{"content":[{"text":"(An explanation is recommendable) \n The study methods are adequate for the essay.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.076615,"width":0.381109,"height":0.036272}},{"text":"5. The body of the paper is clear and does not contain errors.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.121837,"width":0.5212740000000001,"height":0.01644599999999999}},{"text":"4,5","bbox":{"left":0.81081,"top":0.121837,"width":0.02519400000000005,"height":0.01644599999999999}},{"text":"(An explanation is recommendable) \n I marked errors in the text","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.147158,"width":0.28760899999999995,"height":0.03629699999999997}},{"text":"6. The conclusions or summary are accurate and supported by the \n content.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.19233,"width":0.567044,"height":0.03129699999999999}},{"text":"5","bbox":{"left":0.818368,"top":0.19983,"width":0.010078000000000031,"height":0.01644599999999999}},{"text":"(An explanation is recommendable) \n The conclusions is very good","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.232577,"width":0.28760899999999995,"height":0.036272}},{"text":"7. The references are comprehensive and according to the APA \n citation style. \n (All the sources in the list of references are cited in the content and vice \n versa) \n There is lack in the references: the monograph of A.D.Smith from 2004, \n which is cited in the body of the article, but not in the references.","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.277724,"width":0.599275,"height":0.10065199999999996}},{"text":"4","bbox":{"left":0.818368,"top":0.319827,"width":0.010078000000000031,"height":0.016446000000000016}},{"text":"(a brief explanation is recommendable) \n There is error in the references, in second position: Anderson Benedict (2006, it should be write \n from the new line. There is error on page 8th, in the footnote number 6: (Mirjana Mirchevska, \n 2011). It should be: (Mirchevska, 20011).","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.387325,"width":0.793662,"height":0.06590100000000004}},{"text":"Overall Recommendation (mark an X with your recommendation)：","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.512058,"width":0.621956,"height":0.020557999999999965}},{"text":"Accepted, no revision needed","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.545515,"width":0.238336,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"Accepted, minor revisions needed","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.570836,"width":0.274232,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"X","bbox":{"left":0.842957,"top":0.570836,"width":0.014554999999999985,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"Return for major revision and resubmission","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.596231,"width":0.350882,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"Reject","bbox":{"left":0.103698,"top":0.621626,"width":0.05153300000000001,"height":0.01644599999999996}},{"text":"Comments and Suggestions to the Author(s):","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.672079,"width":0.480761,"height":0.020557999999999965}},{"text":"The article is very interesting and important. The author of the article presented rare \n perspective on the issue, but in the Introduction an understanding of the term Macedonians \n and Slavonic nation (page 2) is completely unclear (see my commentary on the page 2 in the body \n of the text). The disadvantage of the article is lack of broader illustration of the identity \n question in the Ottoman Macedonia. In 19th century Ottoman Macedonia people who defined as \n Macedonians of islamic religion were a significant part of these territory. I recomend the first \n issue of Colloquia Humanistica (2012), the text of a conversation recorded in Ladino, entitled \n Las fronteras de Macedonia la konversasion de Geortche Petrov (1864/5–1921) kon Teodor Herzl \n (1860–1904) eskrita in ladino 1 (2012). I recomend either as a context of the problem disussed in \n the essey a research and chapter prepared for the monograph Macedonia: Land, Region, \n Borderland (2013) by Rigels Halili (Macedonians in Albania – from ethnic group to national \n minority).","bbox":{"left":0.095233,"top":0.703011,"width":0.833428,"height":0.22884099999999996}}],"images_bbox":[],"images_bbox_not_text_overlap":[]}