A man in a red shirt is standing next to a woman in a blue dress. They are both holding hands and smiling at each other. If I wish that chap Peel Edgerton had been with us, said Tommy thoughtfully., can we conclude that Peel Edgerton was already dead and Tommy missed him? We made examples of a hand full of them. If the first sentence is true, then is the second sentence true?
yes
it is not possible to tell
no