{"content":[{"text":"ESJ Manuscript Evaluation Form 2018","bbox":{"left":0.209043,"top":0.082792,"width":0.605698,"height":0.030178999999999997}},{"text":"This form is designed to summarize the manuscript review that you have completed and to ensure that \n you have considered all appropriate criteria in your review report. Your review should provide a clear \n statement, to the authors and editors, of the modifications necessary before the paper can be published \n or the specific reasons for rejection.","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.165153,"width":0.833163,"height":0.060999}},{"text":"Please respond \n feedback.","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.239408,"width":0.12520399999999998,"height":0.03129700000000002}},{"text":"within","bbox":{"left":0.230394,"top":0.239408,"width":0.051576999999999984,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"the","bbox":{"left":0.291827,"top":0.239408,"width":0.02462700000000001,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"appointed","bbox":{"left":0.326474,"top":0.239408,"width":0.07941100000000001,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"time","bbox":{"left":0.415842,"top":0.239408,"width":0.035731999999999986,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"so","bbox":{"left":0.461554,"top":0.239408,"width":0.01791799999999999,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"that we","bbox":{"left":0.489348,"top":0.239408,"width":0.06376800000000005,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"can","bbox":{"left":0.562955,"top":0.239408,"width":0.027974999999999972,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"give","bbox":{"left":0.600826,"top":0.239408,"width":0.03470399999999996,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"the","bbox":{"left":0.64545,"top":0.239408,"width":0.024626999999999954,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"authors","bbox":{"left":0.680097,"top":0.239408,"width":0.05932000000000004,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"timely","bbox":{"left":0.74929,"top":0.239408,"width":0.05188599999999999,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"responses","bbox":{"left":0.811193,"top":0.239408,"width":0.07836699999999996,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"and","bbox":{"left":0.899432,"top":0.239408,"width":0.02910400000000002,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"NOTE: ESJ promotes review procedure based on scientific validity and technical quality of the paper. \n Do not estimate the novelty or the potential impact of the paper. \n You are also not required to do proofreading of the paper. It could be recommend as part of the \n revision. \n ESJ editorial office would like to express its special gratitude for your time and efforts. Our editorial \n team is a substantial reason that stands ESJ out from the crowd!","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.283962,"width":0.833239,"height":0.09070100000000003}},{"text":"Date Manuscript Received: 10.04.2018 Date Manuscript Review Submitted: 23.04.2018 \n Manuscript Title: THE MACEDONIANS OF ISLAMIC RELIGION \n IN THE CONTEXT OF IDENTITY THEORIES \n (ethnic, religious and cultural context)","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.393489,"width":0.7843060000000001,"height":0.07302800000000004}},{"text":"ESJ Manuscript Number:","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.486704,"width":0.20477299999999998,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"98,04.2018","bbox":{"left":0.318687,"top":0.486704,"width":0.090698,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"Evaluation Criteria: \n Please give each evaluation item a numeric rating on a 5-point scale, along with an explanation \n for each point rating.","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.528617,"width":0.833346,"height":0.05925899999999995}},{"text":"Rating Result \n [Poor] 1-5 [Excellent] \n 5","bbox":{"left":0.726864,"top":0.596825,"width":0.17795000000000005,"height":0.061667999999999945}},{"text":"Questions","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.606775,"width":0.082881,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"1. The title is clear and it is adequate to the content of the article.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.642047,"width":0.555578,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"(a brief explanation is recommendable)","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.667368,"width":0.31834499999999993,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"2. The abstract clearly presents objects, methods and results.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.732342,"width":0.521348,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"5","bbox":{"left":0.818368,"top":0.732342,"width":0.010078000000000031,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"(An explanation is recommendable)","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.757737,"width":0.28760899999999995,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"3. There are grammatical errors and spelling mistakes in this article.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.822735,"width":0.588431,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"(a brief explanation is recommendable)","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.848131,"width":0.31834499999999993,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"4. The study methods are explained clearly.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.913104,"width":0.371131,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"5","bbox":{"left":0.818368,"top":0.913104,"width":0.010078000000000031,"height":0.01644599999999996}}],"images_bbox":[],"images_bbox_not_text_overlap":[]}