By Associated Press PUBLISHED: 09:42 EST, 15 October 2013 | UPDATED: 12:27 EST, 15 October 2013 With his East Coast accent and tales of living in New York, Jay Shaw stood out when he moved to the tiny farm town of Marsing, Idaho. But he was friendly enough, even helpful, to his neighbors, and they never suspected him of having a dark secret. After about a decade of living the quiet life of a would-be cattle rancher, his past closed in on him one day in 2011 as he was negotiating a purchase of hay near his 12-acre ranch.
@highlight
Enrico Ponzo wanted on numerous charges in a racketeering indictment, including 1989 attempted murder of Francis 'Cadillac Frank' Salemme
@highlight
Had been living as Jay Shaw with his girlfriend and two children on a 12-acre ranch in Idaho
In Idaho, where he had lived for a little over a decade, @placeholder owned a handful of cows and spent a lot of time with his two young children.