Context: Phillips became the winner, beating Sanchez. Prior to the announcement of the winner, season five finalist Ace Young proposed marriage to season three runner-up Diana DeGarmo on stage – which she accepted.

Question: What former contestant did Ace Young ask to marry him?
Answer: Diana DeGarmo

Question: In what season was Ace Young a finalist on American Idol?
Answer: five

Question: In What season did Diana DeGarmo come in second on American Idol?
Answer: three

Question: Which season was Ace Young on?
Answer: season five

Question: Which season was Diana DeGarmo on?
Answer: season three