwaanikum, inna fii zaalika la aayaatin lil 3aalamiin.

  19. Sakat says:

    @ narcole
    Then again crop up a different phenomena ,you have to explain ,what is the language of Allah ,if it is Arabic, then why he established other languages in human ,instead of his own language Arabic.Arabic which only negligible people knew ,and those knowing it well doubt knowing it very well ,then who could deliver it in better way ,you ? , o.k carry on , we are very much hungry for knowledge.

  20. narcole1919721 says:

    You called him a mad man, you never met him nor read his arabic words. How could you say? 

  21. Sakat says:

    I see in your post a rusted IQ ,BETTER GO FOR COUNSELING BABY,you need it urgently.For your kind information ,no intelligent will survive following a mad man and if you claim so (i doubt you are ) ,that is your tragedy ,i am worried ,you have not followed your intuition , i may not be able to place flower at your coffin that would be my misfortune ,i am really sorry for you.

  22. narcole1919721 says:

    Fair enough. And i wont tell which verse which ayat, which riwayat and the numbers. lll just give it in arabic words which you cant find the english dajjal version,  where you only have option to translate the words one by one. how about that? 

  23. Sakat says:

    OK baby forget about Ali Sina's explanations about your Mohammed and his beloved Allah ,if the documents (referred in his articles)he follows to explain his case about Allah and Mohammed are wrong ,you just quote any hadit ,sira, sunna,and Quaran which you feel authentic ,let us kick this Sina and his faith freedom .org from here ,i promise you.

  24. narcole1919721 says:

    Now i see your modus. You only copy paste one or few sentences from paragraphs sent by others. You skipped the truth. You made other accounts, to show as if you have a group. You made alliance as if you're with other religions. You're a paganist. Not abrahamic samawi religion. None of your christian allies denied your hanoman. And you didnt deny jesus. You support ali sina who is now a christian, who loves jesus. You copy pasted ali sinas version of english translations about quran, and mocked about quran, not the translation, cos none of you mastered arabic until the root , you brought references by random writers, who cant master arabic and unable to enter mecca, who never met arab goverment, you mentioned names whom you never met, and talked bad about Allah and prophet, whom you never found what they left, you only have western english translation. And talked bad about whats written in arabic quran you never read, and talked bad about moslems whom you never met, and blame all badness to ALL moslems whom you cant meet ALL. From every message sent, you only searched which sentence or which word you could turn around, and left all goodness behind. This is you. And when someone asked about it, you'll answer, its none of your business. And then you continue with others and interfere. And if being reminded about your badness, ull say thats an exception. Cos in doing this needs a lions heart. You keep talking bad about ALL moslems, and keep making excuse for all your badness and try to skip.

  25. Knowthetruth says:

    Oh Fider,
    U want to set a trap to blow him into pieces with a suicide bomber. Jaki Naik had refused to debate him via emails because he knows all his lies will be exposed.
    One of his lie/claim is that the water cycle was mentioned in the koran where there is not a single verse to say how the water is risen to the sky. Quote me the sura if there is one.

  26. Sanatan Dharma says:

    Ali Sina doctor advised him not to go among Muslims as there is death penalty for apostates in Islam.
    @Debate between Rampal and Zakir Naik
    But there is spiritual guru (Rampal Ji Maharaj) in Haryana state of India in whose program thousand of people come and he has lacs of devotee. Note: he has devotee not the audience like Zakir naik. He openly challenged to Zakir Naik to have live debate with him. Whoever will be proved wrong changed his opinion and religion. You can google to know about him (Rampal and Zakir naik). You can watch his program at 7.30 P.M. daily India time at Sadhana T.V. Chanel. He claimed he sent several invitation to Zakir Naik to have live debate but Zakir Naik never responded to him. He claimed Muhammad worshiped false God that is why Muhammad was much suffered person. He said he would teach Muslim right way of worshiping of true God. He claimed people especially Muslim are suffered because they are worshiping false God (Allah). Worshiping Allah will lead them in eternal helfile. Many Muslim went in shelter and shared their experiences as broadcasted on Sadhana T.V. Chanel.

  27. Fider says:

    First, you have to answer this question:

    "I wonder why Ali Sina is too afraid to debate with Islamic scholars in a live TV show. in front of the public?
    Ali Sina why are you so coward?"

  28. I-HATE-IALSM says:

    Factual and brilliant.

  29. shabeer says:

    "It is not fitting for a Believer, man or woman, when a matter has been decided by God and His Apostle to have any option about their decision: if any one disobeys God and His Apostle, he is indeed on a clearly wrong Path. (The Noble Quran, 33:36)"

    "The Day that their faces will be turned upside down in the Fire, they will say: "Woe to us! Would that we had obeyed God and obeyed the Apostle!" (The Noble Quran, 33:66)"

    "It is He Who has sent amongst the Unlettered an apostle from among themselves, to rehearse to them His Signs, to sanctify them, and to instruct them in Scripture and Wisdom,- although they had been, before, in manifest error;- (The Noble Quran, 62:2)"

    "So obey God, and obey His Apostle: but if ye turn back, the duty of Our Apostle is but to proclaim (the Message) clearly and openly. (The Noble Quran, 64:12)"

    Since the punishment for rape doesn't exist in the Noble Quran, but exists in the Sayings of our beloved Prophet peace be upon him, then the verdict or law for punishing the rapist according to Noble Verses 4:59 and 4:83 above must come from our beloved Prophet's Sayings.

    Let us look at what Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him said regarding this issue:

    The following information was sent to me. Let us look at how Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him dealt with the rapists:

    Narrated Wa'il ibn Hujr:


    She said: Yes, this is he. Then they brought him to the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him). When he (the Prophet) was about to pass sentence, the man who (actually) had assaulted her stood up and said: Apostle of Allah, I am the man who did it to her.

    He (the Prophet) said to the woman: Go away, for Allah has forgiven you. And about the man who had intercourse with her, he said: Stone him to death.

    He also said: He has repented to such an extent that if the people of Medina had repented similarly, it would have been accepted from them. (Sunan Abu Dawud, Book 38, Number 4366)"

    Saudi Arabia today applies the death penalty for the punishment of rape and other cases as well. The following quote was taken from an article from CNN.COM regarding the punishment of a rapist. He was punished to death:

    "Saudi Arabia, the world's largest oil producer and Washington's closest Arab ally for more than a half century, follows a strict interpretation of Islam that calls for the death penalty for murder, rape, drug trafficking and armed robbery. ("

    Here is an article that I copied and pasted from CNN.COM:


    "Two executed in Saudi Arabia for rape, drug trafficking

    August 24, 2001 Posted: 11:48 AM EDT (1548 GMT)

    RIYADH, Saudi Arabia (AP) — Saudi Arabia on Friday beheaded a Saudi man for raping boys and an Indian for drug trafficking, the Interior Ministry said.

    In the capital Riyadh, Saudi citizen Dowaihi bin Mohammed al-Qahtani was executed after he was convicted of armed robbery and kidnapping and raping boys, the ministry said in a statement carried by the official Saudi Press Agency.

    Seyed bin Mahboub Amir, from India, was executed in Riyadh for smuggling an unspecified quantity of heroin into the kingdom, according to the statement.

    Friday's executions bring to at least 74 the number of people beheaded this year in the kingdom, where executions are carried out in public with a sword. Last year, 125 people were beheaded.

    Saudi Arabia follows a strict interpretation of Islam that demands the death penalty for murder, rape, drug trafficking and armed robbery."

    Very Important Note: In Islam, determining the case as a rape case is important and would mean the difference between life and death to the man. There is a difference between a rapist who is caught raping innocent children as shown in the article above, or someone who forcibly raped a woman beyond her will after stalking her, and someone went with his girlfriend on his boat (by her own will) to the middle of the sea, and spent the night there together, and she came back claiming that he raped her.

  30. Knowthetruth says:

    "Now I can see in most places in the world, people start to love Islam as Ali Sina is busy spreading hatred about Islam." / Now tell me why the muslims have so much hate that they have been endless killing between different sects since the 7th century when Mo had died of poisoning.

  31. Fider says:


    to Ali Sina, why are you so coward?

  32. Nizamuddin Sheikh says:

    Dear shabeer,



    But each and everyone say that this book is god gifted, and god know everything about us so it would be in that book not only for Arabs. so you tell publically this book is written or collection of Muhammad's teaching. Because as per the Quran Mazeed god know everything if your quotes above are wrong of the Quran Mazeed is wrong.
    Rg Veda 6:LXXII:1. GREAT is this might of yours, Indra and Soma: the first high exploits were your own achievements.Ye found the Sun ye found the light of heaven: ye killed all darkness and the Gods’ blasphemers.

    Ath.Veda 12:5:60 O Cow, break thou the head of him who wrongs the Brāhmans,criminal, niggard, blasphemer of the Gods.

    Ath. Veda 5:18:8 His voice an arrow's neck, his tongue a bowstring, his windpipes fire-enveloped heads of arrows,With these the Brāhman pierces through blasphemers, with God-sped bows that quell the hearts within them.

    Ath Veda 4:30:5 I bend the bow for Rudra that his arrow maystrike and slay the hater of devotion.I rouse and order battle for the people,
    "For Brahman (Priesthood) he binds a Brahmana to the stake; for Kshatriya (Royalty) a Râjanya; for rearing cattle a Vaishya; for Penance a Shudra;" [Yajurveda 30/5]
    "For maintaining small tanks, God creates the son of a Nishada." [Yajurveda 30/16] A 'Nishada' is the son of a Brahmin man and a Shudra woman. Refer to Manu Smriti Chapter 10, verse 8.

    "Whatever infants die, untimely born, Whatever herds of cattle waste away, Whatever heroes strike each other dead, the Brahmin's wife destroys them." [Atharvaveda 5/17/7]

    And you are giving the proof from Vedas I'm not Hindu and Sanatani that you Justify to me helping the vedas and others Holy book of Hindus. I was muslim and I've only right to say about Islam because taboos are in my won religion and I blame to other one that your religion is wrong this will be baseless argue. Islam means Peace so be Peacefuller not be a killer and told about Non-believers. and Muslim means obedient but we are not obedient. At the night of Shab-e-barat approximately 5000 muslims boy play with law of India. That was the night of forgiveness , remember the Allah Pak, but they are riding motorcycle at dilsahd Garden and abusing the people if really that was the night of forgiveness and remembering the god and forefather that night Allah must punished them but nothing will happen. Maulvis are only offering namaz but doing the business of drugs, allah pak why not killing them. and again as per your statement above Muhammad know only Arab but god know whole world and Quran is the god gifted so all religion should be in mentioned them. be peaceful and live like heaven I again said to you there neither hell fire and nor heaven anywhere all these things are here with us, try to know the truth, resist evil, free your mind from evil , work for the good of others and respect life, not try to make suicide bomber.
    And last things lets suppose Allah never told about vedic religion they are not the follow of the path of god, but why not mentioned about Jainism and Buddhism.

  33. aminthemystic says:

    Sina's hatred and make belief knows no bounds . . .


    "Eighty percent of human personality is formed during the first 8 years of his or her life."

    "When children are beaten, abused and ignored as it is the norm in all Islamic countries"


    "The ideal number of children in a family is two or three. Four is too many."

    Says who?



    Actually – on balance – Muslims are the most peaceful people on earth . . .

    See such hatred. . . . of Muslims . . . and this person is sane? This is why everyone has dropped him other than likes of Spencer and Geller . . .

    – – –


    Sina doesn't need evidence . . . he comes out with such garbage – in the past he has NEVER been able to defend a single comment.

    In the past he has simply resorted to making up personal lies against anything in his past . . . I have exposed such lies in the past . . .

    Somehow I think the circle will continue. . .

    The work is ongoing. . .

  34. Momo says:

    I can't remember when in my life I was asked to kill or to hate. Never,.. I was never asked to do that. All I learned from Islam is that, to believe in only one God, and to do the right things. To love each other, to help each other and to live peacefully in this world. Also not to transgress.

    PLEASE believe me, we are not causing violence. We are not killing each other.

    Please, believe me, please believe me,.. I am not telling the lie.

  35. Momo says:


    Sunni and Shi'ite or whatever, are not basing themselves on the true Islamic teaching. We are the true muslim never want violence. We love peace even more than you. We are not even allowed to kill small animals like ants, let alone killing humans.

    It's all your misconception of Islamic teaching. Please, would you please not hate Islam. We don't hate anyone, so don't hate us.

  36. Hell/heavenonearth says:

    How can you bear witness when you cannot see god? So you are deluding yourself as others had blindly led you into believing this mirage. Keep it up and you got stuck in this 7th century superstition forever.
    This superstition had caused the muslims killing n bombing each others all over the ME and in Pakistan in the Sunni vs Shi'ite and other sectarian violence. If you are happy with that just go ahead. Don't pull other non-believers along into this killing field.

  37. Momo says:

    Ali Sina,

    Don't worry too much, Allah will forgive you. You said to me through email that you are feeling guilty for insulting Islam and you regret it. And you don't know how to repent.

    Just believe me that God is all forgiving. He will forgive you.

  38. Momo says:

    No, thanks. We don't eat porks. We eat only healthy food

  39. Momo says:

    Ali Sina,
    Ali Sina,



  40. chuck says:

    Here's something for you, for your kindness: the one with pork meat is considered particularly delicious.

  41. Momo says:

    Ali Sina,

    Repeat after me, "I bear witness, there is no God but Allah", and "Muhammad is the massenger of Allah".

    Then I am sure Allah will forgive all your sins.

  42. dr doom says:

    if ur zkir naik was rightwhy did not he come to debate with mr sina he is a fraud stop beleving him nd ur mohammad

  43. dr doom says:

    let me tell u 1 interesting story . in january 2 2012 at night it was about 11:30 i was watching tv suddenly my channel changed there was mohammad on tv he came out and gave me a book called quaran he told me to read this shit. i asked him there are so many muslims that worship u day and night and dance allah allah and im non muslim why u came to my house he said to me my dear i was sent by allah he told me that he was a fraud . there is no allah i just wanted to make time pass with this people he told me he met a angel she was so pretty that he farted loudly. she died because of its smell. he told me there is no allah only stupid people here

  44. dr doom says:

    the dogs like zakir naik only barks with half knowledge

  45. dr doom says:

    your religion makes u a terrorists i can give u list of pakistani terrorists

  46. dr doom says:

    mohammad married his own daughter what kind of god he is

  47. shabeer says:

    #create honor by them killing themselves………………………………..

    Malik :: Book 21 : Hadith 21.3.10
    Do not mutilate and do not kill children.
    Malik :: Book 21 : Hadith 21.3.11
    Prophet never take injustice even it against Jew
    suicide prohibited:
    Bukhari :: Book 8 :: Volume 77 :: Hadith 603 , 604
    Death punishment for killers: Qisas (i.e. equality in punishment)
    Bukhari :: Book 6 :: Volume 60 :: Hadith 25
    Killing children Prohibited
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 92 :: Hadith 395
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 83 :: Hadith 1
    Bukhari :: Book 8 :: Volume 82 :: Hadith 802
    Bukhari :: Book 8 :: Volume 76 :: Hadith 480
    Making quarrel/fight between people prohibited:
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 89 :: Hadith 298
    Fighting each other prohibited: money punishment
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 83 :: Hadith 30
    Fighting for physical earning prohibited:
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 88 :: Hadith 228
    Provacation people to sin is prohibited:
    Dawud :: Book 12 : Hadith 2170
    children captive killing prohibited:
    Dawud :: Book 38 : Hadith 4390
    mischief through the land prohibited:
    Dawud :: Book 38 : Hadith 4357 ,59
    Taking self action prohibited:
    Bukhari :: Book 8 :: Volume 82 :: Hadith 829
    Revenge is prohibited:
    Bukhari :: Book 8 :: Volume 82 :: Hadith 836
    Help oppressed people & stop oppression
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 85 :: Hadith 84
    Killing innocent people prohibited:
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 93 :: Hadith 611,23
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 83 :: Hadith 12
    Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 83 :: Hadith 10 , 21

  48. shabeer says:

    # (Ibn Ishaq/Hisham 959) ………………..NOT VALID PROOF…………………..



  49. Agracean says:

    Mr Sanatan Dharma, you must acknowledged the fact that 5000 years ago, human's genes are far more purer and healthier. It is possible for a man to marry his close relative then. But human's genes deteriorated as time flies and that's the reason why incest is disallowed.

  50. shabeer says:

    # It is insult of woman……………..

    As for India, it may be seen that there existed the tradition of
    taking more than one women as wives right from the time of the Rig
    Veda. It is further given to understand that Indra, the most important
    god in the Rig Veda, himself had more than one wife. There is a verse
    (or Sukta) attribute to Indrani, the most important of all in the wives
    of Indra (Rig Veda, Mandal 10, Sukta 17).

    It is well known that Dasharat, the father of Shri Ram who is the hero of the
    Ramayan, had the wives Kausalya, Kaikeyi and Sumithra. As for Shri
    Krishna, the hero of the Mahabharath, the Puranas report that he had
    as many as sixteen thousand and eight wives. These wives of Shri
    Krishna included eight in Rukmini, Jambavathi, Sathyabama, Kalindi,
    Mithravandha, Saraswathy Kaikeyi and Laxmana along with the ten
    thousand daughters of Narakasura.
    the time age of the Smrithi had commenced, the tradition of
    polygamy also became based on the caste system. The law of the
    Yajnavalkya Smrithi decreed that the Brahiman was to have three
    wives the Kshatriya two and the vaishya and the Shudra were to have
    one each.
    Thissovarname poorvyana two thathika yathakramam
    Brahman Kshathriya visham barya swa shudrajanmana
    (Yajnavalkyasmrithi 1:57)
    “In accordance with the caste order the Brahman may three
    wives, the Kshatriya two and the vaishya one. The shudra can marry
    only from his own caste”.
    Even in modern societies in which fidelity to one wife is claimed
    it is a fact the practice of having sexual relations with more than one
    woman is quite common. The only difference being that it has been
    referred to by different pet names. While the rich man fulfills his sexual
    desire in the call girl engaged in ‘Public’ relations, the ordinary man
    seeks gratification at the brothels. Studies have shown that those who
    have not approached the prostitute, called by different names, even
    once are very few indeed. Modern society can hardly seen it as a
    crime. In addition to this, statistics reveal that sexual perversions a like
    wife swapping and group sex are on the increase among the elite in
    society. In reality, many of those who strongly speak out against
    polygamy are themselves slave to such sexual misconducts..



  51. Sanatan Dharma says:

    Please don’t spread misinformation by the story of aadam and eve that we are all products of incest.The Adam and Eve theory is myth.
    silly mythology of creation which you believe in , don’t these questions arise in your mind?
    ➔We are not products of incest between the siblings of adam and eve.

  52. Agracean says:

    Mr Sanatan Dharma, like what I've mentioned in my earlier comment, please be rational and know that you emit spermatozoa and have the capability to make babies. Stop believing all those fiction stories that tell you that you emerged from apes or nowhere.

  53. Agracean says:

    Mr Sanatan Dharma, you can come up with many man made stories or religion about how human beings ended up on this once beautiful earth, blah blah blah…But please use your brain to think for a while and ask yourself where did you come out from? Please don't tell me that you just evolved or emerged from nowhere. It's high time for you to wake up from your wet dream and realize that you have emit some spermatozoa that's able to create a baby.

  54. Agracean says:

    Mr Sanatan Dharma, what incest are your talking about here?

  55. Demsci says:

    Hi, Hell/ Heavenonearth, Sunsetsinmuddywaters,

    I think you are right. But Shabeer, and many other Muslims and Political Correct people keep saying these things ad nauseam.

    Perhaps we should keep reminding them of their own scriptures and also of the violent, totalitarian Moslims who use the same quran-hadith-sira as Shabeer, the moderate Muslims but disagree on many issues with them.

    Then we should say to Shabeer, moderate Muslims; please acknowledge that you do not (have authority to) speak for all Muslims about Islam as a whole.

    Please acknowledge that on important issues there exist different interpretations inside Islam, among high-placed clerics, that conflict with your interpretations of the same issues.

    These different interpretations INSIDE Islam also are remarkably like the conclusions of anti-jihadists like Ali Sina, Robert Spencer, David Wood etc.

    Because maybe Shabeer does not lie, but genuinely believes in HIS VERSION OF ISLAM. But his BIG LIE is in denying that there are on many issues different interpretations of Islam. at least equally valid and supported as his interpretation.

    He ignores and deies even when the evidence is presented to him like a neverending avalanche towards him by us.

    Each time Shabeer informs us anti-jihadists about his version of Islam on issues, he should send a copy of it to those agressive, violent, totalitarian Muslim clerics, that disagree with him and agree with us on issues (but not on how to judge them).

  56. Sanatan Dharma says:

    Adam-Eve theory is a good story for entertainment of children. That has no rational basis except showing fear of Hell and lure of Heaven.As per Vedic belief, right from initiation of creation of the universe up to inception of humans, changes happened gradually as per definite laws of God. Scientists have discovered many of these aspects recently. And when creation was over, humans emerged not as a couple, but in multiple.The first humans are supposed to have emerged as youths and neither children nor old ones. No intermediate species between humans and next-intelligent species are found in any form. So evolution of humans from apes or ape-likes is ruled out. Even the current theories of ‘apes are our ancestors’ are too vague and inconclusive, and full of big unexplainable gaps.The alternative model is that multiple humans emerged from earth, with different genetic makeup, without sexual reproduction. Modern science also does not rule out possibility of this happening. These young humans had basic knowledge of survival just as animals have. And then 4 among them got the knowledge and trained others.
    Because they had different genetic makeup, they could then devise rules of inter-marrying through something similar to Gotra/clan/progeny system which is prevalent even till today. This ensures that marriage between close relatives do not happen and hence prevent genetic disorders. VEDAS have specific mantras to prohibit such marriages.

  57. Hell/heavenonearth says:

    This sabeer will keep telling lies, lies and endless taqqiya.

  58. Sanatan Dharma says:

    Indian society does not approve to keep multiple wives unlike Islam. It is insult of woman. Islam is abuse on the world. Muhammad was mad after sex. Even Veda advise to follow monogamy.
    Rigveda 10.149.4 compares love between God and devotee like that between dedicated wife and husband. Both “Jaaya” meaning wife and “Patim” meaning husband are used in singular number implying strict monogamy.
    In Atharva Veda 7.35.4 both husband and wife state that, “You establish me in your heart so that our minds become one and same.”

  59. Hell/heavenonearth says:

    Full agreed with u.

  60. Sujeesh says:

    It is not Ali Sina who is spreading hatred towards muslims. It is Islam which is differentiating the world into two blocks Believers and non-believers and spreading hatred towards non-muslims .Read the following verses from Koran…………

    Quran (48:29) – "Muhammad is the messenger of Allah. And those with him are hard (ruthless) against the disbelievers and merciful among themselves"

    Islam is not about treating everyone equally.Infact the very first verse in Koran is a hate speech. It says show us the right path ,not the path chosen by christians ,who are misguided and not the path chosen by Jews who are wrong doers, Every muslim who reads this very first verse of Koran is insulting a Christian by saying Christians are misguided people and Jews are wrong-doers.

  61. Sujeesh says:

    It is not about the money , only if someone offers money will his challenge get any attention .For years Sam shamoun and David Wood have asked Zakir naik for an open debate. But Zakir knows he cant win the arguments of Sam and David, thats why he doesnt dare to take up any challenge. Even I had countless arguments with muslims (both face to face and facebook) at some point they get violent and try to stop me or give lame excuses like ,In koran we are told to do what is written and not think (Even if they are against logic,ethics and humanity)

  62. sunsetsinmuddywater says:

    There is no forcible conversion in Islam, do you really think so???


  63. sunsetsinmuddywater says:

    Can't say,,,,, even the the buyer could be a Muslim, he didn't mention anything to which community should they sell.

  64. Sanatan Dharma says:

    //do you know that you also have a sinful nature because we are the descendants of Adam and Eve//

    Who was the ignorant person told you this hell that you are the product of incest?

  65. vijay says:

    Astaghfurallah, how can Momo say that Allah,Muhammad and Muslims. are slave of any mortal ?

  66. vijay says:

    If he was Arya Samaji, then would not have been praising Lord Jesus or Swami Vivekananda as both are not liked by Arya Samajis. Difference between you and me is that you put your forehead first on ground during Salat while i put my nose. The black satanic mark brings darkness in brain.

  67. Demsci says:

    What are your qualifications? What are you going to argue, which has not been argued hundreds of times by Muslims in debate with Ali Sina?

    I wonder if you even checked the section debates of Faith Freedom International website (you can find it on it's homepage). Or if you ever read answering Islam/ answering Muslims/ Jihad Watch/ Islam Watch? If not, you risk only repeating old refuted arguments of Muslims.

    And Ali Sina knows this and doesn't waste his time with Muslims who do not know Islam better than him and who have no authority but who speak as if they speak for the whole of Islam, but very often are contradicted and disavowed by other Muslims.

    For example: Robert Spencer debated an Egyptian Islam-apologist last year, on Aramaic Broadcasting Network and beat him soundly. A few days later an Islamic columnist, I believe on TAM, lamented that Islam was too much being represented by weak debaters who made it easy for the likes of Robert Spencer (and by extension Ali Sina) to beat them and hence make Islam look bad. So the Islamic columnist suggested that weak Islamic debaters NOT engage anymore in debate with the likes of Robert Spencer.

    So consider your responsibility to your fellow Muslims before you engage in debate with "counterjihadists". And anyway you can practice debating Islam with us commenters here as much as you like.

  68. Demsci says:


    excellent reply as usual and I agree wholeheartedly, but bear with me, because I want to get deeper into this what you wrote:

    "Muhammad said that anyone who does not love him (Muhammad) more than his family does not qualify to be a muhammadan."

    If Muhammad really said that while he also said something like:

    "When someone changes his religion, then kill him" he contradicts himself.

    Because on the one hand he wants everybody born as a Muslim to stay a Muslim until death but on the other hand, according to you he sets up conditions for the right to be called "Muslim"???

    I suggest that Muhammad perhaps said something along the lines that anyone who does not love him (Muhammad) more than his family does not qualify for …. HEAVEN! Jannah.

    Because I wonder if Muslims are taught that as long as they remain inside Islam they will be guaranteed HEAVEN after life, or if they are taught that they must fulfill certain conditions to be allowed into HEAVEN after death.

    And Shabeer already has written (copy-pasted) that Muslims are motivated to do good behavior by their desire for the reward of heaven after death. This of course means that Muslims cannot just be content with being (called) Muslims and doing nothing to deserve heaven.

  69. I-HATE-ISLAM says:

    You wonder how your muslim girlfriend and your other muslim friends have to do with 9/11 and 26/11. In two ways : they make the compulsory zakat payment which is said to be for charity but actually go to sponsor terrorism. Then their reaction to the two attacks will tell you the state of their mind. Did/do they support, oppose or are indifferent? This is the barometer to gauge them.

  70. I-HATE-ISLAM says:

    Slave mentality,
    Dr Sina does not owe you or anybody else the obligation to prove his nationality of birth. He is doing a marvelous humanitarian service regardless of his nationality. That is what is important.

  71. I-HATE-ISLAM says:

    If you want to know the meaning of hate, read the quran. It is the manual of hate.
    If you want to know how to practice hate, read the hadiths and sira of Muhammad. He exemplified hate.
    You are perhaps a Hindu. Ask your friends what the quran means by saying that the 'unbeliever' is the vilest thing before allah. They may smile at you while actually laughing at you because to them you are no more than an object of vile and hate because you are still to them an 'unbeliever'.
    You are advised to understand what you are getting into because you may wake up one day to be told that your parents and siblings are your worst enemies.Muhammad said that anyone who does not love him (Muhammad) more than his family does not qualify to be a muhammadan.

  72. Sakat says:

    @sanjay jogdand
    You have done perfect psycho-analyses of this 29 year old boy.These morons are Taquiyya masters.He knew there is no prospect in Pakistan for his existence and also he cannot claim refugee status for seeking asylum in the west .So he thought this kind of tricks will dump him in the west.Of course he was able to extract the sympathy of that noble white lady,however Dr.Sina was born and raised as Muslim and he know these morons from in side out .If you minutely follow the advice extended by Mr.Sina to this gentleman, you will come to know, how brilliant spy this Mr. Sina is,no one can escape from his hawk eye.

  73. I-HATE-ISLAM says:

    You have chosen not to read the following suras; 2:191, 8:65, 9:5 &29, 47:4 which give clear instructions for the killing of those who do not believe in Muhammad's asininity.
    Bukhari 4:52:288 was Muhammad's order for the expulsion of Jews and Christians from Arabia because of their refusal to subscribe to Muhammad's deceit.
    What offense did the Jews commit which warranted allah giving permission for their expulsion?
    An apostate is condemned to death for abandoning his/her 'deen'. Does that make freedom of worship possible?
    How many times is it to be drilled into your thick skull that the so-called freedom of religion verse has been abrogated by several later ayahs of violence as attested to by muhammadan scholars?

  74. sanjay jogdand says:

    dear ali sina,
    this litttttle boy wants a free ride!
    he doesn't want to change himself but thinks that some body can change his life!
    may be he is lured by the name miss pamela geller!!!
    he thinks she will give him a lift and take him out of stinking PAKISTAN!!
    and then he can settle there and start his non sense activities once again!
    abra kadabra!

  75. Phoenix says:


    You don't know what hatred mean.Is Ali Sina blowing up mosques with muslims in them?No,these are your fellow believers.Every single day,muslims are blowing up and killing and wounding hundreds of fellow muslims in Afghanistan,Iraq,Pakistan,Syria and recently west african muslims have joined in on the madness.
    So why don't you save your stupid comments for your fellow mass murdering psychotic brethren.

  76. Demsci says:

    READ! He said NO! in response to your words ……. ALI SINA IS THE REAL SATAN! and there you go: "So Satan, your are Ali Sina?

    If you did not understand even this, how much can we trust that you understood or at least TRIED to understand what Ali Sina says? Can you give a short explanation of what it is that Ali Sina says, means, wants?

    Or are you only here to contradict and defend your beloved Islam and Mohammed? Will you admit that you allow no criticism whatsoever on Islam and Mohammed or will you admit that at least some things Ali Sina says are right and some things he says are even in agreement with what leading fellow Muslims say?

  77. Agracean says:

    Hi Mr Vijay, today, you will find that the world is full of lost sheeps like you, heading who knows where. If every human being is able to find the ultimate Way, the ultimate Truth and the ultimate Life, then, my dear Lord Jesus would not lamented that we are like sheep going astray and without a shepherd. I don't know about the dead man you've mentioned above but one thing I do know is that human beings are stupid and there is no limit to human stupidity.

  78. Demsci says:

    Shabeer wrote:
    " Not only has the Qur'an not demanded
    the forcible conversion of others, it has also declared that the practice
    of forcible conversion is, in itself, an abomination. “Let there be no
    compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from error.” (H.Q.

    But Egyptian Cleric Sirsawi was on MEMRI TV and he said that "In Islam apostates must be killed"

    And when a grown person decides for him/ herself that (s)he wants to change religion/ lifestyle and the rule in Islam indeed is that

    change from Islam into something else is considered apostasy and punishable by death,

    that makes HOLY Quran 2; 256 null and void, a mockery.

    But deathpenalty for apostasy IS what Sirsawi advocates in the name of Islam. And probably because he, just like Ali Sina and us, considers Quran 2:256 abrogated.

    This seems an interesting case of Ali Sina and Cleric Sirsawi in agreement against Shabeer! So why is Shabeer, presumably, only telling Ali Sina and his allies that they are mistaken, but not Cleric Sirtawi and his allies and followers??? Or why at least, does Shabeer not admit, that there are (many) Muslims who have, on important issues, a DIFFERENT interpretation and practice of Islam.

    And … does young, enthousiastic Momo notice this difference in opinion among Muslims? Some of them saying the exact same thing as Ali Sina, about teaching of Islam?

    Here are the the links to Sirsawi:

  79. Agracean says:

    Awesome comment from Mr Demsci! Since you like my sense of humour so much, next time, I'll use this platform to demonstrate how to circumcise a banana, to educate all those ignorant Hindus out there who want to marry any muslimah, of the fate of their phallus. xD

  80. I-HATE-ISLAM says:

    According to the despicable muhammadan cleric, what is haram to the community of the animal sexist is halal to another community. Truly, muhammadanism is only for the insane.

  81. Agracean says:

    Awesome comment from Mr Aryan Hindu! 😀

  82. Demsci says:


    Great answers from Agracean and Sanatan Dharma, who here are very much on the same page!!! Great! I liked the humor of the "banana-circumcision" very much.

    As Agracean says; Ali Sina has no hate but big love for Muslims, it is Islam that he hates. His attitude is about "hate the sin, love the sinner". You can love a person but hate it when (s)he steals, or helps a criminal leader, like Mohammed is viewed by us.

    You ask how your Muslima is responsible for the crimes of other Muslims. She isn't. But see, an animal is not responsible for anything , but she is much more, a human. A human is not responsible for the color of her skin or her genes. But is she Muslim and are you Hindu purely and only because of where you were born and how you were raised?

    No! Muslim and Hindus are NOT races, to be Muslim or Hindu or in or out of a religion/ lifestyle is a matter of CHOICE. She is responsible for that choice. And if she is ignorant about what her religion of choice teaches these other violent Muslims, that is her choice as well.

    Ali Sina does NOT label all Muslims as violent, warmongers. He considers Islam as a very bad violent, warmongering ideology, that in varying degrees influences Muslims in a bad way. You twist something Ali Sina says here and you commit "strawman fallacy" with that, a fault in logical thinking.

    You seem to think that the influence of Islam on Muslims is no more than the influence that the color of one's skin, eyes or hair has on one. But Islam has NOT NO INFLUENCE, and it's influence is NOT beneficial BUT detrimental for many Non-Muslims, as is amply shown here.

    But of course, the impact of Islam on Muslims varies according to how much Muslims themselves know and practice Islam. So your girlfriend and your friends, they may be Muslims In Name Only and less influenced by Islam and also more influenced by values that they THINK originate from Islam, but which really originate from Hindu and Western values. Think about it.

  83. sunsetsinmuddywater says:

    @ Shabbeer
    How do you manage to live in a Fool's ( Islam's) World. I accept the fact that you are really a Braindead Muslim. Thanks to Ali Sina who exposed the religion and I researched about that and I found out that he was really telling the truth or I would have been under illusion that it was really a religion of peace.

  84. sunsetsinmuddywater says:

    One of the acceptable things in Islam …..
    Ayatollah Khomeini's Book

  85. vijay says:

    Dear Sister Gracey, today is not the world of sheep where one has to follow others. One has to make the own way. There is person called Satyanand Stokes, he was a Christian missionary, who became Hindu after coming to India. I can give here testimonial of good lot of Christians who have become Sikhs. Does is matters to Lord Jesus, if one has faith or not ? Truth could be understood only when a person is in Holy Ghost. Rest all is gimmickry.

  86. vijay says:

    As per the same logic Dr Naik can not be an authority on Holy Bible or Holy Vedas.And so with the case of all Muslims like you or your shabbo darling who keeps on copy pasting the things. This makes Ahdatih also defunct and spleen and kidney haram for you as it has blood.

  87. NoBody says:

    Shabeer does a great job of using the Islam texts to further taqqiyah. It's obvious she does not understand the underlining meaning of those texts. Or more likely, simply being deceptive. Any rational person using their brain, would see right through the Islamic words. Their fruits they bare are all around us. These poor Islamists are used by the corrupt mullahs as fodder for their power thirst. They are so corrupt that they create honor by them killing themselves. I'd like to see blood thirsty hater mullahs strap bombs to themselves and practice what they preach. Like that would happen. The trith is that their are NO religions today that will survive in the future. Most are encrusted with old pagan jungle and tribal fears and hatreds to be of much use in the future. The combining of religion and science will bring forth unity. Only when we practice the true living through giving will we be in unity. If taking only Jesus words and living by them, would be an improvement on the world. How can anybody follow a madman like muhammad who was a killer and pedophile?? Only disease comes from a diseased mind.

  88. Momo says:

    hi, SATAN, so you are Ali Sina?

    good, did you read my comment?

  89. chuck says:

    The link is getting jumbled up. Try searching 'nida' here:

  90. chuck says:

    here's the link again for nid from Monier's lexicon:

  91. chuck says:

    You again touched one of my favourite Hindu sacred text, Rigved, and again proved what an avid copy-paster you are.

    //Rg Veda 6:LXXII:1//
    Here is the original sanskrit, tell me which word exactly means God's blasphemer?
    इन्द्रासोमा महि तद वां महित्वं युवं महानि परथमानि चक्रथुः |
    युवं सूर्यं विविदथुर्युवं सवर्विश्वा तमांस्यहतं निदश्च ||

    indrāsomā mahi tad vāṃ mahitvaṃ yuvaṃ mahāni prathamāni cakrathuḥ |
    yuvaṃ sūryaṃ vividathuryuvaṃ svarviśvā tamāṃsyahataṃ nidaśca ||

    The exact word used in sanskrit is 'nid' and it doesn't mean God's blasphemer.
    In the above link check the very first word. It means here poison or venom. A wrong translation, repeatedly endlessly will always produce wrong results. You are using Griffith's translation here.
    Secondly RV Mandal 6, Sukt 72 has no reference to any human in any of the first 4 verses and the last verse asks for bounties for all human. Verse 1, that you produced refers to Sun, moon, darkness etc, verse 2 talks about heaven and earth, light and Sun, verse 3 talks about Vrtra, rivers, seas etc, and so on. So referring to God's blasphemer in a part of verse 1 is completely out of context. Translators should always bear the context in mind something many Western and Indian alike fail to see.

    //Rig Veda 7:93:5//
    You are again using Griffith's translation. But here I see no issue at all even with this translation. It simply is asking that when two opposing forces fight. the one with the desire of God shall prevail. That is the righteous shall be the winner. This is a recurring theme in Hinduism and indeed punya should win over paap. The translation for 'adev' is a little misplaced here. 'adev' isn't godless, that will be devheen perhaps, 'adev' is 'Not Godly' that is a force against godly virtues.

    Actually the exact meaning considering the context of the whole Sukta, it is a mantra during hom yagna actually devoted to Indra and Agni (actually Indra AS Agni in the yagna) will be different, but for you even the literal translation is enough.

    I can go through the other texts too, but then you know, I don't always fall in these diversionary ploys.

  92. Momo says:


    He is an obvious coward. I'm so sorry that I have to be honest so that everyone might awake.

  93. Nilesh says:

    Mr Shabir before propagating Islam as peacefull,kindly go through the history of Islam in India written by muslim historians itself.Just for a referance visit 'dikgaj'sweblog on just copy paste english translations of sacred vaidik texts as they need an intellectual approach to know the essence of it,which a hatred full mind could not have!

  94. Sakat says:

    I am little worried about your future prospects
    /Any jurisprudence that does not relate good and evil to the
    life of Prophet is bound to fail./
    These are foul things from your part, suits only to you and kinds like you hahaha.
    God has decided long back ,if he is in existence : sex is needed for continuation of of his creation( of his species) and of course in his kingdom only two religions exist and they are 1"Male" species (the term "religion" for your accommodation here)and 2. Female species .If any other being (Allah) toss the term "Marriage" or extra marital relation he is not the one we aspire for all of our life.
    However i salute the homo's and lesbian's for challenging ,the very age old above rule of real almighty and they are the real hero's ,who are challenging the very rule of their creator,hats up to them.Let us wait how the real almighty respond to their revolution. Till than keep aside your Allah and Mad Mohammed form intelligent people here..

  95. shabeer says:



    Matthew 15:1-9
    Romans 1:20-32 (from the New Testament) "20. For since the creation of the world God's invisible qualities–his eternal power and divine nature–have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse.
    22. Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools

    Also psychics must be put to death. Let us look at Leviticus 20:27 "And as for a man or woman in whom there proves to be a mediumistic spirit or spirit of prediction, they should be put to death without fail. They should pelt them to death with stones. Their own blood is upon them."
    Exodus 21:15
    15 Anyone who attacks his father or his mother must be put to death.

    Exodus 21:16

    Exodus 21:17
    17 Anyone who curses his father or mother must be put to death.

    Exodus 22:19
    19 Anyone who has sexual relations with an animal must be put to death.

    Exodus 31:14

    Exodus 31:15

    Leviticus 20:12

    Leviticus 20:13

    And on and on and on of "must be put to death" Laws in the Mosaic Law. Here is how Paul, the charlatan, judged these Laws:

  96. shabeer says:



  97. Sam Sudhi says:

    Hey ! Slave of Pedo last time you claimed he was deployed by Isreal Jews . You really have a lizards
    brain . Okay for now he is a Canadian please note it down or other wise you memory will be run out.

  98. shabeer says:

    There is not a single verse in the Qur'an which recommends
    the forcible conversion of non-Muslims. In fact, the Qur'an does not
    agree with the idea of forcible conversions.
    Islam means submission or peace. It can be said that Islam
    signifies the peace attained by the one who submits the whole of his
    life to the Almighty. Indeed, the Muslim is the one who has surrendered
    his own self to God. To say that one is a Muslim is to so conform one’s
    life along the path of divine guidance. This conformance must first
    germinate in one’s mind. It is the position of the Qur'an that unless
    there is a substantial change in thinking there can be no other change,
    whatsoever, of a fundamental nature. Therefore it does not agree with
    forcing anyone into the religion. In fact, the Prophet, who had struggled
    greatly to convince his own society perchance they came into the fold
    of the true faith, was rebuked by the Qur'an for the mental agony that
    he underwent on realizing that the deniers of truth were not going to
    change their stand, in the following words: “If it had been thy Lord’s
    will, they would all have believed, – all who are on earth! Will
    thou then compel mankind, against their will to believe!” (H.Q.
    The Qur'an makes it very clear that the duty entrusted to the
    messengers, who were appointed for the conveyance of the message
    of the true religion, was restricted to the propagation of the religion
    alone; it never included the coercion of others into the faith : “But
    what is the mission of apostles but to preach the clear message
    ?” (H.Q. 16:35)
    over them. Thy duty is but to convey (the message).” (H.Q.42:48)
    The Qur'an repeatedly tells the Prophet that he is only to invite
    people to the true religion; never to compel them to change their faiths.
    “Say: ‘The truth is from your Lord.’ Let him who will, believe,
    and let him who will, reject (it).” (H.Q. 18:29)
    “Therefore do thou give admonition, for thou art one to
    admonish. Thou art not one to manage (men’s) affairs.” (H.Q.
    In short, therefore, the messengers had all been only the
    propagators of the true religion. So was it the case with the last
    messenger also. He had the responsibility only of showing the people
    the nature of true religion. The obligation of the believers, too, who
    were conferred the duty of conveying the message of true religion,
    which was perfected through the last messenger, was restricted to
    this purpose alone: the obligation only of enabling others to distinguish
    between truth and falsehood. Not only has the Qur'an not demanded

  99. shabeer says:

    Any jurisprudence that does not relate good and evil to the
    cannot deal with universal good. Neither can rationalism. The
    European rationalism does not see anything wrong in extra marital
    relationship and homosexuality (Barbara Smoker: Humanism
    His son in law the European traveller, Yoran Scarner writes “They
    me until marriage was legally registered. Indian society does not
    allow premarital relationship. Even the most progressive Indian
    cannot tolerate dating which is quite common in western countries’’
    is to distinguish between good and evil, the good in England
    will become evil in India.
    As far as Islam is concerned the words and deeds of the
    good and evil without the help of divine revelations we
    what happened with regard to the concepts of Ahimsa and rationalism.
    A clear and definited understanding of good and evil help us
    get reward for their deeds in the world hereafter also makes them
    sincere and ready for service and then showmanship or exhibi-
    tionism is practically eliminated.

  100. SATAN says:

    No, My Slaves are Allah,Muhammad and Muslims.

  101. Aryan Hindu says:

    Thumbs Up to 'beloved gracey's ' comment.

  102. Agracean says:

    Are you sane?

  103. Agracean says:

    Mr Sanatan Dharma, do you know that you also have a sinful nature because we are the descendants of Adam and Eve?

  104. Agracean says:

    Grow up, Momo!

  105. Momo says:

    Those who follow Ali Sina never have healthy brain.




  106. Momo says:


  107. Momo says:



  108. Sakat says:

    Mr Zaheer
    Life is very short ,each individual aspire to live happy and peaceful life, enjoying all the comforts arranged by the nature (food,sleep,sex and the surrounding wonders)which his senses can perceive.For happiness good health is essential ,there is a proverb "health is wealh "; "Wealth is lost nothing is lost but health is lost everything is lost",you may not give serious thinking to my thoughts,however i know how important these things are.Wealth is needed for our peaceful voyage on this earth ,but when you go beyond earning your necessity/requirement the very wealth becomes cause for your misery.Though one may be having huge wealth ,but if it cant buy your health what is the use of it. Hard work is no one's monopoly ,but equally it is bad to depend upon the family when your age do not permit such dependence.My advice to you is ,just go carefully the tips here bestowed on you by Dr.Sina they are pearls,if you follow his guidance religiously and bring them in practice ,your life will blossom within short period.In the process of earning wealth ,don't neglect your health (sound mind create sound health,this was deprived to you earlier in your Islam,now you are free) .Don't depend on others for your sustenance ,i consider this is a greatest sin ever one commits in his/her life.

  109. Slave of Prophet says:

    Has Ali Sina any evidence to prove he has been Iranian? Voter Card, Driving License, Passport, other identity issued by Iranian Government?
    I firmly believe Ali Sina is a secret agent of Hindus deployed by Arya Samaji.

  110. Sanatan Dharma says:

    I wrote only my confirmation in which you are claiming you are sinful by nature? One Thing I could not understand if you are sinful by nature how did you give good advises to Mr. Kishor & Jaheer? I would like to know if you have sinful nature who is your role model among these sinner Muhammad / Hitler / Chengij Khan? Both religion Islam & Christianity believe a rapist, looter, mass-murder, terrorist can enter in heaven but not the non-believer how so much one may be good.

  111. Agracean says:

    Awesome comment from Mr Sakat! 😉

  112. Agracean says:

    Mr Sanatan Dharma, am I forcing my views on you or other mules here? Don't you have the human right to heed or reject my good sayings? Why compare me with that Islamic monster? Your above horrible comment shows that there is no difference between you and those braindead zombies.

  113. Sakat says:

    Mr Kishore
    listen to the wise advice thrown at you by our beloved Gracey, for your better future as well for the welfare of your family who raised you as knowledgeable person..

  114. Phoenix says:

    Dear ex-muslim

    Before contemplating suicide again,remember that you're the master of your destiny.You may not be able to change your physical circumstances immediatley but by persisiting in practicing "good-feeling" thoughts you will change your experience almost instantly and very soon your circumstances will change too.
    Ali Sina has given you invaluable advice.Just makesure that whatever thoughts yoy're thinking,or whatever words you're speaking,evoke from you posititve emotions,and then you'll be in the mode of attracting what you do want.

  115. Sanatan Dharma says:

    // I'm a Hindu man and in love with a Muslim girl//
    Say thanks to God you are living in Hindu's majority country (India) otherwise you would have been killed as per Islamic/Sharia law for falling in love with Muslim girl. You would have never dare to say this in Islamic country like Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan etc.
    Ali Sina is exposing Islam which is based on hate.

  116. Agracean says:

    Hi Kishore, kindly replace your word 'hate' with 'love' and you'll discover that's the exact purpose why my beloved Ms Dr Ali Sina created this awesome website, not to hate any muslims but to set them free from this religion of lies and hate. I hope that you will try your very best to persuade your braindead muslim girlfriend to read all the articles in this awesome website and helped her out of this Islamic sinkhole. If she doesn't come to her senses, then, you'd better dump her for good. Otherwise, she'll force you to convert to become another braindead zombie on the day of your marriage with her and not only that, she'll circumcise your banana, as a proof for membership to that horrible cult.

  117. Sanatan Dharma says:

    I could not understand what has Sadhu Sunder Singh to do with Vivekanand this Quote “We are what our thoughts have made us; so take care about what you think. Words are secondary. Thoughts live; they travel far.”
    You are rightly said you are sinful creature. You are follower of rapist and pedophilia Muhammad. You are like to him who wants to force his views on others if someone believe differently from you; he /she is ignorant as you say to others.
    You are incarnation of Muhammad.

  118. Agracean says:

    Hi Slave of Prophet, how in the world can my dear Ms Dr Ali Sina be an Indian when he has such deep knowledge about the history of Iran? Besides that, is it true that a wicked muslim like you wanted him dead by proving to you that he is an Iranian here?

  119. Kishore says:

    Dear Mr.Ali Sina,

    Why is it that you and your followers have so much hate towards Muslims? I'm a Hindu man and in love with a Muslim girl, whom I hope to marry one day. I have many friends who are Muslims and they are very loving and accepting of me.

    How is my Muslim girlfriend responsible for 9/11 or 26/11 or any of the terrorist attacks in Pakistan, Afghanistan and elsewhere? How is my Muslim girlfriend responsible for violence initiated by other Muslims? See, my point is, Muslims are individuals and they are only responsible for themselves. I think it's very ignorant to label all Muslims as violent, warmongers.

    You preach about love and unite of mankind but your love is selfish and exclusive to only people like you.
    I'm not saying you're a bad person, I don't know you personally. However, I'm pointing out that your approach to world peace is rather distorted and divisive because you are separating Muslims from the rest of mankind and demonising them.


  120. Agracean says:

    Hi Mr Sanatan Dharma, please watch the story of Sadhu Sundar Singh and listen carefully to what he preached. There are nuggets of truth in it. India needs many humble man like him who speaks the truth from the bottom of his heart.

  121. Sanatan Dharma says:

    What has Ali Sina to do with the Vivekananad's mother, father, Guru, neighbors etc that he will waste time in searching all these stuff. Ali Sina is believer & follower of principals which appeals to his rational and scientific thinking.

  122. Slave of Prophet says:

    Ali is not Iranian he is a Hindu in disguise of Muslim name and Ali Sina is an Indian. His writings and thoughts very similar to Hindus philosopers.
    @Ali Sina
    Do you have any proof you are an Iranian? You can not make the people fool.

  123. Agracean says:

    In the process of it all, do listen to the audio Bible, especially the New Testament, which contains Jesus' teachings and be encouraged. Also, it would definitely help you if you could join any Christian Church service and activities on Sunday and get to know the Christians there, who can help you to be a better person. God bless. 🙂

  124. Agracean says:

    Dear Zaheer, my dear Ms Dr Ali Sina is absolutely right to say that you're already a 29 years old man and it is very unhealthy for a man in your age to live with your family, especially if you are affected so much by their words or deeds on a daily basis. It's definitely the right time now for you to make up your mind once and for all to pack your luggage and bid your all your loved ones farewell and start your life afresh in another city as an independent, financially stable bachelor, just like the day you decided to renounce Islam for good. After you've settled down comfortably in a nice and safe place, you can spent all your precious time on earth to focus on more important things in life ie. find a sweet and lovely Christian girlfriend, work very hard day and night and save as much money as possible and once, you've earned enough to became a millionaire like me, do quickly apply for urgent immigration to Canada, the land of freedom where my hero dwells.

  125. lonelyloner says:

    @ Momo , pledging an amount you don't have and thus can't possibly pay, is a height of irresponsibility. Your silly assertion only reveal you as someone not worth listening to.

    Oh by the way, do try gambling at a Casino. I'm sure you will really have great time.

  126. Agracean says:

    Dear Ms Dr Ali Sina, you are ignorant of Swami Vivekananda's guru belief and teachings.

  127. @AliSina_FFI says:

    Swami Vivekananda's writings are all over the Internet. No I don't know much about Hinduism, only the very basics, but I enjoy reading uplifting and enlightening philosophies. Many Indian sears have gained a lot of wisdom. It is refreshing to read them and get inspired by them.

  128. Sol Landet says:

    I've read a lot of articles, written by iranians that say the same Ali said.

  129. Sol Landet says:

    In fact, few days ago, I read a post of a muslim that said that nazism is very close to the quran, so he is going to accept it (he is, indeed, a nazist)

  130. Just A Reader says:

    Sir, You mentioned that you were born in Iran. I am surprised how do you know so much about Hinduism and that too so much in depth. I am astonished that you know about Swami Vivekananda's writing as well. I don't think many Indians read anything about him. His name is used by political leaders to enhance their own image with an ambition to get some political mileage. Thank you for writing such a good article.

  131. @AliSina_FFI says:

    I follow the Iranian's televisions abroad and social media. There are some who still blame the mullahs for their problems. Once this regime is toppled and people will have freedom of speech everyone will come to see what had kept them impoverished and oppressed for 1400 years is Islam.

  132. I-HATE-ISLAM says:

    Slave mentality,
    The views of Hitler are acceptable to muhammadans who revere the Nazi devil. Hitler was very friendly with Hajj Amin El-Husseini, the then grand mufti of Jerusalem. Hitler conferred on Husseini the status of 'honorary Aryan' and designated him the "Fuhrer of the Muslim World'. Both of them agreed that the Nazi world view was exactly the same as that of muhammadanism. That is why Mein Kampf remains popular among muhammadans.

  133. avika says:

    Ali, you said that ten of millions Iranian don't believe in islam anymore. But you left Iran a long time ago, how do you know that?
    I don't think that much iranians had left islam, in my opinion, at most 20000 or 30000.

    PS: this question is for Ali only, if you aren't Ali, please don't reply.

  134. Sakat says:

    @ Dr.Ali Sina
    This is absolutely true ,this can be understand on experiential level . The "Sin" and other vile things originates in our mind and by purifying our thoughts on sub-conscious level through regular and sustained mediation we can get rid of Sin,s .Thus there is no need of an unseen God for removing our Sin after our death.Here and now we can permanently get rid of Sin's and from impure thoughts and attained peace and happiness in rest of our life. Thank you

  135. Sakat says:

    @Slave of Prophet
    /Whatever these Hindu Vivekanand and Gandhi said not the authority in Islam. As per Islam only Quran is highest authority and these Hindus views not according to Quran./

    There is nothing like the wisdom's of Vivekananda and Gandhi,s are reflected in Islam and it is not surprise at all ,but etiquette's of Hitler ,Jack the Ripper,s are,and it should be.

  136. Sakat says:

    You have to salute Sina for announcing this fat prize money for poor Muslims,which even they are incapable of handling ,if earned hahaha.

  137. Slave of Prophet says:

    @Ali Sina

    Dear Ali Sina in Islam views of Non-Muslim not acceptable. Whatever these Hindu Vivekanand and Gandhi said not the authority in Islam. As per Islam only Quran is highest authority and these Hindus views not according to Quran.

  138. Momo says:

    Ali Sina offers $50,000 reward to anyone who can prove him wrong.

    So funny and coward. …

    If he really speaks the truth and ready to maintain the truth, why only offer $50.000? why not $5000. If he's true, he will never be wrong.

    this means that he's afraid that if he is really right or not. He's still doubt about his simple logic
    And this means that his truth can only be valued $50.000.

    I offer you $50000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000, if you can prove that 2 x 2 is not 4.

  139. Sanatan Dharma says:

    Each thought in the mind produces a a certain pattern of neuron firing in the mind. Based on this, various physiological changes start taking place including change in hormonal levels, heart-rate etc. Further, even the neurological patterns start adapting to this thought. Thus, if you think of same thing again and again, the neurons create a pattern that next time it is easier to take that thought process ahead. That is why we see people getting into good or bad habits. These thoughts define one’s thinking patterns, and hence his or her personality, health and actions.Thus, each thought influences who we are. And by changing this thought, we can decide who we would be. Further, the same process is happening among all humans. And when we interact with them, based on our thought patterns we produce a myriad of social patterns and behaviors, which further influence who we are.Not only humans and society, this influence is also extended to nature in general because we are designed to exchange matter and energy continuously with nature. Thus we would see that merely by will-power, at times, unbelievable miracles happen in medical science.Thus thoughts become our destiny. We, the souls, are different from our body and mind. And when we die, the body and mind (brain) stop having sustainable exchange of matter and energy with nature, and hence the system decays to death. But the soul, who was controlling this system, is unaffected.Now it gets into another emerging system (mind-body) and starts its journey again. Because memories are part of brain cells, they get destroyed in this migration process. But the soul carries a vital body with it which carries the Sanskaars (traits) with it. God ensures that the new system provided is the best fit for uninterrupted journey ahead for the soul. Now, based on traits, the soul develops its personality again. It also continues interaction with the world outside in the same manner as it was doing earlier and continues to evolve itself.
    At each moment, God ensures that situation we face in the world is best suited for our pursuit of ultimate bliss. This is a continuous optimization process. If we exercise our will to do stupid things, stupid situations emerge and we start a descending to unhappiness. If we exercise our will to do things in pursuit of truth, we ascend. This process is uninterrupted by death.
    Question: What about animals and lower species? How can they exercise their will?
    Broadly speaking, only humans have the potential to exercise their will. Other species can only accept what happens to them and cannot exercise their will? When a soul descends too low that it no more exercises its will as a human, then it gets birth as animals where these tendencies that it had collected can be purged out. Same is case with those born insane or terminally ill.Please note that it is a multi-dimensional world. So depending upon the thought patterns in these various dimensions and aspects of life, the potential combinations are virtually infinite. It is not a discrete system but completely continuous. Thus conditions vary for birth of each soul – in different species, conditions, health, society etc.

  1. 14 June, 2013

    […] you’re in… Alpha Pre-Alpha or Beta. Hint: Other people don't decide what category you're in.Today we’re going to talk about attraction and why attraction is a science and not a choice! We’…action marketing and the law of attraction? How can you become the leader that everyone wants to […]

Leave a Reply