Franklin Fine Arts principal issues retraction on ISAT misinformation

Franklin Fine Arts principal Margie Smagacz sent a letter to parents today with extensive misinformation about the upcoming ISAT and the consequences of opting out.  Parents opting students out and students refusing the test will not have negative consequences for a school.

Please share this to spread the truth. Are you hearing misinformation about the ISAT? Please let us know:

Update, 12 Feb 2014: A day later, Principal Smagacz has issued a retraction of her original letter.  Several points of this second letter require correction and clarification:

First, for schools that are not Title I, making or not making AYP has zero consequences. Franklin is not a Title I school; thus, AYP is utterly irrelevant. Moreover, it is highly unlikely for the vast majority of schools to make AYP this year, even if more than 95% of students take the test because to make AYP this year, a school needs to have 100% meets-exceeds.

AYP does not appear on the district report card, only the state report card and NCLB Accountability Summary

In addition, the ISAT is not (and frankly has never been) useful for instructional purposes because the results are not available until months after the test is taken. And even if they were useful, given the very large number of other standardized tests CPS is using, including the now high-stakes MAP test, it would be silly to think that the ISAT could offer anything more than what is provided by the MAP, CCQB, REACH, or other tests CPS schools are administering.

The SQRP is *not* a test. It is a policy. The elementary school rating this year will use test results from the spring/EOY MAP and the ACCESS tests. Full policy here, and powerpoint version here. For more information on the utter failure that NCLB and state-mandated, test-based accountability measures, we recommend reading the US Department of Education’s own words.


Original letter 2/11/2013

Retraction letter 2/12/2013
Retraction letter 2/12/2013


One response to “Franklin Fine Arts principal issues retraction on ISAT misinformation

  1. It is obvious that principals are being coerced to lie about the ISAT, and it seems likely that the primary reason for this is to prevent the idea of opting out of tests from spreading. The party line from our unfortunate principals has changed from “This years test will be 100% common core aligned” to “The ISAT ‘FORMAT’ for reading and math are 100% aligned to the common core state standards.” I’d love for anyone in the top leadership of CPS to explain to us all what it means to have an aligned ‘FORMAT’. Could it be that they are both bubble tests? LOL what nonsense. I take this shift in the spin to indicate that CPS knows they are under the spotlight and are trying to create plausible deniability about the previous lies they have had spread to parents by principals.

Leave a Reply


You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo


Twitter picture


Facebook photo


Connecting to %s