A Colorado Sheriff is speaking out over the says the death of Harold Henthorn's first wife, Lynn, in 1995, claiming it was not an accident, despite his department reaching that conclusion 20 years ago. 'Based upon the information I've been briefed on up to this date … I do not think it's an accident,' Sheriff Tony Spurlock told CBS4  in an exclusive interview. 'I don't think it was an accident and I think it's very suspicious,' said Sheriff Spurlock, who became the Douglas County sheriff last month. Last year Harold Henthorn, 58, was indicted on a charge of first-degree murder in the death of hi second wife Dr Toni Henthorn, 50.
@highlight
Harold Henthorn told friends that his wife Toni had slipped while trying to take a photograph during their hike in September 2012 and fell 50ft
@highlight
Toni Henthorn had life insurance policies worth $4.5m and two days after her death, a claim was put in for a $1.5m policy, according to reports
@highlight
In 1995, Henthorn's first wife was also killed in mysterious circumstances
@highlight
They were changing a tire on a rural road late at night when the car slipped off a jack and crushed her to death, he told authorities
@highlight
Harold Henthorn collected nearly $500,000 in life insurance proceeds from his wife's death
In an interview with a Douglas County investigator, @placeholder said he had been having a lot of flat tires recently 'due to construction in the area of their home.