WORLD TRADE WT/DSB/51
14May1996
ORGANIZATION(96-1878)
INDICATIVE LIST OFGOVERNMENTAL AND
NON-GOVERNMENTAL PANELISTS
1. Toassist intheselection ofpanelists, Article 8.4oftheDSU provides that"theSecretariat
shallmaintain anindicative listofgovernmental andnon-governmental individuals. Thatlistshall
include theroster ofnon-governmental panelists established on30November 1984(BISD 31S/9), and
other rosters andindicative listsestablished under anyofthecovered agreements, andshallretain the
names ofpersons onthose rosters andindicative listsatthetimeofentry intoforce oftheWTO
Agreement.Membersmayperiodicallysuggestnamesofgovernmentalandnon-governmentalindividuals
forinclusion ontheindicative list,providing relevant information ontheirknowledge ofinternational
trade andofthesectors orsubject matters ofthecovered agreements, andthose names shallbeadded
tothelistupontheapproval bytheDSB. Foreachoftheindividuals onthelist,thelistshallindicate
specific areasofexperience orexpertise oftheindividuals inthesectors orsubject matter ofthecovered
agreements."
2. Theattached consolidated listcontains allthenames ofgovernmental andnon-governmental
panelists2approved bytheDSBfrom entry intoforce oftheWTO to30April 1996.
3. Forpractical purposes, theproposals fortheadministration oftheindicative listapproved by
theDSBon31May1995 arereproduced asanAnnex tothisdocument.
1Thisdocument cancels andreplaces thedocument WT/DSB/4, dated 20February 1996.
2Curricula Vitae containing more detailed information areavailable onrequest from theWTO Secretariat (Council
Division -Room 2025).WT/DSB/5
Page2
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
AUSTRALIA ARNOTT, Mr.R.J. Trade inGoods
CHESTER, Mr.D.O. TRIPS
DICKIE, Mr.I.C. Trade inGoods
GALLAGHER, Mr.B.J. Trade inGoods
GASCOINE, Mr.D.F. Trade inGoods
HALL, Mr.R.J. Trade inGoods
HANNOUSH, Mr.J. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
HAWES, Mr.D.C. Trade inGoods andServices
HIRD, Miss J.M. Trade inGoods
HUSSIN, Mr.P.A. Trade inGoods
JORDANA, Mr.K.M. Trade inGoods
MUGLISTON, Mr.M.A. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
O'CONNOR, Mr.P.R. Trade inGoods
ROBERTSON, Mr.P.C. Trade inGoods
THOMPSON, Ms.R. Trade inGoods
THOMSON, Mr.G.A. Trade inGoods andServices
WILKINSON, Mr.K.W. Trade inGoods
BELIZE LAING, Mr.E.A. Trade inGoods
BRAZIL ÁLVARES MACIEL, Mr.G. Trade inGoods
DENORONHA GOYOS, Mr.D. Trade inGoods andServices
DEPAIVA ABREU, Mr.M. Trade inGoods
PEREIRA SOUTO MAIOR, Mr.L.A. Trade inGoods
RAFFAELLI, Mr.M. Trade inGoods
CANADA BERNIER, Mr.I. Trade inGoods
CLARK, Mr.P.J. Trade inGoods andServices
DEMESTRAL, Mr.A. Trade inGoods
EASTHAM, Mr.P.T. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
GHERSON, Mr.R. Trade inGoods
HALLIDAY, Mr.A.L. Trade inGoodsWT/DSB/5
Page3
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
CANADA (cont'd) HINES, Mr.W.R. Trade inGoods
MCRAE, Mr.D. Trade inGoods
OSTRY, Ms.S. Trade inGoods
THOMAS, Mr.J.C. Trade inGoods
WARREN, Mr.J.H. Trade inGoods andServices
WINHAM, Mr.G.R. Trade inGoods
COLOMBIA CÁRDENAS, Mr.M.J. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
IBARRA-PARDO, Mr.G. Trade inGoods
LEAL ANGARITA, Mr.M. Trade inGoods andServices
OROZCO JARAMILLO, Ms.C.Y. Trade inGoods
CZECH REP. JUNG, Mr.Z. Trade inGoods andServices
ŠRONE K,Mr.I. TRIPS
EUROPEAN
COMMUNITIES
AUSTRIA BENEDEK, Mr.W. Trade inGoods
MARTINS, Mr.R. Trade inGoods
WEISS, Mr.J.F. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
ZEHETNER, Mr.F. Trade inGoods
BELGIUM DIDIER, Mr.P. Trade inGoods
DENMARK BOESGAARD, Mr.H. Trade inGoods
FINLAND JULIN, Mr.J.K.J. Trade inGoods andServices
KUOSMANEN, Mr.A. Trade inGoods
LUOTONEN, Mr.K. Trade inGoods
PULLINEN, Mr.M. Trade inGoods
RANTANEN, Mr.P.I. Trade inGoodsWT/DSB/5
Page4
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
EUROPEAN
COMMUNITIES
(cont'd)
FRANCE ARMAIGNAC, Ms.M.-C. Trade inServices; TRIPS
BEAURAIN, Mr.C. Trade inServices
DELLEUR, Mr.P. Trade inServices
LEFAS, Mr.P. Trade inGoods andServices
GERMANY BARTH, Mr.D. Trade inServices
BARTKOWSKI, Mr.D.H.H. Trade inServices
TANGERMANN, Mr.S. Trade inGoods
VON MÜHLENDAHL, Mr.A. TRIPS
WITT, Mr.P.J. Trade inGoods
GREECE MYROGIANNIS, Mr.G. Trade inGoods
SPATHOPOULOS, Mr.P. Trade inGoods andServices
STANGOS, Mr.P.N. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
IRELAND LONG, Mr.R. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
MATTHEWS, Mr.A.H. Trade inGoods
MOCKLER, Mr.T.F. Trade inGoods
ITALY GERBINO, Mr.M. Trade inGoods
GIARDINA, Mr.A. Trade inGoods andServices
SACERDOTI, Mr.G. Trade inGoods andServices
SCHIRATTI, Mr.G. Trade inGoods
NETHERLANDS BLOKKER, Mr.N. Trade inGoods
DEZEEUW, Mr.I.A. Trade inGoods
HOEKMAN, Mr.B.M. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
NEERVOORT, Mr.W. TRIPSWT/DSB/5
Page5
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
NETHERLANDS
(con'd)VAN DELOCHT, Mr.P. Trade inGoods andServices
SPAIN CASTILLO URRUTIA, Mr.J.A. Trade inGoods
SWEDEN ANDERSSON, Mr.T.M. Trade inGoods
ANELL, Mr.L. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
FALLENIUS, Mr.C.H. Trade inGoods
GRÖNVALL, Mr.N.E. Trade inGoods
HÅKANSSON, Mr.G.P.-O. Trade inServices
HOLGERSSON, Mr.J. Trade inGoods andServices
KLEEN, Mr.P. Trade inGoods
LINDSTRÖM, Mr.J.M. Trade inGoods
RISINGGÅRD, Mr.A.B. Trade inGoods
RODIN, Mr.A. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
STÅLBERG, Mr.L.A. Trade inGoods
UNITED KINGDOM ARKELL, Mr.J. Trade inServices
CROFT, Mr.R.H.F. Trade inServices
HINDLEY, Mr.B.V. Trade inGoods andServices
JOHNSON, Mr.M.D.C. Trade inGoods
MUIR, Mr.T. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
TOULMIN, Mr.J.K. Trade inServices
HONG KONG CARTLAND, Mr.M.D. Trade inGoods andServices
INDIA DAS, Mr.B.L. Trade inGoods
DASGUPTA, Mr.J. Trade inGoods
GANESAN, Mr.A.V. Trade inGoods, Services; TRIPS
KUMAR, Mr.M. Trade inGoods andServices
MOHANTY, Mr.P.K. Trade inGoods
PRASAD, Ms.A. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPSWT/DSB/5
Page6
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
INDIA (cont'd) REGE, Mr.N.V. Trade inGoods
SAJJANHAR, Mr.A. Trade inGoods
SHARMA, Mr.L. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
ISRAEL HARAN, Mr.E.F. Trade inServices
ROM, Mr.M. Trade inGoods
SEMADAR, Mr.M. Trade inGoods
TALBAR, Mr.M.A. Trade inGoods
WEILER, Mr.J. Trade inGoods
JAPAN ASAKURA, Mr.H. Trade inGoods
ISHIGURO, Mr.K. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
IWASAWA, Mr.Y. Trade inGoods
KANDA, Mr.H. Trade inServices
KEMMOCHI, Mr.N. Trade inGoods andServices
KOTERA, Mr.A. Trade inGoods andServices
OHARA, Mr.Y. TRIPS
SHIMIZU, Mr.A. Trade inGoods
TAKASE, Mr.T. Trade inGoods andServices
TSURUOKA, Mr.K Trade inServices
KOREA, REP. OF BARK, Mr.T. Trade inGoods andServices
CHO, Mr.D.Y. Trade inGoods andServices
HAN, Mr.D.S. Trade inGoods
HWANG, Mr.H. TRIPS
KIM, Mr.H.-J. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
PARK, Mr.N. Trade inGoods
SHIN, Mr.Y. Trade inGoods
SUH, Mr.Y.H. Trade inGoodsWT/DSB/5
Page7
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
MAURITIUS BHUGLAH, Mr.A. Trade inServices
DOZEKEE, Mr.A. Trade inServices
NEW ZEALAND FALCONER, Mr.C.D. Trade inGoods
FALCONER, Mr.W.J. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
HAMILTON, Mr.P.W Trade inGoods
MACEY, Mr.A. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
MCPHAIL, Mr.A.H. Trade inGoods
WALKER, Mr.D.J. Trade inGoods andServices
WOODFIELD, Mr.E.A. Trade inGoods
NORWAY BAKKE, Mr.E. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
SIVERTSEN, Mr.A. Trade inGoods
THORVIK, Mr.A. Trade inGoods
PAKISTAN BAJWA, Mr.M.A. Trade inGoods
PERU GUZMAN-BARRON SOBREVILLA,
Mr.C.A.Trade inGoods
PHILIPPINES ESTANISLAO, Mr.J.P. Trade inGoods andServices
PATERNO, Mr.V.T. Trade inServices
SRILANKA JAYASEKERA, Mr.D. Trade inGoods
SWITZERLAND ADDOR, Mr.F. TRIPS
BLATTNER, Mr.N. Trade inServices
CARBONNIER, Mr.G. Trade inGoods
CHAMBOVEY, Mr.D. Trade inGoods
ERNST, Mr.H. Trade inGoods
ETTER, Mr.C. Trade inServices
HÄBERLI, Mr.C Trade inGoodsWT/DSB/5
Page8
COUNTRY NAME SECTORAL EXPERIENCE
SWITZERLAND JOST, Ms.M. Trade inGoods
(cont'd) TRAN, Ms.T.T.-L. TRIPS
WASESCHA, Mr.L. Trade inGoods andServices; TRIPS
ZWEIFEL, Mr.P. Trade inServices
UNITED STATES AITKEN, Mr.B.E. Trade inGoods
ECHOLS, Ms.M.A. Trade inGoods
ENDSLEY, Mr.H.B. Trade inGoods andServices
GRAHAM, Mr.T.R. Trade inGoods
GREENWALD, Mr.J.A. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
HUDEC, Mr.R.E. Trade inGoods andServices
LICHTENSTEIN, Ms.C.C. Trade inServices
LUTZ, II,Mr.R.E. Trade inGoods andServices
MYRICK, Mr.R.E. TRIPS
REYNA, Mr.J.V. Trade inGoods andServices
SCHILL, Mr.C.F. Trade inGoods; TRIPS
SHEPHERD, Mr.R.E. Trade inGoods
VERRILL, Jr.Mr.C.O. Trade inGoods
WALLACE, Jr.Mr.D. Trade inGoods andServices
WALSH, Mr.D.J. Trade inServicesWT/DSB/5
Page9
ANNEX
ADMINISTRATION OFTHE INDICATIVE LIST
1. Toassist intheselection ofpanelists, theDSUprovides inArticle 8.4thattheSecretariat shall
maintain anindicative listofqualified governmental andnon-governmental individuals. Accordingly,
theChairman oftheDSBproposed atthe10February meeting thatWTO Members review theroster
ofnon-governmental panelists established on30November 1984 (BISD 31S/9) (hereinafter referred
toasthe“1984GATT Roster ”)andsubmit nominations fortheindicative listbymid-June 1995. On
14March, TheUnited States delegation submitted aninformal paper discussing, amongst other issues,
whatinformation should accompany thenomination ofindividuals, andhownames might beremoved
from thelist.TheDSBfurther discussed thematter ininformal consultations on15and24March,
andattheDSBmeeting on29March. Thisnoteputsforward some proposals fortheadministration
oftheindicative list,based ontheprevious discussions intheDSB.
General DSU requirements
2. TheDSUrequires thattheindicative listinitially include “theroster ofgovernmental andnon-
governmental panelists established on30November 1984(BISD 31S/9) andotherrosters andindicative
listsestablished under anyofthecovered agreements, andshallretain names ofpersons onthose rosters
andindicative listsatthetimeofentry intoforce oftheWTO Agreement ”(DSU 8.4). Additions to
theindicative listaretobemade byMembers whomay“periodically suggest names ofgovernmental
andnon-governmental individuals forinclusion ontheindicative list,providing relevant information
ontheirknowledge ofinternational tradeandofthesectors orsubject matter ofthecovered agreements. ”
Thenames “shallbeadded tothelistupon approval bytheDSB”(DSU 8.4).
Submission ofinformation
3. Asaminimum, theinformation tobesubmitted regarding eachnomination should clearly reflect
therequirements oftheDSU. These provide thatthelist“shallindicate specific areas ofexperience
orexpertise oftheindividuals inthesectors orsubject matter ofthecovered agreements ”(DSU 8.4).
TheDSU alsorequires thatpanelists be“well-qualified governmental and/or non-governmental
individuals, including persons whohave served onorpresented acasetoapanel, served asa
representative ofaMember orofacontracting partytoGATT 1947orasarepresentative totheCouncil
orCommittee ofanycovered agreement oritspredecessor agreement, orintheSecretariat, taught
orpublished oninternational tradelaworpolicy, orserved asasenior tradepolicy official ofaMember ”
(DSU 8.1).
4. Thebasic information required fortheindicative listcould bestbecollected byuseofa
standardized form. Suchaform, which could becalled aSummary Curriculum Vitae, would befilled
outbyallnominees toensure thatrelevant information isobtained. Thiswould alsopermit information
ontheindicative listtobestored inanelectronic database, making thelisteasily updatable andreadily
available toMembers andtheSecretariat. Aswellassupplying acompleted Summary Curriculum
Vitae form, persons proposed forinclusion ontheindicative listcould also,iftheywished, supply
afullCurriculum Vitae. Thiswould not,however, beentered intotheelectronic partofthedatabase.WT/DSB/5
Page10
Updating ofindicative list
5. TheDSU doesnotspecifically provide fortheregular updating oftheindicative list.Inorder
tomaintain thecredibility ofthelist,itshould however becompletely updated every twoyears. Within
thefirstmonth ofeachtwo-year period, Members would forward updated Curricula Vitae ofpersons
appearing ontheindicative list. Atanytime, Members would befreetomodify theindicative list
byproposing newnames forinclusion, orspecifically requesting removal ofnames ofpersons proposed
bytheMember whowerenolonger inaposition toserve, orbyupdating thesummary Curriculum
Vitae.
6. Names onthe1984GATT Roster thatarenotspecifically resubmitted, together withup-to-date
summary Curriculum Vitae, byaMember before 31July1995 would notappear afterthatdateon
theindicative list.
Other rosters
7. TheDecision onCertain Dispute Settlement Procedures fortheGATS (S/L/2 of4April 1995),
adopted bytheCouncil forTrade inServices on1March 1995, provides foraspecial roster ofpanelists
withsectoral expertise. Itstates that"panels fordisputes regarding sectoral matters shallhavethe
necessary expertise relevant tothespecific services sectors which thedispute concerns." Itdirects
theSecretariat tomaintain theroster and"develop procedures foritsadministration inconsultation
withtheChairman oftheCouncil." Aworking document (S/C/W/1 of15February 1995) noted by
theCouncil forTrade inServices states that“theroster tobeestablished under theGATS pursuant
tothisDecision would formpartoftheindicative listreferred tointheDSU. ”Thespecialized roster
ofpanelists under theGATS should therefore beintegrated intotheindicative list,taking carethat
thelatter provides foramention ofanyservice sectoral expertise ofpersons onthelist.
8. Asuggested format fortheSummary Curriculum Vitae formforthepurposes ofmaintaining
theIndicative Listisattached asanAnnex.WT/DSB/5
Page11
Summary Curriculum Vitae
forPersons Proposed fortheIndicative List
1. Name: • fullname
2. Sectoral experience
Listhereanyparticular sectors ofexpertise:
(e.g. technical barriers, dumping, financial
services, intellectual property etc.)
3. Nationality(ies)• listofparticular expertise
• allcitizenships
4. Nominating Member: • thenominating Member
5. Date ofbirth: • fulldateofbirth
6. Current occupations: • yearbeginning, employer, title,
responsibilities
7. Post-secondary education • year, degree, name ofinstitution
8. Professional qualifications • year, title
9. Trade-related experience inGeneva in
theWTO/GATT system
a. Served asapanelist • year, dispute name, roleas
chairperson/member
b. Presented acasetoapanel • year, dispute name, representing
which party
c. Served asarepresentative ofa
contracting party orMember toaWTO
orGATT body, orasanofficer thereof• year, body, role
d. Worked fortheWTO orGATT
Secretariat• year, title,activity
10. Other trade-related experience
a. Government trade work • year, employer, activity
b. Private sector trade work • year, employer, activity
11. Teaching andpublications
a. Teaching intrade lawandpolicy • year, institution, course title
b. Publications intrade lawandpolicy • year, title,name ofperiodical/ book,
author/editor (ifbook)