Modeling Natural Convection in Copper Electrorefining: Describing Turbulence Behavior for Industrial-Sized Systems
A computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model of copper electrorefining is discussed, where natural convection flow is driven by buoyancy forces caused by gradients in copper concentration at the electrodes. We provide experimental validation of the CFD model for several cases varying in size from a small laboratory scale to large industrial scale, including one that has not been compared with a CFD model. Previously, the large-scale systems have been thought to be turbulent by some workers and modeled accordingly with k-e type turbulence models, but others have not considered turbulence effects in their modeling. We find that the turbulence model does not predict turbulence exists; however, we analyze carefully the fluctuation statistics predicted for a transient model, finding that most cases considered do exhibit a type of turbulence, an instability related to the interaction between velocity and copper concentration fields. We provide a comparison of the extent of turbulence for various electrode heights, and gap widths, and we emphasize industrial-sized electrorefining cells.