Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches

Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches from @freshandfoodie

I recently got into a conversation with my coworkers about whether or not peanut butter is considered a food. It started when I declared it as one of my favorites, and someone said “peanut butter isn’t a food — it’s a condiment.” I guess I can see that being true, unless you’re one of those “I-eat-peanut-butter-straight-out-of-the-jar” types like I am. In which case, it’s clearly a food.

However you classify peanut butter, its sweet and saltiness makes it one of my favorite things. I still eat peanut butter and jelly sandwiches for lunch on a regular basis, and chocolate peanut butter is one of my all-time favorite flavor combinations. I prefer my peanut butter of the natural variety (no added sugar, please) and the crunchier, the better.

I came up with this recipe one morning while trying to decide what to eat for breakfast. I love the way peanut butter melts on hot toast, so I decided to crank it up a bit by making it a sandwich and cooking it up french toast style. The ooey gooey peanut butter and honey center is seriously awesome with the egg, toasty crunch of the bread. The banana is also a nice touch, but I’ll be honest — I added it to make me feel less guilty about the whole thing. And guess what? It worked.

I think we’ve got another winner to add to my peanut butter recipe arsenal.

When it comes to peanut butter, are you chunky all the way or does smooth make you groove?

Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches (makes 1 sandwich, but can be doubled, tripled, etc.)

Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches from @freshandfoodie

What you need:

  • 2 slices of whole grain bread
  • 2 tablespoons crunchy peanut butter
  • 1 tablespoon honey
  • Half a small banana, thinly sliced
  • 1 egg
  • 1 tablespoon half and half or milk
  • A generous sprinkle of ground cinnamon

Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches from @freshandfoodie

How you do it:

  2. Make a sandwich as you normally would, layering peanut butter, banana and honey between the slices of bread.
  3. Meanwhile, in a shallow bowl, mix the egg, half and half and cinnamon. Dunk the sandwich in the egg, flipping over to saturate both pieces of the bread.
  4. Add the sandwich to the skillet and cook for approximately 2 minutes per side or until bread is browned, the egg mixture is cooked and the peanut butter is melty. If you really want to indulge, add some butter to the pan before cooking the sandwich.
  5. Serve sandwich with a side of maple syrup and topped with powdered sugar, if desired.

Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches from @freshandfoodie

19 thoughts on “Melty Peanut Butter French Toast Sandwiches

  1. These look so great! I’m trying to come up with an excuse to have brunch to make them (not that I need an excuse because I love brunch).

    Add some nutella and I’m sold!!

  2. Have I said this before? You and I are total peanut butter twins! Chocolate and peanut butter, a fave combo. Definitely do the natural and super crunchy. Melted on toast, delish. One of my fave snacks as a kid (and still is when I can get away with it) is a peanut butter spoon…stick my spoon straight into the jar and go to town! Your french toast idea looks great!!

  3. I make this same thing–but with almond butter! I also use vanilla soy milk add a tsp of vanilla and some nutmeg to the egg mix….my ultimate saturday morning breakfast:)

  4. Psssh (if that sound can be translated to letters). Peanut butter is totally a food. Healthy and delicious. I often stray from peanut butter for a while after a binge but come right back to it in full force again later. Recently Ive been on a pb&j kick. Love the idea of the french toast sandwich. Melty PB is the best!

  5. Do you deliver international to Mexico? I would love one of these for breakfast, straight away, please! 😛 I’ve had a serious crush for peanut butter that has only escalated in recent years. Goodness, this sammie looks darn delicious!

Leave a Reply to fooddreamer x


You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo


Twitter picture


Facebook photo


Connecting to %s