Ancient steppe herders brought higher risk of MS to northern Europe
Ancient DNA helps explain why northern Europeans have a higher risk of multiple sclerosis than other ancestries: the disease is a genetic legacy of horseback-riding cattle herders who swept into the region about 5,000 years ago.
The findings come from a huge project to compare modern DNA with that culled from ancient humans’ teeth and bones – allowing scientists to trace prehistoric migration and disease-linked genes that tagged along.
When a bronze age people called the Yamnaya moved from the steppes of what are now Ukraine and Russia into north-western Europe, they carried gene variants that today are known to increase people’s risk of multiple sclerosis, researchers reported on Wednesday.
Yet the Yamnaya flourished, widely spreading those variants. Those genes probably also protected the nomadic herders from infections carried by their cattle and sheep, concluded the research published in the journal Nature.
“What we found surprised everyone,” said the study’s co-author William Barrie, a genetics researcher at the University of Cambridge. “These variants were giving these people an advantage of some kind.”
It’s one of several findings from a first-of-its-kind gene bank with thousands of samples from early humans in Europe and western Asia, a project headed by Eske Willerslev of Cambridge and the University of Copenhagen who helped pioneer the study of ancient DNA. Similar research has traced even earlier cousins of humans such as Neanderthals.
Using the new gene bank to explore MS was a logical first step. That’s because, while MS can strike any population, it is most common among white descendants of northern Europeans and scientists have been unable to explain why.
The potentially disabling disease occurs when immune system cells mistakenly attack the protective coating on nerve fibres, gradually eroding them. It causes varying symptoms – numbness and tingling in one person, impaired walking and vision loss in another – that often wax and wane.
It’s not clear what causes MS although a leading theory is that certain infections could trigger it in people who are genetically susceptible. More than 230 genetic variants have been found that can increase someone’s risk.
The researchers first examined DNA from about 1,600 ancient Eurasians, mapping some big shifts in northern Europe’s population. First, farmers from the Middle East began supplanting hunter-gatherers and then, nearly 5,000 years ago, the Yamnaya began moving in – travelling with horses and wagons as they herded cattle and sheep.
The research team compared the ancient DNA with about 400,000 present-day people stored in a UK gene bank, to see the MS-linked genetic variations persist in the north, the direction the Yamnaya moved, rather than in southern Europe.
In what is now Denmark, the Yamnaya rapidly replaced ancient farmers, making them the closest ancestors of modern Danes, Willerslev said. MS rates are particularly high in Scandinavian countries.
Why would gene variants presumed to have strengthened ancient immunity later play a role in an autoimmune disease? Differences in how modern humans are exposed to animal germs may play a role, knocking the immune system out of balance, said the study’s co-author Astrid Iversen of Oxford University.
The findings finally offer an explanation for the north-south MS divide in Europe but more work is needed to confirm the link, cautioned the genetic expert Samira Asgari of New York’s Mount Sinai school of medicine, who wasn’t involved with the research, in an accompanying commentary.